High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/733/2011allowed

Jagjit Singh & ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2019-01-29Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu15 pages

!""

#$%" &"$' ' (()) * & +*%, ( !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!

$%&'( )*+,-(! ,$2( 0,$310,21) + -'./)0! 0 '(()) & + & 1"0" ")! .)0+*%,

!.,/01! "!4 1'"(()"" " * $" '%*$2 0,/&"#*$02" 0"&"1") 3

0"4'"!'(()) #$%" &"$'&*5'%" 6*04'4 !'$4" ' " '

!(*"',)*&! " 0 7

-+04!"! !'*

#$%" &"$'

-+ -2("2 )"

(/ " 807 - *) (/2 "0 *$ * '- 4 / -+ 1*$"$*"2("2 (" / (/ " 07 - *) (/2 "0 *$ * '"$*"2("2 / &*5'%" 6* -+ -2("2 )"

(/ " 807 - *) (/2 "0 *$ * '- 4 / -+ 1*$"$*"2("2 (" / (/ " 07 - *) (/2 "0 *$ * '"$*"2("2 /

' ' !4 *!!* )/

1'! '(!* ""* '))" ' +9 &)&"$'!'" 2 0:; + 0 '

! ' "2 2 & < 0'',"$$"!*) *45" '"))$ ="#$ &"$'4'"$ *!5 ")"*," =" 4$ !'")02)/0")( 6*.*( (&"$'0)$4" ' '" 2 '&*5'"6*4)""$4" ''"2""))$9>" '*)) =" $.*( (&"$''"((*)/ ,*

04'''!2* ' ''* ()/ = )$ '!2()" 4" '+)"!& "0 0 =4 " !' '"$)$4" '(! ,) 2 '"))$ =) " 2'"#$ &"$'"*," )(' 0)) '

2")/22,4"!*"$$"$2""$ .*( (&"$'0 4''"*$' ")4&*5'"6*4"

6*),"6* ) ' 0 '/'$", ' .*( (&"$''"2(()/ 4"$")( 6*0 '.*( (&"$' "" "$ $* 1'!2()" 4'")$"$* !' ',) '

2* " &*5'%" 6*!!*4"4 %" &"$''!"

'"'* .*( (&"$'5' ( ' =40(" '"?* 0&*5'%" 6*( ' .*( (&"$'4 * " ''* ' '" * 1' (* " &*5'%" 6* ' , '")4 #$%" &"$' !!*" '"))$4 $ 1'/ *,/ .*( ( &"$')/"$$" '4))" '! )' &*5'%" 6* 1' 2 ",'" '2*4 ' ), ' !!*#$%" &"$'0 2)/0&*5'%"&"$'04'4""$"*,")$4" ''" 2")/0 4*"$,*" ( & '!2()" ' !''"

")4" ' ' ( &*5'%"&"$'')$"2()/2 2/( '"))$ =* 2/ 2")" ' ( '*$''" '#$"&"$' &"!#$"&"$'* 2"")) 4*,) 2,* 0*!''* $"2/ '" #$%" &"$'*$' ")4&*5'%" 6* 25"$(/2 ' !!( - $""$2/ '!!(0 '/ 2"(((" '2/ * '"0#$"&"$' (($""$2/ '2 0#$"&"$''*2 0 07 ,/ '" &*5'%" &"$' 2 *," ' !2()" 25"$ (/2 '!!( * ' 2* 0!2()" 5( 074" ''"2 25(/2 "+((" '2""$ 2* 4(" ,/'"2"'"!!

* * '"0 '!!* 4/ 1'"?* ( 4(( 1',/4 ( 2 2;2" " 1'( 2 24!*! ,/ 6"()&"$' 1'!

