High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/716/2007dismissed

Surjit Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan16 pages

!" % $ ''( )(( *!+ (& *(

"($ $!, &-

''(

. $"'', ., *!+

///// ''( !" % 0&!" % 1'& % +$", +$

+"#

20 3

5, & 4

3 "

#( *(6 $"

+( ( , 74

($ 8$ 8, #"(& *'"

" #$, "("

# "& :&#, # ''#"(

#$, +$

'# (

(" +( &"# &

( "( ((((" +#( 6 (9

""# ;4 <# 6 (9 +#, '

9"#$"# 4 4 <# ' +"# 3=5

+'#"# :#"&', (" +( &"#, 9"$ '"

( " $+6

"& "($+' & 4

)"& !&# &&

;

, +$

$#& ( & ((&

;

, $6 ( &# "#( "( "&

6( 6 " ( '<$ $> &' 6 ", $ &# 0 6

;

"'6 (& (

(, (6

5, 0 '

? *'"

" #$ @$" & 0-("#"# "

A0B $&"# 6

"("# 0 :( "

$( ( $# $9<,

#$ (

<"#> $ 0 "-& ( " "

!" 1'& % +$", ("&( $$< '# (

("& 1 1 +"# 3=5

6 (9 '&& " "

<&, '# C"6 6 (9

'& -& $ > +"# -"9 ( " " ( "-& '"+', 0 ( C DE*5 (" +("( '

20 DE*4 &&> 0 " $ #$+" * #$ #& '$"

''6> $ #$+" * '( "-& (>

("& 1 1 (& " ("#''& (> &"- # -( ( < " #"( & &"-"&> 9$

$', " & +"# &"- !"

1'&

(""#

$"( ("& (>

1'& ! &

#& ( >

( (""# 9$ '( ! & 96, $9-,

!" $&&>

9$"' ($ "-& ( !"& 6

$ #$+" * &"( '(& $"( "&"6 !"

" "# $"

(( $ ( "E"

9& (

"#$ # (

& ( ( .F& "

#"(> ("&

#- " ( ( .F& "

(

DE* #& &, ("#&

(& 9"(((> $,

( $& ('& +#( 6 (9> $( #"- ("'

3( > 0 &9 '

-& +#,

-"# $( " ( '( #"- 3( > ("'

+ +#(

$6 &9> ("& 6 (9 +# & ;5 <# 4

# > ' +#(

""# ("& 6 (9

-& " '(, $ ('& ('

0 $-"# ((" 88> $ #$+" * '( "E& $"( ('

$-"# "( "" 88 ''

'(> ' ('

(("( +$ ('( <

$" DE* > 0 $&& - ('

( 0 :#!

9$(, * "& $"( ('

('> 0 <

6 " ((((",

-"&

DE* (& 9"(((> !" %

&"#'6 (& $"(

(> 9$"' ("# $"

, $"( ! '($"

& ('&

( 9$ (

( & DE* , ("#&

(& 9"(((> #&( ( (-&

#& &> C(" '# "( DE* < " ((((" -"& (

DE*7> 0 & #$ (" ' ' DE*

&& ( ( 9"(((> ( ( DE*;

* #$ "-& $"

5, -"& &( DE*;A (", 0 <

6 $"( (

(&6 9$"' '&#"# !" %

' <>

5, 0 & !" %

6 + '& #"(,

-"# '"

" DE* '& #"(, # ((& " & DE* A '"

"> 0 +#$ + <

6 (" $&& - ? '9"& &(""# "

'<$

G$ 0 & "

6 + '& #"( (+ ""# "-6 DE*

> $#$(

6 '( < ( #"( :('

$#$> '- &( #& ((& #"( DE*

A, *

(", 0 #" &("&

6 ? '9"& "#$>

5, 0 ("#& 2=

DE* ;

(&"# '

' ('

$" "

$ '

DE ", *!+, $&"#$> '( &9 '& #"( && &("& !&"

'<$ &

$# :, #> "

$ '

DE " DE* DE* 4A

'" "-("#" $ '""(,

$'' #"(

!" % & "'&

$'', "'

:&#, # ('"&

"( & ( '"& $"

(( -"&& &

*, $ "&"# "

$# & 4

#"( !" %

(&, '&& #"'6

+(C'6, (' 6

$'' "'& #"(

0&!" % 1'& % +$", 9$ '( (& $"(

( ( ($

$# #"(

!" % 0&!" % 1'& % +$"

& 4

4, +$

'&& #"'6

( -"& , E "&

" *H( &"'& +'9 *H :('

*$#$, *" *$ &", '&

&, # (&

+"# (

& $ "($ , :&"

#"( 0( '((, #, < $#$(

6 "-6 &"#( ( =& :0, # (+(C'6 $&& - $#$( DE* DE*;

'# #"-( DE*5 DE*4

& ("

? '9"& 9$ '- "

(& *'"

" #$, '

9"(( && -"& $"( "&-" DE*4 ( '#

6 "& $"(

(&6, "# $9"$ < ' *H;

(+' 9 9$ < ( ( 0''C #"( $"#$ "

(

"( "( 0 '&- $#$ $"( "&-" DE* &(& $&& - ( ( 0''C #"( $"#$ "

(

&""

*H5 ? ($< 1 ,

" ' '(, (&

5, (& * #$ ? && -"& $"( "&-" DE*7 ( '# ' '( "& $"( ((((", "# $9"$ < '

*H4 $ #$+" * '' * $<$ 9$( (

+& -&

&(& #& +("&( "# + $"( '

"& &"'

'" !&#

*H 0 '&- &(&

9$"' (& * #$, &6, " C DE*5

? '

$#$ *?.

9 && '

20 DE*4 ( ( ( 0''C #"( $ (" "

( $#$ (+' 9 9$(, *?.

9 $&& - C 20 +

-6 0

*H $ *&

'<A & 1, ="

, '

&, '$"

+#$ (

& & #&"# #"(" 3=5 , ("# " #"(& :#"& *'

( *6 =', A , !"

.&, 39 '$"

? -& #"("

#& DE*

*H7 0 '

0 (& (6 #&(

(((("

+("&( "# + $ ( $"

#& "-("#"

(, -"# -"( & (

*H7 0 :(9

9#'6 +& (&

9$"' (& 0 * #$, &6, && ( 0 .(9< & * #$ 7

4, && ( (+' 9 9$( && ( $#$ :('

&&"" $, < " ((((" $#$(

*H 0 :#!

+ 6 '& 0A? '

9$( ( ,

+& -&

&(& #&, "# '"

G$ '"& -"( & ( '(

'( -"& ", ( (

&& & ;;

*, ''

""#

" ( ( "# -"& #"(

+ $6 &"& ''#"(

&"# $6 " '('6 "-'-& $"(

!" % < ' 9 C(", $#$, '" $(& $"

6 " ('

("&", $, + I

$( " ( -6, < 96 #"(& 9

? "

$"( $( ( ( +'( -"''# ' "-'-& $"(

(

1'& % 0&!" '&& " '( '"

" $"(

'& -"& &

G$ "'

'& ''9"# "( & "" H$$

( "( (((("

-& +6& &+J

H$ !""# 9 0-("#"# "

J ; H$ &'6 (&"# ' '( ' ('

$ '

'6(J 5 H$ " 2=

(J 4 H$$

'"& 9"$J 0 , "( J H$ E "" '6 "&& 9"(( $&"# - ('

0-("#"# "

J H$$ "&""

0&!" % 1'& $( -& "J 7 H$

"( ( ( 9"((( -6J $"# # (, "'

(

"& ( 2'"# ##"-& !&# $"

& ( ,

"'& '

+ $"( , & "& #' $"# " (6& &"# & '

"( $-"# "'&, ""# ( ''( ((&& &"# & ', (+! $" "($"# C"(" +&( ("( $" :&"

#"(, #

39 '

$"#

$- $& '&

''(A

(&, '&

+("&( #"# $#$ &

0 $"(

(, 9"((( '6 *H4 $ #$+" *, *H7 0 '

*H 0 :#!

''6 (& (6 #&

G$( *H( (+! '#$6

(( E "" +$'

+ $6 ( < $" #(

'& ($&

" ''

&(& '

-" "#

#"-

"("

"& 3 -"( "6 +9 $( *H(

$( ''#& -& & $6

"#$ $- "-'-&

$"(

9#'6 &(& #"( $"

( $"(

( ( *H

? '9"& *H5 ? ($< 1 *H7 0 '

'& "-6 DE*

& & ((& '& :0, # &

" DE*

A DE*

A , ("

6 *H :('

*$#$, +("&( $#$( -& $"

DE* *;, "

(

6 "& (

(&6 ' '( $& "

$ '

DE ", *!+, $&"#$ ('( "

$ '

DE ", *!+ $&"#$ DE*

''6 ($9( 9$ ' '( "-& $ ('( $-"# (("( 88 88, ('( " ''"& ( ('

((" ( '6("(, '( & $( 6 $&

;

''( $(, $9-, <&

#& !&# -"( #&(, "( +"# ($ 9$ (6 !"& 6 &"# ( ("F E "&

(( &

#"-"# "( &+

"& + $''((

?9-,

((& $"(

" ( &"( ((& &"'

+-, "

9"((( ($9 $- -"( "6

& $6

"#$ $- ##& #"(

"-'-

&(& #"(

( $"

9"(((

( $- 9 " (#, " & $6 "-'-&

$"(

'('6, $ $6 9'& "(< '6 ("# $"

+ 9'& $- "&'#"# ( 6

G$, $

(" "

9"((( &( '('6 #"(

$" ( ( < $( "&& 9"(((

5 "#' :&# $"( !&#

!" # $$% &' ! () *+,-.*/ .0/ 1+1, $( +(-& ("

"( "

9"(((

6 -"&"6 -' $ 9"(( $" ( (

&"( && ("

$" "

&("#"

2$ , "&&

+" '

" C" '9 G$, E "" ($

9"(( &(

&"+"'"6 (6

4 =&

''( $( "&

" -""(

"( +9 ( ( 9"((( #& "

9$ 6 $& ' -6, "

9$ (&

(&, ( "

6 "& ( "

9$ 6 & (" 9''

#& &"( '

(", &"(

6 (

?9-, $(

"( -""( & #

G$( +&

6, & ((# "

(' &" 9 +(-" " -"( "&"-"&'(

G$ E !&# $! (&2

# ) 4!$

5 *+,6.,*/17-, +(-&

" &"( "( #"- & $("( -"&

("&&

" -"9 (9$"(( G$, (

"( -""( ( ( "

9"((( & #

& C("

< - $"

&"9$"((

$ # 9& '&

''( 9 E "& 6 " (, E "& *H $ *&

'<A & 1, ="

, '

&, '$"

9$ +#$ (

& &, ("# C(" #"(& :#"& *'

( *6 =', A , !"

.&, 39 '$"

? -& #"("

#& DE*

!" % 9$"' +"# E "& & ;;

, (& '" $(& $"

+ ("

6 " ('

("&", $, + I

$( " ( -6, < 96 #"(& 9

G$(, !" & "( $(& C(", $9-, ' , $"( ' ("

'& 6 " ('

("&", $, #"(& 9 < 96 &, &(

'("+'

-" "# ? '& -"& #& 2$ ,

" $"# ( ((((" -$"

' 9($" -$"

' '6 "''6

( (6, !" % &"-"# (& ( 9$( 0&!" (""# +("&( $"

(, $#$,

#& 96

( + (& ' G$

C(" -6 $"#$ ("& ((# -$"

' 0&!"

'& & (+' '("+' E'" & 9$

" ( (, (""# 0 $"(

'6 < '"

-$"

' ($ &"( 9$ " " & 6 ? $( ("

'6 '&& " '('6 '"

& $"(

" (+'"($& +$

+& -&, $6 <

( "( (((("

+& -"9 "( ;4

0 !&#

(, " +(-& 9$ ;4 +#(

""# ;4 <#( 6 $(< +# -&

((((" '' $"(

(&, ( $# C"6

'& '&

"( 9 ( , , !( '( '"

(

#"- "'

$'& 7

# &- '&

''( $

+' + ( -"("

'"& 9"$,

("# !&"

(&, &"# ( ("F -""&, "'"#

C"'

#", $"( +! 9"$ '

" G$#$, (6, 0 "-& ( " " + " $, " *, 9$ $& ( $"( ( 6 &'6

"#$ $- ('&

<"# (

0 !&# "#' :&# $"( 9

# $$%&' ! ()*+,:.,/ . 0/;<*, " +(-&

9$ C (

( "# ''

( +("( '

20 &&

6 $ '( ( 0''C #"( " &

# 9& '&

''( $ $(

&6( &'6 (&"# ' 2=

?9-, $"( +! &(

6 9"#$# G$ E !&# 0 # $$%&' ! ()*+,,

.!=%"%&!$/7-<, +(-&

&'6 (&"# ' "

$ '

DE " 9'& ("

'& ' & 9"$, 9$ -"& & "&"

&'6 9$''6 ""'

G$ &'6

&6( (&"# ' $'& '

0 $"(

'(, &"( ((& &"'

+-, $ #$ -"& && ' '( $& "

$ '

DE " "

&"" G$, ( &'6 (&"# ' &(

"& #& !&#

((& "'

C" &"'&, 9''

(&, &( (

"''#'"6 "" "6 0 +(& "('

-"&

"" '9 G$ "''#'"6 "" "6 $9"$,

"#$ $-

''& " $"( 9$"' E "("#

'' !"(&"

1"# -"9 C"6

+& -&, "& "'

$( C" '"

#"#

"($ ( "+& 3"$ "($

& '#''6

&(- & ( ,

("&"# (

" ( (

G$, #& !&#

& ( $'&

G$ '

& 9"$

" &"( "((&

&"#'6 G$ ''(A

&" (& + $" :&"

#"(, # 9"$" 9<

&6, "'"# '& :, 9'& "(( 9( ( ( $" ( (&

!"'

&# ""# ( 3 ((6 ""

" (

& " "

!"#$ %"& '

(

% *+ '

(