← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2294/2004allowed

Subh Ram v. State Of Haryana

2022-08-17Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan25 pages



     

  





"" #$$  %&

$'      ($



 

! ) 

'*



 

-.) '*



( 

/'*) '* ""



,0$!

! ) $$,$ '* 1") %&

22222     

4 $!"") $  $, $&  

, , $ 

-"&, %$,") 1. (", , 6'&.

#,!) 1. .'

'

,$$, ,0'

$ 1,'!,) 8 '! !9 , , ,) 4 0  ,.!

!, '

:,$ 4*$,.,.

,84  + !$,"



;,'

  ,$$ ,0'

7 $

%+*) $, ,0'

,'

,

7 $ ) !) '

$,

% ., + -"&, %$,"

< '& ,

5

  ,,.

,, ',.

' .'

,$$ ,0'

7 $ , ,*)

 ''

$ ,0'

  

(9 , ",) $ ) ",8,0'

$'

,$ ',.

$,$$ $ !*,.

 ,

, '

'!9 "$ +$ 7 ,.

.,$, = 4>?9 

+!," $,,.

,) ' $ !!" 7$!

@ ' $ %7

,.!) !

$,'$ '! + "$ $,,.

!9 !   

()

$ ',) 8 '!  ""'

 

,9 ", ',."& +  '9

 ,'

$$ 0& #,0&9

$,'

", !",.

7$!

 +"'

'$ .,$

'&) !& +"'

!

"$$ !9 ", "'

+"'

.,* *,' .,$ & '&9

+!,") ' 7$!

+ "$ ,.

+'$ !+*)  !& "'

!

 ",) 0& ("

#,0& !

$$

.! !"'

", !

.* "+ ""

 ,, 7,""

!,,.

", " $,' !$9 $""& ", ""

'9 ' 7$!

,*'

$'

", 

"!$ $') +! +!," "*,.

$ !'

", $*'

'&  +"'

7,""'



 ",8,0'

!  *'

-"&, %$,") 1. !$  "& (+ 0 9

',.

",) 7+ "$ 7  ."$$ 7 $,'$ ' .,.

$!$ $!$ ""

 ',.

$ ",8,0'

A< () 4 0  ,.!

 '$ "+ $ A< (83 ! $ ; $, !.!

$ " -,$! $,$ "

:4 A< (- ''

4 ,"

9 !

+ "  '

.!

$, " ! A< (19 7 , $$$$, "'

$,'

"!$ ",8,0'

,

$!,) ,  ") +!,  *$ $,'

 '+ !''

*



' ) ',"

,) -"&, %$,") 1.9 "!$ + *'

, ") $"'

$"

!*,.

,$,, B-%B "

$,C'

*,' *&

 A< () $'

+,$$$

:! ,*$,., ,'

 4 ,"

!, '

" 4*$,.,.

,9

$'

!,$ 3

?

,.') ',.

$ $'

',$"$ $ A< (> 3D

?

7 "'

""

!  $,',"

!$  $,.

, 

"!, ",.

, + +""

7 , "!, "'

. *'9 ! $ ',$"$ $ )

"'

& ',$"$'

" . ""

 , "!, *'



$$$$,) + 7 , $$$$,) *,' *&

 A< () $'

+,$$$9 '

.!

$7!$ 7 , "!, ""

A< ( (( $,*"&9 $, " " *& '

A< (=9 "!, ""

".

"'

$,'

"!$ ,0'8 ", + $ :$, , > &) '! ) %&

 3

0& ("

$$,'

,*$,., $9 !+*) !  "& #,0& ("

'

, $" ,*$,., ''

4$  ,.!) %

$,

 ", ,*$,., ! ",,$) !"" .,$

0& ("

'

,"'



 $, !""  F',,"

.,$ 3$ "$$) 1.) ,$ ' $ ",'

 !, + $",'

 $$ *,''

' ,  (  ! ,',.

 ' , 4( <"$,*"& , "  $$,$) "'

F4) 1.

,'

 $$,$) *,' ' ''



+! , $$,.'

''"

$$,$ F'.) 1.

 , !"") ,',.

, , $) !. $ ' ,$ E8E ?

'

, D 4(  '

.,$ !

$'9 '',,) !.  ' , 5  $   '

.,$

"''

.,"& ", '

,"

,.

