Amit Arora @ Amit v. State Of Punjab

  

       
 

   




 

      

   
  

 

      

   
 



      

  
   

     

  
 !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2#,



  

3 3

 




4
56




5

  

 



7 
5

  

3  

 

  !

"#,#899',#(800#..8+$,"8:#9"8..#+)#($"#9-+:19$1-+8+(

 ,#+$#+9#08,,#(/;$"#$%18. -'%$1+98,# -
<=(8$#(
7
 = %#)1,$#%#('+(#%#9$1-+,5%#8(>1$"#9$1-+57 8+(#9$1-+5=4 

99',#(8+&8;8,,8.,-"8,9"8..#+)#($"#9-+:19$1-+8+(,#+$#+9# 08,,#(8)81+,$"1*'+(#%#9$1-+<-?$"#%*,9$ "#*81+899',#( 8'%8/"'/#;"8,8/,9-+(#(  

"#/%1#?98,#-?$"#0%-,#9'$1-+1,$"8$-+
 =8$8/-'$ 
<0 * !
8,>1+(#%1+)">"->8,>-%@1+)8, 0#%8$1-+8.8+8)#% 1+A, 8,"8+8)#*#+$#%:19##9'%1$1#,$( -(#.->+B$#+,1-+ '("18+8>8,0%-9##(1+)-+8#%--+(80.#+(-%*-$-%9;9.#$8@1+)"1, &'+1-% 8@#,"3'*8%8,01..1-+%1(#%  +$"#,$%##$-? 8)8+0"-$-,$8$$>- 1+(';-'+)*#+-+/.89@'.,8%*-$-%9;9.#98*#?%-*/#"1+(8+(-+#-? $"#*-0#+#(?1%#8$ 8&#,"3'*8%8,8%#,'.$-?>"19"$"#/'..#$"1$ 8&#,"

3'*8% "-,#$>-;-'+)*#+$%1#($-,+8$9"$"#/8)9-+$81+1+)98,"?%-*

8&#,"3'*8%>"->8,1+&'%#( !
)-$(->+?%-*"1,*-$-%9;9.#8+( )%800.#(>1$"$"-,#$>-;-'+)*#+>"->#%#>#8%1+)"#.*#$, "#1% "#.*#$,?#..-+$"#)%-'+(  #8.,-%81,#(8+8.8%*  #$8+-$"#%#%- -+(8*-$-%9;9.#?-'+(08%@#(+#8%$"#0.89#-?-99'%%#+9#  +$"#,81( *-$-%9;9.#$>-;-'+)*#+>#%#8.,-?-'+(,1$$1+) "#%#8?$#%8..$"#?-'% ;-'+)*#+?.#(8>8;-+$"-,#$>-*-$-%9;9.#, !
$--@1+&'%#( 8&#,"

3'*8%$- -,01$8.'("18+8>"19"(#9.8%#( 8&#,"3'*8%(#8( # ,'??#%#(,$8$#*#+$,B -+$"#/8,1,-?>"19"8+ >8,%#)1,$#%#( "# 0-.19#$--@1+$-0-,,#,,1-+$"#/8)9-+$81+1+)98,">-%$"
5< A'+(#% B ?%-*!
1+ -,01$8.'("18+8   +
4 ="#,8> 899',#(8'%8/"'/#;8+&8;8,, -"1$1,"%88+(*1$%-%8 *1$

5 ,$8+(1+)-+808+,"-0 "#;>#%#$8.@1+)$-#89"-$"#% "#;800#8%#($- /#0#%,-+,>"-,"-$(#8( 8&#,"3'*8%-+
 = !
0%-9##(#($- $"#08+,"-0-+$"#0%#$#B$-?,##1+)$"#1%?89#, #1(#+$1?1#($"-,#?-'% 0#%,-+,$-/#$"#,8*#0#%,-+,>"-@1..#( 8&#,"3'*8%-+
 = # #+C'1%#($"#+8*#,8+(8((%#,,#,-?$"#?-'%899',#(?%-*-$"#%0#%,-+, >1$">"-*$"#;>#%#$8.@1+)>"1.#,$8+(1+)8$$"#08+,"-0  "#,81( 0#%,-+,(1,9.-,#($"#+8*#,-?$"#8?-%#,81(?-'%0#%,-+, "#%#8?$#%"# ,'??#%#(,'00.#*#+$8%;,$8$#*#+$/#?-%#$"#0-.19#

