Jaspal Singh @ Mushkal And ANR v. Ut Of Chandigarh
!"
# $%& '()* (+% (,
$$%% -, * .
/ (
',(
$
! 0 123 #.&/43& & & 0 123& #.&/4324&5422 6, ! , 7778
,($$%% , 7 9&(,:8668.
/ (
',( ;;;;; & & &, 8# , 7 778
$$, ' , &( 9 <*:, ) &( $$%%
$$, ' ,# $%& '()* (+% $$%%
,=* ( *,8, 7778
( ', ( *, >(% # $%& '()* (+%$$%%
%
/(, ,8( $$
,$$%%
/($$%( > % >?# $%& '()* (+% &( 9 <*:, ) &( $$%% ' ( 7* ':
@ , , A @ $ >? ( %,
% &
#* '8 (
',( B(,>? ( $$%% (9 >
,( $* (>%* ,&
", B (&
"
(4
6 %
1461 , ( , * ,'
, '
, *
:$,
: ,% 8>
8$? C8D
,
* % , ( $$%%
! " # "$
%! &
$ '
( " $ ) *%* +
,- ./ 01 )23% %* +&
$ " " )4 0 0 .
50.067 ! 89 0 " " " " , "
" $ ) *%* + ( " "
$ ( "9
$ ) *%* + ( - :-.; 9
" . ) 0%2*4%**4,&<$
"
.= ! >1$ "
? @" 0
<
5@ 0<67 ! )%09 ($ !
<
- > > .=+! & 1
:-.@! - 4AB ($ 9 &" C
:-.((! $ ($
$ !" "
:-.,,! %2*4%**4
** , 0 0
($ 9 "" :-.D 9 ($
:-.#! %2*4%**4 &
! .=3! ,& <$ .= ! :-.8! ,
.=3!
)3 > 1$ "
? 89 0< ($
E E56
7 ! +370 0 ($
%2*4%**4
+)* 9
A** < < ,
/**
!"$
%! !
9 ($
($
C " ($
.=3!9
"$
%!
! ($ ! 9 ($
9
EE 7 !($ ($
@ 0< )%0, "$
%!
! ! 9
9
C " :-.8!
?&1 :-.>>! &" ,&<$
.= !, ,&<$ .= ! @ 0< )%0< ,& <$ .= !
! 9 0 <$ .= *! ,
.=3! "
?
:-.8!9 "
E,E
,&<$ .= !
C E(E?&1 :-.>>! )*3&.0 :-.8!
&
'
<C, 0 .= !
?&1 :-.>>! & 1$ .= %!
:-.::< .= !
&1$ .= %! 9
1
:-.??! & 56
:-.%A! "
%** - EE 7 ! :-.%)!EE
!
:-.%+! " :-.0 9 56 -EE
!EE 7 !
E<E
9 "
0 .= ! ,
.=3! $ ($ <" 9 & 0 .$ ?&19
9
5 6 5
6,
9 "
,& <$ .= !
>1$ "
?
! " # "$
%!
9
" :-.,:-.(0
.=3! 9 ,& <$ .= !
)**4%**4 :-.@@! $ 9 " :-.<< 9
:-.&&!
* *%**4
@ 0< )% 0 $ 9 " :-.! ($ ,
:-.!
* *%**4 &
' ($ $ 9 0 0 :-.
!* *%**4 %+* 9 ,&<$ .= !"
($ $ ! ,
<
@ 0< )% 09 ":-.
D $ 9 ":-.
D% $
9 &
' "
@ :-.
D) .
0 0 < ($ "
"< "
9 9 :-.F! $ ($ <
($
:-.19 0 " :-.
($ <" "
C > @ "-
9
":-.D , 0 " , ,& <$ .= !
:-.9
":-.9D 9 ,& <$ .= ! . ) 0* *%**4
*4%* " ($ $
@ 0< )%0- < .= ! 0 .= ! @ 0< )% 0 < :-.##! :-.! '
9 )*% &.0 9 '
:-.G! ,
:-. !
7 - ($ *% *%**4 , 7 -
:-.FF! 9 " "
:-.;!9 0 ? 0?! 0 .= ! %2 *%**4 9 0 H .=%! ,&<$ .= !
:-.>> " 1 :-.@! ($ 9
! "
,
" D5
6
& (
.=4!
,&<$ .= ! 9 0? :-.11!
5
6
9 0
0 0 %% %%**4 9
0 0" */* %* *" )*%&.0"
-
" 0
0 %** %* *9 $
A 0 0 -9 , 0
!%** %* *&
(! %2*4%**4
/D/)* >1$"
?89 0
($
I
)*% )+&.0
I 0 &
0 , 0 9 " -
"
9 9
9
- " 9 0 " "
)*% )+ &.0 9
" " "
$($$,"
($ "
! .=3! :-.8! 9 ,& <$ .= ! 9
&
.=3!
7 - "
, $
:-.;! ( '
.=) !
.=+ (
9 %,
* % ,($$%%
"
'
& 1$" ,"
89 , <0 , # . ) 0 " ($
"
&
($
%,
* % , ( $$%% ,
=* % 4 *>:
( ( *(
? ( ?
' %,
% >'*' , :( ( ( : ,
,
'( : 8 %?('
, (
,
% B $, 4 % *>:
(, 72%B $
%%? :
> '
9( : E(9'
9 *,( *'(*%
,
(
(9> , >?(%,
* %$$, ' ,($, B ( ( , (9'
(, *'((,
, ( /( :$ , 9
( ( > ,,, *, ' (
*, (, ' ( ?
' %,
3F 6G , 72% ( B ,
, >? &(, 6, $% & '(8 %, #*
% '
, % 8 (
',( 4 >?, 72%( ( ? ( 9% * (,8 ( > * $ :
,*, ( : ( B , + ' >( ( $*:$ ( :8($$%% :(, , : :&*,>( % :(, /(?%% , ?
' B(?B (+ '>((, (? , > '( :
&( $$%%
(( B ,+>
( ,9, * (+% $$%%
*'( ( % ( :
&( $$%%
$ *, +, ( : &*,>( 7*9 % ( : >%H >? % '( ' ( < 9
> @ .= +! " :-.1! 9 ($ ,
":-.
D) ($ "
9
,
($ "
" ( >@
.= +! 9 " -
($
($ &"
89,
"
" & " !
'
(" ) *%* + :-.;! ,& <$ .= ! -.=% J
>" .=3! -.=) ( >
" ! "
- .=+ (< ($ !
$ 0 < 9 $ ) ) 0.0
" 9 ( "
>"
I & " ($
$
! !
", !'
9 890 ) *%* + :-.;! (
" &
!
.=3
%**4, >1$ "
?0<
56 5 7 6 +30 > " > +** 3** = <
,
7- .
.
9 :-.8! " J""
"
%2*4%**4 +)* > 1$ 7($ ! A**
> 1$
/**
!
7- , 7-
.=3! 7- %,
* % , ( $$%%
<
1>
3** "
$
)%0 < 9 "
< "
9 "
C "
.
.
"" & ($ !
"
.=3! :-.8!
9 ,& <$
.= !
>1$($ &
- "
& 1
:-.@! ! *** %2*4%**4 # ($ 9 # -
9 1 "
- " 5%2*4%**469
" 6%2*4%**46 ( " *** - %2*4%**4 4+A ,
* % ,($$%% ( *>:
(( $$, > % ::
%
,
' , 72% $,( ?
'
%,
8(
(
*,, $ :
B(,
,
' ( * 6E@ $,(, : 3F 6.8(
(
*,,
$ :
8B( %($ , 72%B >, *'( (508& ,"8 (
',( $ :
,
' (23F 65 /(
, : (( * ( @ 0<8& ," > *B + % :, $, ( I4 $, 2 3F 658 ( >, ( ,? ( ( > :
> %%' ( ,? >*, ' B ( * + B :
* + B : ( : /( $
,
*
*> ( $, *
(> ( : '
($$%% <$ ' 9 B( ,
:, % 8
, *: 9
,
, 8 B *% >7* F$
( :$*' 7* ': , ,
@ A @
'
'($$%%
,
'%?8($$% %% B 8(7* ':
@ , , A @ $ >? ( %, , 0 "
)*% )+&.0
'
& & &, #* ' 2 5 %% #* ' :>,"8 J :KD <* %