← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8609/2017dismissed

Pravin Kumar Budhia v. Amrit Kumar Budhia Through His Lrs And ORS.

2018-02-15Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul18 pages

 

       

    



 ! "

 #

% &  ''"

 )

*$ (#

% & +

,(&

-&& .

  ''

  

    00000 "

( * &1(( !*

 2#*

!*

 + ,!!3!

+ ,    4&



(



* (   (&  

((

 5  $/ - (&

    +*

",/



7 - +7



,!7

&

8&



//

9

)5 

8(&:

(

 "

/ ( (&

(/

-/



(!8

 %  ! (&

(/  &  

( 



 ((&

(

 (  (

(( & 8(&(& ( *

 $/

8

 ( 

8

(



-

4&

(

!(& $

$ /

3  (&

(

( *($  8

! :

(& 2 ;

$ &



!<4

!7

&

!



/  !% =



 %555>> (

( % =

 

&

! 7

&

 (&

 &

 #! (

( 1 ;

 & 8;! &

?( "

! 7

&

! 8

 4&



(     &  8 ((

(! 8&

(&



$((





?

(/

(/

! (

(( & 8(& (&  / ( 8

 

  - 

( 5( &

 

 /

 (& ( (&

(?

$



;

*

&!(&

?

&/

/



 (

( /

 @(&

 (

 (&

$  /

! ( 8

 

 (& ( (&

( /

( 8



 

 

 $

$

3!(8

(

$

( (&



 4&  (

 



( &

(

 $

5 (!(&







6 /(!(& 

?

(4& $

$ /

3&

(

8 $/

 4&

?

 (  8 ((

( 8

    (&

(/ ! 8&

 $    8 ((

5(&



$((



( 



 8 --

 (&  $

$  /

 

 ( - ( $

(( *(

$

 (&  8 ((

 (&

?

!(&

(/ 

//

9

)5 

8(&:

(

 "

;

-

 ( A

!(&

(

&

?

($

(!  ( (&



(   

- (

&

?

($

&

  $ ?

  (& ( 8(&

(/

 $



! &

 (

& ?

($

( 4&

! 

 (  - ( (&  

((

 

! ( &

 

 (

;

(



  /

  $

 

 (&

 

4& (



( 

( !

 (  & 8 ((

(! ((

(/







8(&

(- (( -/

(



( 



(8(&

 C

& $

&

& 

(

(8(& &$4&



( 

-

/

( 4&

! (&

 8  (

((  (&

 $ ((

    8

- (&

  $

 

 4&

! (&

( /

-&(

/ (

  

8  (   

  

 

     

                    



   

           

 

  

 

 

 

  

    

 

   

    

      !  "   #$ % %  &'

(    )  *

    

   +, -       

 



 

 

    

  

 

           

 #    

           

             #   

      

      

 

   

 

  

   

   ) 

 

     

      

   .  )  "

/

       

 -

.  

 

-. 

 

  + -!     

 



  

  

 

   

                



  

     

#$ %  

   



 

 

  

   !  " & '

 (   

 .



 ) "

0 

   

- .    

 

- .+, -

  

         1 '234,   



' 234,  

1.  ) 

 

    

     

5   

  5

 

55+, -!  

  

 

  

 

                      

         

 

  

 

  

  

      

 

   

    

   ! " #$% %  &'

(    

  

    "

 D 4&



( &



/( //



9

)5 

8(&:

(

 "( ; -(&

( !(8

(

(( / 8

8&& (



(

$(&



-&(



 / (4&

(8&

(4&

(8

&

(

(!





8

 ) $/

!

( 

(&

(8

 



 ((&





(& (&

$((  

(

  ! 3

 A   8 ((

(!



( &

/

$((  



 / ( 4&   

( &

 (&

//

 8&  



- (&  /



 ( 8

  (/( (-



5(8

((8

&

( *--

( (&



   /



( 

(!8&

(& //

9

)5 

8(& :

(

   "    (&

(/  8

! (&



( &



(



 .

 

 



(   &

$/

/

(& 

(!8&

 //

 

 / ( &

 

! 

(  



8&

-(&

!(& 

(&

//

 ( (& ( (&

 

 (&

(/  8

( (&

 8

$/





(

(& 

!(&

( 

  

 8

 

( (&

 

   

 

 % (  8  /

//

! (&

( /  $ /

(/

$ ;

(



(

8&& 

9

)5 "@&

(&





(

(!

