High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/721/2012allowed

Neeraj Rana @ Sonu v. State Of Punjab

2016-11-29Mr. Justice T.P.S. Mann,Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram26 pages

""## $ ! %! & "

(

)*% ""## $ ! %! & "

+ , + !&***

""##- ("# $ ! %! &

. ' + /!

)* ""## $ ! %! & "

12*/ #34

*""##

5 ' + 6 /##34

*""## ''

7% *34

*""##- ("# , + *#8#3#/3%! &

( ## * ""# *4 & 9 !" )*

*"!

#*" * ( !)(

. 3

" # !)( 7*& 4

*4&"

&:""##;

* ! !3(

)*% 3 &

)* !* /!

)* ! "4#:)

* !)( 4

. " &:* # 6!)3( (#& ) <2

3! + +'

*2 %#

;=2%>3% # ?

@ 4 3( 4 8***:""##8 *#)!#:

* "!*&#!

+ +'

*2%* *(88 * #&# 8 A + 32% 2("

(

## )8* 3- 2 !# ":( 3 * 4 *## ! ) )

!("

(

: * +'

32% )

!("

(

: # )8* ,3-2!# ":( 3* 4 *## ! ) )

! ("

(

" B( ** 7*

, +*&"

("# !&***

*( *

8 )"#"!*( *

;* !

* "!*&#! + 32%3 !"#8* : 7* *"

! "

*# # 3& 38* 3 2- CD1 )*3% # E E 4 3( # )8* 2 9*8 )*

# # 8 "

/ # :

)3 !#8 3( 8*"

##)38* !&** * ; ("#()

*(FB%8** 8!

#$ "

! % & '!"

( '

)*)+,,- ./,,! '

(

! $ $ 0/1,

(

"("

12 !

), '

$ '$

4 3 ! (5 "

(6 $ 7 7* ("#)*& 4( ()

3!"

8**3 2- CD1 )*(*

( FB%- !G *"

# *

!)*CH9*8

I!( 3 *& 8***8 ) 4<2 FB%- 7* 3 2- CD

( # )8* ("#

**"

!)*"# ")* <)

(*"

8 ) #*

!)**<) FB" " *"

8 # 9 #

8# #

(*"

8* **#" 8&8**8 4 " #D" 8 # 4

( * "

* ( 8 # 4 " #D&#

8# 4

(*"

3*" # 8**8# "

" 2G!"

) " *& : 8 !% (

( *& : 8# ) ! !(

#8**8 * 4 &:*

(

( 8 9 "

4 )*( " # D' 3 ("# !&*** )

*!""#( :( ***!9 8" 8* *(!

*8*# 98:( &#"* *8 I(#*19

931 # ''& ) 21

### *( &#8 4DB()21F2

+,+

, 38 !**( &#"* 8&) !&: *I!( 6!)#I*

,3#8:

H9 3 ( &: ) 21

,''+', 8* 8

* 4) * ' !

) 4) 3*# *** 4*( &#"* &#9 #

(** " /!

13*%

,3H& :1 9 7*( &#89 "

# D * ( :3 /!

1 8 # *4) 38* !

)4) # ** *"!

**( &#"* '

(#*4"

("#B *) -

!( -* 4)+"(** !#:*" )*( 7*( &#8&:* ("#*( 8**8 98:&:*!#"

*( * (( *##) ( <!

4) *8

#: !&:

*6)" )* *! %3*** 2- CD1 )*"

* %!

#3( !

)4) *3 !# I!( ("# 8* 8 ! ) ) 8**(!

*8 #6#3( 8

*4) 38*

) 8) * ) .. 7* !""#( : ( ("# !&*** 8

. &3 8 !** ! ! 3 & )*3/!

)*(

)*% ! !3 & )* ! /!

)* ! 8

&:*"

# *

. *&

( ! " *# !

()

4 78*#"

#! :

(**" & 9 #:) *

* #* !3*

!)*9* 8**8 " *(89 "

C# )

4 (#) # )8)*),)(& )("

=I >

(* #* ! ! /!

)* ! " * # !