$ $, *,') $, < ,'

""+,.

+,$$$ (G3

 ",8,0'

*,''

" *$, ,,') '$,.

$ $, $&

(G 7$!

! & +,$$ ,,' '$'

 $, *$,

(GD !

+ ) .!$ ) (

,) :,' '

$'

3

*,$,'

$ '

$"'

$, " A< (  ,$,$ .,* !

) ,0'

(G 

 #$!,$) ',"

,) -"&, %$,") 1. $'

5

+!," +7,.

*& !$,"

' '&) ;$) .,* ,$$ ,, .'

, '"'

,0'

,

7 $

% *'

$!

,, A< (

(G5 4 0  ,.!

$'



+!," $'

 (", , 6'&.

#,!) 1.) '&) ,*'

',"

; 7  

-"&, %$,") 1. ! !'

! ',.

$ ,0') !

*'

 ",, A< (  ,,.

,, ' .',.

,$$ ,0'

7 $ 9 '

' *,' '$ '"'

,0'

,

7 $ 9

 ! $'

5

., + -"&, %$,") 1.

*'

",, A< (A '

' +! '"'

,

7,.

$

H!) ''

$ ,0'

A< () ,.

'$ A< (83 "+ ,) $',.

; $, !.!

$ " -,$! .,$, :4

% ! '$'

.',.

7,.

, $$$$, "!$ ,0'

.,*

'  *,.

, , $"'

") *,' *&

 A< (:

% $'

. "  '

.!

$, " A< (1 ,',, 7$!

' +,$$$  $,) '$,'

"

,,.

"!$ ,0'

% $!

9 ?

*'

 ",, A< (% '  ,,.

,,    ,0& '

$ ,0'

3

?

$'



 +! $'')  ,,.

  '&

(G?

% $!

) "

+,$$ ''

,'*, *,' A< (F

(GE $ " ' ,.!

'$'



+!," $'

 (", , 6'&.

#,!) 1.) '&) % $!

!''

* "!, "

'"& $"'

'$,,.

$ :>) '! 

% !''

* !$ ,"$  :> $ ',,

 (G 4$ $!

("

'$'

D

3) +!," $'

% ( 6'&.

#,!) 1.) '

 ' , 3ED  ( 

(G 4 ,"

$'

5

+!," $'

4  ( 6'&.

#,!) 1.) '&) 4 0  ,.!

$ +,,.

A< ( !.!

$ " -,$! $,$ +!,!) ''

"

:4 A< (- 3

?

:4 ," !''

*

,*$,.,

% '$'

.',.

$,.

',$"$ $ 3D

?

A< (> $ $;"&) .,.

""

, $  *'



$$$$,) $,C'

*,' *&



% '$'

.',.

!  "&'

,*$,.,

(G3



 !$!

-!) , $") -"&, %$,") 1. $'





() , '

,'

.& +') ,$"& ''



',"."

,, '



' ) 

'&

% *'

  & ,, A< (I) '

$,.'



' ) +!$ $,.$ !'

+,,.

,',,'

! $'

; $ 

' $,

% *'

'$



' ",, A< ( '",.

, ,

7 $ ) '$ ,.

A< (83

% ! *'

'$



' A< (I83   ,0& +"'

.,* "

% *'

$*"

!

 ' $ !'



' ) ! $,.

?

*'

 ",, A< (% 

,',.

 ,0&

' '$ , !*,.

,0,$ <,""& *, " $,' "$$ "'

H! , .,* + ,$ "'

".

4# ",'$

% *'

'$ A< (%83 ",,

% ! '$'

$ ",,)



' .,* ,',.

$,.

$ $. , '

, "'

'.$ ",

% *'

'$



' A< (%8

1,.

! !,$ +,$$ $'

, '

 ,0&

(",$

$" ,'

, <,""& *, '

(, ',$!.'

?

H  ;$,) +!! ,0& $ ,0'

'.$ ",  J .* $+ , "& "

"',.

, *, ,   

4 , "& '

,0& "'

'.$ ",

% $'

+



' ,$ $*,.

!, !$,"

$ +! $  7+

H! ( ", ($ ''

*,'  ! ,"

A< , A< (% !) "$'

*,' $,

 $ + ''

' , D3D  (  ""

,, ,,.