"!" !* '""/!* * 1' (()) 4 1'/ 2 ; %*"!") ! " !!*&*5'%" 6*$ ! $"!*) *) "2()2 * !(("$$!!*#$%" &"$'$ ! 4)$ - "$ "4!2() !'))4(* *( !2() " )) '!) 2)" " 1'(!* ";2"*2, 4" "*(( '! 1' 2 '!!*4)!*&! "

+ 1'/" '! '(!* " 1'/;2" 4" " ! 1'!!*4!"! !0 "! , =!0 '( (()

@ !*) (("$ ,') ' (()) '2 )/$* ' '(!* "' ") (" ! @ !*)(("$ '& '2 )/$* ' '(!* "' (" !,/,)*, *(( '%*$2 ')* ,)4 9'')!*) '( "$ '*$'

'%*$2 !/! *))/ +9+46*2 "

" ' '4*"$ *"0" '2 /) +4& *" ,* 8 + 0' 4!)),/ '()"! +)"!& "0 5 "))$9>"

'*)) =' 5 '(' $('0:; + :; +

+9'59'4( ' '445"$ !'

$ " ) ,5 -"0 *2 0 07 4 (" ,/&)&"$' 0"'"!!* 04'"!'4%" !!* " '2 &)&"$'&2 6*),"6* +9 &)&"$'" '2 ")4" !!"$ '"20 ,*

0') .*( (&"$' '" #$ &"$' '2 =) !'"$ 9''!2,!50' !2 54 ' '"$.*( (&"$'4 2""$ =!'

'"2""*)! "*) "2 )/)$ '(

4" '+)"!& "0 1' 0 '/',!'"$.*( ( &"$' "*()!4" ' '')( '()"! =" 2'" #$ &"$'"*," )) ' 2")/22, $ '"!* ,* *2""$ .*( (&"$' - '24'")0&*5',"6* 4"

'"'"4"

6*),"6*"!) '2 ' $ "$ , '"$'"20.*( (&"$' "" "$ $* "

8 ()/"$ ' "20!!*&*5'%" 6*4"4 %" &"$'!2 ' .*( (&"$'?* ' ( '04'"!'4,) ,/ '"2 2* " &'( '" '(! &*5',"6* = 4 * " ' 1'/4 4 ' !!*&*5'%"

6* 1',/4 *)/"$,/ '" 4)) 1'4 "%*") " '"'0) '( ',/ 1' 2 ",'"2* .*( (&"$'4 ' &*5'%"&"$' 2/ #$"&"$' #$"&"$'* $"2/ '!!* =40 '!!** 2"(((" '2/ #$"&"$'' '0 07 +9&)&"$' -'"!;2" "0 ''2" ' 4''!2,!5 ,"$"$ 0'" ( '* '"'* ="4"

2 '"2 ' "2" ' ,* '" "!) 4'( '* '"'*

!")" "$'"$ $* " +" 04'')$ '( 4" ' '()"!$"$2""$ '"$0'" !2 54 4''*,) '* '"'* 0()"!" !2 '"'*0'40 '/2 '"2" ' 0*"$ '"$' )) ' 2")/22, $ ' !) '2""$ .*( (&"$' ' "2" ''"4" 6*)," 6**$' ")4&*5,"6*"!) ' " ! '2 ' " "20'"*$' ")4&*5',"6*"!) '"2 ' !!*&*5'%" 6**,) '* '"'* 04', ' '!!*#$"&"$'"" '"'*0&*5',"6*6*),"6*4)( "'"'* ' "20"'"(!0&*5',"6*" 5!!*&*5'%" 6* ' " 4'04'*,) '* '"'* 9'"!'

3 '"$0 '/! ' 0 '4 *)2)) 2" "$ 2 '

+9 #$ &"$'" ' ' !.*( (&"$'

=4 "-"04'.*( (&"$'4 2""$ =!2"-" +98'!')&"$'( ' +9 &)&"$'"'" ), ' . &)&"$'4 2""$ 0!!*&*5'%" 6*#$%" &"$'!2 '"'**"$ "$' "2 =4"'"'* !!*&*5'%" 6*"!) ' ' 2*.*( (&"$',/$""$,)4 ('") /) !!*#$%" &"$'"!) ' ')2*.*( (&"$',/ $""$'"2,)4 )$ ,2,'") / 1'/'!!) ' ,/ .*( (&"$'* ''( (/ 4" '! ) ' 1' 0 '/4 ''* #4 &"$'&(!' = !!2(" '2 '()"! +9 &2 &*5',"6*" '2 ' '! &' ( ' ,*

0'".*( (&"$'0 4 2""$ &'" 2''*, = '")4&)&"$'

'$ !' ,) "$ '* 2* " &"!'" .*( (&"$'4"" "$ $* ()/0'5&*5'%" 6* ( ' (" '5"$0!!*&*5'%" 6*( ' 1' 0'4!!*&*5'%" 6*)$4" '!!*#$%" &"$'0$"$,'"'" 0'0'2 '")40 ' ")4''*,4" "$" ''* = '")4?*" 4''( '* '"'*0 '*(0' ) '

!!*&*5'%" 6*'( ' 1' 0 '/4 4

'! )' !!*&*5'%" 6* * ',/ ' ,/ '" 4)) ''( (/ 4 -'!;2" "0 '( ' 0' '")4&)&"$'!2,!5 ''* ,* ') '* &'" "!) ' '" )4 ' !!*&*5'%" 6*( '* '"'*

!")" $"$ '* " ' , ' '!!*4 ))4"$ '"2 &')" "!) ''*, ' '!!* 4 ))4"$.*( (&"$' &'" "!),* '" ! / =* !!*&*5'%" 6*4 %! '"'* !!*#$%" &"$')"" ''* !!*&*5'%" 6* &''2 '")4" $"!' .*( (&"$'

1'( 2 24!*! ,/+9A 6"()&"$' 1' !* '4('/;"*) 2 '"$04'"!'4*

"!" !* '""/!* * =(( 2 2( 0 :; +.

!!"$ <&@( 0:; +B0 ';'"," '"! " "(!) 04'*2'"'4"2")!'! " "!

1'!!*);2"9.$(&'209 "' '09 (5% 8 9 6 &"$'( ' ()"!"" " '"))$

2 1' ,/ 4 * *

!!*&*5'%" 6*4 54/,/ '()"! 2''* 4/ 3 1'!!*);2"98&-")&"$'093&&+ ,"&"$'6' 9 = )4"6*

- '" ! 0.*( (&"$'0( ' (!* " /04"" "$ $* ''* ()/ =?* !!*&*5'%" 6*04'4!"$" ' '"'*0 ( ' 1' 0 ',/ .*( (&"$'4 * 1'!* '4('/;"*) 2 '"$ + 2 2( ":; +.

A (+9 &)&"$'0 ') '"$ .*( (&"$' '2 9''!2,!50'!2 54 ' '" $.*( (&"$'4 2""$ =)$ '(

-'"!;2" "0'2" ' '"4" " "!) 4'( '* '"'* !")" "$'"$ $ * " < ' " "2 0'"*$' ")4&*5',"6* "!) ' !!*&*5'%" 6**,) '* '"'* : 04' '!!*#$"&"$'"" '"'*0&*5',"6*6*),"6*" 5!!*&*5'%" 6* ' 4''*,) '* '"'*04'.*( ( &"$''$

+9 &2 &*5',"6*" '2 ' '! -' !;2" "0'2" ' 0'" "!) ' '")4 ' !!*&*5'%" 6*( '* '" '* !")" $"$* .*( (&"$' ' , ' '!!* 4 ))4"$'"2 &')2" ' ')" "!),* !!* &*5'%" 6* ' '*, &' ! $"!))/ 2" ' '" "!),* '" ! 1'*$'!!*"" ''*0,* '" 54'/' ( '* 1''* !!*&*5'%" 6*4%!

'"'* (+9 &2 &*5',"6*0'4!!*&*5'%" 6* )$4" '!!*#$%" &"$'0$"$,'"'"0'40'' 5 2 '2 )/ ' 2")/,* '" ! 1'"" ***),'"* -!0'' '!!* ))4"$'"0' '*)' " )'" '")404''!2 54,* ' 2""$ .*( ( &"$' ' 2")/ 22, - ' ! ;2" "0'2" ' '' $"!' ' 1'*0 ') '/((*,/(!* "" ) 1'(!* "'))"*(; %*"!")! " 2, +98'!')&"$',/!!*&*5'%" 6*#$%" &"$' ="), ' +9 &)&"$' !!"$ '"20 !!

