← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/676/2005allowed

Sheo Narain And ORS. v. State Of Haryana

2020-03-02Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu15 pages



      



  !"#$ $

%&' ()) ! $ *$

 



   

    

 

  

      

      

  !" 

  

" !  !" #     !"   

$  %&



  !" 

  

  !"   

 ' ( 



)  ) 

 

     *    )

 +

-'-.$--/ 

-/-.$--/ 

  )  

  %

 &

  *  .( $(-($--  ) 

   "

 

   " 

) 

"

01 '-$ '$/ '$' 

 "

0.   2

  3

 52356 

"

$- 23 * 

   "



   

       

       

             

 

    !

  " #   $   

             %

 



$   

   " #   $    

    # #

 

    !

!   " #   $     

  

  #   

    " #  & #  "    '&

'#'( ' ' '#'

' '#'

 ) '

'

 '*' '

'''





 +#    #       # #  $ !

 # 

  ,   #  " # # *# -   #  .   #     * /  # "

  *0  # -  & *  !

1      2*   " # # #   #   *0 *   #   3# # 

       - # 

  

 )"- # 

      #  #  &    

  *       # " ##    " # * 0 #      # #   -   #    /   #  # 

 4  5  +#  #    2 #

        6 #  " *0 # "   *   5 2*    # (   #

  2# *  ##   # #    "   +# 

 

 " -  #    #

 &  #  # 

 4 *# .   # +# 

  # -  &

 2#  * % 1 )  .  # )    0"

#     # 0  # *# .   # +#  * "    # #     # +#  "    #

  7 "   -   # 5   ,   # "

'

  8  +#    "  +#  * "

    8   -    " 

 +# #'" '

' ' '

 ''#''

     ! *  " 7,

,) 

  ,

  

   "

 "

'' 3 3 *

"   "  * 

   "





 

)! "   0 8 "  

)   

 ! !,

  

  "   

  !  " 



 / 8 "  

)      

 " " 9 : !   "      

!

   +



 " ! "  ( :;/ < 8&

 ,

"   7,

!

 --'$-- 

    ;

  

        

  

     

        

     

  

  

  "

   

            #    $        %  

          

 &

 

# 

 '   ,

"   7,

,   

 

 



   ;

  

     

# 

      (  

    

   #      # #    

 ) * #    

      

  

   # 

 !  

     #  

    "''

  ,

"   7,

 

  

   ;

 $      &     # 

 

  !  # 

  

   

         +         "

 !     $   &

 

" % $              

# # &  

           #    + $        

     #   '   

= >7 ?   "    <

,   , 

 

!

   



" 7,

,   

  *    "

    " 

 "

   '

 /  

)  

   

   !



"  >7 2  " ;7,



   

 ",

  , 

   ,

 ,   ''-   

"   7,

  

   ) , *     ,  

     " ) )



   $0     ! 8 >7<   ,

"  

/ 7,

<)   , ! 8>7<& 1 :;9 <  @ <

 

 < 

+ 

< 2

 "

"

  ;, , 7,

 )   %

  

   ;

  

  ,   

 # # #       

         , -  

      .              /

             . &   %      0      /

      -  

 

       . %        0     % /

       .          1

   

 -  0     & /

      -     - % *.

         0     + /

         .          0      2 /

  #    

  -      34   . %        5        0     6

   

 # # )             3 

%     #   

   

 # #     0  

  



    5        1     - 



     7 3   

  # -  

   

     .      

     0       

  #

    

 . %        0  

 '

* "  



   "A " ) , 

 

 

 

 ) 



 " 

  "     

   

 , ,

  *  ))  ) 

+  

  

   

) 

  

 ;, , 7,



$0   2  " ;7,



" ,

! "



  , !

  . :;' <  

 &

  7,

,  , 

) ! ;

    #        

        

       1  

      

      

        /       -   * #       9#   

         

# 

   "   

 "  %

-

:                

   #   &

#  #'

 

  

  

!    !

(  >733 - :;( 2 



""

 

 ,

"   ,

>7 )  2 + ) 

 ""  ,   "   >79 2  A

 

 "!  ,, >7 "" 3

    "   >7( 2  A

 !

