High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/781/2011dismissed

Gurnam Singh @ Gama v. State Of Punjab

2017-08-30Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri16 pages

!"# $ ! %& '

()(&$*#+"#

, &(& " "-"

!"#"

, &(& .'

/0 .(&$% 1 &23 /0 .(&$% (43 5)2

.(3

6(3.52+34 %$ $& .&1( +33$ 34 %$ + + (10 777777 (43 5)2+ 2&1(3) $&23& 0 $8 &&0 &3 & & ($ () 31(3) $3$ 3*#"#&& 3095 % ($+32+43 82%20 $& 9(5)2& 36&25)224

2 3)($9 !24)% $$ 3

(&20 (3 5 " ! $2 % $% ()& 3 &9%2 $ % 5(0&$% &%$+: ;<!

&2 $+= 5%$=> 324

& $

(3 ) !

;9 & )8$2! &+##+###?

%2 " ! +($&2 &$2$ " #"##:$2 $9 3 3095(0& 15)28& $$2 !52&$ .@ $2 8@+3282 & % $!

$ 8&!(&2 3095 <> 5$3 5)2 & %$ 3 $ &3!

$ 5(0& 15)22 3

$==

$+ 1$)+A3 8

35(02&223 & !3 82 $$2 $98&&

&& %$ 3$&%& ! $2$$0 ($"# . 3%% ) )&$$ # " :;+82%2% ! &3 !5

2 8@8&$ % $ 3 2 34 3$2 %% 9)&& ) 8

&@ ($ % B2 34 8& $923 3+$2

&& ) &$$)092&&3 23@ $2 490) 2&$2)2& C(9+$2 34 3&% 32& &6&25)23$2 && ) 3&% 32& &(5)2&5% $8&&(& 3$2$ &3 & &8 %9)& $03$2 0)+$2 + & !5 ;# ! 5%$8& D$ $2$%& 98$ & %2$ 3$2 !& .)&$$ E $$ !!% ) $% (30 3 !

&3 & &

$ & %2 3$2 !E $$ 3 !!% +( 82%2 5 <> 11$5)28& C( &$ %2$$2 & $ %2 # ($ &2 5 <>+!$ $ 3(%)2& !$ 3&

! $2 )2$ $ 0 & %2 3 0 & E $$ 3 !!% .)&$$ 0($ $2 %%(& 3 3 !$2 $2 5 <> $2

&$(%$ & 5 <>+& %2 0)% 309$2 38&

3(%$ 382%29 3 3 9 !;@)& !2 8 & &8 )2) #)& %28 & $ 3! 3%@ 3$ % &38

3(9& 32 )2 8&& $ 9%@ 3$ % 3 34 &$)$) !!% 15)2&8 &$2 5 <>!!D &0 ) =5=3= 5= & % &&8 &

% % $)$2 ) 32 5(0& 15)2 23 3 $2 & !$ (& $ &&&$$ 5(0 & 1 5)2 +5 <> 11$5)2@ $$2 & 8$22& ! * 38 &$ 343 &$ &D

"82%2 3(9&) 309%%(& 36&25)23(5)2& (C<D

->82 $2

3)&% 3(%$ 3$$2 & $8

$ 3+8&& $$

5$$ 0&& !82%2 <D

;> 8& 3 309&&&$$5(0& 05)2

()2&$ D

* % %%( 8& 32 $98&3 &$ $2 @28$2.1$6( $2 D$39+$2 $9 8& 3(% 30 C.)&$$ 3!$ 4 !%$ 8& &$ 30%@8$2$2 .2 & % &8 & $!

