Narender Etc. v. Hy.State

  
        
  

     























   








   
     
     
  


  


! 

  
"




! 

  








#$%%  &  '

 
 


! 



 (


  


 



  
* +
,-
.'
   
+
+!

'
   


 / 0
+ 
1


2
 '
-
23'
4  +
, 
 '
   


  / 0 



 



!"#$  & 

)
6

( 7-.7
 

 



   
 



! 
 

 
"


 
)
    


)
 
-
8'
'



9:6'
;
  
 














'<7
 
  - 
8

9:6
9
 

 

'

)

 
 











 .

'



)
 
 












 
- 


9:6
.

  
)


   



  




)

)

 



"   .
 


 
 


;'

-9
!
,'
:


-  
- '
-  '




 


 
3
4

 '
- 
 

 

+=

'
2

'



- 
- 


 
 

!  
) 


>
&  '
 "

$36
-= )
-

3
4

 '
-  '





= "

! 
)
 
& 6 '
("
2

3
4

 '
-  
?46 )




6
4

 

  



'
- 
- 
" 

2 
-


  !

 
   
3
4

 '
-   &  '

 

 
) 

=

- 
- 
/! 


7 0
"


=

 

 
"

 
 

=

  
 &  '


'
-9
!
,
"

&
6 '
("
2 )  

 

 

!
2

=
 


%

 '



 
?@:

"




: 



2 
?

 
A '
-  
A ;'

) 

:+'

 "

" 
- 
,'

 
- 


'

'
"
 




 



'

 77"
+=

'

" 

- 
"
 






 
)




"  
)


 



 



 

)

 
 
4
   




2 




 


"

=


6


/"

0


 
- '
" 




 
,

/ 0


  




) 



)



 
6


/"

0
 
 
4

 
)




  
"

 
 '
)
 - 

,

   
"


 
"
@ 

  
9

"

'
 '

'





= 

-!

 = 
) "



"





 
-!



= 
) "


)





- 
- 

-  ,

'
 '


- 
 '
 '

 = 
) "


)



 
- 
&  '
 ,

- 
 







 77"
+=




= 
) "


)




A




'
 )   
 


 '
 


"
 



4
 
 



 = 


 

  
 
=




)


 
   # 

 
?@:'




)
 
-
8'
'




9:6
"


)
  

-9
!
,
 




 
 
>

:


-   
#9 
)


#9
?@:<
"

 
A
 )



-9
!
,


 '
"

"
=




 
 


?@:1
&  '
-9
!

3
4

 '
-  '
"

?46
2 )



'
"

=



 
 

?@:


A
B'




"
   
   

?@:

  A
'

-!

( 
"

    '
 




 
?@:?

?@:#'

   





= 
 
  
!
- 

)
=
  








%="

'




=  
= 






&  '
 ( 

 
= 
?@:





9
 

= 
?@:?<
"


"  





 
,

=




 

?@:?< 



 
= 
?@:'
"

= 
?@:#< "
 
= 
"






  

,

=




 

?@:#<

  



 
=
?@:C
"
 
& 
 
=

& "


+= 


& 

" ) 
 

 
  
   
,

- 
"



 
 

  '

 
 
- 
8
6:6
"
    
6 

   
"
 

  
- 
8
6:6
  '

 
"   

-



  

  


:)
:

 
 
 
"
  
 
-
'
'
8
 

9:6
  
;






 8 9

 

 '




@
:


- 
- '
:

7
2

'
:

7
- 
- 
/! 0'
:

7 

/! 0'
:

7
2


C '
-

 '
% = ( =
4

 '
2 '
:

7
+ )'
:

78
2
1

'
:

7;
6 ) 9 
:'
:

7B
.
- '
:

7
2
32
- '
- 
4

 '

- 

:

7
!
,'
-9
%
:)
:

 




:





,



 
& 

" 

46
- 
"
 


  
"



:)
:

 
; &  '
  

 
- 
 6:6
"


"


 
 
 
"



 '
"

 

)
" 

  
 


=



"

 





  '






'

 


"


2

 




- 

,

=



!
) 
- 
) 
 
  B 9
 '


@
2
-
:

2 7'




@

- 

B
  

 

?@2.



