High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4594/2019dismissed

Om Pal And ORS v. Hsvp And ANR

2024-04-01Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal3 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()**

!" # $ $ !"

% !"&"

! #( ") "

) +,

* -

,, +,

* -./ , ! " * + ! ) $ $ !", !, )-./0 2 / + !! ") * , '%, !, )-!

34/05/!., 000

,,1* 23

6&!. / /2

$ 2 + $" &!

)""

+ 3$7 !

! 4,!2(!$%"5('!3#"2-.

6'2!#!22!$ " 6!##&$7& "# 6! $8&(&' 2 "21 -.

1 2&$9$1 $ !$ :*:*1 !';!%&33< ;2' =1 ($ 6!2!"#1 " %"( !($ 6 6! !3&>&93!;! & &"(!2'67!9!!(>2( !$ 6!9!(!#& "#33" 8!( "# 6! '6&( #3 '* !1 "( 6&' 9'&'1 %"( !($' 6 6! ;2!'!( ?2& ;! & &"(6'9!!(2!($!2!$&(#25% 5"5'*

2'=1($"# 6!'&$##&$7& 2!$'#"33"?') 4=*6 %%"2$&(> "'527!<%"($5% !$"7!2 2!8 >2 65>>&@'1 -!% "2 =1 2&$9$ #"2 $!82% &"("#3($#"2;2";"'!$ "#= "# &"(3&>6?< 2"A!% 165>>&@'"#;! & &"(!2 "* "($ ! & &"(!2"*=($2!%"8&(> ?& 6&( 6!;2";"'!$ "#= "#;2";"'!$ &"(3&>6?< 2"A!% * :*BBBBBBBB *BBBBBBBB

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

62"5>6 33" 8!( 3! !2' $ !$ D**E ($ E** 2!';!% &7!3< ' ;!2 ;2!7&3&(> -. ;"3&%<* 6! %";&!' "# 33" 8!( 3! !2' $ !$ D**E($E**2!!(%3"'!$6!2!?& 6 ' ((!C52! ($ E #"2 6! F&($ %"('&$!2 &"("# 6&'"(@93!"52 * *6 & &'#52 6!22!';!% #533<'598& !$ 6 ;;3&% &"('"#'6&(#3 '#"2;! & &"(!2'("* ($D?!2!2!A!% !$&( !28'"#3*7& ;"3&%< $ !$D*=*E((!C52! ?6&%6' &;53 !'

6 &# 6!9!(!#& "#'6&(#3 '6'9!!(7&3!$ "(%!1 6!( 9!(!#&%&2< #8&3< '633 9!%"8! &(!3&>&93!#"233" 8!( "#'6&( 3 &(#5 52!* -&(%! 6!# 6!2'"#;! & &"(!2'"*($D6$ 32!$<9!!(33" !$'6&(#3 '"(D**E ((!C52! ($E**((!C52! E 6!&2;;3&% &"('?!2!2!A!% !$9< 6!-%2!!(&(> %"88& !!*G

-&(%!%"5('!3#"2 6!;! & &"(!2'&'(" 7&393! "$<1 6!2&(>"# 6!%'!&'$!#!22!$ "E**D*G 8! + ! 2

!! + !!

9 1 / ! 2 &" + !

! ") * , ! $ ! " ) $ $ " 9 ! !

$+!&2 & &""

$7"&9"

$1 "&!1$1 " ! $, "$ ./

!"9 2 & 3$2 9& "2&"

)) !2 9 + + ) $ $ !"

)&!"&

!, : 9 $7"

/ &!

$"2 $2 ""9&

$"$"" ) $ $ + ! )!

" 2& $ ,

22 !

$7., 25( 33& 5$>! .&F28>>2?3

5$>!

A( !") -$7;! "

<=';*

!( ) !

9 <=';*