High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/634/2012dismissed

Rajesh @ Sarkari And Others v. State Of Haryana

2019-01-17Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu11 pages

!"" #

$%&'(" % ))** + ' ,- )

!"#$ %&'()!*+,-.) "/-012"!#"

%&'()!*+,-.)"!-%3)!1-%421-32* .

0%"1' "! 2" % '"3 )' '

%+1! 1 %))** /"%*041" " *! 0 *1,-

"/-012"!#"5 5%" ))*""

" + 4"

%!33 $+43

6- * " " * '" 7+41% (1"

'" 8#9 '"

:912%6-!!+$%&'("1$-,

.%*'"

4%&,)*2!%42" % " % ! )+ "%6*+ '! " 9

;. '! " 8 %3!

5%-2! "! !+ '! " 2" %'! "

;. + 4"4+"3)" 3 *" )-"

19 !% "

+* )-3 "

1 %-2"! + %+ 4 "4+"3)" 3 - 5%! %)!+ " + %**" % .< = '"

4%%*4 %) 1>? .

1 %! % %"* '

) 2 + @@ A"

*B1"

C "" -1% ( ,%

))"

%?3"

,%4 %@2) 3 )) %?3"

," "

*2%!3 %"%+ %2 "

%+- * 3 "

) , " ! ! %"3 %" 36"*)% 6+ %"!**" 3 + 5% 1% %"-+ 4

'+ "*2 %C "" - %3 !-!* 5%-!% % )("

4% @2) 3 5%-28 6- "

4+ % "

% 5%- ""

4 %" '

) ,2 "

4 %3 '

)!**) , %" '+ "*+% 2 %) ," '+ "*!+*" "- % %"* 5%6-*2- 2 *%" %"*!*+.+*3 !-!* 5%-!+* "! % 4" " +36 %3 !-!* *2="

4+ 3 % 63 1* 31* 3)* "4% %"4%'

) 5% 1 . D"*'"

4% %6-6+4% '

) .0;'1 % (1"

) ,21'

)+!!+36 %" 3"

$+" ' 3 22 %)*"! " A3*A;2 4" !3)* " !-"

"4 " 1"

" "**-!%** 2 )+ +)4"

2!!+1 3*-1$%&'(" $-, '+6E+ *-1!!+.%*&,)*2*!%** /" :1 % * " " * '" 7+4 "! ! *" " %+))*3 -!%** 2" % %3"

!%** 5%)!+ " ?3"

+362"

+)) %! 5% 3 %!!+2*!+ '! "

. 5%- " %! %)!+ " 5%!!+?3"

"2"

! 5%-2! "! !1 "! %"

6 , !1 %) ))*

@ !+ * ))"

4 6%* % ))** %3 *-4+ % %)!+ " %"* )" ! @ !+ *))"

4 %' %3 *-4+ % %)!+ " % )" !6- 6*+6 +)) %$+43 % * + 6*2 <%%* !+ * %) " 4 %+4% %$+43 !-!+**- .<F '"

4%) % %2) .*"!. 1 .0;'1% ( ,1>,'+%F+3 $" '"

4% 2$"

"4 " 6-';%'"

4% 5%! "!* 2 ( )" 6-';%'"

4%""=+33 >? . # .< $" '"

4%) % %2 .0;'1% (1"

>34 !-<2% %)*"!3 %"3 A3 %) 1 %)*"!*" 6*2" % %%*)! )+ "

3**)* "! "

.*"!* *" 3) -! "4 *6+** :

.< ='"

4%" %-2"

,) % %% +4% 12%"3" ,% 2 5% 3 %*

) -+ 4'+ "* '

)2 + @@ A"

*B "

C "" -1% ( ,% ))"

*?3"

1%" '

)%4 C "" -))"

4 %"?3"

% -1%" "

*212%%!33/ "1 3 '

) , " ! ! '

) *)% 6+ !+* ! ! %"3 5% 1% %" '+ "*2 C "" - 3 !-!*!%"

) <% %-!%!-!* @2) 3 1 %-2!'

) ; 2 . % "3 ," '

)* 42" % %6-2 "

4+ %!-!*%

<% %-2 " !%+ 2-3'

)1 %-2 %6-""

4 %" '

) 5%- 2'

) %"3 ** %!!+ 2- %"3 !-!* 2*%"" ;

%" !?3"

1%3" % !'

)2!"

4 "*"

! ;

3 %!1%2!E+" , " %+44 "

% ?3"

*-@@ 2!%+* 6%*"

!361 /*+ % '

) 2 )) +))*3 -?3"

@@ A"

*- 5%" !6 2 % !-!*% !"

