Sardul Singh v. State Ofpb.Etc.
!"
"#$%$
'
(
))) *
+ , *
-"%"&!
# "$ %!##&# "
! %"'(
))) .
&# ! )#
($ %! &"* ##&!&"*
'%*+ "& &" " #
,- ..
/--0 ($!
& &"! ##&"#%* 1 2#
3% %4 #&"# &"*&# "
+ &" .50
-.
-6 /--. *&#
!& &"%4 #& ) &
1 2)##
%" *&*%#+ &#"+
$ #" $ &"
# 7--89%" &",/5
"&"
"!
3 1 # :
;2"&"
%!
$+ &"
%" *&*%#&+ &#"+ "
+"
&# !$
$
&"&# "/< -5 /--.
(% 6=,-
&"* #" ('"* &"* #&
&!!* 41+ !&""
2)#
%"&"* +
&"*)4&"
!# #
(%## "
&!!* #) 4 &"* #" %!&"* + )& >"*>"%!&"* + )& > "#>) "&"*
4 &"* * >!4>
&+ 1+ !&""
2!
##" " )& )&"*
# *&"*
!"
%!&"*
"* > "#>(!) &
&"*" &#
(
$
&"* &## % # &(&"* ) # %# &##& %
"
($ " )& ##
% %#
#
&"* &+(
##&!"
#")$)&
& ) "#
)& ##+ ##* )# ($
&"*
!& &" &)! + !& &" %4 # (%
+&##&"
&"* &"3&&! # & !%4 #)& &"'%$" &#
#"
&"* !"*)& 3"# (!
?%!
&"* !!
+ &!
*!
&"* + !& &" %4 #"
# & !
" &# !& &" "@%&&"*(%
"&
&"'%
!
&"'% %"
+4
+ )#
#& &"",- -5 /--.
"-.
-6 /--.)
&"'% )# ! &##
.)# "
(#&#
) & # %" &" ,/5
)# * *&#
" &" &* &"#++ 9%# %!&"* #% " &"
3% " )#
" &"
* &" + &#!#% #
&"
%#%" ) & * > "#> +
++ "
&"*
> "#>A
<)# 4 "&" ## ##&"& + + A
.- "-0 -6 /--."
!&
" &* &"
&
* &"&" A
+ &!
&"'%$+&*
"* %# !&
&"*!$
&"* ,/5
)# #%(# %
($ &" ,-6
" + !
&"
&" &* &""
+!& # %!&"* )# !!"
" #
3% &!
4 &"* ( &"* '% "&!
)#
!$ !!"
"# &!
% "&!
%# & )# * 9#
"#%('
&!
++&##&"
%" &",-6
#%(# "
&
*
&" #+"$ # )& ## #"+ !$ B.+ !&""
&"* B/ &( &"* B,!& &"* B0%("#
&"* "
B7
"**
!#% &
&"&" &##
%" &",.,
3 3&+&"! % 1 #
:3
;2
"&
#
&"" !
&"" !# &+ !& &"% $
!
!& &#&"&+&! &+"
!!
* % "
!# # %" &"#,<<0-/,-/"7..
)# *&#
*&"# &+ !& &"%4 # + !&""
#%
&"'%$($
!!" #(
!# !$&+ !&
# &
% "
" "
+ !&""
)& ## # # &+") &"&+&! )# &+
" &#
B. & +&"* "B/"&!?%+ % %+ ")& &"*A
"!$C&"*
& &!(!
" "
#%(+&##&"# + ($ !
%(!& # " !
%"# &"*
" &"* &"&"*
++&
# " !! %" &" ,-6
)# "&
++&##&"
%"&# (!
%" &",/5
")##
($
&!3% #&"&
(
!&"***& ($
&+ %*"
'%*+ "& "
,- ..
/--0 ## ($!
&!%
&"# "
!
#%(+&##&"#+ ($
!
