Sanjay And ORS. v. State Of Haryana
!"#$% &&$''
"( )$%(*(
"$!+
$(&!
$ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, - % $$&.*/ % &&$''
)$%(*(
"$!+
$(&!
$ "$!+ $01(1!
23 42 564
) 7
!"#! !$%#& '
($") $ $$ "
+" !,-
%#& '
($") $ $$ "
.
*/0
,$%.0%1 2
33333333 ) 78 $ 4!" &55
!$$" * 6# ,& "5"$ ** $ !
2 ) !
5 78&!$$ ( 5 -)(5 &#"& "
4!
$ !# 6
"$ &!$$ ("( !
-)(5 &#"& "
%#"
,!"&!% !
&&) 9** $$ !
"%5 $2
*:)5 %-2
"-
%,
$()"$ 2 &55" " *)" !6$ )
& " ;
;9;<8
," ! & ";8 ,
)
( "( ) "5* " 5 *
"<2 *2" %9 &!=" )$ *25 " % !
2,
)
)
( "( ) "5* " 5 2
& !
& % *
* &) "%
!
%+ 5 (
( "(5" ""-)
%5 $2+"-2
% 5:" !%""#"$1 *" $,
"# % )6 >) ,!"&!%1 "$(," ! 6$
"(!
&!
"#"$1 *" $% *
6 ""( !
)> 5 !
& !
&*2 !
'%!
& "-)
+"-2%,!
"%+"-2 ! !
" ( "&)$ ) " !
2
6 !
%
6) ?
%!
!" 6 !
%5 $2+"
%,
&5"(6&/
"( !
, /" !
"
$+", ,$/"( 6) ,/"$$ 6 !" !
5,!
!
2
&!
" !
"
$ !"% ,!"&! " " & 6) ,/"$$ 5 !
)6 , $$%&&)
* ! , "( ," !: "!
&5
&5*$" !" 6 !
! $ " 6 "( )(! !
5 ("#"( $*,!"$ ,
$"(," !!" 6 !
+""
4!
* (# $$/ & >) $2%-2 "-
% .! 5*$% ," !@ $,%&5 ) !
"
$ 1
*(# "
& : "6$, !
&5*$" +"-2 -2(# @ $,6$, !
"(! ! !
&5*$" ,!"&!!" !"
$6, A!
!
&5*$" $$, !
( )%"-
(# 6$, @ $, 5 !
* ( " ,!"&! !" !
"(! !"(! !
&5*$" 4!
&&) -2$ (# @ $,6$, !
;
,!"$ "-
(# @ $,6$, !
) ,"
5 !
" * ( %,!"&!% /" !
/)$$
,
)* )
%
)$ !
6$,("# 62"-
," !@ $, 4!
&5*$" !" 6 !
"
$ 5!
"( !
5 @("
@":)5 !" 6 !
+"
$ !
5 !
#"$$( &5
&) 5%!,
%&&) *
$ ,2 5 !
* ," ! !
& "# , * !
"( /"$$ !
5 !
2 4!
%+"@("
/ !
!
! *" $ 4!
" , !
*$"& "
("
" !
& % !
6 " ,!"&!% 5$78,
("
= B 2
* ,
&$$ 4!
%&&) *
,
&5*$ " !
"# "( "%&!$$, *
4!
"$) 5 &! ( )
& " ;
;9;
?9;<
," ! & ";8 % ,!"&!&&) *
*$ ()"$ 2 &$"5 "$
4!
&) """ #" C5" .
:
0 "
A%5 / ! , " A %8915:" ! A;%1 )6! !!
A% 6$ -2:)5 A%.
0 .
! 5 A?%.
) !* )" A<%+"-2! 5 A
:)5 A %+" A% 6$ -*$ A 1 " A
.
) !* )" A<% ,! 5 "&$ ($$2 C5" !
"-)
*
%5 $2+"-2
%"!
% ! +"-2 )
$$,"("-)
8&"
,)?C&5 *
#
#$ !
/)$$ 7
! 6$
"( , *
#"
B 2 /)$$ ) ( D *""
6 "*
#
$
$ * & "(! !"(!
C &5 ;
) "
C&5 *
#
"(! $6,
" !"&$)
*
'"-)
%" , ) ! !
)
$&
,) C&5*
#
#$ !
/)$$
"&$$2*$& 7
!6$
"(, *
#"
B 2 ) ( D *"" 4!" ," )
! *
*""EC :9%"-) !
"-)
+"-2, (
) $"
A +"-2! 5% !
,"
% )**
&) "#
" !
*:)5 (# : "6$, !" !
5" ! **" " -2(# $ !"6$,!"
"(! $6,,!
!
$$,%"-
(# @ $,6$,!" "(!
!"(!," ! !
" !
( 8 " )
! !
-2%62) "(!" @ $, $ !"%(# 6$, !
4!
% !
2,
&) / ! *" $
A
% !
," %$ )**
&) "#
" 4!
&) ")
C5" A+",! $ )**
&) "#
" 4!