43"4% 66+ G("** , " %+44 "

% %" '

)2 36-%"3 %" .0;'1 % ( , " %+44 " % % %" 2 ) % "3!!+ ! .<8'+ "*%!6 % 3 .< ='"

2%"!% %"6 %'

)2("** ,%* 3" % %2 ")+ -("

6 2 '

) % !!+) %+ 6 % !!+ ! 5%-!%.0;'1 % (1 . .< <="'"

4%1.<#743 .< 6*'+3"

F+3 %3*2"

.<: ' "

) % : # '; 74 31 %"*(% 1""*@"

1% (1% %"3 2* )!*!* %2" %* ! 1 *)!*6* "

%1 *)!* ! "4 *1 *)!*

5%32*" A'@1 %+6 4 %!") 12%"!%2% 743%" *(%

8 .<';% '"

4%1) % # #1$% &'("2"

4 "

%" "

%) !';36%$ , 3"!*+ 3 1>? .F1 % %* 42" %$- .%* '"

4% !3 "

@2 ) 3 .+* !-!* 6"

4 , ,9 "*!*+ " '

)*" % !33" %"3+ ,% %)" * .%*'"

4% 3 !-!*% *-6 !6- %)*"! "!*+ 3 2"4 6- !!+$%2**16-%"3 ';36%$ :

#1!!+ $-,*+%""!*+ 3 1>? .14"

4 % !!+ ! !!+$% $-,+ " ""! "

)

.<';%36") % !!+$%&'("

$-,2))% 6-'; $ '"

4% , 6 % %3 ,"

4 %!!+ 5%-3"!*+ 3 1" >? .H .1)! "*-

.< 6*$"0) % !!+$%& '(" $-,3"!*+ 3 1>? .H >? .1 4"

4 %!!+ !6%"3 8 . 3 3?3"

%6-!'

) ,2! +! 6-.< '+%37"

* 42" %%!**4+ ' . ' % " '%*%" !6-"*"

4"" 1>? .< 9 5%!+ %2%!( %3%412%"!%2+ "3 "

$+" 5%"

$+"2 3 3"

+ 2+"!" !+ %"

+*!+ 5% "3*)6 2 % ) 3 3?3"

22" %"

%+ '%%!"6 % "

$+" * % !( %3"

%"" 5%) 3 3

) ">? .'

.<83%'"

4%) % : 8 #1%2 ) "

' "3 !%1% ( ,! % 3 ';

743%"*(% 1.*"!' " 1""*@"

1% (1 >, '

+ '! " . 8 #1%!" *)% "!

343';3F"% 1')!"*' 1% (14"

4! "

36-$%&'(" $-,"

A; 8 4" + '! " #9

;.1.*"!' " 1""*@"

1% ( ,!%.*"!' " 1""*@"

1% ( , !!+$% &'(" $-, ,( %" " ""! " )1 %21 %-+ %3 # #$%&'("3 "!*+ 3 1>? .F :

#1!!+$-,3 "!*+ 3 1>? . # .< ';3F"% ) %

#%2) ;

!%4')!"*' 1% ( % -1% !!+$% &'(" $-,"

A; 8 1.*"!' " ""*@"

1% ( % %3! 6+ %""

*3 % !"3 5%-+ % % %-2**.%*%"+) % !2" % %")! "2) %4 3 !-!* 6"

4 ,,9 13("! !*+ 5% 3

$%&'("">? .B 3 $-,">? .D 5% 3 !-!*2! 8 #1!!+$%&'("2 ( %" %+"

.*3/"%10+4 , (+ %)" * 3 %6 %)" *">? .: '( !% %)" *">? . ; 2 ( )" *"

41">? . !!+$-,% *-3 3

#4"

4! !*3 %")" *"

# %" %+ "

"**4 )+"1 0+4 )- 3 " >? .>> 5% 1)*"!2 %"%+"

"**4 )+"13 2%%4 !)" *3 %64 5%)" *">? . '( !% 2))1>? .AA :

.<%'"

4%'; ) % %2) ;

!%41 .*"! . 1 .0;'1 % (1 , !" 3"!*+EE3.0;'1% (14"

43"" '

) , !% %>34 !-<.0;'1% (12%='"

4%3 3 1>? .

,! +! "

E+ )!"

4 ,3))*"! "

>? .C1) 3 3?3"

%6-'

) ,* *" 6 **'3+44*6 2%"(-

.< *2 '"

4%1 "';1) % !!+.%* &,)*2"

4 "

%") ! ,3"!*+ 3 >? .FF 5%))** %*?3"

! < 7"*'"

4%) % %% 4" %"%+1)" )* 1>? .,,1 -$-, 5%3 %%+2 + %"*6+ ,% %2 -!+3 -" !4"

2 %") %%+"

E+ " < $% 74)*6+4% %+33 ! ! 6"

4A;

14" + '! " 1 : ;.1.*"!' " 1""*@"

1% ( < '%3%'"

4%%6+4% % 2))I #14"

4 %3+'

)

< . % ) % '

) *" % !2%"" 1%* 42" %'

)

: '"( 2) %-!*'

@2A!+* -1C "" -1 % ( '

)2 ("

4*"E+2%"*" "

%"! 3 "31 8 ) 146+ 8 -1!3 23 !-!* ""

"!"3"

*-+) '

) '

)!**) , '"( ('

)! .0;'1% (1"

%"2 '

4 %"33" %12%%2!*6+4% 6- % !

