High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/704/2005dismissed

Ranjit Kaur & ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2018-12-21Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu11 pages

!""

#" $% & ''(( % ) *% #+ '

& ''(( % ) *% #+ '

-%."'()"

* " " % #" $% & ' #$%& '()*+#,-./0+ $1/234$#%$ '()*+#,-./0+$#/'5+#3/'643/54, *

/"&(-,0! 0''(( 1

0 "

,&0! 0 &''((

$'"(,,3(0! 0 &' " " 1

#& &3#0) '% 4! - (0*% #+

$1/234$#%$7 5&"6%,7 3"(("' &!+"

5&' ''( !"7"

("" "

" % ,"

&#%,7 8

0 +4" " ()" 6%,0) ,%0"

)" ! 2

0"3&"!& & !!% #" $%0-%7($%05"' "

*()"

,&0 6 "

,&3!&,3" & " & !'% "&+(% )! " 1

01 0

0 89* !!% #" $% -%7($%3 ! "! !% )! " 1 9* % ,"7'" 7

(" '4"

:!& "

%( 3& % & % ,",%"7'" 7 ";7 & !!%5"' "

*( )"

,&0 6 "

,&3! "! !% )! " 1 : 89* % ,"7'" 7 (" '4"

: "

%( 3& % &% ,",%"7'" 7 ";7 & (( &!!%3(! "! ! % , ",%"7'" 7 &7 &% )! " 19* (( & !3 % ! !% (4 <&+ 7 &+ & ''(( #" $% &" ''(=%&"+ 5&! &'!% " % &((" &

0 )9*" 7)"

,&!"%=7""(>'" (0) ,%0,"

, 7"" -%7 $%3" &+% #%" )9*" 7)"

,&( ,3" & >-%7()"

,&0 +($"& )"

*>--+"

,&3

""( >'" ( 5&4 7 +( *3 $%7 & , 7, !4 >7 ''("! " + &! ."

,'"

3& & &' " 3" 7. & 7 5&! !( & ' " " 7. & 7 > +(-%7()"

,&3 &% 4," , 7 "

#%! ".7#" )"

1 )&,"((0" 77"" - (0) ,%!&""(>'" (0 ) ,% > + "

, &'"

&! & &"

#%3"

7. & 7 0! & 7 "

#%-%7 $% 5& ?;!% "," 7&" 7 & 7 >& &7 )9*" 7)"

,& )9*" 7)"

,&3' % " &7 )9(7&" 7 &7 &'("! " &%,& +($"& )"

,& @93," &+" &" 7 5&'("!' 43 &' -%((#" )"

*+&# )"

,&3(' &' %,&" '( 3'' >! '( "!+ (0! ,+% =% . "(07 !&+; &'"!+% !( & 5&3 . '" !4773'' 5&!!%3 !"37 &"+&

#%3 #"

>'" (0 * "(0 &30 & 3 7" " 0 A%&"

)&""

&&'" ( 2

<"(7,3 ," &'("!,"

, &-%7 $% > +( %.& ")"

,&3 0A%&"

( ,3" & &"( &! 5&"

=% ' 3'' 5&' 7 73( ! %! 9 ", " 3 !7'( !&(( 3 '% %' !7'( " (( &!(7(" " 5&'!% " ;7"

%7+3"

%'' &! 5& 7 &!!%3(!% )! "

11 * 5&4 " &! &'!% " 5&!!%;7"

! 5&!!%3! "! !0

"!+ 5&''(&+ "(+4 &''(( ,"

& #%,7 &( "(% * " " -%."'()"

&%+ !-%7 $%"( &"!"7" ("" & !7 ! "

A !% ( ''"

, +&( & ''(( &7 (4,% & &'!% " &"( '" ! A !% (''"

, &) &7 (4,% & &'!% " & '" !+4 +(%+ %'' &#%,7 &( % +(303&( !% ( &' " " %+7" & !74."

(4+ & ! <&&( !% ( &' " , &%,& &#%,7 !4!%((4 *< )%7 "'$%-3(&7"!(,((4;7"

-%7 $% )&3

4, )&3+%,& &&'" (+4 $%&(4 63 $% )& , '"

0 ?; * :0 & ''("! " '("!0?; * 0 & ' " -%7 $%, +%

B+% )& %=0?; *0 &)>0*("!) " 0) ,% )& &(," '"

* &''("! " & '("! & ' " -%7 $%3" 7. 7 )&&7 & 7 ?; *? 9 &!;7"

0&7" & -%7 $%3+%,& +4 &'("!!!7' "+4 3(" 3&7&&(47 "

&A )&'A *< ) #> ! %! &' 7 7;7"

> "! &((3"

#%" &+4-%7 $% C9 #%"

5&3%'"!"( '+% 7. ",& "!0 !.0 +!. % .0 +!.+ &%''; 7" "0 +!.

",& (3; 7" "0( &",&%' .

