Lovely Kumar And ANR v. State Of Punjab


   



 !

!"#$# %& '

('






        
&  )*'+
+'+'+   )*'+
++  

  

! " # $"

% "

&!#





"

!%      

'      

  &  # "#"  ()*)(*++!"$"#

+,
 

(," 

"  & "

# "#  # "  #" -*., /



0!+12*34/04,  5

  # !"$"#   #

, ,!

 -!
%.#" $ /+ ' #%!

%0!



-*., /0 +6

(*!***7, "&    "

"     $ 

" 

-*., /0 +6

(*!***7, "&    "

"     $ 

( '   "   #  &""

&  "    "  

   # 8"

 & # 

"





$

"$"

,


 *(*6(**. ## & 9"

 "

0 "& "

$#"



   &   

 & :""

&     $ 

&



 

"

&

 "

&# ,8"

 

$  '      &&&"!$ 

 &  &"#

'#   "

 ## 

'   # "

#"

&"

 ,"

, $


" " 

"

 "

 ## 
 

!     ,"

, $      # 

          #  "

   &""

&  "

&'# 

   ""

&"



  ""

#"

# #" !  "

  $ #   "" $

 #!

&" 


$ 

";

  &" #

"

&   ## 



"

&

 &# ,8"   &" #

"

 & "



&!   &#

  

:# , 8"# 

 ! "   &" $ 



""

#"

# #"

$"" " "

&"

"

&   



 "

&7 "

&# 

 " '# 

!"$","

"  , $



$ 

 8"

<  "

"

""

   ## ,




"  $ "

" ," 

"'  #  "



 " #  ""  '# 

" #

 ""

9$" $  " 

&" = (2*1(**>8"& 

"#  " >(+)>,(.+>- "

 # 

">>+66,>*>16' !&  ## 

# ,8""

 

 <  

 /" ""#   " '  

  9 "" &    $"#   <

&

$"   #= ()*1(**>!  )**

   # 

   &  $"  "  $","

   , $

 

##

"? $ 

 8"

   8"$ "

& & "

  ' $ "& 

&"

& #'# 

   " &   

&

  ,  " "



$ =  # 

, "





@<:!A,+*/
 

"   @<


 

"#  &"

#  =     "    $"#!    

  B/  @<
7+  $   &"  

"& "

""

 - '  !A,+*,/
 $     (-!?"

"0 !

"

' 8"$ "

&"

 9"

#9"

"  4
"



# ""  &"

&# !$"#$ #  "

 

#

$  "

" " @<B'/ "& "

="# #

" "

C  #"

&

 

"

C   @<

 8"$ 

 9 0  4:

"

&

:

""

& &"

& <

#  # " "# @<07+9 &##&

  ###

#'/ "& "

&="#  

  &"

 ###

#@<?9#

" 

# 



   


# ,8"  "#"  @<D$ " # ,8""

9"

"$ #   #" !$"#$  "

" " @<%   

  $  

      

     :

"& !/ "& "

&="# ###  "

"       # ,8"  

&    >(+)>,(.+>-  9   ##    #     ##   (-++        E  "

 

!

&

0

 !

#!

"

"

 ## ,
 

# ,8"9 "

" ""

#   " @<8' "#" @<D! # 

## (-++@<'

"" #   $   B "##" #


 !0

"&

!  34B
4,  5

&"

&#



$ ""

&# "

 "#" '

 B
@<F$ #"'  ! # "  "& !        #"  +)-      0   0

  # !+>)-340 04,  5$   "

0  . '# $ #

"0 "  

0"8 "#"



&"

!

"

"  *)++(**> 6    

  $   #

&        # "  #" -*., /0

" 8 &!

"

!"  +(++(**>$"#

  & "

#   2 /   

"

"# ! <



  $" " &"

& # #  ) A  <

   #"  -+-  0 0!   

 " & 

&"

 " #

 ' "

"

# #

 "

"# '     # ,8"$ "

&# "

&"& 

 

&  $  "  "

, " "

"  

"$""""

 !