9&&$

5A+ (10+23)23& $D F$2 $ $&

(3$ % %(& !4 &$)$ +%28& $ 3$2 5 % ($+32 "#*"##2 35 % ($( !3)$2$$2 !%$& 3&% 3% &&

(&20 (3 5 " ! 5%$+! 3%2) &)&$$2 82%2$2 3 3 3 $)($93% 3$ -

*5(0& 15)282 &$2 4 &$)$) !!% $2

$%& &$$ 33 $ )3)$2 $

3)&% 3(%$ 3$$2

& $)2$! & 3 3)$ 9 !2 ($

!) !%2)&$$2 32 3 $ &$0&2 %2) &! 3)&$$2 3 3 &&&$$5(0& 15)282 8&$ $92 3 309 *5) 5)2 &$$ 3 % $ $ $2 &$$ $ 3 09 $2

4 &$)$) !!% *) 15)2 " 3 &$0 1$5)2 &!

!!%8$ &&82 2&$ 32&!!34$D 43

-& 5$&2.2 $3 3$2$ " #"##:82 2 8& @)&5 +

5$$ 4& -+$2 5) 15)2 3(% 33$2 $90 232 4 ! !%$&3 !!D 3 2& & 0 ) =56= ( $2 %& $9 ;

13 5)2+ @+ !!% +A(32 3(% &( 3 3 $)$ 4 2% ) )&$$ # " :;3&2 8) $2$$2 4 2% &$3& )&$ 3$2 !.1$5)2 &3 $ A(323$2$$2 )&$$ % $!%$ & !&%

2 9 &D ;? G 11$5)2+5 <>3 3$2$

" #"##:2 8&8 @)&5 <>+323( $ ! 2 %%! 5(0& 15)2+2 )8$22&)( $$ & $ 89% &&) !A3 8

382 5(0& ) 15)2 3(% 30 30 232 !$ 3&% &)2& 3 $$9& ))2$$ $!

& %20 &

E $$ 3 !!% .)&$$ 0($$2 3 3!$22 3$2 (3 2&&$(%$ &5(0& 15)2% 3(%$ 3& %2

0)+% 309$2 382%29 3 3 9 !;@)& !2

2&!($2 3 3 )3)38) !$8 & &! 3& )$2 & % &&8 &$2 )2

.+ 3 &$0 1$6($ 32&!!34$D G?2&

43 82 2 2&3 3$2$& )&$2 $9 3 2& +$2 8& $$ 38$2 ; !$ % %(& 43 &$$ $& 38

3 3 $ & ! 5 ** 82 $ %$)

43 ))&$$2 8&($$ $ 0 $ D$2

& 0($$2 33 $ %& $ 3 3 !& %$ 09$2 $$2 &$% !5%22(3 5)2 23(3 3% (& !%%(& 3(5)2&&0

%%(& 38 (&()$2 )&$ 3)&$2(3 5)2 G 3$2 3 3B 2 3 &$0 83 5)2 3(% 3 $2 ) &( 3 3 3 3 % 9

) G-3$ 3# "##; )&$ 3$

5$$ 1&D 3& 3B ")$5)282 &$$ 3$2$2 @ 8& %%(& 3(5)2&36&25)2&$2 90 )$ 2& 4) 3 2&% (&&30 )

3 %2%$ 3 3$2$ 9 24) $9$2 4) 8$22(3 5)2&23+ 3 5)23 &%& &8 3))&$2(3 5)23 &82%2$2 98 $33( 82%2 2(3 5)223@ 32&0 15)2 2&3 3$2$ 324

%$ 3!& 9$$2 &$% !2(3 5)2&$2 98 )22&%& )&$2(3 5)2

3$ ($+( %$ 43 +2 3$2$$2

2&0

0 &$0&2%2) &! 3)&$0 3%% 3)9% 4%$ 30 3!

24)% $$ 3

(3 5 " ! 5%$43 () 31(3) $3$ 3*#"# $&0 ))) 3+24 %2 ) 09!)& $

& 3 % (& !

$2 $&+ 82 &&) $2 () 1(3) $+24 &(0$$ 3$2$$2 !& %$ $&& 43 $ ! !%$$2$$2 ()2 3 $8$ &&&&$$ 24

&& %$ 3 $ $2 $ %$) 90($ $2 &38$ && 9 5(02&223 2& $0

309$2 2 (& &24 &(0$$ 3$2$$2 $%& $2 0& D$ 5(02&223 & 30 !$ !3 $% $ 3$2$ &% $2 %%(& 3 24 3 43 $ $4 !