*&*5'%" 6*#$%" &"$'"" '"'* !!* &*5'%" 6*"!) ' '2*.*( (&"$',/$""$,)4 ( '" ) / !!* #$%" &"$' "!) ' ' ) 2*.*( (&"$',/$""$,)4 )$ ,2,'") / 1'/!!) ',/ .*( (&"$'* ''( (/ 4" '! )' 1'!* '4('/;" 4 "%*"02 ",/+98'!')&"$'"'" 2 =" 2 * '" / 9'/ '!!*4*)$25! ", '"2 1'*0" " * ",) !!"$ +9 &) &"$'0 ' 2 " ,'" ' 2*4 ' ), ' !!

*#$%" &"$'02)/0&*5'%" &"$'* 2/ ' 2")" '( 4'2'' ("2()/2 0 '*$''" '#$"&"$' &"! '!!

*," '!2()" - " ,)",)4'/#$"&"$'4*)$" 2/ +9 &)&"$' '" 2")/22, 1'*0 ' 2 " ",* '(()) " ,)"' 1'!'"" !2() <* ' ''* '!!* '!2()" 4 %! - " ,)",) ' 4' '/4!'"$ .*( ( &"$'! '0 ' *)2))4 "!,// 2")/ 22,

!!"$ +9 =+2%" &"$'0"!)* 2 42,/!!*#$%" &"$'&*5'%" 6*"'"(!" :; +C+& 1'"!)* 2 )* ")/" * "! '42*"$ '!* " $ "4'")"()"! !* /

=D,) '&*(2* ""2")(() A A !" ') ?* * ' "!)* 2 2 , ' ()"!

"!")0* E $ '!/ "!"2" "$2 ") '" ! '!!*0 '- "$ "$

"! 6 &5"/0+9 80'! $"!))/( '

)) '! ",/ '!!*(42

" $ "0,* '2 '"" $ " (( , 2)!'! 0"2*!' ''"2) '( ' '!!*(4

* '$"))" $ 2*) "() "2, ; ! "$ '! "4'"!') '!/ '2 0!'04(5/ 9 " 2 ' )" / ! !"!*2 ! ' ' ! " ' ) '!/ '"!"2" "$

2 ")4 )* /0,* !*,/"*!2 0 (*!!" !! ") 2 '!!* ! " * ,")* /0" "'"

,/ "!) ' " * "0"$*!' ! " "2"",) 1' " 2,$ !!( "$) "!"2" /"!0,* "

" ) '!/ 2 "),%! ") " !"20"

"2 5 ')" "/)*( ' !"!*2 ! !' ! =40 "

*!' 2 " 2 * ** (* !2(*)" 2 '" "$ "$

"!0 " ' ( 2 0 '" "/)* *!' 2 )"$ '!/"*))"

" - " 4 '/ (*! ', " '"* $"$ ' ) "'"(, 4&! " ':"!!

"!) ' " * ""&)" & 6 50 &3

E 2 ")"E '"$' $" ) "!"2" "F " 4 "4 ") $* " !"2") (!* - *)/"$ "),)/!(4" ' 4,%! " G " )/0 ' *"$ )",")" / ' 2 2 ,/ !!*0 !)/0 *"$ ' *!' 2 2)* ")/ - " ?*" (",) ' ( *(! !!* !"22/',!2()) "

/ '*$'2 '")"$!!"0 ' "*!2 *"$ ' " "$ " $ 9'("!2()) "

/'"7' 4,') 0 '"'"$')"5)"' *!'

"2/ ,"$ ) <) "2/ " *",)"!" "2( '" $" / ' ") ' *,?* "! 1' 0 ' (*( ' E*) $" ")* / ! "F " * ' ' "2/

!"*"$ ")")",) 1'(2"" ' ")* / 2 2 )"5)/ 2") ' #*$ ' (!* 0 ',/ *) "$"2"!"$ %* "! :*"$ '" "$ " $0 ) 2 )"5)/ !* )/ , *! " " ' " "$ "