<8'"( !6 % 3 < . 8 <% 343 %))"* %" !"!+ %"

6" % '

)2 + @2 ,% ))"

* -?3"

C "" -1% ( .< ='"

4%% " ! ! %"31%21!+* 3(! ! 2" %%"3 .< ='"

.<8'+ "*2 C "" - 5%-!% %)("

% 5%-2 %6- "

4+ % "

% 5%- ""

) , %" '+ "* +% 2 % ) '

) !**) ," '+ "* " "" % "* 5% "* 2

2*%" %.+*3 !-!* 4" " +36 % 3 !-!*!+* 6 "! *2="

4+ 3 %63 * 31 * 3)* "4% %"4% '

) , 2 3 %)" *12%%2!*6+4%

5% "

!" " ))** $% & '(" $-,2 "

A; 8 #1 4" .*"!' " 1""*@"

1% ( 5%-3"!*+ 3 1>? .F >? .1 )! "*- %6" "!*+ 3 1)" *2! ( )" 5%( !% 2))

# !!"

4 .<8 3 % '"

4% 8 #1 % !" *)% "!343';3F"% 1')!"*' 1% (1 6+ %! " 36-$%&'(" $-, , ! % 3 %!!+ 5% " ""! " )2 +6- %3 $%&'("3"!*+ 3 1>? .F

# # !!+$-,3"!*+ 3 1>? .1

# 5% 2) 2 ! % 6" "!*+ 3 36- %3 5%2 A'@?3"

A'@) 1 >? .1"

A; #: 1" # A'@ ) >? B >? B91"

A; 8 1" # 8 # !!"

4 A'@) 1>? B1"

A; 1 # 833"! "43(9 9 2"3 % 3"3 # 833"6+** 3( 9%6 "3 !+ -3"3 ;

) ) 8 #1" %!3 ! % # 833"! "4!3(98%6 "3)" *1 3(<91 %6 6 !3!!+$% !%36 # 8 33 ! "4 3 - % "3 %)" *3(<9!%36# 9 II! "4* 42" % 34="

# 333""! "413(91 % 6 !3!!+$-12 "

%*6 - # 33 " ! "4 3(9 % 3" " 3)" * 3(<9 !%36# 9 II! "4 !!"

4 *6 -?3"

)" *13(<9 <92+ "

2("

4 :

)A'@) 1>? .1 %# 33"! "4! 3(9 9# # 33"6+** 3( 9 9 % 6 "3!+ -3)" *3(<9!%36# 33

! "4 !" "

! A'@ #9A

#1 A; 8 14" + '! " #9

;. '! " 898 %3! 1 .*"!' " 1""*@"

1% ( 3 - % "3 33( 616!+-"3%4 " 2

""+*!%! " "!3( ." *3(<9 %6

!3!!+$%&'(" 8 # ; "!*3 % ? $+"!"*! " 36-!!+$% &'(" $- ,1">? .F1 >? .1)! "*-1 % )" *!%362" % # 833! "42!3!!+$%&'(" )" * !%36 2" % # 33 ! "4 2 ! 3 !!+ $- , !-332) *-)) %( !%2 )) 5%* + 6*2%!! *-4" %"

4 !! ))"* %) 1>? .1>? B >? B9

2))** .%*'"

4%&,)*"! ! 1 %2" ""6-.<8'+ "* !!"

4 %"31.%*'"

4%&,)*1 2 %"* 2%" %"6 %'

) !!+.%* '"

4%&,)**4 %3! " ! +! 5%+4% %"*- "

*4"

4 %A;16+ %3" "

.< ='"

4%%* " ""!!+.%*'"

4%&,)* 6 %"*

@ !+ * %))** %3 *-4+ % "

% ) ! .< = '"

4% .<8 '+ "* % ( % ! %%)" *1 %%2 ( 6-< . <8 '"( %%)" *12% %! %!*%"36+4% ; 2"** 3( -" !"

%) !12%% ( % ! %%)" * 5%! %3 " % ' )23 %%)" *12%%2!*6+4%

@ !+ * % ))** 4+ % % "!) !""

% 3 .< ='"

4% .<8'+ "* ; " 6-.< ='"

4%"

%+EE1>? .

1 % "?6-2 "

+ % "

%12%"

%" 3 1.<8'+ "*1%) % %2 %6- "

4+ %% 5% 3 .< = '"

4% .<8'+ "*+*-+)) 6- %3"!*" ! % !+*" ! 5%))** %*3? $+"!"*! " >? .B1>? .D >? .FF16+ %""

*3 %) ! ;

%*!3"

%" ! % !* % %!" !(+" 1 ) 1 ! 2 "

2" %6*

5%)!+ " %) %!4"

%))** 6- 6*+6 5%" 3" "

%))* !!"

4*-1 % 3""3" $"'%3 7+4 #

4%'"%+ 7+4 <% %)("

49 B9 <% %) 6* B9