Kanwar Pal @ Palu v. State Of Haryana




   
 

 !"#$%&&

     
   

 %  '(

& )
)

)* +

 '(

& )
&)&)+* 

 !" # $# "

 %"&# $ "  '""#
!#  &)&)+*, ("   )

"& )*   $  

    +  

, " ' 

- )#!) .

!)*/#", # "     "  ,  "  )   

     0  1'  

    

)     * *   

          

 #23

 *  #

)"  )  * *      (",  " " 4 +#

) )" *

))

)"* *

  "   #  1

  ",    )"   ) "  "       "  " $5 
" $ )" %"#


 !)*

 * "*

&    67 

   

)  "  * #  "  *   "

 * 672

" *"    )   "81 672 "* &#"     

  *  *  

 "  "  "       

)"  "*    *         . /  
"* )" 8, 

"  %#

)",  " )"")  ) 4

  "  "      )  , 9 :   

3   "*

   % 

)"        *  ,  " *#  ,  "  *   " 



 )" $ "* "   

  "

)"" $ "*

)* )

 "    ,%    " %"    0

+    , 4*# 4 +#" $ " *
"*  )"#" 

 * " "*#")

" ;

) )"

*  #"* " "



 "*#")

,  

",   

"*5 $

) " * * " ,4*#,"

   

  <"  "   % 
"*   )"#  "    " * "" " )  ("*  ) "

"

 $ " " $ )" %"



"

)"  "*#"

* )

)"")

* )

- 

)   , #"$ )*%  "  % #""

, %  ,  )  < "" , ) 

#"81

"

  ))  , &* ("

$  )  * ** 

"85*   )  7 " ,

")" % ("

= 

) 67-#67

675 ") " $  * 



 *  )$  

*" 6$   % 

 **  , " " " , $   )"67*, " ("  ,  ,&   **7*   *$ )*     "

)   1  "  $

)    > ># ,"   )"  

 ? "



'"*   #

," 

"  *  , "    

 "  *    "   

     

   @ ''*   $  ) 



)

    *  )$ )

"  #" 

  40''# 

 " * ', "1 $  ) ); 
 )  "        #  "    7*

* & < #"  " 

 *  *   "81 6$ #"



37*  )",  (" " 7* ,"  )" <#"   "*.



.

 /  ""

 "* *   A 1 )" $

) @2 4 +#" *  "

 "*

""   #, 

) "

"

"
"* )"

," (" 

 % *"$ ,)

)

 ,"



" "   ;

> >,+2>*#"  ) "

? " " )"

" *"

"   )" "*"" $ ,  #, "   $ "* 

$ 

"      ""   )*1
 

," *"""

*  "

 

"  

= "*"

" *$   "     < ,"   )"  *  "  *   

   "    ,  "    1    % "  

7*    <0  "    "  *  81  

 *   "

 * <9 % "  % "")"

" 

,

 """ ) *

7" ,  * 67    4  <A  '  $  *  *$        )  "  **  7*     <@  !  "  *# 
 * #    678 " % )

*   "1 $  ) ); <4'

, &*   "

$"  " 1=) 

 "(" 7* <+


*'" " #"

 " **7*   

"  ,



" )*%  " 



/

 ""  " "  "

7   * " )" ""

,   

)

" """ 67 >

, 

$

"7" , 

" ** 67!2 67!20 ("   7* <>1

",  )"#") 

 $  )  "* 7 ,$ ("   7*  <     *#    -   ) # " '    67  *$  ) )"* 7*   " *

"   !1# "%

"

"  67 2  2("

     "

  4 >, " 

 " $ "

* 67 20

"

"  67 29  ("    "  7*  <

 ?*  5, ("

  #1'('#.1 ) '

 )

(* '  "1
/#!   #!)*"  " "

,)"" ""    *  1


  7*

)  "  , * #  "  

 "  "   

 )*1
"7" ,  " 67B "  "$ #"   

    "   2  "

*   

     0 ''1 "  "

* #"  




  

  



 

       

    

      

   

    

0         

     





  

!!"

  

   

 

             

  #   $  # %



 & 

 $ 

 

   

' 

         (   )          

   

 



       

* 

+     *       $        +    ,*- .

 / 0  



 



  1 +

  

#1, '

& 

#1,$



  

   



 



 

      

   

 

2 !

!!3 

  

4  5    5 %4   ,

5 #*   6 %

, -

  + 1 #'47 87.78" 9

      



  

 

  







 

(#    



1   

&    #1,

  

 

 

.#6 ,



 

2:"

!

!!3  

  



  

 

       

 

    ;  "

 #  "   2  7*   )"#? ; #C"  5 #?
" # 
< #" ,)"" 

)*,  *,>+ 09++A# "

*- , D $

$ "   67

  $ "= *67
6

"? 678"

 ""   ("  '$  *) & )*

 # $ 

 " 

 ,$ 

  )"

)  , " '#" "



,"

' 1 " *   ,""

""     ,   *  $ (" 

  )" " " ) "& )* 

 ' ")

""  "  *  "

,  , " ,

 , ,  $

*

1 "

"

#" " * , ""

 "  1 ) $"*  , " *"" " *  )$     "" * )""$** 

" *#, "  )     

%"# " "  

,   "  , ",

 , ,1 $"*  

" * $"

,  , " , " " % "



 

* "   1 "

"* $ * , 

  $   $ #, * $

* )     #" " 

  , 

 *  $ 

"  , ) , 

 *  $ #"* $* , , " ("



" ,*  ""   

" * $ ) ,   &* 2<

,"  )"

<  &< #  ) "81  " '""    % # 

)

"

)

 ,

"

"

 

"   <" ,"

 )"<#" "  

," *"""

**  " *

"   " * ,  )* 1


 "* "

 "#"* $ 

, ,



$ 

* , )  ) )

" 

  *6$ "*  67B)

)1
   > 

,

) $ "#  ) "" 

, "

 *  " 

"*  

,""

" ,  $ )*  """

" "

, 

)"  

"*  "*   "#  ,*  " ,"  )"<#"

 7&   

," *

 ? "

> >"$ ),"  )"<

"

7&    

 *   ,  <     , $,  1    " )"

  % ""    " <*%  

"   "*.

  /

 

 "*   "#,"  )"< , )   $ )

 *""

  " )"   % ""  )

*%  

," *1 " ,*  " 

 * & ""   > >



, *

6  ?00  @ >*  4 A  *#  67
C  $   " " 1     '"

  ) "  

'

," "  *!)* & ""  *"#" "

  ?0A  > > )  

*#67
'$ " ""  *- 

& "   '

=  #    *%  "  $     7  &    

#"1 $  ) )) "  ) " "  "        > >    !)*     "#    

,*  "" *  

  @"6$  

, )

"  " "

   

")     "    " "   "" "  " *)

 (" #" " ,  )  $  , "   ' '  )")*  , "  

   )  "   #  "      

  "

$"*  ,*  ""  

 $ ) " )

" 

" *    $

, " ") " " ,*  ","

"  

<

<"*  

# "" $ $$* " " *

$  "         , "  )  "     

$  )         "     

     "

)  " & )*  $  

  

, "

 ' <"$"  

,""

 "$ 

 #"   

"    "    *  $ (" *           ,     *    $    "  "  *   *  " "     $        )     "  )",  * ,) 

  $

, " (" #  *  %  * $ * * " *""  *"  "

 $ "* ,,    " * **  , " 

" " ,,7   

"

"

"" "") "



 ""

  1" , " , " E,*' " *  

 

   /    3"<# 5 5 =5><"2 

 /-& (  

  

         

          ? =>

    

            

 

 

5  



      @  @ @  @    1         

@  @@ 

    @  

 5   



     



   

  ?F''

>#+4 ''.'/ 94G  %           

              

  

@

  @@  @   A

      B = >1        







 

  %

 % 

              





  

   % =9>

          



  

=<>

      

  

   % =C>

       



             

   

 

  



  

 



 

  

 #"   *  

"  *

 &< #""  ) "81 672    "81 672#" " * ) 

""

)" "* *  " 8,



 ,

 ""   # * #")

 ) 4 

9:  #  $ "   " "

3 . /  "*#"

 %  )"   " *,"

*



"

* "



 "#"  

" 

-  ) <  " ,*  "81  

, " *  ""

3# #" 

 %



 

)

"

) ,

"

"

 

""   ("  "   

$     "         "#  "    

 

"

) 

37* #,"

  *

 , "%

*

, "  

 "") 

  "  7     )  "      

37*   #  " "  $  "  $$*     "    7 ""

)" ,& 

"" ) $  "

)*"

" "* " ;,+ "$
  "#,"  )"#"

 "   "*  "" 

 % *"$ ,)

)

 ,"

 "*

""   6$ #"" *  " "  *   *""  *

  "    

      ,  "    *

 
 *<+#"

 " **7*  

"  ,   ""  " ""$  *  "

7  * " )

 " )*% 

 ""  ,

" 

,    ", ) , 67 > ,   "#$ ")""*    *
"*   )"  

    "  

 ,"    "   #

.   $ #," 

 $  ) 



"  "  $$ " *

 ,"" "  3 #  * # 
"*  )"  

   

  (" #"  )"  *  )$ 

"

$ "  , " ""   ) """  



)   "  "*   "  "        6$ #  "   $  """  " $ ) 

  "  )" $

) @2 4 + "#" "  % %"$#"  



$  "

   "#  $ # #81 672# " " ))  , "*  "*  #" *    * "  

,* 

""   "* ""

  "*

"      "   #  * #  ")  

   .,"

 /6$ #" $ "" *"    $ ) * * "* "# &# " "" "*.

  /  ""

3   %

 ,"

  "*

" "   '

=  #   """ 

 ,& 

"

* , "  "

  "" 

   *

,

 

 

, )  "   "' "#"

/

"*

 "*

""    *

 "

" * ("

 ,    "     "     "     "  #"  

) ""

  "*

" "   # * #")



  "  7 " *  # " "#"  " *

? "$ #  ,   , "$ "

,    ,  "        (" #  "    "

")  ,

$

  @" 6$  ,  $%

  1" , " , " E,*' " *  



$   @.

/ ''@+ 

2 D          



          

     

         

      

 



 

 



       

 

  



  % 

 







       

 

 A    

   %     

 



   

 



  

 

!

"#$%&'

& (( )*!   



  

0



  



   



@  @



  

  



    %

      %  

 +,, 

   "#$$&'

- (( #*.!

   



   

   

  

 

 

           % 

            

 

   

 

   #

  99  5 .

 1         

        

     

            

   

   %    





     

   

 



/

     , 01 "#$$&'

- (( -**

        

        



    

 

 

  

 

  

     

 



 1  

  

   

       



7 

 



  

   















  



 

      

 



 



  

            

  5

   

A 

' 5  &



   

  #

9! .5  #

1

 4A 

  



 



1  



    

 

 





  3 !!     

          









  



'   

     

 





   



   



          

A   

    

    

  

 

    = > 

   

  

    

 ;

1" , " , " E,*' " *         

 !!2=>  454 =5>9 

1
  

  



  1

  



  1 #

!8

) (     

   

   



    %

 

      1 %             

 



 %       

   

    '

     

 

  

5  

          

          

 

     %

  

    #

 !8   

 )  (

                 

                

    %

    

       #

 !8   

   %

 

    





   

 

 

  

    

        

    

  

 %

5    



    %  

 



 1   

  



 

01 #$.*  !

&#)2

'

=  #

 ,  ,*

 , " 

" 



""  "    ,7  

") ",   " *

  @"6$ 

 "

    $    

     %   "  "    *   (" 

" $"* 



 "  * $  

   *             *  $ 

 " ,$   &  %

"$ 1 $  $ #" " % "   "  *  , "

 *  "

 # " , $   $ , "

"  ,,=     "

)

1 "

   #  "    "         *   $ $"*   " " *?

,#           *    $ #  "  * $  "



   ,  $  )

  "   #  "$#  "  ,  "

,)

&"  1 "

 # &<   "" 2

  )

"

)  

 * "*

  

"

"

)"# # "*

" "   # * #")

."*  / H * #) "*#"**  "* "

"*  **,  "#" ,,"  )"

<

"  *  " *,

)""  ) *1




=  "**  "* "

   "*

,"""   # $"**"  )*("  

" $"*  

"  ") "* $#" *  &<

,"

 )"<   #"$#

 ,  "

* &< 7 "* $   

""  * "*

 ,

"

 

,"""     #"* 

**  "  ) "

*  **,   ","  )"<   ") " * $#        *  ,  "     1  #  "    *  <,  )""  )* 1
#"$#" *$    " '

"  ,& * 7*  

$ * 67B   >#"

)

) 1
 

, ) $1 $,  ""

*  &< 

,"  )"<  

 "* $   

  "# " , " , " E,* '   "  *    ,       !. @/ ''4+0 

3    

  



  



   

   

  5

           

   

      

                 1   5     




  !

  "?=#55 83273">

"

  

   

    

  

      

(

      

  

   

  

  

 





      

  

 5 #

'

.

/ +

# ?=#55 9"!% 99> @99       

   

  

 

  

 

 



    

  

        

    

   

 D  

     

     

   

  



 %

  

   

 

   



 



     

            

 

      

 

     

    

 

              

 

    ;

 -

    .A

 #  /  #

 

 %

5 

   



    

 



     

   

-  

 C<?=#55 <C2>
C< #

      %

 &    

A 

 5 #  5 $  1   %     & 

 

  

%   



           



     

-     

 = #

   0A  /

( > =  > "

' 5

   

         <8?=.#   %#55* $.2!>
2!

 (

               

       

 .D<.D8%    

% 



    

 

   

     

  %   

    

     

 % 

   

 

      

       '

 -              

% 

     

   

   

           

       

    

  

       ;

(" 

" $"* 



"" "  *% 7&    

,,"  )"<#" "  "* .

  /

"7&   

* ,,"

.  )"<  , $,1 " )"   % ""     "  

*% 

#"

"  "*.

  / "#,"  )"

<

"

   " 

? "#"



   

    7*   1  #    ,  7 &     

   %  %

   $ #  " "  = 

,    $#  "  "  7  &     

, , " *  $ #  ,, $ ,

" '<" $'#        # 

   ,      $        7  &    

# * 

"" *

   

, , " $ 1#"$#"7 &   

 ** 

    " *,,      ,) # * ,

 "',  $    "  

;

 

"$  , " # " )"$ 

& )* 

, " E,*'

"

'#

""  ,  ,*

* , "



" ? ,#,"  )"<

  "*.

  /#," )

&"

 *

   "    

 "   "

  "      

37*    "# * * "  ""

  * $"  "* ) *



* " $#" "

)   ""

/  "

) " $"  1

 #" " ,"  )"<

 ""   )*1


 $"

*  * "*#" **  "* "

 

"    "# ,"  )"< , $ "$ " 

"  *$    67(2 ," ; # !$ *   #!)*  > "     "

* 7*   (" 7*

<

?*#5,("

  #1'('#.1 ) '

 )

(* ' 1
/!   !)*#"% "

, *



""   )*1


"7" ,  " 67B(" #" " ,

, 

 $"" "  , ,"  )"<

"   )

)  ) *1


"  *

<  ,,, $ , "

'  ?  ,#  "    *

        

 "    ,

 I  "

 *   #,  ,

, , $  " *

  " <"$) ")"

"  *

,"  )"<



"" '"

          "  *    ,   "  & )*     $    (" 

 )" " $"*  

""    ,

" * & "   > >



0 , *

6  ?00  @ >*  4 A*.67
C/$ " "1  '"

 ) "'

, " "  *!)* & " $#"



?0A  > >* 

*#67
'#$ " "" "  * & " '

=  #*%  7&   

#"1 $  ) )) " "

" "    > >!)*#, " ) ""    , ,"  )"<$#

"")*  , " 

  ,  "

   67
C

67
'("

, "  ""  , "  *- "  > >

"

   ) "

!)*, " 6$ "

* 

  0 ''#  "   2   "  "     "  )   - "       " *  

 "  "      *  " $#"  )* 8  #" 

  "  *

1  '"

  ' ,"  "  " I 



$  )       "#  " 

 6   ?  00  67
C  

@ > " "1  '"

'" " 

& " 

 )" $  ) 

   "#"

  67
'  > >* , 1  '"

" "" ) " ' ," " 

*- .

& " /$ )-  

   ""



$  )  "

 (" 

   67
C

67
' ""1  '"

" $ - "# ""   )   

 * ""   *" "#<>1

",  )"

$  ) );   "



37*   "1   '"

"  $  ) "

 #$ ")""* "$

" * $  )  6$ #1  '"

 '

, "   - 

- "# "

    *   "  *, "  

& "" # "  "    "  ","  #" " 

,

  "    '

=  #" $  

 $ " "  

*

 8*        "     "   #   

 "&  ))"")#"       *   

 "  %   "      #  # 1
#

  ("    ,"  , ,"  )"< 

? " > >

"

 ""  )*1
'

=  #"  **  *$    67(2 " ; # !$ *   #!)*

"

  

  ) $1


"

 

,  ) " % ""



  )* * 

 '

=  #)  0 >#"

1 *$ "   67  "* ', ) )" " 



*

 ,*% )"

   *  )",7* ,  7  

"  
* !1 "%("    

*$  0 >

 

 , " ' $# 

) #"



*  * 67 20

4 >

     "

 , "



 & 0

" 

,  -  ) 

'

"

)  67 29*"# "

* 

  0 0''#" "" ,   ,$#"  "  ""  "  

""  *""*6$ #  

* * , "  ")  % "  *% )    *   

     0 0  ''   $#  "  



$  ,  " 

"  

#",$3    ,

"     $      

     %  "  "    *  $ , "  1" , " , " E,*' " *03 /45  


 

 !!

=<>454=5>45428C 

67    8

9,!

"#$$$'

$ (( &:&%

5 

      





     



   





  

     

  1        



    



      

!

&***"#'

(( "(, '

#:$ "(';

"&***'

# (( :%#%

  



 

    

    

    

             %     

            1 5 





     

   

  



 1

       

    

   



    , 7 9 < =  /   !

> &*** "?'

( #.#@ &*** "-'

( "(, '

%% "('

 #"  $"* ) $ $" $$* "  " * "   *"* "

  

*  "   (" 

"   * * 

   "$ " #" " 

* , $ 

# * ** #   * * 

   # " # "%

 "  * 

" ,

," "  *

" 

" 



 #"$

- * " "$  , "



* , "

6$ ""  *    ,$#   ""    , "

'

" E, *'  )    

" ")  " <

 ,*

* , "  

" ""     ,   , 1" , " , " E,*' " *     , 9 !!<=>4545 C8 ?7
) 

   

   

         

     

+   

 

 

 

 

 

     

 

*

 

         A       

 F#

?

+  9 

7, 9  =!

#$$* "#'

( "(  ,'

&%$ "('@ 01 #$$* ( &*$A

.         &     

      



  

   F#

 

  0

  !

#$$&"-'

( "(  ,'

.- "('@01 #$$& ( ):*'

( 

  %   

 %     

-  

   

 

 

    

%  

   G               %  

   

 



      



    %     

   

.       % 



F#

1  9  0  /,

0  !

"01 #$%) ( #*$#'

 /           A 

  B(A       

%   

   ( A    

  

 

$

    B=.

/  #  , 

/    ,

   "#$::

0( " ('

-#?'&

,      



 

H       *

 





 

=#

? 



  < 0



  !

"#$%:

"#'

( :)$'% 



 +7,  0"01 #$)) ( &#?:'+9 

  =



  =  "&**& "%'

7 &%.';

$ ", $ 

* ,$#

* 



 "

  *" *)

- & )*      $    

          +  

, " 

- )#!)*

  #"



*

 "

)*     

# 

#

 #

) 
     

   

                       
 



 

      

     (" ' ,

*  ,% )

)* +

   &&     &)&)+*

*     <"" % )

D 2? <"",  D 2?