0!('

( "!0 '+ &&%( ( (,3 ' "

!(%"

, '7"%7 (3 '("! % ("

,% 3 %7 0+%

",& "!&&(&3"

,4 &7 &+% 3'&3"

! , %( "

"% ?'"7" "

3 + 7 & 3% '(!&'%3' D

5&!% &"

&"'"

3' "!7"!&!. %( ; "+% &;

B 5&3%"!" !% &"

4!% % % 3 7 7"

% 5&'++(% " + 3 #%" &3+% 37 &

";4 % " + 3 & ' 7 73+%

&% 9 &" !;7"

0 & '!""!((4 ' & " '' 7 7"!"

" ' 3" &

B +%

#%"'+% #%"0&!

+! !"% *< *+&' )"

,&"7"

>" 7 3 , ! #%,"

,&"+"(" 4 3 &=% " !! (4 >" &43"

> "" &

0" 3)% 4 >3 ' &&% +% 1

* 0&( ,3" &&"7 &-%7 $%3' &"&% >7 &3!( , &% "("

& ." !& >" - 7 & #" $% !7 "

& ." !& > !, " #" $%"

&!% )&3&("

,+ (! , . "( )&'"

.(. "( &7 &-%7 $% 4 ' (% -%7($%0 3&7&!, "E"

% 0 &"7 & "+4 &3"

,+% ,7 !& "!. $ "('"

.( & !( &&"7 &-%7 $%!%,& " )& " % % & ." !& >"% !(5"' "

*()"

,&0 3&7&(!, "E"

2 % 03 "

& &." !& > ''&"7 & '%&&+!."

&." !& >(!" 6 "

,&0 3&7&!, "E"

&% 0" & &74

+' &"

, "0 ",&+%!7 >'% +( .

& '% &(7 !!"

, &"70 &7 " ."((&"7 &+4 &!!%3 & &3'' 4"'% =% ( >" & 7 &% 7 &"&"

&"( >"

, 7 & % !(5"' "

*()"

,&3(%!

,"& &" & 63 $% $%&(4" >*3 $%7 %&&"7 & ""(>'" (0) ,% >" 7 3!+4 &'("! 9 &"!;7"

&' & " !+ 3 &" &% & -%(()"

,&3+% &(7"

% >"7 &3 . ""(>'" (3''"

&+( . >7" & $%&(4

63 $%3" &"7 & *< ".7)&,"((&! &4"

,!( " 7 +4 &! > "" &

0&3' ?;!% " ," >3 ""(>'" (0) ,%0 &'("!=% +% :

* >! & 7 -%7 $%"

& &'" ( )& 3 &"

, "% +% "

#%" !"

, & 7 0&+ "

7 &(4! " )%7 '

$% )&!( &' " " 7. 7 5& 0&! & 7 > ;'("

7 & &'(! & &%7+"7'" & 7 5& 7 3(", :

+4&"7 ) 7 "?; *A 5&%7+"7'" &' " & 7 "?; *A: >"", %?; *A: >7=% " ?; *? 5&'"

&! 3?; *?: >' & 3& &

7 37+4 &!0&7"

! !"% &%,&% 9

&"!;7"

0&' & 7 3!+4&"7"

&" 3 & 3" "

, <& &! & 7 &!0! 3 ' 5&! 3 "

,% " > .+% &%

% !& 7 1 *<2>*3 $%7' &

0&3 ' "

*("!) " " 4) ,% >( ,3" &*>--%7()"

,& 3' +&- 0) ,%0"

! " 3" &' (("

,% " 5&4&7!77 " & +4(! " 5&4!& & ' &&% %7+' 3 "

, (4+% -%7 $%33''"

+( . )&3("+% "

53(" $%&(4 63 $%3' & >7-%7 $% &""(>'" (0) ,% '" #'

*< )9,&#3 0A%&"

>'' =% ' 0?; *> >! & 7 -%."'()"

*7#" )"

,& > . &+4' 7 7;7" *< -%."'()"

,&' & #" $%3&"7 & 5"' "

*()"

,&3&"+ & -%7($%33"5"' " *()"

,& ,&3(+ &-%7($% 6 "

,& 3 &&%+ " -%7($% >"7 &"

&" ( 7& & >% 7 &"&"

& ( 7&" 7 & )&3(%!

03& &!7+!.0&!7 .

3+% &"

!" >3 ""(>'" (0) ,% )&3 #"

>'" (0* "(0+% & .& 0A%&" 2 *<8)9*" 7)"

,&' & &7 )%7 -3( >+ "

&! ?; *: 5&! !( &" #%

" 7. 7 >'% >-%7"()"

,& +"

,?;!% " ," !"