  '

 
 








 

 
 
- 8
6:6



7 
?@26'
    

2
-
:

?@22
 
)
   

6 


?@2?

"





?@2#

?@23
 




    


:)
:

 

   '

&
6 

 





)
 
-
8'




9:6'
"

 
- 

,

"
>  
  
 -!

( 
"
 
 





  
 
!  
 #
 



)
   % 



-  
 

)

 
 



)
 
 % 


 
 ! 

) 
 !   
& 
 
 



 




)
  
 
   % 
 
   
&
6 




"
 
 

 

=


 '

"


   

(



=


 '
"




 


 
@ 

% 
   




)

   
  -
<
9:6

 
! 
 D


) 
  '
)

 

)



" 



% 
   

"    
) 


 
 
 


)
    '



 
- 
8
9:6 % 
@
   
  
 
- 
8 9:6
  
)

 
 
!
"


 
 

  

 




 >
  
) 

  
= " 


  
  
 
)


 
   % 
@
   
 


) 
& 

"


 )
 

! 

)

)






 
 



)
 



)
>  
  
9
 

  '
 


 
! 
 
 

6 


/0

/60
B
  
         '
! 
 
;

B
/0

/60
8
  

   '
! 
  8;


/0

/60

 
  

 

'
! 
 
;

;
/0

/60
;;

 

  

   

 

4 D) -
6 
 
BBB

BB
9
-
6 

 

     

)  A

'

-  
 
 
! 

"7


!



  
# 
 

'


 )



  
 


7





=
   


'


2

'

'
- 



 
  )





2

'


- 

)
 
 
% 
@   

- 

,




"

 
    


  2

'
"




 
 
     

"

 


 '


 


"
@ 





'
 ( 
 '
"



- '




=


7



  

 
  )

'
"


- 

,



- 
"

 ( 
  

= 
) "


)


  '



 77"
+=




=  ) "


)


4 "'


&
6 

>  )


 '

- 

,

'
 
 ! 

  



 





 
 
 


%
-  
 

"


 

 

 
 !  '
 
"



- 

,


) >  '
)





)



  


 
-
8'
'




9:6
 

* ( 

)





   
+,-."# /-,+0.+  . 
  
 '
 
 


)






 

 
    
&
 
!   
  




@
:

78
2
1

'
+ 
A '
6
4

 '
-  '

:

7
2


C '
-

 '
% =
( =
4

 '
2

:

7B
.
- 
,'
&
6 '
% =
( =

 '
("
2



 

 


  




:

7
2
32
- '
"

 
!



 





:

78
2
1

'
+ 
A '
6
4

 '
- 


;'

@
 

-  " 

(==

B
 <
% 
 )   " ! *7   

          

 

    



   

  



       & 

" 



 
!

" 


 
?@:3

 
) 
  +%
)   
A


@



-










% 
  " ! *7   

        

   

  

       

     

    

   & 

" 




 
 

! 


 
?@:4

 
) 
 
+%


)   


- 




@ 2

 
-
;


<
% 


 "
! *7        !      

     "       #        & 

" 



 
!

" 


 
?@:

 
) 
 
+%


)   
A


 7
@

" 

- 



 )   "
! *7        ! $    

       "     





% #  " 

    

 & 

" 




 
 

! @

 
?@:,

 
) 
 
+%

)   
-


! 


- '


'
2

"

=

"



6  
-   
?@:%

>

) 
  


34
- 
"

)   
- 
 



'
 
 

  
?@:+
) 

=
 
 
 
! 




 
?@:+<


 

! 
A

'
 
 

  
?@:(

=
 
 
 


- 

"



 
?@:(<

 
! 
 
- 



'


 


 
?@:A

=
 
   

! 


2


"





 
?@:3<

 

! 
 
- 
 




 
   
?@::

=
 
) 

 

! 



A
"


 



?@:A<


 
 

)

 

 

 
2


7@ '

 





 
 





 

 7

 

  
 
- 
  



@
 

- 
/ 0


) 
 *7    

      $    

        

       &  #  "      !    

    

     # 

         $     

       '       $  $

  ' 

 (" ) *        +     



     

,      -       '   $ 

  

          .       *   !   

  , & 

" 




 

!

( 



  @

 
?@2.




+% 



-

)
"


 
"
  
 


 
2


7@ 
)

-  
 '

  


)
(







- 
)


 

)
 


! 
)





  
 :

7
2


C 


;'
2

-
!  

% =
( =
4

 '
2 )
!







@
4

)
  "


: 
"

 

4


! 
 
)
)

@
"

)



@
 
!




 
" 
4 



?@:.
   
)

   4






   






  )
! 


 

 



 
" 
4




?@:6
    
"




 

B

% A




 
  '

- '





)
! 
)


: 
"    
& 
"
  



  
 
 ! 
 
"

)




  " 
: 
"

 

 
 



?@:2




)

  
&  '



 
#-%
"




) 

 =
"

"


4
  
! 


2

'
+=

- 
 
)
 
=
?@:
?@:

"



6  
2


7@ '
  
=
?@:
:

)

"





6 


4

 
 
+%


 
 
)

 
 
"

 

2


 :

7
2
32
- 


8'
@
 



"

 
!


 
" 



 "
)


& 
 
"
 

@

6
4

 '
- 
 
" ) >    "

&
6 '
2 
A
@ '

 
"

 .:
B<
 

 
"


& 


1."# 2"3-0"4-10
+
%
)




 



  
" 


"


9


 " )

'




  
 
)



= 
 
)


4
"  
 
 
 


"

 





 

) > 
 "

 
 
 





  
4
 
 

?@:$
4





 
" 
 
 


 
) 
! 
8
2 

7@ '


 

"


!
"


 


"
 
   


 

;
4
  
 






8 8 (


 )
 
)
@   



@ 
 
 


 
 
 
  '


 )






 
2

 

)
! 





@

)
  
"


& "

)

@
"

)

@
 '
  '

"


)

 
%="

'
!
- 
 

) !


)


- 
"  
 
"
& 
"

  



  
 
 
!


 

9


!





'



+%
?@
:4'
 

)
"







)


& 



"
 

 
@
E

 )



 



:

'

"

 
 
"

&
6 '
2 
  


 
& 
 
)




 
    
" 


"


9


 "
)

'


  
 
)



=

 )


4
"  
 
 
 
   
  '




 "

 
  '
 
 

& !   
  '


)
  
"


 
 )
)
"
 
 
 
)



 

- 


'



 
    '


 )


!

- '


 2

 
"

 
"

 ! 




 
# 
 

:

78'


 
 )





- '


)
> 


 
 
2 7
2
-
:
"


 


 
 




 
?@2.
"

)
  )  .5#"!

+!6-10 ; 9

 

 '




@
:


2

'
:

7
- '
:

7


:

7

;

) 

:+'

 "

" 
,'
  - 


 "


"  






"
=

4  77"
+=

 )


"
 



9

"

'
 ,





- 


  
) 






/2

0


 
 


"

 
 
4

 




"


 
"

 
@ 

) "

9

"

'
 







= 



= 
) "

 



 '




=  ) "


)

'
"



"
&  '

- 


'

,



 
- 

 

 = 
) "


)


&  '
- 

,

 


"



 77"
+=

"
  
- 
 ,





= 
!  )


4


)

'


'





  
"


F:D
 






'

"



"   
 
+ )
-
+ )


=



 

- 
"



"
 
@ '
)






" 
"
 
&
6 '

("
2 '
"



 


 

?@:'
"

)

  
& 




:

7
2

-
)  )  
:

7
- '
"


!
" 


-





= 
) "


)



 





 '



= 
) "






- 



  

= 
) "


)







 
&  '



"


 B :

7




!
" 




2





 '


= 
!

)


4



- 

,



- 

 ( 

! 
)


"


= 
A

 )


'
)

'




 








"
   
9
 '
- 

,

'
 
 '
"

(





"
 & 
  
  
" 






 





) 



 
!
 