!
5 '%0%##$1+)">"->8,$"#1+:#,$1)8$1+)-??19#% %#9-:#%#(801,$-.$>-.1:#98%$%1()#,8+('.,8%*-$-%9;9.#-+$"#/8,1,-? (1,9.-,'%#,$8$#*#+$,'??#%#(/;899',#(8+&8;8,,$>-*-/1.#,#$,-+ $"#/8,1,-?$"#(1,9.-,'%#,$8$#*#+$,'??#%#(/;899',#(*1$%-%8-+# #%--+(8*-$-%9;9.#8$$"#1+,$8+9#-?$"#(1,9.-,'%#,$8$#*#+$,'??#%#( /;899',#( -"1$1,"%8

"# $%18.  -'%$ "8:1+) 8(:#%$#( $- $"# #:1(#+9# -+ %#9-%( %#$'%+#(8?1+(1+)$"8$$"#0%-,#9'$1-+#,$8/.1,"#(/#;-+(%#8,-+8/.#(-'/$ $"#9"8%)#,?%8*#(8,8)81+,$$"#899',#(

<

#8%+#(  9-'+,#.  800#8%1+)  ?-%  $"#  800#..8+$,  :#"#*#+$.; ,'/*1$$#($"8$+-$#,$1(#+$1?198$1-+08%8(#>8,9-+('9$#( !
1(#+$1?1#( $"#,#$"%##899',#(8?$#%
;#8%8+(*-+$",('%1+)$"#9-'%,#-?$%18.

"#%#>8,+-#:1(#+9#8(('9#($-(#*-+,$%8$#$"#*##$1+)-?*1+($- 0%-:#$"#9-**-+1+$#+$1-+ '00.#*#+$8%;,$8$#*#+$,'??#%#(/;!
.--@,:#%;8%$1?1918.

"#08+,"-0#01,-(#1,9-*0.#$#.;,$8)#*8+8)#(

"#%#9-:#%;-?*-/1.#0"-+#,0-,,#,,#(8+(->+#(/;899',#(*1$

7 %-%88+('.,8%*-$-%9;9.#0-,,#,,#(8+(->+#(/;899',#(8+&8;8,, (-#,+-$1+8+;>8;9-++#9$$"#899',#($-$"#9%1*#  "#01,$-..1:# 98%$%1()#,8+($"##*0$1#,"8(+-$/##+,#+$$-/8..1,$19*1,,1.#,#B0#%$$- 9-++#9$$"#>#80-+$-$"#9%1*# #8.,-9-+$#+(#($"8$!
9-'.(+-$/# 9-+,$%'#(8,8+#;#>1$+#,,1+8,*'9"8,"#>8,+-$$"#-+#>"-$--@$"# (#9#8,#($-$"#"-,01$8.

-+#B8*1+8$1-+-?8+;1+(#0#+(#+$>1$+#,,$- ,0#8@8/-'$$"#9%1*#>"19"$--@0.89#1+$"#*8%@#$8%#8('%1+)/%-8((8; .1)"$9%#8$#,8(-'/$1+$"#98,#-?$"#0%-,#9'$1-+1$>8,,'/*1$$#(

, 8+&%1#"%'38'..#8%+#(((.



'+&8/:#"#*#+$.;

,'/*1$$#($"8$$"##:1(#+9#-?!
98$#)-%198..;#,$8/.1,"#,$"#98,#-?$"# 0%-,#9'$1-+ ,!
>8,'+(#%,"-9@"#"8(+-$9-*#-'$>1$"$"#(#$81., -?$"#08%$19108+$,1+$"#9%1*# "#,'00.#*#+$8%;,$8$#*#+$,'??#%#(/;

"1*1,?-'+($-/#+8$'%8.