!
"&"$,"
* 6) !
"# "( " &)& 62 !
5* # $$ !
&)5 ,!"&!,
*
) "( !
&)
"# "( " 4!
% " !
& )
& " ;;
% !
&&) *
)* ! !
&5*$" * &) "-) !
&&) 5 $2
* !
&&)
# !"5 A!"$ $ "( !
#" % !
** $$ !#
C5" .A .
!$, % "&$"&
%7 "6%,! ! *
'%&)& 62!"5%!
) !
$$,"("-) !
&&)
*:)5
8&"
,)
C
&5 , *
#
$
$ ) & $ !"(!
$ 6$, *
4,"&"
,)
C
&5 &!#
$
$ ) & $ 5*$& -& $2%&$ 6$,
;
) "?C &5 #
*
" 65"$,$$$ " ?&5 55"$"
"&$)
4!" ," $ ! !
&$ !
*,
6$ " * # !" !"
EC . 2-5 EC .
$ # "( 5' EC . .A 1 6"
"(! $ * # !
&$ !
, 62
*:)5 EC .EC .
4!
"$) %
"(6 ! !
* **
&" "( #"
& %!
$ !
$$ ()"$ 2 &55" "
*)" !6$ )
& " ;
;9;<8
," ! & ";8 ,
"& 6#
%(( (" !
"-)(5 &#"& "
%&&) 9&#"& !# "$
** $ 8 " , ! "&"(!
! ) "( !
&2 !
** $ % !
&&) 9** $$ 5 $2"-
! "
!
** $>)!"5 6 %#"
<
'
$ $$ !# () ! !
"$ ) ! , ($2!
$ ! &! ( )
& ";<8 " * # (" $$
8 " () 6 !$ !
$$ ! " , & ) "(! ",!"&! %** $$
*:)5 ) " "-)
? !
&) ","
! 6
6$ * # !,!
! ) " "-) ,!"&!" * # 62'EC . , $$ 5 !
.A .
!$,
'
$ $$ !#
!
*"" ("# 62& EC :9%,!
"%**$"& "5# 62 !
*$"& EC
:%
/"(*""%,!
2 ) " 62+"-2, (
) $" " " 2&"
&)5 & *
*""%" , (
) $" 6) !
& <
*" !
("( !
)(! !
*
B 2 /)$$%4&%,!"&!" &" ," !E.1% !
)
"-) +"-2" (
) $" " ,
*" ! !
) " 62 !
, )"&"
&) !
'
$ $$ !#
$"
)*
!%,!
" !" ) ! !
$ )
F ! " 52% A! "5*$2 &$
"-) 2= &)$6 (
) $"
"( !
62% , F(
) $" G
>)"#$ (
"($" G )&!& >)
$2&#
," !" 56" &$) E"(! !$2 & ";
8 %,!"&!"
*)" !6$ )
& " ;
? 8 4!
" "& " ,
!
, F(
) $" GF (
"( $" G&5 6
5" 62."#" " &! !"
) ""
$
& '" , !
$ )
F1 $% ! !
C*
" D(
) D " - & "# !
C*
"D (
D" #
"-) 2,!"&!&*) $" ""55 " (
!,)$6 "-) 2,!"&!&6
D(
) $" D% !
%,!
&
"6 "-) 2 D(
) $" D%!
5
< "-) 2,!"&! (
$" "
5&$) & ";
%8"
$ % %" "6
"-) 2D(
) $" D$2 *) * !
"&$)
1 " ) "( !
C*
" ! !" , "-) 2,!"&!D (
$" D "6 " D(
) $" D%5 "(6 ! !
"5
5 !"(G 4!
5 #"
,, C*
62 !" ) "& #
$(
') ($ '
('
# $( "5"$ *
"5"$ % ! "-) 2 "6 62 !
& D(
) $" D"
"
2 ! 6)
"5 $25 "&$" !
, $"/ $2 "
)&!
2* "-) 29*""" !
2* !
2 ,)$ & !
#" " & ";<8 %,!"&!
#" ( "-) 2 )"&"
" !
" 2&)
)
&) !% )&!"-) 2,)$$$," !" !
56" &$) E"(! !$2 & ";
8 %,)$6
*)" !6$ )
& ";
?8 "#"
, )&!
*""% &! ( )
& " ;< 8 & 6
) " 4!
$,$"," !
"-)(5 5) " 5) " " **$"&6$ !
& !" &
4!
%" " !
$ ! ** $$
" 5"(!" " 5* &55" 5)
A%6) !
$2 " &) ( #) "-) 1 & * "6$26 $()"$ 2 5* 5)
," ! !
"6 )
& ";<8 4!" & ** $$
" 5"(! >)
$2$$ ," !" !
56" &$) E"(! !$2 & ";
8 %,!"&!" *)" !6$
)
& ";
?8 4 !" % !
"$&)
** !# ( $ ($$2 , ( " !"
$ # & & " G 46)
()5 %$ $ $$
!# $
$"
)* *
(
$ +,
'
'
'
$ $$ !# !) () ! " !