 
& 
)


@

 '
)
 


 
 

@


 
  


 
 
) @   
 & 
 

)
  
 




'



  
  
9



 

)


  
 
"
 





7
)
  

2

-
 

"'
"

)


 

?@26
# 
 
?@26'


 )



=



;


:+





  
   

"
 


7 
"
 







  '
2

'

'
,

- 
"

 

 





 
 
     

2



- 
 ,




 
 






"
@ 




"

'

 
"



- 
 
=

2

'


- 
& 
 

=






 





 

 

@ 


9 " '



 '


)
  



  
  
 
"
 
 

) 
  

 
 
- 


9:6 '
'

  
 
 '
"


)
 )

  

    

# 





 
" 

'




 )




2



"


= 






 


- 
"


= 





& 





 
" 



- 

,





 
 
&


:

7
2

:

7


  
- 

,



- 
  

( 


= 
) "

 )

'
)



 
)'

!
- 

@
:

7'

 


"


- 

,


  
 

2




)
) 

 
- 

,



- 


9



)
  '
- 

,

 





- 
+=

   
"


= 
4 "'
"





"
" 


)
2

'
- 



'

"



 
& 




@



!





9



"

 

@


"



- 

,





!
  
 
  '
 7 @
:




 
) 
 

* 
- 

,


 
 

 

! 





& 
)

+=

'


'
"



 






  '
)

) @
 

 
  '


 )


 



 
 ! 
.


- 

,


)


>  
&
6  '
 
 
 
"




)


A



- 
"


) >  ''



 

 






"  


 
"


- 
  
,

 
"

@ 

) "

  



'
 

"


 


& 
 
  


! 


- '
)



 
 
 '

 

 



(
@
) 
) 
 


"

- 
 
!  9

 


 
@ 

=

) "
 
 




- 

,



- 
 

)
'
 
  







7


)
  
 
2

'
 '



)
 


 
-
'




9:6
 



 
 


 
- 

))  

>
 


"


 


-!


=
 

2

'



- 

 
  )


4 "'


 
@ 
   
 
  '
 


'


 )


 


2



"


= '
"


 
 



- 
"


= 


)


4 "'




)





   


& 
'



 


:

7
2

/! 0'
:

7
- 
- 
/! 0

:

7 

/! 0
9

"
  
 
! " 


  
  

)
)

 
!
" 

'


   

?

9  
A '

:

7'

  
  


  
4

 


 
  

- 

B

 2

'

'
+=

- 
"




 
"



 
4


  
)


  
=
 
 

"


 





  '
"

"
=



'




+= 
&






) 
! 



  
)
 
=

)
  


% 

   
)



'
   


 
" 

'
)



)
 
 
 

 


 
!
"


 

  '





'
'

  
4 "'



 '

 7 

)



 




 
 
& 
 

=


) 




 '
)


 
"

3
4

 '
-  '



"
 
@  '

 


"

&
6 '
2 '
"


 
 2

?@:
"

:

7
-9
!
,






4
 



@

'
'

B
-

 

=


 '



 '
'


 ))

)

 
 
)








)
  
.

'
! 


"
 
 
 
 
)

) 
 
"

)

 


 
  '
 7 

)

 



 




 

) 
 
8

% 


 
   )







)
=









)


 
6 




 
! 
4 "'

  


 


 
 
 

)


  !
" 






'




 

9  
A 
+  '

 

#-%

)

  

?@:&'
 

)

)
   


! '
"



&

 






"
=




) 
 
 

#-% +

)

"
@


) 

 7







6 

 >
% 


   
 






- 
 


)
  


-
'



9:6'


 

 ?@26
9  '
- 
"
 
 =
2

'
- '

+=



"




@

! '
 







'
 

 = 
 


 
 
"
)

'



)
>  
 
;

"'
9

 


  


 

 



 

2

-
- '
"


7@ 

"



'
 
"





'
"

"

 



2 
-
G
2 '
)
- 
 
-   



  
"

! '
@'
 '
 
   '
2 
-


 '

- 
=





=
 



 





 
 
 

- 
4 "'




)


 




= 
(
@
)

) 


"

    )
! 
=





 
 D
 

=< '
"

"



 
 

   
?
 '


 
 



%

- '
 

  
@  
 
 '

 
 
 )


 
=
)  
  
 
"


 
)
 


)
 
 
B
%
&
6 



  
 
 
 




 
  
"


    

 
- 
8'




9:6



2

'
- 


'
"


)
 
 '
 

)
  
 
'



=

  
"
&  

)

  


 
-
8'




9:6'
;
&   

 



  
"



  
 


 



  


>

 
 

 

 



'







 

 
 '
 '

)








 $

  

=<

 C <(

 )

C <(