$2 !&

%$ +$2 % 4%$ % $&(&$& 9 0&& !!% 8$ & : 3% (& 24 !($2 &(0$$ 3$2$&% &) &&3 9 0 ($$2

@&& 3)$2 & &!

9&&+$2 + &%$$9 %0 $$%2 $ 5AA 3% (& 24 & &(0$$ $2$$8&%(0 $( $ 24 35 <>5$3 5)2! 82 4 &$)$) !!% 15)2< *>23 4 % $ !

$ )3) $2 %%(& 3 3 $2 0& ! 2&

D$ +$2 & 33 (0$!( # $2&33$ 90

)( 3 0 2! !%%(& 36&25)2$2$&%

$032&0

3! 2& +2 % $0 $$0($ &% (& !9% $03 3! 0)% 309 (5)2&3&&(%22 % $0 3)($9!

24) $$ 39 (3 5 " 5%$ 3% (& !

$&24 $2(&9 3!

%% $% &3!

%C($$ 309& $$)&3 () 1(3) $ " 23+ 3% (& $)$2 5$$ 2&&(0$$ 3$2$ () 31(3) $&8 & 31(3) $32&0

&& 3!$ %$ 43 3$2&0

&(0$$ 3$2$$2 !%$(

! 9 !% $038&3(9 &$0&2 3! &$ 9 * 5(0& 15)23 G5 <> 11$5)22 35$$

(& 2&!($2 &(0$$ 3$2$$2 &$$($ 9&!

)(3&3$ 3098 3(932 $$2 $ %$) 9 !% $033$2$ $2 %%(&$% & && $ 3 $8$ (3 $%(& 93 $$2 ! $2&0

&(0$$ $2$%%(&$% &(3 82%20 38 3% )!@ )&$$ (0 3$2 !%$$2$$2 9 @ 83 $ %2 &2 8&$2$0 $2@ 80 ($$2 $2 0) 3! A 35$$ (& 2&!($2 &(0$$ 3$2$$2 !& %$ 33

& $&$3 &$0&2 33$2 43

3 09 !(9 &$0&2 & $2 %2) & ! 3 )&$ 0 $2 $2

%%(& 3 $2&$2(&0

&(0$$ 3$2$$2 1(3) $ 3

& &(!!

! 9!$9A 3% (& !

5$$ 2&$2(&9 3!

3&&& & * 24 &3 4&(0&& &33 30 $2& ($3 8$2&&&$% ! 3% (& 24 & (& 3 - 3 $ &$0&2$2 !%$( ! 9 !% $03 ! $2 ! $2 %%(& 3 3 ( $2 $ &$ 9 ! $2

4 &$)$) !!% + * 5(0 & ) 1 5)2 * 5(0 & 15)2+82 $2 8$ &&0 D+&$$ 3$2$ " #"##:

2 )8$2 !!%&8& $$2 !52&2$ .@ $2 8@+32+2 4 3$ 2 % &&) ! 5 <H> 5$3 5)2 $2$ ( 5)2 & 3 6&2 5)2

$4 )3%%0 ) )&$$ # " :;3 24) $2 82%2 $2 9 24 $ &(9 $ & 39 32 *5(0& 15)23 3$2$( $ &3!

