← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5600/2022allowed

Ashok Chopra v. State Of Haryana

2024-04-04Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger7 pages

        

   

   

!"# $% &#'()($*  ++

),$- ,$./!

++++++++ #"("($*#/ 0#/)1) 2"!"# $% !/3!*!

++++++ #).$*&#*"

    4 5 + 2  2  /#)#*" /+ &("3! 2!*6,(7 &8$'!"# %$/ ",# .#"("($*#/+ /+ 0(),!9 !9(-7  !/3!*!+ + +  2 7 + + ,() () ! )#'$*& .#"("($* %(9#& 1*&#/ 2#'"($* : /+++ $* ;#,!9% $% .#"("($*#/

),$- ,$./!

%$/ 6/!*" $% /#619!/ ;!(9 (* '!)# ;#!/(*6  $+ : &!"#& ++7 1*&#/ 2#'"($*) < !*&  $% ",# !/'$"(' /16) !*& )3',$"/$.(' 21;)"!*'#) '"7 < ,#/#(*!%"#/ /#%#//#& "$ !) 4",# 2+ '"4 /#6()"#/#& !" $9('# 2"!"($* 2!&!/7 !"#,!;!&+ + ,# %(/)" .#"("($* %(9#& 1*&#/ 2#'"($* : $% $&# $% /(=(*!9 /$'#&1/# :< ;3 .#"("($*#/ >!) >(",&/!>* 8(&# $/&#/ &!"#& +++ :+ 1)"$&3 '#/"(%('!"# &!"#& :++ $% ",# .#"("($*#/ () %(9#& ;3 9#!/*#& 2"!"# '$1*)#9 (* $1/" "$&!37 >,(', () "!-#* $* /#'$/&7 )1;?#'" "$ !99 ?1)" #@'#."($*)+ +

/(#%937 ",# !%$/#)!(& '!)#  >!) /#6()"#/#& $* ",# ;!)() $% !  ./#.!/#& ;3 21; *).#'"$/ A(),$/( 5!97 >,$ !8#//#& ",!" $* ++7 >,#* ,#

 >!) ./#)#*" (* /(=# *8#)"(6!"($* /!*',7 !"#,!;!& ",#* ! 2.#'(!9 #))#*6#/ (*%$/=#& ,(= ",!" ! "/1'- ;#!/(*6 $+  9$!&#& >(", (/$* .(.# !*69#) #"'+ >!) 6$(*6 "$ 2(/)! %/$= !=),#&.1/ >,#/#(* ">$ .#/)$*) >#/# "/!8#99(*67 $*# &/(8#/ *!=#93 ),$- ,$./!

.#"("($*#/ 7 >,$ >!) ,!8(*6  -6+ $.(1= !*& !*$",#/ >!) '9#!*#/B !%"#/ )$=# "(=#7 ",# )!(& "/1'- >$19& /#!', *#!/ ,!*( ,!*!* !*& )!(&  -6 $.(1= >$19& ;# &#9(8#/#& "$ /!,=?##" 2(*6, !*& )!(&

/!,=?##" 2(*6, >$19& '$=# *#!/ ,!*( ,!*!* (* ,() '!/ ;#!/(*6 $+  <<< "$ "!-# ",# $.(1=+ % )#'/#" )1/8#(99!*'# ;# &$*# *#!/ ,!*( ,!*!* ",#*  -6 $.(1= '$19& ;# /#'$8#/#& %/$= ),$- ,$./!7 &/(8#/ $% )!(& "/1'-+ $*)(&#/(*6 ",# )#'/#" (*%$/=!"($* "$ ;# /#9(!;9#7 ! /#.$/" >!) /#&1'#& (*"$ >/("(*6 (* $C*!=!',!7 !) .#/ 2#'"($*  $% 2 '" !*& ",# (*%$/=!"($* >!) )#*" "$ 2 !9?(" 2(*6, ",/$16,  21;,!), ,!*&#/ !*& ",#/#!%"#/7 ,# 

!9$*6>(", $",#/ .$9('# $%%('(!9) /#!',#& !" ,!*( ,!*!* $* 2(/)! $!& %$/ )1/8#(99!*'#+ * ",# =#!*>,(9#7 ! "/1'- ;#!/(*6 $+  >!) )##* '$=(*6 %/$= ()!/ )(&#7 >,(', )"$..#& *#!/ !?>!/!