, $$ ,.

$, *,' .,$ + 

 !&

 ','

"".,$ ',.

!& + ,

H! "

""+,.

 K 



             



   

          !"

#        $    

% 

     #

   

   #  &  $ &     #   



     ' $       $  &        &        $   #    (  )         *

   $  #       



$    & 

    $     $  #              +      *  (#  $

     $ 

  

 

   *

       

 #    

  $                        

  * (  #     *  , -.

 & %      

 (   # &

               & 

               $      ! # (  ##   # .  $ #$           

/ $    0 $       $  (     121#

% #  $        &  $  $ &   #    $

                   +

 "3 +" "

""4+546,0 .     $               #&    &      %    $            

  G!$) $'

$'

, "$"& , ",'

,.

$ $  $  "* ,

,.

!, ' *,') < ,'

! +,$$$

G3 

 -

!'*) ',"

,) 1"

%$,") 1. $'



''

',"."

< ,,

$ ',) .'

  5 &$ +! .! $ " 0 =

D '

""+,.

,0,$

    ( 8  $   $ #        

& 9!

, $ #  #     & 9!

"

,  

  #  (# 

#   & 9!

  (8#  $  0  :(" ;          , $ # $     & 9!   G 

..+") ',"

,) 1"

%$,") 1. $'

' $$'

& .,$) 1. ''

3D

?

'$'

',"

,') 1"

%$,") 1.) ".



0& =" ''

',"."

< ,,

$ ',

H! < ,, ''

 '

( !,$& ,.

$$"'

H! ."

',, , ,

H!&  $*'

""+,.

,0,$ ,   $    # $   

  .  $   &   

  (8$     & #   "

0   (8       $    $ #

5( 5 &  # #    &      $  

0   

&   #  

.  $  (   &  

< $ # <  

 = ,  

&     .  $  (     $ # $  &  

GD $! ,.!) ''"

!"

'

 !

-,$! ) F) 1. .! $

'

," ,"'

#$

4 ,"

!$ ',.

 F) 1.

% $'

$,'

",) !* "'& $

'

' ,$ D) DD) DD

?

4(  ,"

% *'

,,'

& ", A< GD8

G,!

' *,' . "$'

?

 !,.

. $) ,"

) *,' 0'.

''

) *,'

$ ' ,$ E8 E ?

4() +!$ $'

0& ("

;,'

!.  '

.,$

 $ ' $$'

*& '&)

$'

'. ,.$

 , ,$

4 ,'

&$ & , $

8  ,$! " 68$ 4(9 '" & ,) ! '. 4 

!9 $ ' , E ?) $'

'. 4 ,'

&$

""

$ $,* $$ , ,$ + ''

 "&

:",.

..,*'

0'.

*,, ' $)

,"'

$ ") , .,* ) !$  

H! "

7  D

) +! , '

,'

." !,.

*,' ' ''

5)  ",, ' , D  (  ,"'

""8$'

'

 ,,.

$ ''

$$''

$ 0 ,$!,.

;,$, '$ $,$, !, F',,"

.,$8& .,$) 1.

=+ "

!$  ,"

!,.

!* !'

"'

$"

""8$') "'

 $"

$,'$ .,.

!.!

'



>'

$"

"" !$ ''

, .'

0'.

*,, ' $ $$'

.,$ ""8$'

 $$, " *,$ $$

H!

, "$ ,$'

!,$ .'

 ""+

,H! '"& !$ ,.

 ,$ !

,,' 7 "





( +!$ $ ", ''

 -"&, %$,"

1. 5



( ,

 '"& !$ ',.

!,$ ,') ", $,, ,  , "$ $& $ , ", !,$

,,H! ", . ,* !$,"

 -"&, %$,"

! ! .,.

1* !$,"

-"&, %$,")

,"'

!,.$ ,$ !

' ,'

,

7 $ 

+!

',"

'

.$ $!+ $,$ "'

 $ $  ,,'

,,,H! 7,.

'*. '"&

7,.

$ ",) $, !$ ,'

$!, * ,,' ,$ !

,,' 7 "   !0"& ".,.

$'9 ',$ .'

", 7,.

7$ ! *!,"$  $!$  0,.