( ) 4 ) # ) 8)*) , )( & ) ("

EI E

( * #* !7* (

:#& ) )

% ' - ,'.(97$ :

8**8!*( * (( *##) (8 # 4

(* : ** ! *!* (8# 9 "

4(( ! & )* !# ) 4 ) #

)& )("

=I > ,)(" *# !

( 7*!# ) 4 8(9

( *

#* !" *# !

!)*9* 8** 8"

" *(89 "

!)*"# *"

##* 4 8 " " #: !&** * ; ("# *!& 8 (":) * "

# " : 8* * 4 : & 4) #) )8C*(* *8I(#*38**8 98:&:* ## )8**( * (( ##) (

& 4/!

!*(" 8* * # *( ( &#"* 19 DI2;1 # '' &#9 #

!( - ' D *) * "

# 3 * & 4

" :8* 4 1#9*# 9;/!

4 )* D . ( H#3 * ("# !&** * 3)

*( **! !89 8 *(# :*88

9)** " * !&*** C##*& 4* ! 8*#*:8 "

#! :2*(*)

* & !"(3*8) ) ** ! 9 8)* 8##&) *!)* #8I(#*8* *! ) (

" J** **!

) * 3** ! * & 4 ! 3 & ! /!

)* !# )8* (

" 8 (

:# ! 8**(88:

(* # )8* * ("

8*8 * (&#*##* " *)* *

(()* (!&G!* *:

*!)* #8 D+. 3 $ I!( / #)

* (8**"

#* & !"(3**) ** ! ! !8* 8 !"

** !# )8** (#: & )* !3 /!

)* !% ! #*(E** 4) ( ** ! ) #(*8* 8#*:"

):(3) #(* ("

** "38* * 8# 4#&#** !8* ! 8 !)*) #

(7*:8 ) (( :** ! * *&

:7*:9*($ I!( / #

*( * (( * (&!** 8*&#:

*( *"#*B:3*8) ) C(&9

(

8 ( *D*:3*8*"* ) "* !

3* ! )*8(3*( 9 8*! * (" *(!

* 8 ("#; !&***

98:) #

(

&:* C * (&#*8 ("# !&** * *&(!

! *"#)-"

" 8**8(** ! ! E D

. 3 ("#; !&*** )

* !""#( :( ** ("#( !% (

)*% #1 )*3 / #(*3 7!

J# K 3 8 K ) !#8 3( C( * (

8* ( 9 )*3 % ( ) 3L(! ) 3C :!(

)*% 8

* ,, C) 4

:""( ! !* (( * (" * # !

( *# ) 4 " !)*9* *:""(8"

" * *(89 "

# # )8**! "C# ) 4

!##(

:#8**8!* (( *##) (

( ** !*(8# 9 "

# 4(( ( *88

< H 8 4D* ("# *4) 3*##)* !8"

* # 2##G1) 38* !

(( * ( * # 6!)3 (

# (9) ("# *"

3 * (#%

% <)"

("!*&#! + +'

* 2% ) ## * !3 *: 8 * )*

)#:4

3 8**3*:"# )!#:

#( # ) # *3"

! B(8:* 8 # "

4)*!!

& ) *( &

9 7*!

)* B( ! ++3 %3 * ()4&

!)* *

) # *8"! *(38***: <!

3! & !*

9*"#**88

9)** " < 3 !#8 3( C#

** !

(* * "& ! +"(**8"9!"&:*"

#8** 8 ! ** ! !/!

)* !

9*"#* . & ! "(3*8)** "7* ( '

# #8* G! & !*("9*(!"7*:

9*( 2 8* *8

##)##:

: !(

)*%

9*"#**8 ! : (#C89 ! :&:*"

#* &:( 4)""# * C"

# (89 J**8# #6#3( 3**( 9 8** 84 #4* 7*##*!

9*"# * # ("# * * )# !#

& **" ) ) *

!)**

8##3*# # *###*! )!#:

* "!*&#! + +'

*2% 8 *(# " * !)( 7*""##* !&)8** ("!) !)( 4

*4 (!"

* 4 *""#

( 3 8**8 )4 * "

# # 8# G! J*4* # !#

& **" # #:K*

!)*#:8** &# H !#

* ""## * )! * * ("!) !)( 4

)*#834

* !&# *: #82* ) * * * ""##* !8(*<2*")3

("#3 !&*** %J 4#4####) )*

#4#!)* !#I!(

)*8I(#* 9)8:*) #

( 8

&:* )*

9 C # *!&( *4 ("# !&*** *#8 " &

* )* #

9) : #)# ) * " 3 &! !&G!#:*)

(**

:G!* (( ##) (

"*""##* !*&:4) & 4 8* &: #4##) # ##) )*( 2*( "

! *""##* !8 (*<2FB%- 28 &# (!

I(#*8 !&*** "!#)*

( #!)* )* 7* "

! 8 #)!"

8 "

! !&*** ("#%J 3(H#%J+3$ I!(

%J, !

)*%J+ " "

:3 %J !&** * ("#8* " 8* **"

##)

* (( ##) (

(*"

# * ) 4*(FB%7*!

)4) * 3( #)**%J+(H#3** ("# !&*** **""##* !"

* !

) % & ! , "( 8 (

:#3 8* * 8 ) ) &9 * * ! ) *

!)* #8I(#**8 " !"

7*!

) 4) *( %J,$ I!( 8

** **) ** ! !

!8* ""##* !8 !"

8*#(9)"# ((* #

)** ! 8## / # (* ""##* ! #

G!*(

*(* (#4!

8*** !

*"#*B:*8 ) 7*# ( !

)4) *""##* !*( B !# ) )* 4 #4(* ((

##) (&

%J+ !

)* '. 38* !

(*(* ) &

# *( :

8#!*"

*%J(* * 8 * " )8*

B( ** !#!

* # 8** * # # 8 ! * #) * ""##* ! )!#: * * #)* *

44#&# *

("# !&*** 8*#"" )* %J (*( *(#" *(FB% (&:*(&

# 7**# "

. & !'"(*8)*

) *## C # &!3( C# 4

* " 8* 8 # :)* 3 ! 8* (!

* 8:) * (" (#:

!* *% *9##*&

: ) #

( "#

(** ! !&*** (()(!

*8*)4*( #:* ) # ) <!

*:8 ("#) ) ** ! % 6)* 7*# (*(**89 8)! * *8

9** "

& !( *& !8 ( *"

*8 (" ! 4*(** "7* *!

(8**

)4) * . 7* 4 : *) #

(8"

8) (&:*!*"

8**8

*((& *"

#" : 2*

B( 3**(** !# I!( ! ) )#("

( #6#3(

* (!

*8 C!

(***(#8# !* ( #C( 8#4: ) ! * 9** (

** * ( 7*8# *( *4* !#I!( * # ) (

87*8# *

B( ** )4("

**88(!

&:$*# $49 *&

*9) *"

#C# # " )*"

) )*)$*# $4938* 8 :* 8

# #7** # (*$9

3** *

* 4 8 #

*4) *&:*"

# C

# 8** #8$9

8 $9*# !

(" )*( ! ( 7**# (*$9#!

()*( *& #) ( ##28# !( *

B( ***#8 ""# )$9 7*8# *( ** !#I!( 8# &

!)*

( # "

! 8

)* ) )& 4C #3*(**C #8*4) )#*##

) (&#8 "#

*! ( 9 9##* -&#8 4&# * <

(*& 4( %J !&*** 3 *)&#**! !8# :9 8 *(" *"

3 *8

9* * "

& ! ( *& !8 ( *"

* !

7* # (& 4!*(** 8 #: ) *## C #3 (

! ( ## * * -&# "# * 8 4&# * * !(3 ""# : )

&&#* ""##* ! 8 !# *4 ( :

()# !

* (" ) )* (( ##) (*"

("# !&*** 8* ( " "

! ("# !&*** 8G! # 1

4 3*"

( :C #8**4&:* ) #"!&# G!#:3 &#" 8###98* ) * (# : ((8** (" 3*

* ("#** 7***3* ##) !

9"# *##) 4

! 8* * 8 (" 8 * &:

("# !&*** . 3 )" & ! * ( *

(* ##) !

(*& 4 !( %J 8# &#** #:*#4## ##) )* *&

3* 8 !#* #8$9*(#:((& 8* ) *(!

* 8 2* 4*# #8 " * )*"

9)#)# )*

" 8* ) *(!

*8H 3## !3* *)* 94 #4*""##* !* 2 # #8 * 8* 8 48 "

( *

! 4 3**488**4 &# *! & ## 8 %J+ ( H# #3 &! * * ("# !&** * %J C ( !*## & 4 8 * * * * * ""##* ! ) * !

( ) (

:# *4)8**8 !

) ** ! ) *!)* #8**! ) ( " ) ) *( #3*(*( *"

# . #( & !* ( *

(*8***##)#: *" "

( ) 7* B"#

*" *"

! 8*:* ((!(

& !*

( * # )*( # *"

#" ) *

7**

B( 3# (** )4*( !% *()4 *"

#F4 * # *( *! * ##) !" . !"* 7**# "

8* ) *##) ("# :( ! ** " * !&** * 8## *# :" *(3:

& 4 %J, $ I!( / #: 8 3* !""

! 4 * C 8# * #8

B(&:*%!&#%

2 *

B( (&:"

! 3*# 8

* # (*(

*(9:( *"

# 7**(**"" * 2##G1) (*(FB%D&

* 7**((* ! **(8

! *"

!&** * ("# 7**

B( (&: !#*** *!8*! :

* *E4;C4 8 ** !

*(*( ("# !&***

9*( % # 4 8* *8"

%38* 9*( (9(4 !&*** F4 !&***

* )*(9##

( (&#(3* !""

* !&*** F4* !&*** *( +-.#9*

)*4

%J+ !

)*&

8* (*!* ##)#: ! B !# # !""

! 4 ## C 8 # # * #

B(#)*&:%!&#%

3&! *)* ( *

B( !&*4 "

(:)#* **"##:*##* ! * ( *( '.

**:*(:B !# &

*( ) ) (() (!

I(#* 9)8:* ) #

( * (!

( 3( %J !&** * ** (H#%J+ ! & :8

(*#)#"

48 #:!"

*(%J,%J+3*

8 8 * "

! 3 !""

! 4 ## !##:3 * "

! 4 * 4 !##: &

*# ! : 9 & * ""##* ! 8* ) * 4 #4( * (( ##) (

8* () #44 "

! &

(*#)#"

48 "

%J/!

18 * * ' 3! ( ** " # *(

9 ( &# "* '' &#9 # FB%

- C*( &#"* &

# % # 4 3 ( 4 (( FB%I .

! *

B( 3 ( *

* ( &#"* FB%8 :# C! 9 :"

(*" 8* 4 ( *( ##*( &# "* 3&!* (: ) * ) D*(

3!8 & )*(3&!* !

!" C( &

*#"!

* ( &#"* 3&! * "

!* &

)4)

* *(

)*(C(8

&:"

# . )" & !* ( *

(* ##) !

* !( :"

) # ( &#"* FB%&:! /!

%J8 "

!* !

) # *F4 "

8* ) *: *!*** #* "* %J8"

!* *& 4 #4( 8***!4 !#

"* #*( :8* &:* ) 4 : 7* " "

! 3 %J * I!(

9( &#"* (9 ''

(/!

41%J *( * 6! : C !)*( &#"* &:"!) ( # (":& )

,''+',7*(* (**"!

**( &#"* 8* !: "2*

B( 3*"##:** & ):

) )"!

* ( &#"* *

#( * 8): !( :"

8* ) "!

9( &#"* 8

*#)#

%J +2"

1 )*8"

CD3% 4 3( * *##) !

(FB% ("# !&*** !"

8***(

(FB%- *& 8**

(#<2FB%- 8

) 7**"

# )8** ((& *"

#" :#!) ("# !&*** C

" "

!)*"#FB%J +- <!

3*# !G!"

) " & : I(#*4G! "

FB%J +- 7**) !"

(

( *& : 4*""# FB%A<

(*"

3*#&#

8* 8&3 " #:E&#

" 8**8 4 #" #FB%3FB%FB% "4#:

9*( "

4(( FB%H3FB%1 FB% *(G! 7**# 4 *# * *"

(

( #" #FB%

9* (*"

4(( FB%J +-7* ' 3*

!""#( : ( !&** * ("#

) )9)8:

9( &#"* '' *8&:* ## )8**(7*!