 

 

 "





"$ "& & $"#$

& " = &"

& $&  "

#" ! "

8"4



 #""

&"



"

#" !#

"

 9$ !

"

&  &  !  

 "#

  #

"

 

&

8"$ "

& 

## 

"

 "  



$ &"  #

  &

&#   '#"  # 

"

&

" 

"  

## ## ,


  "$ &  .** C

 $#  #

#

$  $ ## " 

"



"

"  



$ ' $ ""

& 

""

$ $" "

&

#&'     "#" $ $ " 

#  "

 8"$  "

& "

&

 "  

," 

" 

"  "

"

"

 1 /  #" #! ## <

:A,+,8 "



!

& !  G"

!B &

0

 !

"

$          B:4  @<:A+7    @<:A+7:  :A,(  

  

! ="# !
/0H "//9  ;

!

"

$  # "

#"# .)(**-6.*@<:A(7:A,- "

  

!  :A,.   "   "

!  :A,6  

"  

  :A,2

  $

"

&

" ?"

"0 !B &

0

 !  

"

         #        ##    # ,8"$  



  ##  

 $ :A,)" 

!0 ="# ,&"

="#!

"

,//  # @<:A)7:A, 18 "



$  "

 

&9   $ 

 # ,8"



$ 

## :A,>  

!"

& 



$ ""

&<     @<:A>7'  ! #" #$ # > =  #"

" # #

#

"

#  

"!

" 8 &! & "

  # "#   

      #   "  

#"  -*.,  /0  "  "

 &    &     # "#"    ()*)(*++

$  # "

  

  & ""

 &   # ()*)(*++ +* && " $"   "  &  # "#"

 #!      



 ++ A     

  

  #       

" 

   

"#  <

 # #  +( / ""

"

&

!

# 

 #      "



$ 9#   A,.,"





!

 

A,6 "

! # $" # 

$ 

" 

"# 

"

"$

# ,<

A,6, "

9  #  

#  ! $ # $ ""

$"  

,"

, $$ "



" 

"






"

 

#   #     "

9 #  " " " ""  #



 "

 #  "

# "

&"  @<:A)79  # 

" B:4"

  # 9  #  $" # "

:A,-,"



!:A,. " "

!:A,6,



:A,2, $

"

& # "  # $

 



 

  

"



$  

# @ !:A, 1,8 "



!$"# "

  "

!    #  

  $   "

     

&     &   

 # 



$ 

9   #  #    &#     

  $"    "#  

    "  &

&  





 # 

' "

 "# " # # $ $   #

  "

&@ ! 

#  $ 

# 

"

& "

# &

&"& 

$ ' ! #  "

"  # "  #" -*., /0



  +- =  

!

 # #  

# "  A,.,"





! 

A,

6,   "

!         # !  "  "   "      # $  $"# 

$ 

"

#

#" $"

$     /"  " 

"# " # #  "

 $""

 



&#     "#"  @<D!"#   # $ "

&



'

 

"

 #

' !#  "

"  # " 

#" -*., /0

  "

  "

#" ++-, /

@" ##!+1)(34@" ##4,  5



" 

 !  "&# "# 

" 8 &!

"

 +. A  # "   "#  +6 '

  # "#

 " 8 &!

"

  # "  #" -*., /0/   

##" -*., /0!$"

&"

" 

  "

, 3+5 '  $

  # 

 "    $"

#"

# 

# 3(5  #   ##

$""

)



& 3-5     !$

   # #  

   



  "

 

I

3.5  #  #    

      "

 #

#"  $"  

$  +2 / "



# ! " "  # ,8"



 " $"

#"

# 

#$""

 



&$

" *(*6(**.$"

,


" ()*1(**>"$""

"

 

& +) A,-,:

0

!#"

  !:

B "# "#"



'<"#&!%

"# 0&!