%"# &"*
" # "$ %! ##&# "
!
%"'(
" #(
%#
( *&")& !
%"# !
*%
+ !&""
&"* #%
#&"*!
&"'%$!!
* !$%# )& # * ) "(% &+ !&
) #"#"+ !$
" &#+&"#"4 &"* &"
!& &"*
#+
+ !&""
)#+ &!
*!!$ ($ B7
"**"
$ % &
/< -5 /--. .-=,- + &!
*!
.,"
&+"$
B7)#&"+
" &"#%
&&
&"'%$)#*& %#&"" " (
%# )& # * ) "!&4 > "#>
/
&"'%$)#+ &"
& *!
.,"D9$
A+&"
&"'%$)#* "
($
"(#
&!*&!
&"&"
B7
&"'%$)# *& %#%!" !&
%"# !
*%
)#"&"
&"!
!"* !$&"!*&"*
&# "
+ &"
% )# !!
* 4 " ! 6=,- "/< -5 /--.) #
A
. &"'%
&"* )# ($
" &* &"
& "-.
-6 /--. .-=-- * "
$"
)"&* #)#!"* "%* " &"* !# (&
# $
!# !$&+ !& &"*
#
!&
+ !&""
)
&"&+&! )# &+% $ &"&"
&!!*
%"# ! &"
% #
#
# &"
)#&"
*
&"
"
& + &"* "&" %#%" &#&#!#%
E> "#> 1A
<2)#!!
*
" &"&"
& +&"*
"!$&"
" %(!&)& ##
!!
* $ ) "
%&"*
&
& + &"* #
&"
)& ##(A#B."#
"
)# &"
*
" "$ $ +
)#
&" &#
B/ "&! ?%+
% %+ ")& &"*A )
&# %
%+(&+ ##&"#&
>F.>"
&#!#%
E>F/>"
#4
(!
> "#>1A
<2">F,>"
$
'
+A
.-" !!$)&
"8# &+ %+(&+ ##&"
& +&"* >49.>%" &##
&"
3%
%+( &+ ##&"#"
+ + "+ + #"!# ) !# " %" ( & +&"*
%"# !%* " & + # &
&" &* &")#" &")# &"
"
&" &*
& (&
%+ # &+ !&
& !!
* &"#
&"( + %(
%!"%" !&(!
*%+ # !
%"# !
+$ (
(% & + &
&#)"*"
)#"&"
&"! !$ "
$" )"&* #&"!*&"*
&# "
+ &"
&"*
& *!
A
.,&"'%
&"* 3&&! # & !%4 #
.-=.- "/< -5 /--.
)# ($ B7
"**
.-=,- " #
B7
"**
!& A
0*& "($
!& ./=7- ",- -5 /--.") & # *
&"&"A
08.
&"'% )#%"
+4 #
*&"
",- -5 /--. 6=,-
!& &"A
,)#*& "($
!&
(%
&"
& "
,8.
)#%"
+4
&#"
!& &"A
7*& ""-.
-6 /--. &
"
78.
&"'% )# ! +4&"*#
($
++ &
!$
. &"'%
&"* )# ""
(#&#
&!$&$
)# *&#
.-=,-
!
## #$
!$& "$ #
(
"%!$ A !&"
($
+&
!$
"&"'%
&"* )
#& # #+ &!!*
&#" &"*"
# )
&"'% )# "$ #" # &!
)#
%# ) &
%! &+ !&
&+ !# !$ " &# #
. ) &
+
(#&# &# "
+ &" #) !!#) (
3% #&"*" + !&""
8&"'% #
"
"
&+ ) )#
%"&"* + "
(%##
&!!* #)4 &"* "%!&"* # "&"*
$) + )& >"*>"> "#> !$ 4 &"* &# >!4> :
") & %!&"* * > "#>(!) &
&"*" &#
"
!
$
&## % #
&(&"* ) # %#
)#"
($"""!+*& "($ &(&"*
##&!"
