← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/104/2015dismissed

Vikas Kumar v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-04-05Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina,Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal17 pages

 

       

 !"!#$%$&'(()  

    

    '  *+

( ,,(,(,   *+

( ,

 

---    

     



       



   

     !"

     !  

!#



--- 

 

 .(   

/))) $

  !

   !  

!        &  

!#

'  (! ) *   

* ** $+ , -.$/ &   0*!

 ! *12 3 4$5-6 $.

-.$4#4.+7+.6+,5  2 8(9289'  )!" "

!! ( 3 -+' )" !: !

*#4.+7 +.6+,5  28

-

! !     

8  " -6 $.

-.$4"  *" !  !"   ;   !

" ;3 //+<#$  *  8 "  *   

=   27 * *" ;8  " * 

!! !

   "

!  

0 3  *7*

( 



8&1 (; &)"  ;  >?

>" "

" "*!         

                            

  

   



  

 

    !"#   $ %&'"(%") 

*    + , *  %(       



  

 

 

#  *    #   - -* .   

 #    - - , $     - -   $ /                                -           0 1 *"(%'     

     %( )  * ,   "2  - -       

          

 

3  

"2%("(%'%4'(*          

!5'26&-'''""  

    7  



   8  8                  !" #  # !! 

 ! $ # #

!%&%

'!

  % ()   !

* !) $   '! ! 

 !

 +#  ) 

,

%    &4((*         

     *           

        . 

 1



   7 , ) *  

 

    ,  

           *7        )  

  * 

 

  9    

              - --  *    -  --/     - 

 

:           ;

  "*& !   "

27 *      :: !  *  !*  ! #4.+7

" !4+ 28 2: " *  & "      ?  &! "*!!   &"  

    !   !!*!  ! !  27 * *"  ! !!*2 ! #;@ !

   

*   !!

 & !*    *

 !!

 "  %" ! 

 (  ) 

" !      "

"  !    " *    !&

!!    3    

 " 

 ! @.6 $$ -.$4 

  &  !   !#+.6+,5  28 "          !  %   "

&   !  "       !

    $.

$$ -.$4       "  "     @ !  *!

* !!"  8  2: * "

  *! !

 !-.<8

 !  ! 8   0*   +

1*  !!#4.+7+.6+,5  28* !!( 3 -+' ) &" !

* !! *&"

& *&!   /

  !             !  *   !!? * "

!  ! ! !!" &?  : #4$48

 > !

 * !  ! ! !!   *  !*   "           "

  &             

!! ! ! % &   &    &"

& !   !  &

  !  !

(!!) * "

&    "   !!   *   "(!!)"  * &  

    & & " * 



2 !!    !   "

"!"  *"*  ( ) *   --!!

 "

 "  &*        "    !!      ; (! )"  A* *   &  "

 " & >  (  )  &   !

 !   (  )* " " &"! * (!

)  !   B          @ *!!

! "    *1 @ !     ! ;

*  !* (!

)      

1   !     " & ! &       "!!! &  !        !& <

2!!!? "

  8   *  !

 **

* "!: !! ( 3 -+' ) !

*   * * &* *  

,

  

!  (! )  *      "    **    !     

 !     8 " : $.

C          !     

!   

-

 " !  $$

   !       

!    !       ** * ! !

    & "

1  !   

 "   !4.+7 28* !! ! 

*&   8    "   * !  %   8 "

 *  **  *  !

"* * !   !! ! ; 

  !     !! ""  "   !!    8 !  !    !  " & 

!!

(!!)



;  !   8  "

   !  

       

!  

*    8 "



*  ** *   !4.+ 7 28!$$47 2> ! !   ! 

! ! !   "9  $D&      

*" !! ( 3 - ) !!

  ! $$47 2> ! !  "  

! " !!   !""

&  !!! "

& 1  & *  

!   

&

3 -+'  "&*  * *  $-

2  "  ! !



!"   *   !       !  *  !

  C4 ;  

* &*  !

"  A" !! ( 3 -' ) $5 -.$-  % &          -5 !       

*    

*   *  !  & "         "

     -$...#"* !!         &  &*  7 * * !

 >B" * !!   

@"!   *" *  "* *-/ ! !*" *  "

&    

* !! * *  !

 *  **!"

& -4 -.$4      - /!   *  ;B187 !

"

    !!  

    *   !!3   

! *    3  !7" 2!  !! " $.!  !

* ? &!

&!   & *  

 *  < /!  *     "    >?

> &  

. !       >?

1 "

 ! !*** !" ! 

      >?

E "

" !<



   * !     !!!

! "  !  7        >?

;    "

    *  "

&   !  "       !

 @6 $$ -.$4  

  &  

!:!   ! **!!

!

C/ & "! ' 

(C4)       >?

; "

"

& !"  ! 

 7"!! 

  C< ;*" !  3 !! !     "9 !

-4 -.$4 ;   !   - /!"* !

 

!"

       "

     3  

!! " "   ! &" ?

!* $.! 7 C/C<   !

     !  !  

C$B

 7  *"    7  ! !!    ?  &!

 -6 $.

-.$4 ! :>?

7 1   !  ! &     >?



1 *   !  "

&?      **!!

   &!    "

" 

/ &! ! &

>?

 "     C- * " *

;

*

 >?

B#$>?

B#$+ !!

  * !"

"  !    >?

B C+  3       *   ;B18  7 !

           !       0  -.$4     

!

   * !&**    *" -5<4<+#  ?"   

" &!

*    *!!

1    !  #    >?

0#$  ! & ! !>?