$, '

$,$$ !, $) !+*) ", ','

& & !'

 ) ".

! !$  

. $, $ 

 ,,' .  "'.'

 $ " $

',"

< ,, 

1* !$,"

%

',".""& < ,'

!

,*H! ", & ..$$ $* $"*$ 

$,) !& !* '

!,$ *$,

*H! ,., .$,$  !* $$$'

*,4 $''  !  , ",.

*,,H!

,* $..$'

$, ,$ *,,.

,   " +!$  $..$'

' ,$ "$, " *,,.

*,,,H!

',"

*,' '$

. *  ' , 4() $ , $$ ' $!+ & ,,

,

' ",9 , ,$ "& $,." "+ ,0& $'

,$ *,"

 '&

,<H! + $,'

!* $'

""8$'

,,' ,! $!+ '  $ :> $, $ "'

 , ! , !$ "'

 +& '',.

<H! " 7 

$'

,0& <,$ ,.! $" ' +."& 0'

,"



<,H! $  $ (G 7$!

,$ !,.!"& ' "

>'

 $"

!$ ,'

 $ ,$$,$

' "'

$"

""

:,$ ,.

'"& ) "+ ,$ +""

$"'

 ,,' ,*"*,.

,$$, , ,"

)   "'.,.

 $!"'

!) $, *,'$ $$ " ,$!

*$, ,,' $$. , ) "

!

*$, .$ ',"'

$$, ,",& "$ , ",,  ' '", ,$ $",$  $,"& 

4 ,$ $ '"& ,$ "7'

'+  $$,, $

%  "$, " $,$& <", '"&   !$ ,.

 ,$ !) !$ " <",'

4 , ,$ 7 , *,+ ! ,$ !,.

'

$!+ ,0'

$,$  ' ," $

',,) $!)  " '$'

, &)

',"

,, .,*  "

7 $  ' "

:! )  > A<  +! ,0'

'

,'

!$,") $,$ ') $'

.,* ",    !0"&) ,$  !$ $!

 $;"&) *$, !.'

"  

 $,' $!)  *,$"&    $!+ + ..$$$)  

+! "'

' ,*"

 !$,"

'"& ''

>) , $  ;"

7 "   !0"& "$ !$ H $!  , ",

3



 !,.

7  ,$ ", $  '

+ $$ +! ',.

*$, .! !"'



$ +!,"

.,* ""

"+

 $!

$  "& #,0& ("

'

, ',.

,*$,.,) +!$) ! $ 0& ("

"$ '

,*"*'

,,' ,"

 ;,'

!.

"!.!

(      ! ,$ "$ +!") "$  ,$

' ", " $ 4',)  $ $!'+ !"$$ $, *$, ',.

, ' "

3D

* $ ,0& ,$ $!

 ""'

*,"

 '&

  "

!  ,.

+"'

$,' <,"",& "'

,$  , *,"

 '& $ !, , "'

* "

G,!

+ $$ $'

!*,.

'

,*"*'

,,') , ,$ ',," '$'

!+ ,0'

$'

,0& , +!  '$'

"$$

,$ ,$') ,0&  7 " !

3

:!  , ,$ "$ ' "

+!! ,0&

 $'

"" !.!)  $, $)

+! $'

!,$ ,.'

$'

',$"$ $ 7 "'

""

 !'" $'



""

!$ .',.

7+ "'

. !$ *'

! $ ',$"$ $ . ""

 !'" *'

 ! , !$ 7  ""

 !'" + $ :> ,'

 +!! & "'

$,$ + !    ,*'

!

A< (%  "'

''

!)

7$ , ' "

+!! ""

 $'

$,.

,0& ", ) +! " 7

,$ ,.

7'

", $,') ,7'

 " $'

!"+, 

, %"

$'

,0& ,.! ,* '

! !,.

$ ,$ ""

$!+ ' +!

',".""& < ,'

,0'

,'

 +!! ,0&  $*'

$ ", "'

$'

"" "$ "*$ " $,

 ! !') " 7 +! $$"'

) !$ ! $'

,0,$) ! $* $" ",'

 

$!  & !"+, !, ) ! $  "$, "



! ,   7  ,$ $  ,,') . $, '

 !) 

+! $ " ''

 &

,*,"

%$,") 1.

',"."