,& 7 *< ".7)&,"((!7 & &'" ( >! & 7 -%7 $% >3'

% " &7 4"

,!( " 0?; *A03& &"7 & & 7 0&7 7 ?; *A:

5&!!%3 +4&"7 >! '( "!+ (! ,+% =% . "(0?; *07 !&+;0?; * &'"!+%

!( &0?; *1

<& 7,7 &" !"!%&"

+" & -%7 $%37" *< -%."'()"

,& >7 &"

(3 #" $%&"

&" ( 7& & 5&3 "'% + 3 &+ &+% &"( -%7 $%3!( , & % "( "

& ." !&

+% 1

* >

*+&' )"

,&*< 3(' #" $%'"

.(. "( -%7 $% -%7($% & "+4 &3"

,+% , 7 !& "!. >!( &!%,& " )& " !' 5"' " *( )"

,&+(!.&;" 6 "

,&3('

5&4" & &+ ' )&3 . ""(>'" (0 ) ,% )&&!"

B+% )&37"!((4;7"

+4 )%7 ' $%-3( *< ".7)&,"((! &4"

, !( " &! !"

,& 7 0*< ".7 )&,"((+ "

&! 3& &-%7 $%3" 7. 7 >!& 7 &%7+7. &7 " ?; *A )& " 2

!!"

, ' 7 7 ' 0 -%7 $%"% ' "!7"&!.%( ; "+% +%

B 5&"

#%"3%"!" !% &"

4!%

8 % % 3 7 7"

% * 7 7;7"

3 ! %! +4 ) # > *< *+&' )"

,& 3 & 4 3"

>&," %(=% !!"7 >&"!( &

3&"!&&"7 &-%7 $%3 " >37"

0&30&" 7 3, ! #%,"

,&"+"(" 4 3 &=% " !! (4 & "7&3+% 4, ) 7 7"

(34+ . ! " " +% 3" & !% " 9 " &! &''(( & &3 % +4 & '!% "

*<2 > *3 $%7 & . -%7 $% ""( >'" (0 ) ,% ( , 3" & $%&(4 63 $% *< )%7 '$%-3(& "

& 7 & 3("&( !!7'

"3& '("!+%,& &"

#% 5&4"

,!( " 3 7+4 &!(% "(4 9 "(" 44"

,!( " *<

".7)&,"((&! & 7 + "

, &'"

*< )%7 '$% -3( -%7 $%& '% ( &%7+ "7'" & 7 !+4 ".7)&,"(( >&( ", &7 8 *< -%."'()"

,&&(' & &3"'% &7"(4=% &( "

&" +4&"7 & *( "!+ (0! , +% =% . "(07 !&+; &'"!+%

!( & 3 . "

'" +4 & '("! )" '( 3 ( ''

5&''(( &(;7"

! < 6'()"

,& "" & &3)'

!&"((,&

3( 5& 3"'% ,"

,( #" $%

< (3"

,&' & &.

3 ,& >" " -%7($%37" ) ,% <1 (+")"

,&&(7 7 =%!!% #"

,& 1 < -%'( )"

,& ' & & .

3 6 "

,& )"7"((40<#" )"

,&' & &.

36 "

<2>7#' & &.

35"' "

*()"

,& < )%#" )"

,&-3(0)*0) ,%0&! %! & =%"40"?; < : ("

!&+ '(! & =%"4' +4%+7" "

, & 6 "

,&3% "

5&! &7 " & &"3&(7" ," !,"

&7 5&" 7" "

&! &''(( & &!& !77" %"!" 5&3 !!" & !77" %"!" 5& 4"

, !( " 7 +4 & " (% 4 ("+( 5& " %

!4(4"

(,"

, &@9 A !% ( &''(( &(,% & $%&(4 63 $%3 ;7"

5&";7"

3 7 "("

"3 & 7 >*3

$%70 3& ' & 3& -%7 $% 3 . &'" (0 $%&(4 63 $%&(!!7'

" &'("! *< )%7 '$%-3(&(' & 3& -%7 $%3 +%,& +4 &'("!0&3!!7'

"+4 3(" 5&3

! &4"

,!( " =% " 37 !& '% & &%7+"7'" &4"

,!( " 0?; *A:0"

&' ! ".7)&,"(( 9 &4"

,!( " 0 7(( &!!%3 7

2 5&'(("+"&",& (4+ #! +4 & "(% 5& !!% & ! " % % (3%( 7+(4 !77" & 7%-%7 $%3" &!77 +#! 5&'!% " & ' & 7 " 5& ''(( ."(( -%7 $% +4 '"

.("

, . "( &3"

,+% ,7 !& "!. 0 &' 3& . &'(("+"& ' &70"(" ,3&"!&" 3"((+ '%7 & &' 3' &'

& '4 & ' " " 3" & , & !7 !"! ! 0 & "(% &3=% ! &''(( 5&"! (("

&! ,4 !

!"!(("

&3(( #%,7 &( "(% 5&" 7" "

&''(3(( & !"7"

("" 5&7&+4"7" 8 (( &''(( +"( 5&"+"(+ !

!(( 5&4+!77" #"( % , &"7"

,' ! #")&7 6%,

,&)"&% 6%, <& &'."

,: F: <& &' +( F: