High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2408/2004dismissed

Parmjit Kaur v. State Of Punjab

2020-02-19Mr. Justice Vivek Puri10 pages

!"# $%""!

& $% '($)

*+,-.""/

0&1+2 /////

& (+( && $% +0* /////

$4 &

&)5// /1+.43$'& .%$&6

&/ 5(/ 7(67(6.. +0*/ /

/ 89 6 &

6(*

4:(&&6 0+4: &$% '$3'&$4$4 $%( & 4& 4 "//""! (( 4*,&6

+4:

' $+&. .34 ;6'6&6

&6(*

'$3'& %$ 63: '$&& 4 &6 $%% +(6*

+4 '&$ < $% &6

'$&'(+:(4 (,'6$&$ ' +*(&'

('&.-#<=%$(6$&.>&6

'&>?4( & 4&$+4 :$:$$+( ($ &%$

$4$%& , (4&$ ,% $% (/.""."""@.4 %+ &;6 $%&$%+&6 +4 :$:$$+( ($ &%$

$4$%$ , / 89 ,.&6 ( +&%$&6*,&6 '+&$(&$&6 '& &6&$<//"".(

'&$ +4 :6$% &%%. $:;&6 *60 :64$&6 (;

$%%' 3 6'

$4 &$( '6 $'

4$%% 01+%$ &$4,.16+4$4 &'/A6 &6 &,;(*$+&""

,4((6$&%$&6 ;,'$((:.&6 ,( $&&

& 0&

1+4'66&$;6

(&&:$&;$:+,*:( &6 ;, '$((:4$(

:&6 &,''+( 4'66&$(

4;, %$&6 $&4&6

&;(

4;&6&6 :+,*:(/ ;6

. +* '

($.

,.1616 ($

4&&6 $&.

;(0$ 4&6 &,44 &&,$%&6

&;(3 % 4/ (

'&$ +4 :6&$

&&6&&((+(

'& 4&6& (6 ;(',:($ '$&*4&6 *:(4&(( '66(&$*

'$4+'& 4/

(

&$%6

: :6&&$:

&&6 '6 '$4+'& 4&6 $%:B && 4$%%'

$5:(&& /$;

$( 4'$%4 + $6/''$4:

,.&6 '$( & $ ;(

4/6 '6$%&6 :+,*:(;('$4+'& 44%$&6

*:(

,6+(7;( 4/;$(

(;

:6:<":( '6$%

,6+(7%$ '6*:;

& 44 :'$& &(&6

%(&*:;

&+ 4$+&&$* !1:(/4<"":(4$&6 *:

&6 '$& &(;

&+ 4$+&&$* -7:(/4<"":(/

%$+ (

(4&;$*+ 7

(;

4;&6&6 * :

(($> >/

' ( ;(

44&6 %& +( ;( 64 4$3 &$ *60 :6/6 '&:&'

(;

&7 &$ (($ 34 (

& , $/

($ ( '6 $% &6

&;(:$&'$4+'& 4&6$+:6C4,$(&*

50&1+4 '&: &'

( 4 %$ &6

& ;

&7 &6

(($&6$+:6(

($ '6 $/ (&$%&6

& ;( '& 4/ +D;( 444( &'6 (&&$4$ &6 *((&6 $%. ;( :(& 4/ &+&$&6 (&&$.&6

& $:;&6 '(

&,4 ;& ( ;

$4+'

4 * %$

(

'&$ :6. . &&$1$&; . ;6$3 %

&6 %'&($%&6 4&6 (

(;&6&6 * :

(($> >/ '

&$%&6

$&$%&6 6 ' E 4 '$

&$$%3 (&:&$.&6

& $:;&6'66&$'$''+( ;

&&$%'

& / %' '( +4 '&$<$%&6 '&;( 4 $+&:(&&6 ''+( 4/6 '$& &($%&6 '6:

;

4$3 &$ &6 ''+( 4*+&&6 ,

4 4$&:+ &,4'

4& / 89 $(+*(&&& &('( .&6 '+&$6( E 4(, (%3 (.

,. A *60 :6. A

:6. A$(&*

:6* :6. A!(

'&$ :64

A< (

'&$ +4 :6/

, $%&6 '$&*4 ;(

'& 4*, A<(

'&$ +4 :6&6 $% A *60 :6/ A<(

'&$ +4 :6

(

& $%6

: :6&&$:

&&6 '6'$4+'& 4&6 $%:B && $%%'

$5:(&& (&;((+(

'& 4&6&&6 ;(($ '$&*4 &6 :+,*:(/ 6

$( 4 '$%4 + $64 '$( & $ E6*& ;(

4/ '6$%&6 *:(;('$4+'& ;6'6

4&$ ,$%

,6+(7/

(;

4;4&6

&,4(

(;

44&7 &$ (($34 , $ E6*& /

($ '6$%&6

&;('$4+'& 434

'6 $ E6*& 46 (&;( '& 44&6 :$+4($% (& E6*& ;

3 $6 / +D E6*& ;( 44 4( &'6 (&&$.$&6 *(($%;6'6 E6*& ;( :(& 4/E6*& (&6

$&+4 '&$<F$%&6 '&/ 6

& $:;&6&6

&,4&6 (;

$4+'

* %$ A!(

'&$ :6;6$;( $(& 4( %%'

'6:

&&$ 4;6$3 % %'&($%&6 / +&&6

'$+& ( $&6

(;&6&6 (($> >/6

&, ;( & 4&6 76*, A :6/ A$(&*

:6* :6 &$$7 &6 (

( &$ &6 $%%'

$% &6 6 '

E 4(

$&$%&6 6 ' E E6*& <.&6

'$& &($%&6

;

%$+4&$* &6&$%

,6 4(/ 8!9 6 (&& &+4 '&$/ //.&6

&6( '$ '& (($%&6 '&:&'

(

::(&6 4

4&6&(6 ;( '7 %$6 6$+( $:;&6&6 $ '6 44%

'& 4&6 &'( /'66&$'$''+( 4 ($

46 %

'&$&6 4%+&6

4&6&(6 ;( 63: &,;&6&6

&4$&6 (&'

$%&6

&.(6

6(*

'& 4&6('( / 8<9 && & $% A * :6 ;( 4 ;6$

$4+'

:(& $/-$% / /&,. /A1616;(

$4+'

4&6 4 34 / 8G9 H4 0+4: &4& 4"//""!.&6 ''+( 4'66&$ ;( 'D+&&

4. ;6 ( &6

& ;( 6

4 :+ &,. '$3'& 4 4 & 4( &$ 4 $/$%&6(0+4: &/ 8F9 :: 4*,&6 %$ (40+4: &4$4 $%( & .&6

&6( (&&

/ 8#9 63 6 4

4'$+(

%$&6 & (4

'$4/ 8-9 A6

(( :&6 0+4: &$%&6

4& '$+&.&6( *

:+ 4$* 6 %$%&6

&&6&&6 $%&6 '+&$ 6:

($&6 4

$(&$$%&6 ($ ,/A1616.

&;& ((.;(0$ 4&&6 $% ,*+&6 ;(:3

+ *,&6 '+&$46((&

4&$&6 ((*$E(A/ 5$ $3 .&6 ( '7$%& &$4'& &6&&6

&;( '$('$+( (($$%&6 '$&*44%+&6 $ .&( :: &6 '$(( E&$$% A *60 :6&6&( $$ *+

;(&'&4$ ;(*$7 ;6

(;

*$7 $$&6

.6 .&6 '$& &($%&6

(63 *

4;&6/ 8"9 &6 '$&,.;6

$&:&6 0+4: &$%&6

& $+&.

4 && '$+(

6(:+ 4&6&&6 '$&* ,*&$ *( '$3'&$$&6 4

$(&$$%&6 ($ ,/5

, * '+( 4

&;& ((6(*

;$$3 *,&6

&4 6(*

E 4(4 ((.&'$&* ''+(&'

&$ 4(*

3 ($( +&%$&6*,&6 (;6$ &$&6 ,/ +&6 $ .&6

&;((&&:$&6 :+,*:( 4&6(&$* '$(&+ 4&6&(6 ;(63:&6 7$;

$%'$& &( &6 $%/5$ $3 . & 4:

&$&6 ($&6 *+ 7

('$&*

'$(&+ 4(''+(&'

&$4(*

3 ($$%&6 '+&$( &6 ($&6:&$4'& &6&&6

&,;(&

4;&6&,

$&$%& / 89 &&6 $% ,.4

&;& ((;(0$ 4*+& 4+:&6 '$+( $%& .6 ;(:3 + * :;$$3 *,&6 ''+(

&/((+'6.&6 $%&6 '+&$6:

(+ $&6 4

$(&$ $%&6 ($ ,/6 4

$(&$$%&6 '$&* 3 ;

4;&64(&+(&$(+( '$

,* '+( $%&6 $%%'