< ,,) ""& ''

,,"

 &,.

.! & >

!+*)  , 7 !

!

' ,$ ;, "

4

 ) ..$$ $'

$,$ ,0& !  "

$ ,.

,.

!"'

 ",) +"'

!* *,''

.,.

$, ,.

 !

H! *&  ''

$, $  ,,' '

, ! .$ $!+ "

'



 !,.

,'

,$ , . + ,,' !,.

$, ,.

,,' ! ,$ $!

+!," "'

!*  ,'

'

*$, $ "$"& ,*"* ", ",*$

"!.!) , '$  $*'

!

','

!,' 

!*,.

$'

,0&

& $" ') , ,$ $ " 7

',.

,"

!*,.

$'

,0& <,$,.

,.! $" ' 0'

,"



,'

,"

 0$,,'

',.

H!.!

 "'.'

$,$  '') ','

7 &

, !*,.

$'

,0&

 <,$,.

,.! $" '  !  !,.

! .,* *$, ,,'  '

,0,$ '

$) $"

',"."

< ,, ,'

  ,*,"

%$,") 1.) +! . & ,,"

''

$ 

$, ,$"

H! ,0,$ $ ""& $!+ *$, "'

',$''

,.!"&

3?

,.

,") 7  " $,.

,0& $" ') " ;,'

< ,'

! ! 0,.

, ,.!"&

$ "'&  $*') ", !,$ '

  $,' " '"& "   $$$ ,., .$,$  $  !

$

& $,< ,0,$ !.!

$, "  !*,.

'

$

$  ,,') $, ;,'

<", $ !$ $ '

"& $,.

,0,$ ,.

$, "  "'

$" $'

+"'

 ,

G! !,.$  $ < ' $') +! $ ,$ $$"'

$$,"$ ! "+ <$

$'

$,$  +& ",7 +'

$'8""  A< $*,  '

 ",7 $" $,.

$ $$ $'

,0&

$ "+ ,$ +""

$"'

+!," <,$,.

,.! $" ')  ,$ <'

+,.!

 $'

."' $" $ $* ", 

 $ '$ $$" $$,"$

>'

$"

"" '

*,$ 0'.

$ .'

:,$  ,.



 !

" # $  %%&'( #)

3E?   $$ D +!, '",.

$ ,, *,' , ,"

,") <   $*'

+! $, ,"$ <", ,0,$ "'$ + $"$) ,$ *,' $, +,$$$ ,$  $'

,0,$   ,",$ " 7 ""

4 !  $*'

+!! !

"$!'

 ,<, "&

,<'

, $,

$ 0'

H! $'

0'.

'

"'

$"

"" ,$ '

)  * $ %%&'(&+ 3

   $$ 35) <   $*'

$ $$  $ ' , 5) A*,' ) $ ",$!

" ,* ' ,$ $ $!,,.

' ",$ $, $ ",$!

*& ,.',  ,$ !.') &'

$ " ' 

 $ '

,

, ,"

", ",

$"  !) ,$ <'

+,.!

L."' $"$L ,$  ''

"

'.

A* ,  !

 ,$ ' "," ! ! +! +"'

$$& +! ""'

,$, <,' "

"'

,') "+

7$ ' ""+ ,

3E

H! $ ", ''

  "$ '$ ,$,

!

,'

($  $ 7$!

,$ "$ ' "

%  ! $ $,'

$ ','

 

 .,.

$,  "!,""&

4$,."& $,.$ 7$!

 ! > ",8,0'

,.

$ +!  ,'

,0'

!$,"

 +!," .,.

$ '') 7$!

','

!*,.

' $

G!& ','

'& !,$  ,$ $$ $ 7+

4 ",, A< (83

*'



''$$'

',"

,) -"&, %$,") 1. ;,'

  ,$$ 0 ,0'

7 $

H! ',.

' *,' '$ '"'

,

7 $ +!$ .',.

0 '

$ ! 

(

H! $!+$  0 "$ $'

,0,$ ,,' -"&, %$,") 1.) !+*) " $  $ , ) $ $) !* <",'

$,

! $, '$ ",

0 $ 1,'!, >"

! ", "$ $'

,0,$ 

(G5 4 0  ,.!

$$< ,, '

,'

 $ + ,0'

,

0 +

,'

; 7  ,*'



!$,"

% ! $'

7$!