/(&6# $% )#/8('# /$!& !" ,!*( ,!*!*+ %"#/ )$=# "(=#7 ! '!/ ;#!/(*6 $+ <<< '!=# %/$= 2(/)! )(&# !*& )"$..#& *#!/ ",# "/1'-7 %/$= >,(', ! .#/)$* '!=# $1" !*& )"!/"#& '$*8#/)!"($* >(", ",# &/(8#/ $% )!(& "/1'- %/$= >(*&$> )(&#7 >,#/#1.$* ,# 

!9$*6>(", $",#/ %#99$> =#=;#/) )1//$1*&#& ",# "/1'- !*& %$1*& ">$ .#/)$*) )(""(*6 (* ",# '!;(* $% ",# "/1'-+ 99 ",# .#/)$*) ./#)#*" ",#/# >#/# !../#,#*&#&7 >,$ &()'9$)#& ",#(/ *!=#) !) ),$- ,$./!

&/(8#/ 1"! 2(*6, '9#!*#/ !*&

/!,=?##" 2(*6,+ * ;#(*6 )1).('($1) $% ,!8(*6 )$=# (*"$@('!*" )1;)"!*'# >(", ",#=7 )#.!/!"# *$"('#) 1*&#/ 2#'"($*  $% 2 '" >#/# )#/8#& 1.$* ",$)# ",/## .#/)$*) !*& ",#(/ $."($* $% 6#""(*6 ",#=)#98#) )#!/',#& ;#%$/# ! !C#""#&

%%('#/ $/ 99!D! !6()"/!"# >!) !9)$ .1" "$ ",#=7 1.$* >,(', ",#3 $."#& "$ 6#" ",#=)#98#) )#!/',#& %/$= ! !C#""#& %%('#/7 >,#/#1.$* 2 !9?##" 2(*6, >!)

: (*%$/=#& !*& ,# /#!',#& !" ",# ).$" !" + != (* $%%('(!9 8#,('9#+ +

%"#/ %$99$>(*6 ",# &1# ./$'#&1/#7 ",# )#!/', $% !99 ",/## .#/)$*) !*& ",# "/1'- >!) '$*&1'"#& !*& ! .9!)"(' ;!6 >!) %$1*& 93(*6 (* ",# '!;(* $% ",# "/1'- *#!/ ",# &/(8#/ )#!"+ * ',#'-(*6 ",# )!(& .9!)"(' ;!67 $.(1= >!) /#'$8#/#&7 >,(', $* >#(6,(*6 >!) %$1*& "$ ;#  -6+ ,# /#'$8#/#& '$*"/!;!*& >!) )#!9#& !*& ",# )!=# >!) "!-#* (*"$ .$9('# .$))#))($*+ + 5#!/*#& '$1*)#9 %$/ ",# .#"("($*#/ )1;=(") ",!" ",# .#"("($*#/ () (**$'#*" !*& ,!) ;##* %!9)#93 (=.9('!"#& (* ",# (*)"!*" '!)#+ " () )1;=(""#& ",!" ",#/# () 1*#@.9!(*#& &#9!3 (* /#.$/"(*6 ",# =!""#/ "$ ",# .$9('# !*& ",# (*)"!*"  ,!) ;##* 9$&6#& >(", 19"#/($/ =$"(8#+ " () %1/",#/ '$*"#*&#& ",!" *$",(*6 ,!) ;##* /#'$8#/#& %/$= ",# .#"("($*#/+ + 5#!/*#& '$1*)#9 %1/",#/ )1;=(") ",!" ",# .#"("($*#/ ,!) 1*&#/6$*# !'"1!9 '1)"$&3 (* ",# (*)"!*" '!)# %$/ ! .#/($& $% : 3#!/)7 < =$*",) !*&  &!3)

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

1&6#7 !"#,!;!& ,!) >/$*693 &()=())#& ",# !..9('!"($* %$/ /#619!/ ;!(9 %(9#& $* ;#,!9% $% ",# .#"("($*#/ 8(&# $/&#/ &!"#& +++ 5#!/*#& '$1*)#9 %$/ ",# .#"("($*#/ )1;=(") ",!" ",# .#"("($*#/ () /#!&3 "$ !;(&# ;3 !99 ",# '$*&("($*) !) =!3 ;# (=.$)#& ;3 ",() $1/" $/ ;3 ",# "/(!9 $1/"+ 5#!/*#& '$1*)#9 %1/",#/ )1;=(") ",!" ",# .#"("($*#/ () !9)$ >(99(*6 "$ %1/*(), )#'1/("3 (* ",# %$/= $% (@#& #.$)(" #'#(."