$ 2 3

# A3 8

3 5(02&2 23 8&&& %$ 3&3 $8$ && 3 3$2$$0 ($ "# .%0 ) )&$$ # " :;% ! &3

!5 2 8@2 %%($& %8 &@ &$ ($ % & 82 8&&$$)0 &3 &$2 34 & $8&2 3)0%@ ( 30) 2&$2)2& 2&3 3$2$$2 34 %3&% 2& &6&25)282 && ) 3&% 32& &( 5)2& *&$$ 3$2$&% &(& 3$2$$2 &&

% $%$2 0)+$2 +2 & 3 ))2$$ ) & %2 3$2 !.)&$$ E $$ 3 !!% 3 3 $ & %2 3$2 !E $$ 3 !!% 2

&$2& & %$8 3&D

"3(9&) 309%%(& 6&25)23(5)2& * C( &$ 35 <> 11$ 5)2$ $$2 & $ *&$$ 3$2$5 <> 11$5)2!$ %2)$$2 & $3&% 32&3 $$9$ 332 &

& 30 30 ($$2 ))2$$ & %2 30 &

E $$ 3 !!% .)&$$ 0($0 3 3!$2 23$2 % & $ &$ $2& %$8 3&D

*3D

- *!($2 3 3$2$(3 &$(%$ & 5 <> 11$ 5)22 3(%$ 3& %2 !0 3382%29 3 3 9 ;@)& !2 *!($2 &$$ 3$2$2

@ ($$8 & &8 )2)# )& %2! 32 3($$2 $ &&$%0 &3 3& $ % & !($2 &$$ 3$2$$2 &3(

32 8& 3$ & $ % 82%2 8 )2)8& (3$ -@)&3: #)& 2&& %!%93 3$2$$2 $2

% &8 & 38$22&& 0 ) =5=38$2$2 & 5 <>0 ) = 5= 2&!($2 &$$ 3$2$ 3%&

$9 )8$2$2 0)33%%8 $@ $ 43

9 D ; !

&34 & )3) 9 !2 !3&% $ ! &$ 9 &&&$$5(0& 15)282 8&$ $92 3 3095(0& 15)2 15)2 & &$$ 33 $ )3)$2 & !0 33$2

3)&% 3(%$ 3$$2 & $ 3)$ 9 !;@)& !2 ! 0)% 309$2 3

G 2&& 3 G5 <> 11$5)282 3 $2$ " #"##:+( $ !$ 2 %! 5(0& 5)2+2 %2 & $33&% 32&3 $$9$ 382 23

33!

0 ($$2 )2$$ & %2 30

E $$ 3 !!% .)&$$ 3$2 !$ ( % & $ & %2 30 2+$2 38 & %2 3(3 2&&$(%$ &09 5(0& 15)232 8 )2);@)&8& 3! 0)% 309$2 3 $2 !

&3$2

8$ &+82 8 %

3$ )$2 2! 30($ $2)&(0&$$% (30 %$ 3& &$ 3 (0$ 4 %$9 &$$ $& 3% (& &24 && !

) (3$2$$2 93 $8$ && 95(02&223 82 & &$$ 24

&& %$ 3&3 $8$ &&09$2 $9 2& $0

309$2 3$2$$2 &3 && & 2)293 (0$!( : 24 &3 !

&3&(0&& $& 3 (0$% %$$2$ 5(02&2 23 2& $ 0

3 09$2 + && %$)3 $8$ &&&( !(3 3 $( !8 %$3

& $3$ $2$ 9%& ! 93 $ 8$ && 2& $ && %$ 3 4 ! 3 $8$ && 2& 0

&& %$ 30($ $ 38 (3 $%(& 3 $$2 ! $2&% $ D$90 3 1(3) $ ! =0 5(

($ $ 3& % & %'

()%* *+, *

- .82 $8&2 3$2$ %& % $0 3 (0$ 3!

D$ !3 $8$ & & %982 & $2) 3$ &2 8$2$ 43 ! !!%&&($(&$8 $29 "# 9 $ %& $ 3& !% $ / ).0

()%* * 2

+$8&2 3&!

8&'

3-.

*4*.) ") 5* #

'*.

