High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/706/2011dismissed

Azad v. State Of Haryana

2015-12-17Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mr. Justice Arun Palli10 pages

" # $

% &# & '( $ )

&( $

, #-(.( /0 -123+

45#260 &( (& , 3 #$ - ,7(,&

&( / 3#$ - , ,& /,.% &# & '( /# &(

&( 85.. (/3#$ - , /," # %.#(,((#& 3#$ - ,3 1(-5.-5(

&(9($' (/(3..(., /,#$ - ,/ 3 6 / ,&. /#/,

, ,

!"# $ $ %& $ %&

'() $ " $*

+ , " $ %-. '()$ / "0. " " 1 2 %& 0%& '() $ / +"0." "

$ 3$

(4 $ $ ( $ 4 "

.# /" / " #

" " $ 67 &8

. " $

5 " 9 $ $

" :(%

$ 9

) 5 *" $ 9 ; " $ 9

$ $ 9 $

< $ $ 9

(43 " 7 /.

-. =.&$ " 9 7 ' /$.,(4 ,(/4(- * '3 ) =1 (7 ( 6 3$ (4 " "

=1 (78 9 =1 (>" $ ( "$ ;'/$

? "'

$ 3 -) ( ) $ %& '()$ ((: 9$ 3 $ " =1 (@ 3 $ $ A# A

$ A# A !$ B$ $ $ 5 3 "

$ =1 (, -

" <$ (

9 "/ $ /) 7

-. =.&$ $9

=1 () 5 %

" <$ =1 (4$ '* : < " " :

% %

" < =1 (= < $ $ .

9 3

% %

" $ 9 '*: $ $

5 " =1 (# 6 8 $ $

. 9 3 : $ =1 ( ' ) $

" $

; " $ %-. %&

+ $ %& '()"$ $ + "$

9 " %% ) ( ) $ $

@ $ "

;'/ 7 &

+ "(

=1 ?@ '

" /###(,( / ..( /. 5#4 "

4 &( (& , 3 #$ - ,7(,& &(

/ 3#$ - , ,& /,.% &# & '( /# &(3 &( 8 5.. (/3#$ - , /," # /#%.#(,((#& 3#$ - ,3 1(-5.-5( 3 ,9 " # "

. /#/,.

; "$ 5/. ,& /,.

,& ,;< / (/4&(/ 1#,& (-261 '(/4 - /

,& ,,& --5.#& #, '/ 7 6 < /4((/ /, - 25- 5 7& .$(#- $611 =3,& /, - - $#26,& (- 7 . .($- 5&(.- /, #(-,( /(/ .-5,( /- .(,.1 '.(,

# 52,5 & 2 $- /,/,( / /# 5/. ,& /,.(.

/ , .5., (/ 2 . ,& $(-,(1 .5-& (' (/-(#/, 4 . 5/# .& -'3 2- 1./$ 5. /#=#;&/;< / (/4&7 .# #

5, ,&- 3,&(.,,&(/4# /26&(17 ., 1 ' - ,

/# (/ 1#,& (- 2 5,,&'(#/ (/4 < /4((/ /, - , ,& ,,(13(,&. 1#(.- /-6 .(/,& (- .4 #(/4 - 5 ,&- 3(,& #61 '. /6#(/-& -,1 (/.(.,&(. ,& ,< / (/4&#($ /, - # .;7& .,&$(-,(1

6 /<7 / # .;: ,&,&7(,/...1 (/#7(,&,& --5.# 2 5,& /& 5 /& 5&6& # / ,5/(,6, . /#(#/,(6,& --5.#

, /6,&(.3$/ --5.#7/ 1(/4 -&

,&#5(/4,& ,( #&6& $ .

2/#56(#/,((#26; /# ;:$/ /, - (/>5.,( /7 .- $# 1,& ....( / --5.#" #/#,&.-(-51., /-.3((/(,( 6,&(.#(.- /-6(/ ,&4(., ,( //512 ,&- 3(3(/,&.(. ,&- 5 ,&- 3 (,& #61 '. /6#(/-2 $ 3;< / (/4&# .#,& , #5, ,&(../ ,-&(/4 &(.- (/-(#/, /#'(#/ (/4 < /4(3& ,(4&,/# /#& #4($/,&/512 ,&$&(- .

:* (/ -

:* /#5,&&, #,&- 5 ,&- .25 25,(/ -,,&- 5 ,&- 7 ..($& (-- $#,& /,

- 1,& ....( / ,& --5.#7(,&4(., ,( //512/#(/4 .

:* .7 .

.(. &/=, 451/, (.#26 /# /( 5/. &(

(& , (.,&(.,& ,,& --5.#7/ ,$( 5.6'/ 7/(,&, ;: ;

,.,(#/,((- ,( / # ,& --5.#7 .- /#5-,#,(.

.,,# .(,( / 7,& ,(#/,((- ,( / ,& --5.# ,&(.,,(1 (/,&- 5,(./ (#/,((- ,( / /#(. / $ /- /# ..5-& --5.# /,(,#, 2 ->5(,,# /,&(.$64 5/# & 2 $- /,/,( / /# 5/. ,& /,.(.

4 (// ,.5., (/ 2,(.,5,& ,(/,&(.- ./ ,.,(#/,((- ,( / #

,& --5.#7 .&#/ -,3 / (- ,( /7 .1 $#2 ,&- 5, 26 #5-(/4 --5.#" #(/15# -31 '(/4 6 - /#5-,(/4 ,.,(#/,((- ,( / ,& --5.#" #&(. (- ,( /7 .1 $#26,& /$.,(4 ,(/4(-/,&(. (- ,( /3., ,1/, --5.#" #7 .

- ##26 /###(,( / &( 5#(-( % 4(., ,?

5,6@354 /

/,&$6# 67&26 --5.#5.#, ,(-( ,(/,&(#/,((- ,( / # /,&,=,,& ,.(/-,& (-& #.& 7/&(1, ,&7(,/...3 ,& 3&#(#/ ,7 /,, 8 (/,&,.,(#/,((- ,( / #/ -,3,& (./ 1 ,( /,&(, .& 7,& ,,& (-& #.& 7/" #,

7(,/...( , )..5-&3 --5.#" #&(1.5.#, 8 (/ ,&,.,(#/,((- ,( / #3&- // ,#($ /62/(,/ 7 ,&(.

/$/ ,&7(.3(,(. - .(/7&(-&;: /#;& #.5(-(/, ,(1, . /#(#/,(6,& --5.# .,&61 (/#7(,&,&1(/,&- 2 5,& /& 5 /& 53(3;< / (/4&#($1 (/# 7(,&,& --5.# 2 5,& & 57& .$(-,(1;:

6 /<7 / 1 (/#7(,&,& --5.# 2 5, /& 5 5(/4,& ,( #3 --5.# 7 .

, '(/4/ 1. -& ,&..5-&3,& . (#7(,/...7

'/ 7(/4,&/ 1. ,& --5.# .(#.,& ,3,&6- 5# .

(#/,(6 --5.# " # /# &( (/ ,& - 5,3 7&/ ,&6 # .

7(,/... 4 (/.,,&1/#,&.-(-51., /-.3(,- // ,2. (#,& ,(, (. - .7&,&7(,/...& #/ -- .( /, . /#(#/,(6,& --5.# ,&,(1 - 11(..( / ,&-(1 ,& ,,&6& #(#/,((#,& --5.# /6 ,&(.,,(1(/,&- 5, &5.3 ,&(. .

/3,& . (#- /,/,( / /# 5/. ,& /,.(./ ,,/ 2

/4 . ,& - . 4 (/., --5.# " # /# &( (. - /-/#3(,., /#.56 $#B /#,( - 5,& .- /.(## -& /#$6 (/,(/#, ( 4 (/.,,&1 /#7(/#/ (4 (,6(/,& (154/#85#41/,.

.,&(- /$(-,( /(.- /-/# 7$34 #(/4 --5.# & '(3,& .-5,( /& . (# , $(,.- .26 /# .

/ 2# 52, (.,6 ,& .

/,& ,,& $(-,(1;:

6 /<7 / /#,&#($ /, - ;< / (/4& - 5#/ ,(#/,(6 --5.# & '((/,&- 5,- 5.3,&6(#/,((# --5.#" # /# &(25,4 #(/4,&(#. /7&/,&>5.,( /7 .

5,, ,&7(,/...4 #(/4&(.(#/,(,6,&6=..#,&(# 52, 2 5, &(.(#/,(,6..5-&3(#/,(,6 --5.# & '(- 5#/ ,2., 2(.&# 26 /# .

/ 2# 52, - /#63 /,&2 .(. - $6 1 2( & /2 /4(/4, $(-,(1;:

6 /<7 /3 --5.# & '(& .2/ - /$(-,#(/,&(.- .26,& /#,( - 5, 2.$(/4,& ,,& --5.#

& '(& . (#, = (/&(. ....( / $,&. (#1 2(& / #(#/ ,.& 7 ., & 7,&., /1 2(& /= ;:- 1(/, &(.

....( / &5.3.(/-1 2(& / ;:7 .- $# 1,&

* ....( / --5.# & '(3,& &7 .,&,&(# .. ( /, .,& /#,( - 5,

73(75.=%3(3- $611 4 #(/4 2(& /=3(,7 5#2- 1- ,& , ,,&,(1 -,(/4,& - $6 ,&(.1 2(& / 1,& ....( / --5.#% &# & '(3 (,7 ./ ,(#/,((#26;: .,& /2 /4(/4, &/- $611

=%3(,(/#.1/,( /,& ,,&1 2(& / 1.5/4% # )+)3 %

)+:A)A+ 25, ,& (. / , $/ / ( , $(#/- $ ( 2 /,&(.

., - //-,,&(.1 2(& /, ;:

# -51/, 6$(#/-& .2/2 54&, /((/,&(.- //-,( /,& ,,& 2(& /=7(,& . (#%/5127 . 7/# 5.#26 ;:$/;:7&/ # .7(,/..3#(#/ ,4($&1 2(& / /512/ (,.%/512/ (,.- 5 1 #..5-&3$/(,& . (#1 2(& /=7 .- $# 1,& ....( / --5.# % &# & '(3,& .-5,( /& . (#, - //-,,&(.1 2(& /7(,& $(-,(1;:

6 /<7 /. .5,3 .-5,( /- .- // ,2. (#,

2 $#26 /# .

/ 2# 52, 4 (/., --5.# & '(32/(, 7&(-& & ., 4 , &(1

,& .

/.- ## 2 $3(/#(/4/ 1(,(/ .

2 (/4

(# 26 --5.# " # /# &(3 1 (/, (/(/4 ,& (154/# 85#41/, - /$(-,( / /# # /./,/- $/# , 4 (/.,,&13,& . 1 #(.1(..# 7$3.(/-,& .-5,( /& . (#, $(,.- . 4 (/., --5.#% &# & '(26 /# .

/ 2# 52,3,& (/#(/4

1(,(/ 2 (/4

(#26% &#

& '(3(,(. --,# /# --5.#% &# & '((. ##, 2 ->5(,,# ,&-& 4 7&(-&& -#,( ## -- #(/46 D

ED E ? " +