Munish Gupta And ORS v. Suresh Kumar Gupta And ORS
!"#"$ %
&'()&&*)
!
"
!
!
!
#
!
$ !
!
# % & &*)+), ' ( # () # % *
+,+-.+/01-2
() 3$ " 04 25 ()
!
# ()
##
(
+.+/ 01 2
()
#()
#
$ ( % & ! ( %/6/ # .+/ # ()
) # !#! # ! #
++.++*
#
) 7!
# % . %
. )
.
)
# %& * # !
) 8 $ 9 !! 3 0 # !
:
!
);2 ##
( !
## # !
#
(
%+6- !
-, 5 <
# % .
## ! )#(
! #
!
! ) ! #
%+6- !
-, =++.+*
(
## # % . !
## % *#
!
#> , .- +++8 # >/
!
# 9 !! # # % & ()
## '
' #
# !
$
)&+&+/# #
##!
(
!
!
<
## % . 4!
# 8 ! ! 3 # ! # $
# # ) 9
5 ! 3 () # ,+ ++ +++8 ( !
<
!
# # )
%+6- !
-, 5 !
++&.+/
# % *
) # (
!
!
( # !
#
#
#
#
= +.+>.+/ #
& % * ! )(
## # ) (! )
#
##
#
# )!
!
"
#
$%& ' (
) *
% ) !
+,-(
,.-/
0
- "
-
-
-
$%& '
) *
) !
+,- (
,.- / 1
0
!
"
#
2
$%& '
) *
$%& '
) *
> 1
3 4 &
&
#
##
!
#
) !
#
# 5
% !
- -
- $% & '
) *
% !
$% & '
) *
%
1
- 3 4 &
6 ' # ! () #
() ) (7!
? 7 7 # ! )
( ) !
!
# =
# %&
*
()# % . # #
- ! !
# ' ()
##
! # <
(
! # >/
!
! ) # (
!
#
!!
!
' !!
#
>/,+?)
+ -++8?) ! !
.--,/?# = ( #
##!
! # 7!
#
!
$
+,+-.+/
!
# ()
## '
(#
$
()
$ 7!
#
#
# $
) (! # ) !
(
# #
( 84!
3$ () "
#
# #
( 02 ' ! # !#!
# ! #
#
# $
@ # % . (
* # !
) #
02 %
! # ! ) ! !
# 02 <
( !
##
! ) )
!
<
7!
!
( 0 2 ' !# !
! !
# #
)# !
# 4# % . 4!
# !
) ' )
# (
# !
)
#
#
#
# ) !
#
'
## (
!
# =&6 .$$ 0 2 '
4 !
"
! 1
# # !!
(
/
# !! ! # !
#
## ' !!
# ( /++8 ? #
#
# !
/ + >& +6*8
#> , .- +++8' $ "
# ! ( ! # # 7!
0 2 ' ) ()
!
#>/ ++ +++8
#
!! # ! #
++.+* )1
() ! ( # !! ' # #
( 1
!(
##
#
! 0 2 %7!
!
(
!
) #
# !#!
# !
0 2 ' )
#
! ( ! ! !
! ) #
(
!
!
, 012 $
) 7 ! %
(
4!
!
# (
# # !
) (! # 012 '
! ! ()
##
! # # #
(! # !
# (
!
!
4 (7!
!
(
#
!
#
7!
<
# ! ! !
7 #3 9! #A;( $
!! "#$ !
!?
# #
'
(
/ # # 7 !
!
) 7 !
!
# < !
! ' #
# !
() !
! ( ( !
(
!
. # 7 #4 A $ %&'())%*)+)
6 ,& %& "- .//$0 12 3+ . /
!
1 # ( ! #
#
# 7!
! ( 4 ")"
-- 0 /2$" $# !
)(
##
! (
# !!
#
#
) < (
()
##
#
#
# !!
(
# (1! (?
)( #
!
$
() $
#
##(
!
# )
! # #!
!
!
## 4 ! # ! # ! (
! # ! # $ (
! )#
!
#
#
# 02 ' !
)$9!! 3 ( ! )
) # 7 () A;( $ " ) ,&, %*)+)) .//$" / <
(
#
&6 >
+
>. # 7 0 2 !
(7!
!
#
!
)
# ! ! !
!#!
) #! !
+ # !#! #!
# #
B ) (
C ' #
!
(
# (# !
!
(#! 02 <
!
)#
# > , .- +++8
# $ # !
! ##
% % 0
2
.- ++ +++8 .
.- ++ +++8 & 5 !
! 3 & .- +++8 >
!< 3 +& /- +++8 - '1 3 -* .- +++8 *
A ! < 3 . -+ +++8 /
A ! < 3 ./ -+ +++8 02 ' ! ) !(
## D
=##! AE4 5 # # !
1! 4!
< (
# $
< ;
5
.
# !
,#
# !
$-.// $ ## # 51 '
( * & * ., >-/ & .- /* &/6 %$ / ., ,& -++ .> .- +++ 4#
1 0 2 , 6 .* &*/ * >/ &*> $ 9 9
! 6 .- &- .+/ . *, 6.>
! + -+ 6, 6,- , * .+& 0 12 1 1 % 31%1221 < (
! 1 #
! # # )
( ( # !
) 0 2 '
!
> ..#
#
+.+&.++>
# ) #
# ## #
# #
# !
( # ## #+F#
!
!
#
#
&+ !
8 ? # &+ !
# ) #
### # # !
( !
# !
! #!
.
? (
!!
# 1 # &+ !
(
! )
!
#1 !!
#
7!
9)# # !
(
! 4!
##! &+!# !
)
)
#
#
# > , .- +++8 <#
# >/
!
! # #
)
!! !
##
# !! ( !
## 0 2 '
# +-+>.+/ ' 1
(
## #
#>/
!
!! ' !
()
##
) # ! )
(
# ) 9
5 ! 3 # ,+ ++ +++8 3
!
++&.+/
# (
)'
#
##; ! ) (7!
&
!
$
1
# G G- ( 1 ( #
) !1 )
! # ' # !
!
!
#
( !
#
<
#
$
1 > 0!
)2 D
(
7 # $
) 3
9 5& '
5 % &67 - 0%2+) ) ./ 80 $27111 (
# !
&6/ &6,# $
!
6-*
# #E $
)$ (( ()7!
( # $ $ 0 2
(
!
!
)( # % .<
#! ! !
.*- ./+ # 7 () A;( $ ))&9&-: ) 0./ .28"8 1
!# !
> !
) !
) !
( ( #
(
!
# )
) $
!
<
) ( # # $ #
## (
( ! # 7!
# ! !
(
! # ! !
# 7 < ! #
( #
#! (#
# #
02 <
!
#
#
(
(
) < ( ! ! # ! #
# ) (7!
# (
# ! (1 ()
$
(
#
# !
) # > , .- +++8$
> ..# 3
#
- 71
8
9
!
"
" (
:8
-
:8
8
-
3;<1 1
%
"
:8
- - =
"
* < (
)
#
&+! ( # #
!( # !
(!
!
' # !
( !!
'
##
) (
# ,+ ++ +++8 ! #
) # (
!
!
# ! #
( !
#!
#>/
! 02 !(
## # () !
## # !!
!
)
#
) (
# #
##
!
# ( !! '
9
# !
1 #
# (
# !
!
!
) ! ) (
< )
( # $ $ (7!
!
)
!(
!# 7!
/ # ' # !
!
#
)
) #
) 7 #
##
(
#>/
! 02 3
! # <#
#
!
#
## 1
! #
#
)
# !< (
!
!
( ! )
) 0 2 $ #
!
)( 7 !
#
!
(() #
# ( #
!! )# % . !
)8$9!! 3 ' )
#> , .- +++8 '
)
( #
# ! ( ( ( ) # !
<#
)
!1 #
##(
, (#
$ '
##
) 1 G>!
#AE4 (
? #&+ ! ! ( !D !D1G>89 (
4!
# $
)
#)# < # )
) !
<
# !
$ # #+ #
# !
# ! # ! ) # ()
## >> ##!
! !! !
) ( (
(! ( 1 # # +&*), .$ 1
7H G 8 I G
%