+++ ;#%$/# ",# '$*'#/*#& $1/"7 )$ !) "$ #*)1/# ,() ./#)#*'# ;#%$/#

 ",# $1/" $* #!', !*& #8#/3 &!"# $% ,#!/(*6+ ) /#6!/&) ",# $%%#*'# 1*&#/ 2#'"($*  $% 2 '" () '$*'#/*#&7 9#!/*#& '$1*)#9 %$/ ",# .#"("($*#/ /#9(#) 1.$* ",# ?1&6=#*" /#*&#/#& ;3 ",() '$1/" (*  "("9#& !)

 

      

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

.#"("($* ,!) ;##* =!&#+ + 1/",#/7 9#!/*#& 2"!"# '$1*)#9 >,(9# /#%#//(*6 "$ ",# '1)"$&3 '#/"(%('!"# ,!) )1;=(""#& ",!" *$ $",#/ '!)# 1*&#/ 2 '" () .#*&(*6 !6!(*)" ",# .#"("($*#/ !*& ,# ,!) 1*&#/6$*# !'"1!9 '1)"$&3 (* ",() '!)# %$/ ! .#/($& $% : 3#!/)7 < =$*",) !*&  &!3) !) $* :++ + " () !9)$ '$*'#&#& ;3 9#!/*#& 2"!"# '$1*)#9 ",!" (*8#)"(6!"($* (* ",# '!)# () '$=.9#"#7 ',!99!* )"!*&) ./#)#*"#& !*& ',!/6#) ,!8# !9)$ ;##* %/!=#&+ " () !9)$ *$" &().1"#& ",!" "(99 &!"#7 $1" $% : ./$)#'1"($* >("*#))#)7 $*93  ./$)#'1"($* >("*#))#) ,!8# ;##* #@!=(*#&+ +  ,!8# ,#!/& 9#!/*#& '$1*)#9 %$/ ",# .!/"(#) !*& .#/1)#& ",# .!.#/ ;$$- !) >#99 !) '1)"$&3 '#/"(%('!"# &!"#& :++ $% ",# .#"("($*#/7 %(9#& ;3 2"!"# $% !/3!*!+ + $*4;9# ",# 21./#=# $1/" (* ",# '!)# $%  



        !   " 7 25 /(=(*!9 $+   &#'(&#&

 $* ++: $;)#/8#& ",!" (* '!)# $% 9$*6 '1)"$&3 .#/($&7 (*8$98(*6 D1!*"("3 /#'$8#/#& "$ ;# $% '$==#/'(!9 *!"1/#7 >,#/# ",# "/(!9 () 3#" "$ '$==#*'#7 ",$16, ',!/6#) ,!& ;##* %/!=#&7 ",# '$*&("($* $% 2#'"($* : $% 2 '" '!* ;# &().#*)#& >(",+ * ",# '!)# $% # $" %  & '

'    #     /9+ 7 ",# (8()($* #*', $% ",() $1/" $;)#/8#& >(", /#6!/& "$ !',(#8(*6 ;!9!*'# ;#">##* /(6," "$ ).##&3 "/(!9 61!/!*"##& 1*&#/

/"('9#  $% ",# $*)"("1"($* $% *&(! !*& /(6$/) $% 2#'"($* : $% 2 '"+ 2(=(9!/937 (* ",# '!)# $% 

 (

         ) #%  25 /9+ $+ :

7 &#'(&#& $* +<+7 $*4;9# ",# 21./#=# $1/" 6/!*"#& ;!(9 "$ ",# .#"("($*#/ (* ! '!)# $% /#'$8#/3 $% '$==#/'(!9 D1!*"("3 $% '$*"/!;!*&7 '$*)(&#/(*6 (*'!/'#/!"($* %$/ $8#/  3#!/ !*&  =$*",) !*& ",#/# ;#(*6 *$ 9(-#9(,$$& $% '$=.9#"($* $% "/(!9 (* ",# *#!/ %1"1/#+ * ",# '!)# $%        

7 :7 &#'(&#& $* ++:7 ",() $1/" 6/!*"#& ;!(9 "$ ! %(/)" $%%#*&#/ %/$= >,$= '$==#/'(!9 D1!*"("3 $% '$*"/!;!*& ,!& ;##* /#'$8#/#& !*& $*93  $1" $% : E) ,!8# ;##* #@!=(*#&7 ;3 $;)#/8(*6 ",!" (* 8(#> $% &#9!3#& "/(!97 ",# /(6$/) $% 2#'"($* : $% 2 '" '!* ;# &(91"#& "$ !* #@"#*" !*& ",# .#"("($*#/ '!* ;# 6/!*"#& ;!(97 -##.(*6 (* =(*& ",# /(6," "$ ! ).##&3 "/(!9 !) #*8()!6#& 1*&#/ /"('9#  $% ",# $*)"("1"($* $% *&(!+ +

) /#6!/&) ",# $%%#*'# 1*&#/ 2#'"($*  $% 2 '" () '$*'#/*#&7 (*

* '!)# )1./!