"#%#>8,+-#B0.8+8$1-+?%-*$"#899',#(?-% $"#%#9-:#%;*8(#?%-*$"#* "#;:#%;?89$$"8$!
,'??#%#(,$8$#*#+$ /#?-%#$"#0-.19#8$$"#"-,01$8.>-'.()-$-,"->$"8$"#>8,:#%;*'9" 0%#,#+$8.-+)>1$"$"#(#9#8,#(8$$"#"-,01$8. "#.80,#-+$"#08%$-?$"# 1+:#,$1)8$1+)-??1918.1++-$(#,08$9"1+)$"#>#80-+$-$"#/8..1,$19#B0#%$ (-#,+-$9%#8$#8(#+$1+$"#98,#-?$"#0%-,#9'$1-+*-%##,0#918..;>"#+ 8+#;#>1$+#,,"8,#,$8/.1,"#($"#98,#-?$"#0%-,#9'$1-+

"#*81+899',#(8'%8/"'/#;1,,$1..8/,9-+(1+) +$"# #:#+$-?"1,800%#"#+,1-+"#>1.."8:#$-?89#$%18. +;-/,#%:8$1-+*8(# /;',-+$"#8..#)#(%-.#0.8;#(/;"1*1+98',1+)$"#(#8$"-? 8&#,"

3'*8%>-'.(8(:#%,#.;8??#9$$"#?'$'%#$%18.$"8$*8;/##*/8%@#('0-+/; $"#  0%-,#9'$1-+  8,  8)81+,$  $"#  ,81(  ,$8%  899',#(  "#%#?-%#  >#  "8:#

< #B#%91,#(('#98'$1-+1+(1,9',,1+)$"##:1(#+9#8(('9#(/;$"#0%-,#9'$1-+ 1+9-++#9$1-+>1$"$"#%-.#0.8;#(/;$"#,#899',#(

!
1,$"#,$8%>1$+#,,1+$"1,98,# #"8,/##+0%-&#9$#(8, 8+#;#>1$+#,,$-$"#-99'%%#+9#  $"8,/##+8..#)#(/;!
$"8$$"# -99'%%#+9#>8,'+?-.(#(>"#+"#>8,89$'8..;(%1:1+)$"#*-$-%9;9.# $8@1+)$"#:19$1* 8&#,"3'*8%8,01..1-+%1(#% #,'??#%#(8,$8$#*#+$&',$ /#?-%#7 0 * -+
 =8,%#)8%(,$"#-99'%%#+9#>"19"$--@0.89#8$

<0 * -+$"#,81((8;

#"8(,'??191#+$$1*#$-%#9-+91.#"1*,#.?>1$" $"#:1-.#+$8+(-'$%8)#-',-99'%%#+9#$"8$$--@0.89#1+"1,:#%;0%#,#+9#

+-%*8.0%'(#+$*8+>-'.(+-$"8:#-*1$$#($-%#?#%$-$"#0%#,#+9#-? $>--$"#%899',#(-+8+-$"#%*-$-%9;9.#>"19">8,?-'+(08%@#(+#8%$"# ,9#+#-?9%1*# "#:#%;-*1,,1-+-?$"#%-.#-?$>-899',#(>"-8..#)#(.; ,8$ -+ 8+-$"#%*-$-%9;9.#08%@#(+#8%$"#,9#+#-?9%1*#1+ $"#?1%,$ 1+?-%*8$1-+%#0-%$,'??#%#(/;"1*1+?89$$"%->,8(-'/$-+$"#:#%,1-+-? !
8,%#)8%(,$"#%-.#0.8;#(/;$"-,#$>-0#%,-+,

=

,  %1)"$.;  0-1+$#(  -'$  /;  $"#  9-'+,#.  800#8%1+)  ?-%  $"# 800#..8+$,!
"8,9-*#-'$>1$"8$-$8..;8%$1?1918.:#%,1-+$"8$-+$"# +#B$(8;"#,0-$$#(8..$"#?-'%899',#(1+?%-+$-?808+,"-08+(-+ 800%-89"1+)$"#08+,"-01+$"#)'1,#-?0'%9"8,1+)08+?%-*$"#,81(,"-0 "#1(#+$1?1#(8..$"#?-'%899',#(8,$"#0#%0#$%8$-%,-?$"#9%1*#8+( $"#%#?-%#"#9-..#9$#(8..%#.#:8+$08%$19'.8%,-?8..$"#?-'%899',#(?%-* ,-*#0#%,-+,>1$">"-*$"-,#?-'%899',#(>#%#$8.@1+)1+?%-+$-?$"#08+ ,"-0 #1$"#%$"#08+,"-0@##0#%+-%,-*#-?$"#0#%,-+,?%-*>"-*!
9-..#9$#(  :#%;  :1$8.  1+?-%*8$1-+  >#%#  #B8*1+#(  /;  $"#  0%-,#9'$1-+  $-