"

 &$":





#  #   # ,8"

 

, J

" $ "&

$    





# #/$"

" (6# -# /$   #        $         "  #

" &  '    "

 #"

#

 # #! "; !$ ! "& "

$ "

#"C  $

  "&

 # #!

$# $ "&

 '

&"

$ ## 

"        #  $   

"  /  $   

 

  

#   "

# " #' "

&7#" $  '"

"

# #$ 

0$   ":

"   $  "

"

     $       "

  

 # !  #"

  "  "   "  ## "# 

   

";

"

& -6# <(6# (1<(# $  "

"

  # " 

&"

 



#  /  $           

!  $   

  " 



 "!$

& # "'"

$

! 

;"

 $  "#$"



 "

 #

 @

 $ #"& "$   "

$ <# "&

"&& :

# 

 &$     #!<#"

# # 

"$ "<'"

" !

"

$  " "#

$" # "#

&$   "

 # $ "

" "-<(# $     #

 

 !$   "#" # :

"  $  





.<-# $   "

  +7- 




$ 

 & #  "

#

" $ #  "3)5 "

" $ #



";"-<-# +6<+# $    "

"

 " 

#$ 

## (6*00

"  $  "

##    #  

 & $   

(<+# $   "

# 

"



#$ $"#'

!

 <!

# !  &!" 

" $ # &"&"

$

  

 "
$  

"

"

! 



&

$  

&"

"

#  #
"&

"

"

 "$ 

  "&"

/ 

"

" !#  "

"# $ 

&  ! &

<"

!$"#!$  "#" "



# 

#  K  "

"  "# < !#   # ,8"

!$ 

&  ! & <"

!$"#$  "#" "



# 

#   +1 /" #" $ " # "#  < " 

"

" " #

"#



" 

"

 # " #'9 4<0 "

#  0% 32 45506$'.217!8 99  ('
''
:#,#%2;<   "$ < $" "  $"  #9"" #" "  #

#   "     <

/ #  6#$-%1  =  %0:8  6$'  +  ! 

 -:$- : 

< 

  '
''

:#,#%2

9 4<0   "$  

"# " #" " 

' " "

&   "#" # @<D'   " # "  "#" @<D$ $ "

"&  # ,8"@<F"  "

:"

# B "##" #


 !  !0

"&

'

$ ""

&<  #

 "&

"

@ &"  "#" 

D,+$" "  

  "&

    # ,8"  

 "

 @ &"    +- # 



,+,(('

$ ""

&< "

"

 @<F &" "

""

"    $$   #

"&





,+,(( $    #C " "&

"

"





D,+

' !# ,8"

"   "#" @<D/   "#" @<D!#  # & "#   " & ""

& $" ,"

, $

 

' "  "#" #

"# #  #

" "#" 

&"

&  ' !  "  "   "     # ,8"  

    " $"

#"

# 

#"

&"

&$""

 



& +> ?$!C "

" $ # ,8"

$    #    #     

      

  "

#

#"  $"    

    $             '  <

A,.,"





!   # 

A,6, "

! # ? !"

"

<

,"

,#"!    &"  "#" $ 

"# ## &"

   "



&"

& !       ## 7

     

  

  

   #  

 $ '       $

 "  "

 & ! ## ,


 



&""

 &" #

"

$  

&  



"

&

 "

& #  #   &#

"

$ '  



,


   "

$"#  &$"" $ ""

&!$ "

"

  # "    "

!  "

"  "&# 

 ' !    $" !

 

"

#

$

"  "

 & ,8"' 

#

 

     '   & ## ,
    #  "

   $ "

$ ""

&$ "

" 3#, ## ," 

"5 !$"     $ "

"

!

 "

7"$

"

,
 

' ! &

 &  (* A,.,"





A,6, "

    

 "

 & 

   $  

&$   # "

&



    

 /

 # !" $ ""

& 



""!""  <# $"  &" '

 # "#"

$" 



" #  '$"#     &

    "

  &   /    "



  # !     "    "#  " #$ "

&# 

"

"



' "  

 # $ "

#   

  

#  "#

  "$" # 

 ' "  " #  " 

#  #  



#  &

 & "

#"

 &   !A,.,"





 # & "#  "

# ,<

 " &

$ & "#,& <

"

" "

 #  " $"

$ #

  "9$ !       "   & ,8"  

  "

   &""

& 

   #

"#  (+          " !         "    

 ##

#  # ,8"       "#  #   $"  A,., "





!   / " @<:!"