(&&+(.+

((4+& '$:

&:$+4(&6 %$/ 6 ($

$3($$% ;;6'6 D+ (&6 $%4

&;& ((&&6

& $%( '6$%(+(

'&/&($ ,+

$%'+&$4 3( 4&$(

((+'

44(

, :

: 4$+*&/6 $%&6 '+&$ '$&* 4('4 4

,$&6 ('$ &6&$4

&;& ((;( & 4 &$* 0$ 4& &6 $% ,$%0$ 4.6($& *

E 44+:&6 '$+( $%& / +&6 $ .&6 ,6(*

'& 4%$&6 ''+( 4

&4&6 (&;( '& 4&&6 $& 4$ E&$$%&6 4

&;& (($&6 ('$ &6&6 6( *

;$$3 .4$ ($&& 4&$( ,4$+*&&6 '+&$'( / 89 6 & (&$,$%&6 (6(&$* '$(4 4 &6 ( (&6&$%,$&6 ;& (4&6 ($ '

;&6&;&6$+&'$$*$&$$%&6 4

&;& ((.&6 & (&$, '$&*

$/6 (+ &$&6&

($'&(6$ (& ,

(+'6%3$+$%

($%$&6

($(4&($&

0+4'

$'6&$4(&+(&4(+(

'&&6 ;&6$+&:$$4:$+4( 43 4 ($(/ 89 &6 (&&'( .A16166(*

E 4+:&6 '$+( $%4 34 / 6(& (&% '&&6& &6

,6+(7;( 4%$&6 '$('$+( (($$%&6

&$ (&;( '& 46( /&((:%'&&$$&

&6&4+:&6 '$+( $%6('$(( E&$*,&6 44&$

+* ' '+&$. 6 6( 4&& 4 &6& 6( &6+* (($( ;

$*& 4*,&6 &6$+:66 6(($+:6&&$

&6&6(&6+* (($(;

$*& 4%& (+$:6&6 (&%%/ &(

& &&$$& &6&&(%+&6 ::6((&& &&6&6 %

4,'$

&:(&&6 (;6 6(&6+* (($( ;

$*& 4*,&6 /(+'6''+(&'

(.&6

&$($+:6& &$* +&%$&6*,A1616;&6

'&&$$*&:6(&6+*

(($(*,'

:6&6 (&%%.'$&* ''

& 4/5

, * '+( 4

&;& (((($'& 4&&6 $% ,6(*

;$$3 *,&6

&.&'$&* '$'

+4 4&6&&6 '$3'&$'$& * (+(& 4 &'+ ,;6 &6 ( '7$%& &$4'& &6&&6

($ +&%$&6*,&6 (( &6

$' 4*

/ (+'6''+(&'

,* '+( A16166(*

:3 +

* :;$$3 *,&6

&4 E 4(4 ((.'$& * & 4&$* ''+(&'

&$4('4&6 $%&6 '+&$&$&$/ 8!9 4'$+(

%$&6

&((

7:&$*+ '(

&$&6 '&&6&&6 & $ '$44$ ($&4'& &6&&6

& ;(%$+4'$('$+( (($$%&6 '$&*4/6 ($&6:$ '$4&$4'& &6&, %%$&;(4 &$&'

$+&&6 $:$%&6

'$&*446$;&6 ( ;(&( $&

$% ,/6

&;(

,(&&:$&6 :+,*:(4&'$&* (+ &6&(6 ;('$('$+( (($$%&6 &;$:+,*:(/ 8<9 &,* &$ 46 &6&&6

&;(%$+4(&&:

$3 &;$:+,*:('$&:

,6+(74$;&(%$6 &$ $3

&6&(6 ;($&'$('$+( (($&6 $%/&6( :4.

'* 4 &$4 '($

$& 4( !"#$" %&'($)

'*'& '('&*'&+,- .

.,',+/%'0-'( '*.- ;6 & 6(*

44$;(+4 ) I '

(($( (&* (6

($;6$'

( &6&&;($&'$('$+( (($6(&$ (&* (6&.