 #,$8/.1,"$"#08+,"-0$"#-%;0%-&#9$#(:#%;>#8@.;/;1$ $1,+-$8,1?$"# 0#%,-+,>"-,"8%#($"#1+?-%*8$1-+>#%#8/,-.'$#.;,$%8+)#%,$-!

!
"8,1+?89$98$#)-%198..;8(*1$$#($"8$-+#-?$"#0#%,-+,>"-,"8%#( $"#1+?-%*8$1-+>8,8.%#8(;@+->+$-"1* $1,%#8..;,'%0%1,1+)$"8$#:#+ ,'9"8@+->+0#%,-+>8,+-$8,,-918$#(/;!
5('%1+)$"#9-'%,#-? 1+:#,$1)8$1-+$-/'$$%#,,$"#:#%,1-+-?!
+-'%9-+,1(#%#(:1#>$"# ,'00.#*#+$8%;,$8$#*#+$,'??#%#(/;!
1,9-*0.#$#.;8+8?$#%$"-')"$8+( $"#%#?-%#1$(-#,+-$1+,01%#9-+?1(#+9#



#$',+->$8@#'0$"#%#9-:#%;-?$"#*8$#%18.-/&#9$,0'$ ?-%$"/;$"#0%-,#9'$1-+ >-*-/1.#,#$,"8(/##+%#9-:#%#(?%-*899',#( *1$%-%8 $1,$"#8(*1$$#(98,#$"8$$"-,#$>-*-/1.#,#$,>#%#->+#( 8+(  0-,,#,,#(  /;  899',#( *1$ %-%8   $  1,  $"#  ?'%$"#%  98,#  -?  $"# 0%-,#9'$1-+ $"8$'.,8%*-$-%9;9.#>8, %#9-:#%#(?%-*899',#(8+&8; 8,, $1,+-$1+(1,0'$#$"8$$"#,81(*-$-%9;9.#>8,->+#(8+(0-,,#,,#( /;8+&8;8,,  +(#%$"#,#91%9'*,$8+9#,,'9"%#9-:#%;?%-*$"#8/-:# 899',#(0%-&#9$#(/;$"#0%-,#9'$1-+(-#,+-$1+8+;>8;9-++#9$$"#*$- $"#9%1*#

"#%#>8,+-%#8,-+?-%$"#*81+899',#(8'%8/"'/#;>"- 8..#)#(.;-0#+#(?1%#-+$"#(#9#8,#(9"8+)#"8+(,$"#01,$-."#',#( $ 8+;%8$#1$"8,/##+,'/*1$$#(/;$"#0%-,#9'$1-+$"8$$"#01,$-.8+($>- .1:#98%$%1()#, >#%#%#9-:#%#( ?%-*899',#( 8+&8;8,,   +.#,, $"# 0%-,#9'$1-+#,$8/.1,"#,$"8$$"#,81(01,$-.8+($>-.1:#98%$%1()#,"8(,-*# 9-++#9$1-+>1$"$"#9%1*#899',#(8+&8;8,,98++-$/#9"8%)#(>1$"$"# -??#+9#'+(#%#9$1-+5%#8(>1$"#9$1-+57

"#?89$%#*81+,$"8$

 $"#01,$-.$>-.1:#98%$%1()#,8+($"##*0$1#,8..#)#(.;%#9-:#%#(8$$"# 1+,$8+9#-?899',#(8+&8;8,,>#%#+-$,#+$$-$"#/8..1,$19#B0#%$?-% 9-++#9$1+)$"#,8*#$-$"#9%1*# +?89$>##+$#%$81+8(-'/$8,$-$"# 0-,,#,,1-+-?01,$-.8$$%1/'$#($-899',#(8+&8;8,,1+8,*'9"8,$"#,81( >#80-+>8,8..#)#(.;',#(/;$"#*81+899',#(>"-1,8/,9-+(1+)