7 (" >!) $;)#/8#& ",!" "$ !""/!'" ",# ./$8()($*) $% 2#'"($*  $% 2 '"7 ",#/# ,!) "$ ;# )1;)"!*"(!9 =!"#/(!9 "$ (*&('!"# !*3 &#6/## $% '$*"(*1("3 !*& /#619!/("3 (* &/16 &#!9(*67 )$ !) "$ #*!;9# ",# $1/" "$ %$/= !* $.(*($* ",!" ",# !''1)#& >!) "/!%%('-(*6 (* &/16)+ ,# )!(& %!'" >$19& ;# ! )1;?#'" =!""#/ $% "/(!9+ :+ $*)(&#/(*6 ",# !%$/#)!(& %!'") !*& '(/'1=)"!*'#) !*& ",# %!'" ",!" ",# .#"("($*#/ () (* '1)"$&3 %$/ ! .#/($& $% : 3#!/)7 < =$*",) !*&  &!3) !)

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

),$- ,$./!

() $/&#/#& "$ ;# /#9#!)#& $* /#619!/ ;!(9 )1;?#'" "$ ,() %1/*(),(*6 ;!(9 )1/#"3 ;$*&) "$ ",# )!"()%!'"($* $% ",# "/(!9 $1/" 99!D!

!6()"/!"# 1"3 !6()"/!"# '$*'#/*#&+ $>#8#/7 ",# '$*'#/*#& 2"!"($* $1)#

%%('#/ ),!99 ;# (*%$/=#& !;$1" ",# /#9#!)# $% .#"("($*#/ !*& ",# .#"("($*#/ ),!99 (*%$/= ",# '$*'#/*#& 2"!"($* $1)# %%('#/ !;$1" ,() !&&/#)) !" >,(', ,# (*"#*&) "$ /#)(&# &1/(*6 ",# .#*&#*'3 $% '!)# "/(!9 !*& !*3 ',!*6# (* ",# !&&/#)) ),!99 ;# '$==1*('!"#& "$ ",# '$*'#/*#& 2"!"($* $1)# %%('#/7 %$/",>(",+ ,# .#"("($*#/ >$19& !9)$ %1/*(), ,() "#9#.,$*# *1=;#/ "$ ",# '$*'#/*#& 2"!"($* $1)# %%('#/+ # >$19& !9)$ %1/*(), ,() 1*&#/"!-(*6 "$ ",# #%%#'" ",!" ,# >(99 *$" (*&196# (* !*3

 (99#6!9 !'"(8("3+ ,# .#"("($*#/ ),!99 !9)$ !..#!/ ;#%$/# ",# '$*'#/*#& $9('# 2"!"($* 2"!"($* $1)# %%('#/ $* #8#/3 !9"#/*!"# $*&!3 "(99 ",# '$*'91)($* $% "/(!9+ + * !&&("($*7 ",# .#"("($*#/ $/ !*3$*# $* ,() ;#,!9% ),!99 ./#.!/# !

(@#& #.$)(" #'#(."

+++ (* ",# )1= $% )+ 77  !*& )1;=(" ",# )!=# >(", ",# "/(!9 $1/"+ ,# )!=# >$19& ;# 9(!;9# "$ ;# %$/%#("#& !) .#/ 9!>7 (* '!)# ",# .#"("($*#/ /#=!(*) !;)#*" %/$= "/(!9 >(",$1" !*3 )1%%('(#*" '!1)#+ + $",(*6 #@./#))#& ,#/#(*!;$8# ),!99 ;# '$*)"/1#& "$ ;# !* $;)#/8!"($* $* =#/(") $% ",# '!)# !*& ",# %!'") !*& '(/'1=)"!*'#) /#'$/&#& !;$8# !/# $*93 %$/ '$*)(&#/!"($* $% ",# ./!3#/ %$/ ;!(9 !" ",() )"!6#+ <+ ,# .#"("($* () !''$/&(*693 &().$)#& $%+ +

99 .#*&(*6 !..9('!"($* ) 7 (% !*37 ),!99 !9)$ )"!*& '9$)#&+

 2 

 ++ )?-) E,#",#/ ).#!-(*6 /#!)$*#&  #) $ E,#",#/ /#.$/"!;9#  #) $