6 2 * &""&*"" ! !
) " 62"-)
+"-2 ,
)"&"
&) !" " 2&)
)
% !
"$)
!
" !$"( !
** $$ ()"$ 2 &55" "
*)" !6$ )
& ";<8 % !
% !
&#"& ")
& " ;<8 " $"6$ 6 &#
" & ";
?8 '
$ $$ !# )
)65"
! " , & ) "(! ) * #& "&&) ,
$"(%,!"&!, !
$" !
#"$$( %!,
% *
#
"("# " !
78" !
6 & #
" &&)
*:)5
$
"# "-) % !
&#"& " !
$$ )
& ";< " ) "6$
'
$ $$ !# )
() ! "-) 2 % ) " 62"-)
+"-2%" "6) ** $$
:)5 ,!! $
2)
( *
"5 ! 2 %
&) 2&
""& "$ 2") !
"6) ** $$ -2
"5*$ % !
% !
&#"& ")
& ";< " ) "6$
'
&) $% !
6 " !
&) 2&
""& "$ 2") %&)$ " *) ()5 "
62$ &) $ $$
*
!
&) 2 &
""& % 6 ! !
** $$ !#
)
( ;5 ! %?2 5 ! %2 %
& "# $2 2
"#$# "2 !
&
'
&) $&)$ " *) & ! !
78
" !
2 )6 >) !
%*
"$5 ?2
! $* " !
"
"(*
"% !
" &5*$" 5 !
&5*$" " ! !
$$ !#
2 )&!"&" % !
2!# !, )6 "# "5* # " !
&! &
"($ $ * *
) "( !
& #" %8"5
" " !
** $ 8#"
, !
A<.
) !* )" , $$ *""("# 62!
%,!"&! !, ! ,!"$ 5"( !
*""% "-) 2 % ) " 62+"-2%, 6 (
) $" ," !)
& "( !
" & " 6 !
5 "&$
* ! !
"-) ) " 62+"-2, )"&"
&) !" " 2&)
)
% !
%"#"
, !
-)(5
" - . / " " ) ! !
""(
& 62 !
"$) ! !
$$ )
& ";<8
&
& " " & ,!"&!" & $$ )
& ";
?8 8 " !
$62 !" ) "+,
'
' ! ,!"$ & "
"( !
) " 62"-)
% #"& "5" " $ &5* ")
& ";<
, "( !
&5* "%" " ) 2 !
) / " & "
" !
"&"$* " " !
&&) ** $$ *2 !
&5* " 4!
*
"# * !
-)(5
)
F
* "(," ! !" -)(5 %" " *
" " ! &5*$" "
:) ! )
;
"-) " !" &
!
, , 2 &5* "62 !
$ "$)
)
62 !
)
& " ;<
, "( !
&5* "%" " !
) 2 !
) / " & "
" !
"&"$ * " " !
&&) ** $$ *2 !
5) &5* "
!
,"
% !
, "( &5* " !$$ 6 ) "$
&"
" !
5 &)$ 6
&#
) , /"&"$* " " !
&#"& 8 !
" & % !
$$ " $5<2 (
1
" 6 "(
" !
** $62 !
'
($ ") $ !
, 6$ (( !"
&) $ !"5" !
** $, #" '
($") $ 4!) % !
$$ ! )"&"$* " " *2 !
&5* "
1,
% !
"-)
&5*$" "
:) & "$$ 6 ( &5* " )
!
+"& "5 5* "&!
* #" )
& ";<
% 62 !
."
"& '
($
#"& ) ! " 2% :*) !$ 4!) % !
& &5*$" "
:) "
!
."
"& '
($
#"& ) ! " 2% :*) !$ & "
( &5* " !
)
+"& "55* "&!
*
& " ;<)6 & "
G ! !
$ $%** "(6 !$ !
$$ % )65"
! "& 2
$ ($"&) $ !
$$
* $6)
% !
&5* "526 *" "-)
*
+"-2
62 !
."
"& '
($
#"& ) ! " 2% * && "($2% & "
"( !
6# & &"
&)5 &
$
* $2$$, %,!"$ 5"2"( !
! !
, !
$$ "
)& !
"$
2)
( 62 !
5%!,
%"
5 & ";<
% "-)
+"-2
, &5* " %9 %9
& "# $2 "& !
"$ ) !
"5* " %9 &!% !
$$
"
* "
%9 &!," ! !
"$) 98$$>)("
," !"*
"
5 ! 5 2 !
5 ,"$$ 6
* !
&5* " 6 *" !
""-)
*
!
6$&
5) !$$6 *"62 !
."
"& '
($
#"& ) ! " 2% * 8 " 5 &$ ! " !
$$ "$ * " !
5) " ," ! !
"$) ," !" !
"5 "*)$ % !
$ !$$6
!# 6
" 5"
"$9 )
26 %"2%,)$ " &! ( %&& "($2 *! &*2 !"
6 *$& !
"$ !
& &
3 9 ) 7: