Smt. Priya Singh & ORS v. Smt. Hem Lata & ORS
!
!
" # $% & !
'
( )! *#% ,-
( ,.! (!+ ,-
( % *#% ,-
( /!
- *#!.+ ,-
'
1!
, 2 3 # 4
3 5,6#
7 '
-2 )# 5)#
-7+ 9 8 :! 8
''2
';
<
#2
= '2
# ' % + 22: '2 !-
&
#8% +
>#2
2 % =# - % 6#
'2 # #' + %#!
+ 2
. 2 % 8 # 82.
'' % %'
'' 1!2 %'26
%
:#2 ' % 8# ' #8% #+ : 282
!#+ ''2 %-
'
<
#2
= '2 # '
3+ - :!!
''2 22:+ 2:
- #8% ''2
'
<
#2
% 2
= &
'+ !
!+ #8% '# : 2 + -
2 #' 2:
2
' 5 + 22: ''2
'
#8%
2:
#'!2
%
1! ! 2
# ''
8.
5 #'
7 6# + !+ ! .
22 ! 6# 2
: - + ! ! 2
% 8 !% #
!2 6# + !+ ! :#2
>#
2- ' =# %
'
# ! 82: "6.
!
But if a non executant seeks annulment of a deed, he has to seek a declaration that the deed is invalid, or non est, or illegal or that it is not binding on him. The difference between a prayer for cancellation and declaration in regard to a deed of transfer/conveyance, can be brought out by the following illustration relating to `A' and `B'
two brothers. "#$
%
"$ & '"#$
%
"#$
On the other hand, if `B', who is not the executant of the deed, wants to avoid it, he has to sue for a declaration that the deed executed by `A' is invalid/void and non est/ illegal and he is not bound by it. ( ) ' %
* +
)
( "#$
!
, ' * %
)
If `B', who is a non executant, is in possession and sues for a declaration that the deed is null or void and does not bind him or his share, he has to merely pay a fixed court fee of Rs. 19.50 under Article 17(iii) of Second Schedule of the Act. But if `B', a non executant, is not in possession, and he seeks not only a declaration that the sale deed is invalid, but also the consequential relief of possession, he has to pay an ad valorem court fee as provided under Section 7(iv)(c) of the Act. Section 7(iv)(c) provides that in suits for a declaratory decree with consequential relief, the court fee shall be computed according to the amount at which the relief sought is valued in the plaint. The proviso thereto makes it clear that where the suit for declaratory decree with consequential relief is with reference to any property, such valuation shall not be less than the value of the property calculated in the manner provided for by clause (v) of Section 7."
@ 4 +
2
3+ :!!
'# 8 ! + : 6# % ,2!# !+ !-
8#+ + . 22 !#+
2:
2
5 #'
7+
>#
!#+ 2:
#'!2 3 $A82 -
'
) ' . !
/
' 12
,) 34+ $ !
+ '
!+ 6 ':
#'
, 2 3 #+ 8#2
#
B
+ 6 ! ': # ''2 -
#
8#2 #8 2 =# % #
%%
' -2
# # %8 $ !
? ':
, 2 3 8# % %+ %#
%%8 #!
#
%%
' 2
6' $ !
? =# #'
, 2 3 ':
! , 2 .' %%#% # :!2 =# % !2 # =#
% '# #'22#
% '#82 # 8#2 # #8 $ !
2 ':
, 2 3 %
# 8# 6 #8= ! !
=#2 '2
*' -:
8-+ ! '
3 22
! :!2 6 ':
, 2 3 # 4 2
#'!2
8 % 2+ % % !"#
Pawan $%&'%&()*&+,-./0(&+)1.&23 &)01 $%&'%&((&*1('+45&3 &)01