   #   "

    

,"

, $   &

" # ""# 

 " '"   

"

$  "

$" <' !"

  "##  ! #  $   $ "

&

 ## 



$  ((      !     "#"    @<D  "   #  /  "#" !#   "

  " & ""

& 

,"

, $

 

/  "#"  # 

$  $   



$  (- A,.,"



!  #  " # ,<

  ## $  "

&

"#

"

# 

(**-" " 

&  & $""

9 

 " & & "

 "

  +6*-(**6 
 9" !

"

# #"$ 

 "



" 

 ## " !< " $ 

  ## '  !# # #" 



"    $"< "  !#    #

 ""

# A,6, "

! # 

"" #

""

# ,<



## $  "

&

"#

"

#

(**-" " 

&       &  $"  ## ,
  

     

"    
  

 $    "

&  "  $     "    



&$"  &   " #" 

& "

 
9" !

"

 ## " !

  "

 "  <   $  

    ##     

" #"   & !  

""

&$" 

" ## 

  ""

&"

"

#

#  (. '   ##

" #$   $ "

## 

# ,8"$ ""

&$ 

& "

 " 

"! ,"

, $ # !$"#$   &

7"



,


 (6 ' #" #  #

  #    $" #

$   :A,+,8 "

"

& $ !

& !  G "

!B &

0

 !

"

!"#   B: )6!***7,$ " "



"

  


8"



   *6*2(**>  "               "     ##

#'# "B:"@<:A+79     

 B:      1)!6)67,  $   "   "

     

  "  

" 

  # ,8"  

 $" 

"   (>*6(*+*'# B:"@<:A+7 "

"

!

B: $  "  "

    
 

 # ,8" 

  ((*2(**>0 "@<:A+70"

"

!

B: )22(17,$ " "



"

  

," 

8"

 ((*2(**>$"

" ++*2(*+*/$  # ,8"

$ #"



"



B:4 #     G"

!B &

0

!

  !

#

"

:# ,8"

$ $  ""

#"#


:A,),"

!0 !

 ,&"

="#!

"

,//  #    (2*6(**2    @<:A)7!  $"#  $        +2222C

" $""

    %

!

 ,H 

 "!?

" "!'"

:" "#

"

$ 

$

"

&"

  8"$"


  
+!2)!***7,' " "

  8"$ <#   &


3

5!$"#$  $ # 

,


"

"$", # ,8"

' !  "" #$  ##    # B:4"

# ,8"

@ !  $    #   "

 

  / 

 
      # "

&B:4

"

# !""  "      $   "

&  

 

         

    #

 

7"'

$   & "

 "

 # "

:A,-,"



!:A,. " "

!:A,6, 



:A,2, $

"

&

:A,1,8 "



!

 "

 

&!$   # "

   "

! # ' !"

"$  " " #!<"#" "

##

 #  

# $" #

$ ' !             "     # ,8"  $  ## $" #

$   

 (2 9$ ! " "#" " # #  "

  # ,8"$ #   "  

 

       

     

       # & "# 

"

 "#" @<D " & ""

& $" ,"

, $

 

:# ,8"$  "

&$ #"  &9  $  

 &

 & $  /  ## "

&#"

# 

#  $    #   " "

& $ #"  &'"0 "

# .!!%41,:! "'6$'+  !

:8% 99 ('
''
:2'><;  "$

, J? 

   $    "

"   " " 

     "  ##  #

<  " #  "

"   "

#  " " $ A $

  

&!        <#    

 #"

# 

# <#

 $ &

#"

"

#"

# " 

  

/  

 

"" # 

 $" 

&"& # 

!"

"

" !"$"# "   $""

&#" +*>/



0! " 

#" -*2/



0!""