&

(

(





8

!(& $/

  

( (  (

 

$  (&  

! (&

(&



(& 

(5(

(( / /  8

&



!(&

(

( 5

//

&  

! &  &



   

 ! ((

"#$%&'(&')'%"

 '$%#'$%'$*+,#&#&)-).'/ 0#),'

(&'1#),%')"

'$%*+,#&)(

(

( 8&

&

$$

4& 

( $$

!8&

((

(



4&

(

$

( (  

(/

$

 

8

A ! 8&

//

;

 (&  / ( 8



   C

 ( 

  8 $

  &  (&  8(

  (&

(/ ( &

 :

6 

!8&

 $

 & / (&



 !(&

8



( 



8



 82



2 

 34 ((

  '' #%%5 #&)-) 6) 7-+-&# %#&) **(#&'+

#*-) $8*9 #+5'$%*+,#&)E2 

!22((

-$ '$%*+,#&)#&)-)'

&'1'),'$%'$*+,#&: 2 

2 ((

"/#& $8,#&)-);

&%,'''$%*+,#&)E-1#),0-/'&#&)-) -),  ++''$%*+,#&)2 

E2< 

32  ((

'

&  $8, #&)-) ')('  $8, '$% '$*+,#&

  !

 



  ((

 /'&%##(  $8, '$% '$*+,#& #&)-) '&=,'"'$  $8,'$%'$*+,#&

 &

! 

 

 

 &

 (&

( 

  - (& //

;

 (& / ( &

 

(   8 ((

(    (&



( !&

&

8

$(

&

(  /

8 ?

($

 &

  $  ?

&/

 

 

 $

 

- (&

(4& (



( /



( !

 (  ((

(

&(& ((

(/



(/

 (&

 

 (    (

 8(&

( &  - /

 (&

(

 4&



(     

- /



-

/

(/

(4&

!(&

;

(

 ( 8

  $ (/(  (-

 $

(

 8&

(   ?

( *



(   

- (

  /

 (&

( 

 /

$



!/

-(&





-

 4&

((



 

 + ,!! 3!

+ , 

(( ! ;

 5&







  4&







?

(/

(/

(!

 



/

(

(( & 8(&(& (4&

   

&/4&

(8

 



 ((&

 $

 (

(

  9  

 (&



!$

$ /

38

 

5(



( &

 /

!(&

(/  //

( 4&

-& 

 

 

 &

 ( "#$%&'(&')'%"

  '$%# '$% '$*+,#& ) 9')# )-(&'

 &

 

((

(& 

((



 ! 3! A

  ?

-$

(! 8&&

 F26  7       

          

   

 

  8192"

  

 

        

     

 

       1



       

       

  :  

     

 

  ' /

;

  <  

            

        

     

             

      

     

 5

    81<*



 

  

       

     

 

     

   

 

  ٱ

 

   

   

 





 

            

         

      2= !   > ?    

     ;

 0 ' *

    81  , ,%   

 0 * 



       

999  6336 

  

        1          

 



  2* )      

  

  

  

@A"$B;

 

C8     

  

 

  



   



  

 1     

  

    



 <' /%?%    



    

  

     

 

  

 7   

          

    

  

  

 $

     

     "

   6 

  2/    

          

 ;

  D) ' /      

          

          

   

     

 !  %   A  "$ B ;

 

    

         



 D



% (

(



(5 ( 

!(&

(8

-&(  8&

(

 8(

 8



 



 8



 5 ( 

 

 8

 

 (&

8&



 

 8

 

 8

 &

  (&

//

% (

!(&

-&((&

( /  

   5( 

 (

 

$  

! (&

( &

 

-&( C

8

 8(

    (& / ( &

 

$  4&

-&

 "@!

! "

( $ &

 8

$

8(

! (&



(

 $ 

( &  &

   4&

! (&  

(  ( (&   (   "#$%&'(&')'%"

  '$%# '$% '$*+,#& ) 9')# )-(&'

(



( :$

!

 ?

-$

( (   

 

 



(      '' #%%5 ) 9')# )-(&'

 &

// ( (



5 ( 

!(

(& */ 6

( (



$(& $

$ 8 ((

(( ;

9

)555  

 9

 )5   " 

; - (    

& 8 ((

(2

!

!(&

(/

  

$ (& $

 $    / ( 1

6 /( (&



( ! 

$(( ( $

 

 4&

6 /( (&



(  !

-

 (









! -$ '$%*+,#&) 9')#)-(&'





 



(  ! (&

( 8

-&( 

(

  $$

 (&  ( !  (   

   &

! (&

(&

(

-&(

(

$$

!

