Surinder Pal Singh v. Ram Singh And ORS.
!" #$ %&'!&( )
*'&+& !*,- ""& .&'
!/*,-0"-& 1+"
!" "!#
&"$ 2& 2'+,)+#!")
&"-1""& 33333 "!# $
%&'( -#!-!!#-4'&+-"&( -1&"&1""+&#"+!,!""-&+&+!"+ 5 678'& 9 :);-&%("-%<#"1""1& &&+%("- 1""& 2!,!*,-!+!;! !&=!->!'&+&)-! %+/+ 2& 2'+,)!&+#'&1&","-1""& '%/""-!" !&=!->!'&);-;!;& "--'+1'")-!+ 8#'"+!!,&/""+!"+5? 5&1#" -'/!'&,
/!&!)"'!"+!+1'&*!-%)"&#" '1!,!&;"- !/*,- !+<;!">!'&-!
&/"+!,&/""#'+"% 1& &/+ #"!", "-+ " ""'""-'"-'" ;! +#&+%("-"&!'&"+<'+,/"!++#&+!"+@ - !11! 1& &&+ ;! ! +/+ !+ "- ,'!& *#+ 11! 5A5A 1+,!+<'+#!""-'&"!+"+ & -!&, 56
-& "&/ &+& "- ! &/"+
,'!&*#+11!
2&2'+, '&"-&'%/""-!""-#'" +%(*'&+&
!*,-!+/&=*,-!,!" !/*,-!;!!+<;!">!'& #-!,,"-!
&/"+<'+,/"!++#&"-1&/"-!""- -'+1'"1'&#-!+"-!/ !&=!->!'&%("- !"-&) !/()2!,!*,-;!'" "-! "-1&1&"();-#-;!! !#"&!1&1&"()1+,!+<'+#!";&)#"-& "&/"!("-!11!)!8#'"!11#!";! +%("-+#&9 -+&"-1&#+,)"-&+1!&"(%<#"-!% +)%'""- !/-!%+/+'//!&(;"-'" &!/,"-' !#")"- '&"%;;!;!(+!;!( &/"- !#""-!"!&!+(!#'"-!+ % +-'&";!&4'&+" &!/"-'!"-1""&-!+ "'1!"""-1&1&"("-1&/"-!"--!+!&,-"%(%&"-"- 1&1&"(*#"-!
&/"+%<#"1""-!%+/+ ;"-'" &!/,"-')"-!11!!!,+'+& &+& '
5 ;'+")%'"(!&'11&" -#"") &'1"-&!"+#++#'+'"%("-B%*'1&/'&" ')& *+'
,'
-+&.&/0,/'0'
, -+&$ 1%1( %( 1$ ;-& !&!,&!1- )!/!&%&!";! "#+%("-*'1&/'&"!+"-/!""&;!&/!++""-,- '&" "- 1&/ "-!" # "-& -! % !+<'+#!") !
'%&+!"'&"8&#"<'&+#"""+"%(!;& !" 8&#"-<'&+#""+)("-&;'+ -! -!&+ "- !&+ #' & "- 1""& !+ !11&!+"-1!1&%= "- &"%'-)2&2'+,-!+&!+"-%<#""-!" /1',+&+&;'+%!11!!%-'&" "-;"-!""-
2 &;'+%/!"!!% ;"-4'"1+% &"-'&";-&!1!&"(-!+ !&!+(!!+"-&/+( !'")#!-C-%1&/""+"""'""- "-&+1!&"(%<#"!!,+'+& &+& '6& )"- !;&;'+%DE) &)'#-1!&"(#!"%1&/""+""!""- 1!&!1&#+,))7:'"F!+7:/'"!'%<#"-'" 1&&"/"-!"-%<#"";'+%!1""&1&+'#1& &+& ' " 5 $9
!
" # "$ % &
!'
'
"
(
'
) "
( %*
"
!
! (
"( ' $ "
"(
'
"
"(
!
!
' ( + '
"
( !
"
"
'
(
' $ "
( '
'
"
"
# ! ( +
( ( ,
"( $
*
( ' $ "
1 # "
("(
( ! (
" + "(
( &
'
% * (
!
#
"
'
!
&
!'
'
"
(
'
) "
( -
" .
'
' '
(
'"
! '
/
# #
" "(
'!
"(
!
'
( ' (
(
!
" ' " #
%0
"
1 '
(
"
+
# "
("( ! ' $ "
(
! !
2+
3 4
4
"(
!
3 5 "
*
"
#
" "
!
!
67
' )%+)1&+"-!"!"-4'"&!","&,-") "" & "&" "- 1&1&"( &!" & "- !+<'+#!" "- !11#!")-!%+!";"-"-!11#!"!+"%(!1!&!"'" - &/+( & "- 1""& ;! " = "- "&/ "!( "- !
&/"+'"&"-1+, ,'!&*#+11!)%'"""
%<#"-'&")+&+&+!"+A ?-!+"!;+"- 1""&"%/1!++!,!&1&"!" !&=!->!'&!";! 1!++"-!""-&;!#!- "&"-(;&&1&"+"= /1!+/"+1+"#!1!#"(%(/,!!11#!"'+& &+& ' -!
&/"+ +, /+&+ &/"- &!"+#++#'+'" .,4'5'-.&/' +'
6 -+&$
3%3( 12 "-%!#=+&1 "-/!""&)!/ "-;"-!""- "&!'&"-!&,-"(+/+"-%<#"!'//!&(/!&-& ;! ##! & "-"&! '&" " &!/ "-' ;, " "- 1+#( "-#'"";!#'/%"'1"-%<#"&"1!# &#&+/+#% &"-'&"!%,"" &!/"-'%( "",'1!""))&,-"%(%&"-"-!#"&!1&1&"(!,&/" "#!!;!(%1& &/+%("-,!-&#! +/ "- +&-&!"-1 "-1""&%, !&=!->!'&-!"
%++/(;)"-&;!+ &!/,"-';," "-1+#( "-'" 2&2'+,+'&,"-#'& "--!&,)-!& &&+"
7 "- <'+,/" &+&+ %( "- '&" 8&') 9' :+'4'-$ ''
;/& .&/ '*,++'
,'
, -+&$<%1(%(727;"-&,!&+ ""-1&#+'&1&#&%+'+& &+& '!+ -& +1'"""-!
&/"+<'+,/")%'""- !#" "-/!""&-& "-!""-&/+(-!!&!+(%!!+ !+"-!%# !( $
1& &,-"%(%&"-)"& &#;!&&!"+ -&!"-&!1#" "-/!""&#++() !&=!- >!'&;!;& "-1&1&"(%(&"' !++ ?6)"-')-)! 1&"-1& *#" @7 : "-+'*'###");! !%'";&
&"-&!"!"+!%),&'+ &"& &# /!+'" 1"""!++/+ ( %&!" / -! " % #"&'+ ! ! 81& 19!9"-1+,'")!,+"%1+,!" "-"!# "-1""& =0&/'&4$ %"!# ( &')+ >8
#+-+&;'? *@&' , A@
#+-+&; &-'0 A@