 "! ,,>7B  :;1 

 

 , 

 ""

,  -.-'$--  ) -'-   

   )   !

%

 



  

8)  +

   ",

)"A B

      

) 

 <)

      !

    *   ) "

  !  ", )"A

 2

 ,

,   3

 

      !

    ",   



 

      )   !

  

    *  )

  

 ) "A ) 

     )   !

     

 )   %

     ,

  )

 *   " 

 :    A

+  %

   ,  ""  <

 :

   ",

)"A

 !

   "

 )

)  

 ""

  

<)

  ,

, B   "

) , 3

  ",   3

   &  < ,) 

 &)

  

  !

     !

  



   , 3

   

"

   )"A   ,  "" * "

   ,   )   %

 

 +,  , , ""   ""    A 

    )  %

   

) ""

 )   ",   ,  

 ,  ""  

 !

   , <  * 

 ",  



"A     !  ",  A )    ,  

      ,

 

  ,

 " )   " !

 >7 2  " ;7,



A 

   



""  " !   )    A   *      , A 

)     )     "   , )

 ,     ) 

 

  $'-  

0    " , ,

 



 "  =  ,  , )

 ""  "       )   !

 

 ,   "    "   )

) 

 :

 ! A

, "

" , !

, 



  

"

 "

,   , !

 



  ,  A 

   )  ! ,

 *    ",   

  , <

 

 %

 

 3  

 <

 "A $ :;. 2  + 



 

 , ,

>7 

 )    " C2 >7  

   ""

    

<)     ) 2 + ) 

 ""

  ,

"   ,

>7* ""   

,

"   ,

>7@ 

<) ,

"   ,

>7  "     "!   , ""   B    "! 

 ,"" <)  ' :;- !

 

  , 

 ""

,  -.-'$--   

     )   

  "

"   &

"

 

)  +

 

 

  , * 



 A *   ",

)"A *

.

   ) "

)   <)  + , 

 ,     !

     * ,

 " , 2

,

, 

 & , 3

 + ,  

 ,        !

  ",   *    ,

   

  

      " 

 ) "A

 

 

 "

   ,   " 3

   )    * ,

  "



   )   %

 "  ,   

+  ) 

     ;

; 4&) , 

 )   

  ",  " ,    



     ;

; , 

) 

  <) "

      ;

; ,   "

      ;

; < ,) "

    ) 

    )   %

 "  

 *  ""    ,  "  ""  " *     ) 

A %

 3  

 3 A <

 *    )   ;

; 

A  , 

   ;

; 4)) ,

,   " ) ,   <

 :

 "

   



)    

 

%

 ",

 ,

 

  <

 *   "

"     "

  )

)    &  

  ,   

<)

< ,)

   "   

"

   "

  )

) , 3

  3

   & , , 3

+ , 8 

  "   

"

     

 , "

 

 A  , *    )    %

 

   

 ,  "" * , ""    %

 

   ,  ,  "" *

- 

 

"

   ""   %

  %

 

 

  "! 4) 6   )   %

 



)   )      , 

       A  )   ;

; 

 ! %

  

 

"  ""  " *   

 3  

 3 A <

 " ;7,



"",  %

<

 ,

" 

  

  )   "      !      )   %

  !

 )

 !   

  ",

 , <

 &    )      , ,  "" 

 

 

  "" "  )      

"  --   ,  ""

 ,  "   ,  ""

 0 :; 



-.-'$--

 

 !  "     ,  )   ;

; !

    , !

 %

 

 

   



) * ", )"A  ) ---?-'-  *     ",

 

    !

  !

 ", 

     ,

   ! "    " 

 ) "A )  2

 ,

, + , 8  , 3

 

3

 ",

    !  ) "A ) )  !

   

" *      !

  

  *  "

 ,    ,

 

 %

 

  ",   *    "

 %

 

 "  

 * 

 <

 ,  ""   , ,  A , 

!

  

 <

 B

 

   %

 

    ",

 , <

 *     " 

 "

 2

 ,

 

 ", 

"

  *  ""

     <)   

  

 *

 , "

  2

 ,

,  "

 )

) , 3

 ", 

   *   ""

  "

   

 < ,) 3

 , 3

 + , 

 , *    ,

   

  * " %

 

 

 

 

  %

 

 

 )  4 " "!6 "" "

  %

   

   "

 %

  %

 "",)

 "" 

   2

 " ;7,



  

"  /-  %

 

 

 * ,  ""  

    

"  $-    %

   !

 ,

 "   "    A

 $-    ,  "  ""  "     ""



+    , 

   

 )   %

  ,

 "  ""  "  " , ,  $-'$--  $-- 

   2

 ,

 

!



 <

9--  

, 

!

     *  )   %

  

 "  ""  " 

    ,

  / :;$ + ) 



  

 ""   "

"   ,

  ""   !

 >7* ""

<)

 >7D 

""   

 >7 "" 

 ,

"   ,

>7E "" , 3

 ,

"  ,

>7E? "" , 3

"!  "

  2 

A

   "!   ,



$ 9 * C8 

 >7<< * )  "

7 )

;

 4)

 6 $4 ;

6 $)4)

6 $"4

6 $ 4 6 $ 4 6

$4A6*)  "

 7 )

' 14 6 ( :;/ < 8&

 

 

    !

 

 

+  

    , 

 

   

 

   ,

"   7,

  

<)  ! 8>7<

<& 1 :;9 < @<

 ,   

 

   %

 

 * "       "A " ) , 

 

 

 

 ) 

 *  ))

 ) 

+  

  

   

) 

 

 ;, ,

$0  . :;' <   

 &

 

 "  , 

!   $- *  "  7,

,    

+   $ * "    "

:;1 

 

 

 !

 

 %

 

 

   

8)  +

   ",

)"A  -.-'$--  ) -'-  

  *    ) "

 !  "

 

 

   , 

)   %

   ,

  )

 )   3

 

               )   !

    ,

  )

*   :;1 

 

A   )   %

 

  , ""  <

 :

   ",

)"A    " )

"

  %

 

 

 

 )    "  :;1 

'

 

 

      ", 

 !

  , <  *    ,    

 3  

 <

""

  ,  , :;- !

 

 :; 

 

,  !

   $$ *  ,

 :;1 

 

  "

>7 2  " -'-

 ,

--'$-- 

  ,

>7  ,  )   :;- !

, 

:; 

 2

) !) :;1 

 A  )    )

 

)  ""

 



A

"     )    

 !

   , <

    

 3  

 <

 2    "

"

  )     ,   :;- !

 

   

"

  !   )     

 :; 

 *  ,

 :;- !

 

  " 

  A :; 

 !   )  ) !) 

:;- !

 

 :; 

 !

 ,! 

)   ,  )   

 

  ! 7,

   "

"

)  !

 

 

:; 



 

  A

    )   

 3  

 <

 :;- !

 

, 

:; 



 

 

   

     

" ,  ""  

)



  ! %

 

 2

  ) !) :;- !

 

 ,

"   *

!   , ""

 :;1 

 

 %

  "  

 :;- !

 

  

 )   %

 

 "  

 :;- !

 

0



    )   %

 

  

   )

   :;1 

 

 



 ""  " !  )    A    " , ,

 3  

 <

 :;1

 

 

)     )   

+ 

 !

    :;- !

 

 

:; 

 

 ,

  " * "

"

 !

)

 )   %

 

 )   

  

 

 ""   

<)   ,

" 7,

) :;/ < 8 &

 * 8   >7< 

>7<& *  " 

7

 " )   

<)  *  "    

  !  " 

 

 

"

'-$23 

"

0.23 $' ""

        * "  

 

 "

'-$ 23 

 "

0. 23   

 * 

   "=

  "   ,

 "

'-$ 23 

 "

0. 23 !  "



"  

 % ) < ,) , 3

 

   

<)

   "

   

 

 

 ,  $    "

 

" 

< ,)

 ,  '   

9 ,

  "

 

" 



 

 0    ,

 

  "

 



, 3

 

 '   1 ,

 

$   "

 

" 

% )   3

 

 ,     "

 

" ""   

<)

 , 

/   

 ,

  "

 

" 

    

)  ""

  

 !    

 , 

/   , 

   "

"    "



 * 

       )  * )  )

 

   )

 

"   + ,-./   +

-

- /  .% (0 1

$ )  ;

 :  A

? 

D? :    ) D?