. '

,'

!$,"

+!," 7$!

,.

(G ','

$

""

!$ !,.$ $"

7,.

 $, ' "

+!! ,,' !'

+& ", '

$,9 G!! 7$!

$  $ $ ,,'

3

H!

,* $..$'

$, ,$ ""& ,   " *,,.

H! ,$ !,.

'

$!+ ""8$'

& ',.

, ,"

 7$!

,'

+,$$ $ ' !,.

 &

7 $

:! ) "" .,.

, ", $!

 $7,.

.',.

7,.

$ +! $'

.,.

7 $ ) ! !  $ & ;"

4 ", $'

+"'

7 $ .,$ +!

& !

,.! !* *7'

 +! $'

!+,$

H!  *, ,,' $,.

,0& ", $ , .,& $  ", ,',.

'$ .,$

+ ""8$'

7$!

) '$ $

*,,.

!

,* $..$'

""8$'

$ 

!

 "$, " $,$& ,$ .'

", 7,.

*!,"$  !$ H $!) ,.

$$ !$ $! +""

$,$$

:! )  ' , 4( ,$

'  

'

H! ,$ "& $,." ,0& $,'

!* $'

 ""8$'

",

 ,0& ,$ *,"

 '&

H!

',"

,, .'

,$ *& *,,.

H! ,0'

',$!.'

?

 '&$



' .,* ,, .',.

 ,0& *,' '$ A< (%8 ",,) $,.

$,.

$ $. , ') ,0& "'

'.$ ",

!

& ,,  $"

7,.

 ' , 4(

H! ;,$, ,,  7+"'.  $ , 4(  '

!

H! ,,' ,$ $,'

!* 7 " ""

$''  "$, "

,* ,.

! $ ,0&) ,  $,'

,",'

,0& $  ,,

,

'

3

>'

$"

"" '

0'.

# !,%$    )!# 3

3 

, ," 53) +! ,  $*'

  ,''

,0&  $,'

B",7"& $ '!) ,

$  ,0& ,$ $,, ',& $  $ '!

$$,""&

$ '!

+,""

$   " $" ,0& !*,.

.'

',& $ 

>'

$"

"" !$ "$ 7

',B$ ',"

F,$' H<,".&) 5!

A',,) +!, ,.

!,$ , B'. ",B) , !$

,'

. = ?5 '. ", $!"'

,

,  ,0,$  '$,.'

B'.$ ",B

4 ,$  $*'

,0,$  *'

 "

 "& , ',$$$) $!

$) &$,"$ $!"'

$,''

'.$

H!) ,0& '

$  0$,,'

'.$ ",

$,''

*,+) , ! $ +,!,  $  ' , D 4(



4 *,+ ',"'

',$$$,  *) +! ,., .$,$ ,,' +""

"  $..$'

$, !$ '

' "9 ,*$,., !,$ ,$ $!+ !* ,'

 *& , 

9 "

!

'$,'

&,.

 ,*$,.,9 *$, '

,$ ,"& "7'

,) "'

'"& ,.

 ",9 $ ,0& ,.

*,"

 '&9 + $,'

!* $'

,,' $ :> $, < ,,   ,*'

!

$,.

$, $) $!

+ !*,.

$!+ ' ,'

 +!! ,0& '

$ ,0'

"'

$'

+9 ,0,$ $ ""8$'

<",'

$,9 $'8"" !*,.

. $, $  ,,' ,.

 !9

',"."

< ,, ""8$'

!*,.

''

,*,"

%$,") 1.) *",.

$ $,< ,0,$ $9 ,.! ,* ' !*,.

'

*," " $') ' *$, !*,.

'

 "$, "

 *,,.

""

!$ $ $"'

,.

$ " ' 

,'

  !"$$ $, $&

H! "" '$*'

.'

, $!

'  $",.

;,"

% $!

, ,"'

 "+ ,$ .'

+

H!) 0'.

*,, $ $$'

.,$ ""8$'

 $$,'

$ ,$ ", " $ $,' +&  "

H! "

,$ '

H! , .'

0'.

,$ $ $,' ,$ ;,'

!.  '

.,$

    

 

 

 !"

# $  %&"

# $