#  !      #K () ' !

  "  # ! " #   # # "  #  #

  #

""  "#"# ,8" 

'  "

#" ++-,@" ## 

" 



  # ,8"     #

"   "#"  $""

   

    

& 

   $   #   #  

 "

 

,"

, $' !"

# "



 "#"

"   # "  #" -*2/0   "   (1 ? !

$  #

&

     #   "    #"  -*.,  /0!       , 

&#

& #" -*2/0$" " 0   # "#"

&   

       "   #  /   # #"

# 

#!

 $" $""

 "$#" ((+3+5

3(50 0'9 4<0 "

#  4':!,+' %0 % -!:  6$'  02  +:#%#.$    %0  -!:$? 

;  '
''

:#,#%2<9 +
  "$

, J((

 ""  #"



&#

& "  #

0  # "#"

& ##   #$"#"     " # # '0

 # 

 ""   " "   B  #

&

 #" .>1 /



 0 3  C  5 / "#

     #

"  

&#

&  # #" -*2/?"



0<""

# '  ""  

 8 & #" -*2/



0$"#" .>1 /



0  # #  # "#"

&

##   " #$   / 

#

& 

 #"  .>1 /



0!"  #



  ##  ##  ## 



  " #

" "#"' "" #" ((+0

 # 0 #

 # "

 &

$ #

0 # "#

## 

 # $"$"#" #

&  &  # "

" #! #   #

&  # #K ' ! " & "

"

"

# &# "#" 

  # #" -*2/0"

 #" -*., /0 (>


  #      

          

 " "$"

  #9# 

,"



"        

"   "   ## ,

     

&  "#"  ""

 "

 -* A  # "   "#  -+


3

?+5 ## & " "  "

"

&!!:   !0

8 "!

"

   "! & # "

"  *2

*>



*1   *2*-(*+)9 

 "" *.



*+ A" "" ! & "

" 

+*

!*> 

*>  -( " 

"3

?(5$ &

 ""0  +>++(*+(  ## &    " "     (**+(*+)     "  

"

&!  ="#"

"

&    !  0

  8 "!  

"

!    

& # "

" *(

!*.   +6+((*+( 

 "" ++ 

+>  & "     *-  

!  *-   

  +>     $"  ""  9$ !"



" # # ""# "$  " "  +)+*(*+(     "  

"  "

&!  !    !  0

  8 "!



"

!" 

"3

?(5 & # "

" *(

*-   +)+*(*+(



 ""  *+

!*( 

++ 

$" ""  & *- 

!*6 

++ "

"   # "   $     !    $        #    +6+((*+('  ! ## & " " +)+*(*+("



"3

?(5 & *-

 

"

" !

$"  "

 

    " "     (**+(*+)       & "     *-  

!  *-   

  +>         "

     &     #    "

"   "  $           $   & 

"  " ' "# ="# !

"

  "

 $"

&  , J " 

"$7 "



&  2*

B!"    0: 

  9 :/  $"  '(:

 $"    

&"

 $"

#

/ 

#"  $" /



 #

"&

!?



9" !

"

  " #

"&" / "  "#"

$"#   " ! "  

&"

$ 

 "# =:!% ?

:  9" !  

"

 $"  "#   8

  ?

  +)>    *)*>(*+(' "#"

 # "#"

":#

"

"       9  # ""  "    # ""#  

    #

  

&"

 " "  "  

&"

  $" /

"

" /

   K -- /" 

" # #" # , 8"

""

&$"

"



  "

#

# ' "   

#"  -. '  !"

 #

#"

# 

#!"$  

<"      #   

       "   

&   -6 ' !"

&"

"$  ""# " ! 

 "

 $'# "#" 

  # "  #" -*., /0" "



"

  & "

# "#  # "  #" -*2/0 



 # &"

"   "

  &  '   "


(*!***7,  

"

#9$ !"

   "

!



   & "&  "

"  


 "

0      

    "       "

       " $"/ # "

""


3

?+5  "  $""

# " $

"

 # 

+'+'+ 

++   

#*)!(*+) 

A  &7   L7? A   L7?