0 C6    B> 8 73 ; &

!  * 3 ,+$6,55,<5 

'!   

! & *!

 

!  >?

 1    !   

   -.

$.

-.$4-/ $.

-.$4>?

#$  27 * 2 **@! 

  C5 ;    >?

> !    >?

>#$  12>?

>#-     "

 ! * *      "

!

 * ! *  !"  !      ! !>?

 @$>?

 @+" !  

  >?

 @/>?

 @6>?

 @< 

  *>?

 @5 $4

3" "  !   ! 

! !

!

C/ &"  (

! )

 !

?              *     $, .6 -.$4  -<....#   "

*!!3 $+<,$....-.5-<;B1877 !



    *"  

 !! % "      &  -6-...# *   &&"&!

: 1    ! ! &   !!>?

B$  1      !!  >?

B$                  -6-...#  "      & !!&"&!

:-$ -.$4   *   &     !    "

 "        !!  "  <-544#   C+    3          !

?     7   " A&   * !  

& ;(  )   !  7    A*   * !  

& %  "A&   

  !!"!  *  "  - /!" 

    !!   " &!!!! ( 3 - )

 -4 .6 -.$4    :               !    ! (

! )    - /! !!

( 3 -+ )& *  ;B187 **-4 .6 -.$4       3 !$$47 2> ! !

  "   !     !*& ! !" !&!

&!! "

&



2 !   !& ! (!

)"!&!

&   !!& "

& !!( 3 - + )&   

*

$+

BC/

  E * @787 !

%  !  *!!!

"   E

*

   !

"  * *! ?!! 3 ...,-.$$.$6<6<    $$$-6<< 65"&*  !!  -/ $.

-.$4 >?

BC/#$"   !!  *!! %     " "  * *! ? !!3 ...,-.$..$,,..    +-65<-/ $$ "&* !!-/ $.

-.$4 >?

BC/#-"   !!  *!! $/

BC6 *  * =72 !

B  7A  !  *! 

 ?!!!

"    * E

*  *!!3 +-<+.-.$...645- +-<+.-./....../ ! & >?

BC6#$"  !! !!!

"

 "   $./$-<-# "&*  !!-/ $.

-.$4 %   !!>?

BC6#- "   $/$--44#"&*  !! -/ $.

-.$4

$6

3 ! !        !!!

(!!)"  

!!&   

*    !

 & *& &   "

   *"

* "!!     !!"   &  &  &    "  

*  & $<

BC<

 * 8 !"     ! &    0   >?

BC<#$    *  1             * " "  !

"

    "&    !

        *  1   1    " "! ! ?  "

 "  % 

0 >?

BC<#- "  *   * & &  *

 $5

BC-0&E *   #

  

  8  */-3"E  



! 01   ; " ! 

*  E

* (!!) !



*  ! *!& ; ! 01 >?

BC-#  >?

BC-#             * >?

BC-#3    !! C &!

    ! *!&  

-.$-3   -.$4  ! "" 4-6/54#.+ $$ -.$4 $,

BC$; * 8 !" ;:7*

%  B !1   !   (

!)        B  "  "           *$$- ?D !

%      &  **  " ?7

 *   $5.....# 1    " *   !   !  1  >?

BC$# >?

BC$#7 % ""?   " 

!   " *   !

!!"* 1 ! 

  ": ! !

2" !    "  *!

  (!!)*     "

"&* !!"

 ""* -.

"   >?

> 12>?

>#- !

(!!) !  

 B   

3 ,4/+5444---/ $.

-.$4 $4.

"

"&

!    

  "

!"*"5/,$,+/.65 3



  " *     !                 "

!& !   ! !   &  !           

  * *   *

   !! !! 

 *  < /! -$

C5 27 * 2 **@!   !

?     !   

   &" 

2" & "  ! !

   &  !              &       3 ,+$6,55,<5 --

BC+3 *   ! !! 3   ( 3 4 )"" *   

!

 & !!

   " * * 1  !

  =  & *     *       &!



-4

BC,  !! !!

    ! * * !  !

  &-.$4 !

-.$+      !!3  "" *   

!

 *   ;  

! &!

* >?

BC5#7  -+

BC4       *         *

( 3 - )  !  "

 ! " !  &" *

&

  !

      

    "!!&  "

& -/

C5 27 * 2 **@!   !

?             !       !   *  *  "!!!" ! 

 % !  ! !!

""*!* !  ;!"* ""*!  & C52 **@!   ! 

! !! "  * !  ! *1    * *  %     !!      *1  

 !

      ;      & *!

@ *    !

  

!   *!& ! !$.5    B!    (C5) !

  

!

"

 "* * "

*  ! %   !

?  "  !! !! * * !!   &   & & *   ! -6

BC50" * !    * 1% B !    >?

BC5#

% 

-  " ! "      &    " * *1    "!

(!!) -<

 !   (C4)         "



 * 8 "

"    >?

> &

   !: *!!

!    

  &    !.6 $$ -.$4!

! ! +.6#+,5  28"  ! !  * " "   *!!

! -5

      !                  

* !"" "

"$.     *!!

! % C/ & !

?     !

(!!)"*!!! !!  !  ! ! & !

"

 *"  " 

&    %   !

 ?  !!     " !"

**"  *1  % 1 ; 3   " *1"

"!5 $.     "

!

(!!) " * -,

>  * !     !! ( 3 -+ )    !& 

&  * ! ! 4.

2 *  ! * 

    *        

  *      *  * 

8:& 

! *  

 

  

     8 ,.66 -.$6 !! *&   ,(,(, 



 

(()      #E