-&(

(  !8&

G 





 (!(& 



9

)5

" (

$

B



!(&

/

-

 4&



 

- (&

(

! $  (    8 

8

(4&



(-

?



/



( 4&

8

( 

( &

 

 



  (&  */ 6 

( 

0  '

#&)-) '

 

4!8&

(&



(&

((&

(

(  $

$ ((

-&(!

( (&

 ($ ! (&  

! &

/(  &/

( &  

//

&8&&

 -8(&(&

(4&

   /

 ( 

 

 $ (/(  (-

 4&

( /

/& 



 3  (&  (  ?

-$

 F6 

 

 ;

  < ' / %?%         

              

     1

  

 

    

    

   #%  % )    



     

  

   E          

     

      

  ,   

 F  

       

       

    

    

       

      

     

 !             

    

    =  %  !A &  B    G   D %

  @ 9<<C %'/9<+  -                         

  



        

  



 

+7 " 00/ 9HEG =9* E       

        

      

 

 



       

 

 

  

        1 

    

 

    + %  G  ! A !)'   ?% 23 F( F   %  F       (  $   %  @ 92/C%'*=0  

                  

 

      

  

 

   $%

  00* 6< %G /33  

                  

           

    



                A '

  ' 

 D    939)F'==E <**

?  #   ? A  ? @ 92/C%'292   1

  - 

  .  

 

 1           

       

 

     %

$& 0/=0%? 3/

 

 1 

      

 



    

       1

 

 

 

      

            $  '

   :

 ?

 %

   F  9<66!8'6*    



  $!   $ 

  

- . 

  -  

 .+ G   (7 8  % F  9<6 !8'=3=       $"

    

  

  

 

      

 .  ! &ED A B;

@ 9/*C6 %%=9= % +  -

        

 1

     

    

        E   1



     

   

     

 

     

         

   

 % .



 )>4& % >

'@ 9/0C6 %%9  +  -)  

 

  

 



 

 

   

    

 

 

    

     1      

   

  

    

    8  

 % 

  

        

   

  

    $          

 

  

 

1      

   

     

       

          

. 

  

     

       

    

       

 



   

          

 $

           $           1    

                   

   

      !  

              

     

  



  

 

      

       

     

  

 

   $)

   

 

           

  



       

          

   



     ?

     

  

           

 

 "

       

     

  

   

 

 

   

   

  

     



  

   

  $     

         



 

   

 

 

     D :$

! '"#),0-/'&88'&.''$%*+,#&)#&)-)00 *% '$%*+,#&)< 

4!(& */ 6

(&

(& ((



(( 8 

8&&



$ -(&

B







(- (

(

(

(

)5 " 



($

8 (&

(( (

&

&

&(

($  ?

(!



&

  $

 $  

 

 

$ - (&



   

 

 4&

-& (&



 



//

 (



$$

!



(



( /( 

-

! (&

( 



( &

 (&  $ ((

 

$$

( 

)5 "

(8

!8&



( 

+$ ,



(( 

((



/

-!(&

/

( $/

( + ,

?



(( 8



! 8&&

8

 

$ -(&

B





- (&

 /

! (&  */ 6

(   ', ' '/1'

 >#

 '$% *+,#&) #&)-) '$%&'/ >  +,&*-8, #8',# &)'$%*+,#&)44 

4<&

(& 

8

-

 (

(!

(



(

;

( 8

( - 8(& $   

(  & 



 ?

& //

(!8&&

( $/





(

/



( $

?

( */

(

(

?

 $



$ ;

--

!



(

/

2

!(&

-

(( /

(

?

(



(-



&

8

&  $(



!

(



(  (

 8 ((

(!(&

 -

 &

( &

 (&  



(

 (&

(

 (   $



//

-(&

  $ 4& 

( ( 8 $&

-&(







(- -(

?





(  4&

!    8  (&  

 $  &

  -&(   8      (&  */ 6 

( 0   '

) 9')# )-(&'

:

 

'"#),0-/'&88'&.''$%*+,#&) 9')#)-(&'

', ''/1'

>#

'$% *+,#&)  9')# )-(&'

 & 

 (   ( (& ( (&

-&(  (&

(/  

( - - (  &

 !

8

-&( $ &

$$  (

$ 



(G 



 ( !(& 

(

 ( $/

/



( 

( *

-! (&  $/

    +*

",/



7 - +7



,!7

&



(



! - 

$

(!  $

     



 !"#$   - (( @&

; ->

 

@&