* *. ) *"*# )'* ))) # *.*)* 2).5 #

2)"* *#'*.)5) 6# 24*. 5"

7).'*.#) * *'

#*"'* )))8*.*)* 2 *. ) 5 # * " "

# *5)*'*.24*.5* # * 2 *5 *.) 8 *.5))5* ) 7*.,# 4*.5* #)*.,# *. )5 "

# 5 *5)*'*.24 *. 5* 2 #)" , . "5* * ).5 # * # ) ) 2 *. )5 * *.

'* ))*. * *9 ).5 #",'# '*.#)*5)*:

" $2 $%& +& %2 38& 3$2 ! E $$ 3 !!% $2 $2

8$ &%(3)$2 E $$ 3 !!% 24

&$$ 3% &&$ $9 )3)$2 82%2$2 & %28&% 3(%$ 3 4& & !5 ;# 5%$24

3(9% 38$2 & $2) 3$ 3 (0$$2 $(&$8 $2 && ! 8$ 23% 3(%$ & %23&%2) !!%3($ &$2

%%(&$% &$2 !%$$2$ 3 $8$ &&2&0

309 % $0 3$ !$$ 2

2& $2(& !(9 &$0&2 3 $2 !%$( ! 9 ! 2 ;@)&! 0)% 309$2 3$2 % "" $2& D$0

&(0$$ 309 3% (& &!

$&$2$&%

&3 9 !0 ($$2

@&& 3)$2 & $03$ 5A!

$&%2 % D$ +$2 + &%$$9%0

$$%2 $ 5A&$& 43 $$2$$2 $ )230

($E 09$2 $ 8$2$2 & && &$ %( !4 (0 $ ! 5A "* 24 &3 !

&3&(0&& $2 $%& 9 8& 3 " #"##:2 & 8&& $$ 5A :"##: !$ 0 ($$2

@& " 3 &$0 1$5)2+2&!!34$+ 3$2$ :"##:.1$6(23 3 &

% 8 )2)#)&3(9& 38$2& &0 ) =5=+= 5= 3 =56= !

3 &$) $2 &

&% 5% A0 $ 9 3 %% 3)9+ 2 3 &$ 3 $2 &

&% 5% A0 $ 9+ 23)2 !($2 3 3$2$& )&$2 & 32& 8& $$ 38$2 "- 2&& 3 3 &$0 1$6(82

3$2$ " #"##:2 8& &$ 3&.

5$$ 4& -+323 &339& 5$&2.2 $23 3

%& $9$ 2 3 3$2$ :"##:2 23 3

3& % 8 )2)#)&$ 3 &$0 1$5)2!

&$)$2 8$2

&%5% A0 $ 9+23)2382

!$ 3 &$)$2 23 3 $$ 2 3 3$2$ & )&$2 $9 32& +$2 8& $ 38$2 (& $ 5A<D F>&2 8&$2$$& & %!%9 3 $2$& & & % &8 !

(3$%$

3$ 38$2$2 & % & $2 %%(&$% &$2 & 2399

$ 3 (0$$2$$2 & &23 0

$ 38$23 $2(&+$2 3 9+!9+& 3)$2 &

&%5% A0 $ 9 (3 &)!%% =0 5( ($%& $ 3& % 1 # % 7.()%* *95 ;

"82 $2 8&3 9

!-#39&& 3)$2 & !

$&%2 % D$ 0($$2 & & !

(3$ $%$82 $ %2 !!% %2 % + 3$2$$2 3 9% (3 $24 %(& 39 1(3% $ )2$ !$ !

&31(3) $+$2 3 9$2 $%& 3)$2 & % $ ) * %(& 93 (0$$2

& %982 43 3% 9 &$0&2 &$2$$2

& % 2& $0

$ 38$23$2 & 23 3$%$ $ $ $2& )3& 309 3% (& !

$&& $2(&!

(3$ 3 3 ! $3& 3 "; 3% (& $) $ 6&25)24 $9)( $2$2 % $0 &3$ % &% (& $03

8& 934 4 2% C( &$ 3$2 0) ) 39% $) 8& !(5)2&82 23@ $$2

2&3$2$$2 0& !

!% &% (&

$03%%(& 36&25)2% $0 30 !

24)% $$ 9 "G 24 &3 !

&3&(0&& $&% %$$2$$2 $03 8&!