1'!! ,* ' E)* "F 2 ))42!2('"!!* '""$' - ")* / 2 4")/ $" 4"$' $ *"$ ")0 ' " "$ 4*) ' $ "! " !2() *!' 2 G '*$' 2 ' ")"$ !!"0 ' 0"*!2 !( " :" *!'")* / 2 ( , *0 ' )4 '*) "! "" ' * " $ " ! "! ' ") '"$" / ,")/" $" / '(,"$;2" - '"0E '"$' $" ) "!"2" "F" " ) $*$" * 'E '" $ 2 'F ' !*) , * )"!" " 2 " - !'!5 ()"! ,'"**"$ '!* " "$ " 1' ;!)*" !2()) "2/ " "2( '4" '" "$ 4")),2"!)" ; ! " 2 " '*$'*!'!2(*)" 2 !* 1' ?* )"!*!'

E' !* F 4")) !2(2" ' ")"$! ?*" !*! "$2"$ *)" "$ " *"$ ' ") $0 ' * " ' (!* " ( '!'$)))$" ' ' E"$' $" ) "!"2" "F"" )( ! " * ' '(!* ""!'$ '"*

9')/ ')$*$ &! "3+4'"!'( ! '!!* 4))*(! 4" 4';2" *"$ '!* " "$ ""!"2") ! - 4*)),* *) &! " 303 3 +4'"!')/4(!*) $* " (! 2 2 ,/ ( *"$ ' !* " "$ " =40 &! " ' :"! !

"!( ' E '/ ! "2 " ,/ *,?* ! F" 2 2"!* / 2"",) '; ' '/!,( ,/ '*,?* "!/ ! - "?*" (",) ' '! '!* ") 2 !*)"! )/) '*,?* "!/ ) ! ' ' '""!/ '*$'

"( 2 =!*!' 2 !*) ),!", '4'"!'E *"')"5" ' !'" "!F *!! *) (!* " 1'"("" ))4

E =42*!' " 2 "!" 2 !!* 2/ , ( G+" ' 0 4'/ ! "( "!" !?*! " 2 "!" 2 ( !!* /

!0 " ' !* / ()"!

"!02*!' *!'

" 2 "0 4' ' " 2* ! " 0) " "! )/ '

! ',/"!02/,( F

1'"(""(2" '" "* !* ") 2 " ' "/ !* - -" )40 ' " * 2 "! (*2( " ' ' !* ") 2 ' ,; ! '*$'!2(*)" -' 0 ' "?*"2 " ")")"$!5"

'2"" " "H3@:3

3 38I 4"$ =40 " !"!*2 !4'" "'4 ' (4 " !2()) 25 2 4'") " !* /0)/"$*!' "2/4))" " "*4"))

"!) 8 1') "'"(, 4&! " ' :"!! "!) ' " * " 4!)"

""6 '"6)*$'H- 3& AA 3"@#A83 3 &I - 4 , " ' 2%" / ("" ,/ #$'0# 0 &((

-(( A830( E

1' " 2 " $" ,/ !!*( ()"!

"!)"$ '"!/ ! 4'"!'2/2/ ( "!"2" / ' , 2 2"",)""!,/ ' ! " - " " "!"2" / '($""$ ' " 2 "0 '?* " " - !")/4'" " "!"2" / !'! ' $" ' " 2 " " !! - ' ) "!"2" /" 2 "',$",/ !!*(4" '* / ' 0 '

4")),2"",)""! ' 4")) ,'" ,/ '("" !)* "!) ' " * " ' ' '',!2(*)" - 2* 0 ' 0 , ') ' ' ("" &! " ' :"! ! 4" '" ' ('"," " "0 *) !2(*)"H'I,*", ""$ ' " 2 " F 2('"*(()"

8 9 '("" ' '!/ ' )2 0 ! " '" 2 42 '," ")* / 2 04'"!'

! ")/ $ '"!"2" "$!"!*2 !,*!' !/0 )/ *2" ' (!* " ! F 8 1' (!* " ' ") ( ' ! $" ' (()) ,/,)*, !!"$)/0 '(()"))4 '%*$2 0 " 1'(()) !?*" )) '!'$ 2$" '2 1'(()) ,)

'4" ' %"&'2 #*$

="&"$'&"'* #*$ 9' '(5"$7 J7 9' '( ,) J7