"#-99'%%#+9#"8($8@#+0.89#1+/%-8((8;.1)"$8$8*8%@#$ 0.89# -+#-?$"#0#%,-+,?%-*$"#0'/.19>8,8,,-918$#($-,0#8@#1$"#% 8/-'$$"#-99'%%#+9#-%8/-'$$"#8..#)#(%#9-:#%; +$"#,81(?89$,8+( 91%9'*,$8+9#,-?$"1,98,#+-+8,,-918$1-+-?8+;1+(#0#+(#+$>1$+#,,8,8+ #;#>1$+#,,8+(8.,-8,8>1$+#,,$-$"#(1,9.-,'%#,$8$#*#+$8+(%#9-:#%;-? $"#*8$#%18.-/&#9$,%#8..;98,$,89.-'(-+$"#98,#-?$"#0%-,#9'$1-+

'%$"#%  $"#  0%-,#9'$1-+  1+  8..  ?81%+#,,  ,"-'.(  "8:#  9-+('9$#(  $#,$ 1(#+$1?198$1-+08%8(#$-?891.1$8$#!
$-%#98..$"#1(#+$1?198$1-+-?$"# 899',#( '$$"#0%-,#9'$1-+"8,9-*#-'$>1$"8+'+/#.1#:8/.#,$-%;$"8$ !
"8(8+-998,1-+1(#+$1?1#(8..$"#899',#(1+?%-+$-?808+,"-0

5

$1,$%'#$"8$!
>8,+-$,"->+1+$"#*#(19-.#)8.%#0-%$8, $"#0#%,-+>"-/%-')"$$"#1+&'%#( 8&#,"3'*8%$-$"#"-,01$8.

$>8, -+.; 8"'.>"-"8(1+?89$/%-')"$$"#1+&'%#($-$"#"-,01$8.8,0#%$"# 8/-:#%#9-%(  -*8+;0#%,-+,9-++#9$#(>1$"$"#1+&'%#(>-'.("8:# )8$"#%#(8$$"#"-,01$8.8+(,-*#-+#:#%;9.-,#$-$"#(#9#8,#(>-'.("8:# ?'%+1,"#("1,+8*#$-$"#"-,01$8.

 $8+;%8$#>#(-+-$(-'/$$"# 0%#,#+9#-?!
8$$"#"-,01$8.-+$"#,-.#)%-'+($"8$"1,+8*#(1(+-$ ?1)'%#1+$"#*#(19-.#)8.%#0-%$1+8,*'9"8,1$1,?-'+($"8$"#"8(,'??#%#( $"#,$8$#*#+$8$$"##8%.1#,$0-1+$-?$1*#/#?-%#$"#0-.19#8+(,#$$"#.8>1+

4 *-$1-+

7

,%1)"$.;0-1+$#(-'$/;$"#.#8%+#(9-'+,#.?-%$"#800#..8+$, $"#%#1,:1%$'8..;+-#:1(#+9#$-(#*-+,$%8$#$"8$$"#%#>8,*##$1+)-?*1+( $-0%-:#$"#9-**-+1+$#+$1-+8..#)#(.;,"8%#(/;$"#$"%##899',#(>1$" $"#*81+899',#(8'%8/"'/#;

 "',$"#0%-,#9'$1-+"8,*1,#%8/.;

?81.#($-#,$8/.1,"$"#9"8%)#,?%8*#(8,8)81+,$$"#899',#(800#..8+$, 
<

99-%(1+).;  8..  $"#  $"%##  800#8.,  8%#  8..->#(  8+(  $"# 800#..8+$,  8%#  89C'1$$#(  -?  $"#  9"8%)#,  ?%8*#(  8,  8)81+,$  $"#*  "# &'()#*#+$-?9-+:19$1-+8+(-%(#%-?,#+$#+9#%#9-%(#(/;$"#$%18. -'%$1, ,#$8,1(# "#;/#,#$8$.1/#%$;?-%$">1$"1?$"#1%9',$-(;1,+-$%#C'1%#(1+ 9-++#9$1-+>1$"8+;-$"#%98,#

 "  #     8;


 "  # '.8$1