(30)82%28&@ $$2 !%%(& 3(5)2& 82 6&25)28&34)$2 %C( &$ +$2

9 %%(&$% &82%2 3$ 3 9 %(& $2$ $2 $2 %%(& 3 8 23 ) !

% && ! $2 C( &$ &$ !$& $%& 82 38 0& ($ 9 &$) & $ %2 $2 $2 8$ && 3 09 $2 %%(& & 4 & B ")$5)2+$2 4 9!&$ &$$ 3$2$2 @ 8& (5)2&36&25)2&$2 90 )$ 2&4)

30 $2 2&% (&0 &2(&+%& 3

$ )$5)2$& 04 (&$2$$2 9 *) & $ 3 ($2 D$9 ! $ 0 $8

&& 43 $! $@ 09 3$2 &$$ $(3 5 ** 82 0 $2 23$@ &$3$2$$2 924

!& 9 3 309$2 $ &$% !5%22(3 5)2 82 8& % $ & 2(3 5)223(3 % (&3$2 38 (&()$2

%& )&$ 3)&$2(3 5)2$2 %%(&$% &$% $0

3$2$0 382 8 $4 )$ ) %3

% 9 $ 38 (3 $0 @ 8)&$ 82$8&$2 $2 0)% 09 3 "

($2 +$2 !%$$2$$2 %C( &$ 8&0 )!%$$ (& )&$$ (0 & & @&4 ( 0 ($$2 $ $& 34 82 8 (3 24 D&$ 82 8& !%0 )!%$$ (& )&$$ (0 2 $2&% $ D$2& 3 ;

13 5)2+ @ !!% ! + A(32 82 23 0 ()2$ $2

&( 3 3 $)$ )&$$ !4 2% ) )&$$ # " :;33 3$2$$2 &3 )&$$ (0 & !

5$!($2 36&25)28&& !

(3$ %9) $2

&%3&82%2&)$2 ((&(9%& +$2 8 )3) &% (& &8 & $$ 33 9& $&!

&$0&2$2$2 8& $ $2&% $ D$ 90 3 1(3) $ ! =0 5( ($ $ & %+ .

# #*.)()%* *1 2

82 %& 82 23 31

82%2$2 8 $2

%%($&3$2 1

8&!

(3$ $)#0)& ! 92(&@ )2)-@) %2 $8&2 3$2$! 1 $ 3)

4& & !5 *;3;- %$+$0 &% $2$!$2 &!

(3$ $03$% +2 & &( 24

$$ (3 4$ 4& & %$($$2

$9& 3$2&!($2 0

2 3$2$$2 8 3=% &% (&= & 8 &&0 ($$%(!%$3$&&$$ !382%2&3 0 $ $ 33$2$ )4 %&

3 $0 %$(29&% " &&

#,% 7.()%* *1 2

$2&

2 3$2$ !% $0309$2 32&0

&$0&2 3$&!

3&%2) (& !

!$2$2 8& % &% (& ": 2(&+ 4 8 ! $2 0 + $ & & $$ 3 ) &$ $2$

$03$% &! 3& &$0&2 3+$2

0(3 &2!$& $ &$0&2$2$$2 923 @ 8 3) *# B2 !%$& $%& 3)2$ $

0 31(3) $&8 !3$2$$2 382 8 $4 )% )!%$$ (& )&$$ (0 382 @ 8$ %2 3 *) $ %2 324 $% ($8$29 D$ $

1(&$!9$2 $03 $ &2 8$2$9 8& % &% (& ! $2 & + 8 (0 $ &(0&%0 $2

$ $ ($!

$2 0 2! $ 6&25)2$2$2 8& % &% (& 3% $03 $ )( $2&0

& 3 () 30 $2& ($ * 4 8 (!

&33&%(&& &+8 3 $!39!$9$2

() 31(3) $3$2 &2 09!! 3 *" & $$2 &3$2 093&&& 3

!"#!$% 2 B2 & @)? & &?

B2 $0