* '+( 6$;6 ' &$* (($(;&66(

' 7$;

/ '&$<$%&6 '&:3 ((&&+&$, '$:&$ $% &6( $(&$ * '+( $% (+ &$ 3 *

;/ ( &6 $(&$ & ( $%

'&$<!;6 ($ (+ &$ (3 *

&$*

4;%$ (($$%

'&&'

(/J 8G9 6

& 6( +&%$&6 '( $% &$& 4 / 6 (&& & 4+4 '&$/ //.&6

&6(4

%'&$% ,$%'&:&'

(%$6 (($/&($&&6

'( $%&6

&&6&(6 ;($'

& ,(&&:$&6 :+,*:( ;&6$+& 63: 7$;

$% &6 '$& &( $% &6 *:(/ 5$ $3 . &6

3 ($(($+:6&&$* +&%$&6*,&6

&(&$&6 '&&6& (6 $:;&6 6 $ '6 4 ;( %& 4 %$ 6 6$+( 4 %

'& 4&6('( 4$ ($&($+4&$* '$3':/$(+

$&:

34 6(*

$4+'

4*,&6

&&$ (&* (6&6 4 3 ($ ( +&%$&6*,6 /6 ($&6:$ '$4&$4'& &6&&&6 $% (&.&6

&;(',:,'6 4;&66 /6

&6( %'&$% ,$%'&:&'

(%$6 (($/ 5$ $3 .&6

&6( &6

;

.*($$(&, :(&6 *,&6 ($(+'6&6:( 34 &%$&6 &

$ '$4 4 $ ($ ( 4 $+& %$ &6 %

'&$ $% &6

&&6 (&&'( / 6 & $ '$44'& (&6&&6

&;((&&:$3 &6 :+,*:('$&:

,6+(7;6'6 4'& (&6&(6 ;('$('$+( (($&6 $%/ 8F9 6 (&'$& &$ +&%$&6$* 6 %$%&6

&(&6& ( $ &6 *+ 7

( ;

, *$7 & &6 & $% &6

$4+'&$&6 $+&/&,* &$ 46 &6&&6

&,;(

$4+'

4&6 $+&%& $%

$4$%$ , 4&(D+&

&+ &6&($ 4:

&$&6 (:6&63 $''+ 4$''$+&$%

$%& 44+ &$&+ ;

4& /5$ $3 .

($( ;6$63 64

&,63 & (&% '&&6&&6 (

6($&*

4;&64+:&6

$4& 4&6 '+(&$4,/ 6 ($&6:&$4'& &6&&6

&,;(&

4;&6$ (+*(&&+& 4/ (4 (. &6

$& $% &6 6 ' E E6*& 4'& (&6&&6 '$& &($%&6

(;

,6 4(/&6( ($*

&% 4&6&( ($&6

(;

&'&4:

4;&6&6

' /(+'6''+(&'

(.&'$&* (4&6&, 0+4'

6(*

'+(

&$''$+&$% & 4:

&$&6 ($&6 *+

(&&6 $% $4+'&$&6 $+&/ 8#9 &6 '( 64. , 6( *

'& 4 *, A< (

'&$ +4 :6&6 $% A *60 :6/ $&6&6 (63 :3 4 &

44(&(%'&$,'$+&;&6 :4 &$ ,4( D+ $% &(

4:&$&6 ,$%'&:

(%$&6 (($$%&6

&/$

;

.*($$(&,( 4 $+&:(&&6

&*,&6 (4$ ($(4

$+&%$6 %

'&$/ $&6&6 (&$&6 ,63

$( 4% ,(&(%'&$, 4;&6 :4&$

(

'&($%&6 /6 4

$(&$( ('$%4 4%$(3 4 :$+4%$%$+4:&6 '$3'&$$%&6

&/6 '+&$6( (+''

((%+

, $3 44 (&* (6 :+ &$%&6

&* ,$4&6

(64$;$%, ($*

4$+*&/6 & $+&6( %4:( $%'$3'&$$&6 *(($%

4(&(%'&$, 34 (&* (6:

&6 :+ &$%&6

&* ,$4&6 (64$;$%, ($*

4$+*&/6

0+4: &$%'$3'&$6(*

'$ '& , 44%+&6 4 D+&

& (

&6 $3($($%&6 '&.6(*

$( $&6

&/6 0+4: &$%'$3'&$4$4 $%( & .( 4*, &6

4& $+& $&6 *(($%(&(%'&$,4

4&6 ( 4$ ($&(+%% %$,

: &,$ :+ &,;6'6, '

%$,& % *,&6($+&/((+'6.&6 %4:($%'$3'&$ 4$4 $%( & .( 4*,&6 & $+&. %% 4/ 8-9

$ &6 %$ (4 ($(. %4: $ & &6 &

.&6 ( (4((( 4/ 8"9 6

&($* 4 '

((,(&

(* && 4%$

'&:6 (&($&6&(6 ,+4 :$&6 & $( $ / 12

3)4 " $ 56