# )$ )&
& ) "# &( &"* B/ $ )& ##
% )# "
!
&"'%
)# #&
&!!* 4 ) &
&"'% ) #&
" #" %
&"'% # *&"#
# &+( ) 9 &!!* # " ) @%! &+ "
*&"*
% &"'%
&"* )# %!!$(
($ B/ &( &"* "" &"*#% %!( & ($
&" &# ##9
A+&" &" ) & %! # !$
&# &(&!& $ B/
*&!!$#
)## "&"*&"
&# %# )
#)
% %&"*) & 4 &"* &# >!4>
$ # %!" !!)
&"* # &"&# "" &# %!&"* * > "#>(!) &
&"*"
!
#&
&"* B &!
&"'% & % # %
" 4&!!"
&"* &+
##&!"
#")$)&
& ) "#
3+&"*
" &"'%$#%
($&"'%
&"* & &#) ) &!
&"'%$ #&( ($ B7
" **&"
& *!
.,) & &##%" =9
!
#
( &"'%$)##
( :*& %#&"" ;"
) "%# )##& ( :# ;
& &!&*+# )&"*
&"'%$&#A
.,8.
&#
&"
B7 "" !& &"A
./*& "($
!& *& &"&"A
./8.
&"'%$+&* "* %#
!&
& &+ !$ "
"*& "
&# @%& + &"
&"'%$" *
&"'%$D9$ (%
#
#
@%&
%!& +&"*" &"&"
&"'%$)#*& %#" (
"%# )& # * ) "
"
&"'%$#
)& "4 $ ($
)##%
&&
)#"&"&# )%"5+ A- 7+"
'%# (
!
$ ()&
,+)$ +
+&!&"
%" !$&"*("
)#%
)%")# %# !$ (!
&"* " E
'%*+ !
&!3% (# # %" =9 :$
%
& ' (
)
% (
*
+ !,&
*
#
( !-./% (
!01./% ( (# !
&!3% !
"+
%( &"
!!
*
&"
&"'%$#%
($ + !&""
&"* )#*& %#&"" " (
"%# )& # * ) "
)# " " !& &" *& " ($
&+# %"
#
3% # )#"# %
+ !&""
9&"'% "
*
&"*
&"'%$
+ !&""
D9$
* & # &"&"
"
!("
)# "
&"'%$) & )#"&"&# )%"%# )& # * ) ")#*& %#&""
&+"$
)& ## #"+ !$B. & +&"* " B/ "&! ?%+ % %+ " ")& &"* A
($
+$&"&
& +&"* )#"
#" ) # %+( &+ ##&"# "
+ + # )&"* $ > "#> +
(% #!& $ #"
#
&"%!" !
!!"
*%" "$ &"
&+& $
&"
&" &* &"
%"
@%&! #&
B.+ !&""
9&"'%
&"* " B/ &(&"* %!!$ (
($+ &! & "" &*" #& & &# #"#&#
* % &"# &&"*
"!%#&"& #&# &(!
&#
# &" #%
&" (&"*&"* + *%&!
&"*!$
'%*+ "& &"
,- ..
/--0 ($!
&!% "& &"*
%" &",/5
&# % ! # *#
@%"
%+ #
#
)
&# &
8 @%
" !!# " &"
!&#&#+&##
&#"(&!&" &## &#(&!("# !!# " " !!
" "
3 &
%&&!*&#
# !!*
"&
"++& &+ &#" # &"*
+&"&"* &
"# !! 4 "
##$#
# + !$)&
'%*+ )& % + % 4
&"*&"& )
!&(&!& $
&#&"# &"0/E3
"#%(+& + !&" % )& &" & )+"
# +
$
*&# $ # !! 4
4
#%(+&##&"
+ !&" " % %
#)
# " )& &"
&+ + &++ &
!$
A &$
2 3 -.
-/ /-.5