)4) *3 ( &#"* 8 4

(%J *I!( 8* *"!

* *"*

(%J/!

17*( &#"* 8# 9 "

& * *I!( /!

18 *4) * 7** 8# "

4 "

:< H%! &3

*) *FB%MM3&3*"* ) "*FB% FB%' *"

8## & : %J. 2 9*8 )*

*4) * * "

# " : %J + 2"

1 )* *

*& 4( %J + %J 3%* ) "* 3

9"FB% FB%' *"

* CD% 4 3( 8*)#( * 4 *( *"

#4(( FB%$ 2"

!9*8 )*%J8* 8"

CD3% 4 3( # !" 4) * "

%3( !

)4) 3*

!""#( : ( ("# !&** * . 8***( 3/!

!3 &

6* (

% *!#"

*D. 3 *

(FB%N %J+ !

)* 7* . 3*

! 3/!

! &

6* * 4 *

(( FB%L3 FB%L- FB%L- "4#:<!

3*#

)*("

# !

(FB%M 3FB%MFFB%M<! &:*(

"4#:!

) 7*"!

! *# !

(3!

) 4 : 1D ) #) )& )# EI E

(** ! !)*9* *: FB% 8"

" **: ) #) )8 9 "

4(( FB%FB% "4#: !)*"#FB%M/ "# * 4 :8"

" 7* 3!/!

)* !) 4 ) #) )

(*# "# #(& )# ?I @*(8# 9 "

# 4 (( FB%F 3 * # ) 4 (

:#(97$ % ' ,'.

(* #* ! 8**8# 9 "

4(( FB%<FB%MC 8

!)*"# *"# * 4 : 7*8# "

& !* 4 : ) #) )) &:! & 6*

(* #* !" *# !

(3 8**89 "

4(( FB%/<!

3*! # ) 4

FB1D 3

!)*9* 8** 8 " *(89 "

4(( FB%6 !)*"#"

" *"

* 4 :8FB%M6 7* . 3*8

*( (H#%J+<!

*# )

( $ I!(

%J,! .3 %C#

% *<!

3*# K " 4 !<2FB%MH FB%M ) ) * ! ("# 4) 3"

**## %J 2$ I!( *"

#" : %J2"

!9*8 )*!

)4) * !*(" #:

" #

* **(#( *( #* %J& 4!

C I8# )* "

! * ## # ( &#"*

. ..

* " 8** 8 &

( # (": "

4 * ( FB%J

-3 FB%J

- FB%J

- "4#: 7**# "

4*### 8

( &# "* !(& '.

''.

'''

'+ FB%J

-<FB%J

-/ "4#: !*### & 9

* * * (" !*

: G! ! , *2F4

*)! *###8"" * (

:("# : # (":$ (":38* *"

" *

*###38B(*

*"!

& 4( <!

%J I "# )* !"

(

( *& : I(#* *"

( 1# ##)3( !B * " # *"

(

( "

FB%7##* 8 (

( !

" * " 3! **8*(

*) * 938**8! !**

: !

%J*(3 (3"

" #"#FB%%

*"# !

4)*( ,+ %J' 269 3%JCC # )*3%J 2

# )*%J 2/!

8 )*8

(#8 **: * !#:8

4FB%O3FB%3

FB% FB%

" * "4( %J, C 4 )*3 # 9 7D D3 (

**"

(

:#& ) )

% ,,,(9 !##8 ) *( % )* (

)* ( %J' )*3# 9 ) )!*

:!( 13 #"

) ) ) (

:# & )

% ' ,'.38**"

38 ) * ( I"#I!( - (*I!( 3 %*9 %J. * $**36!#1) 2#36#*

8 "

*( ":( , C

*( $ I!( ! . * %

4*(FB%D C (# **$ I!( !

) # *"" %J, !""

* "

:"!

2*#)* & 4!( %J,$ I!( %J+ !

)*3 #!*4##9 ** !(#4* () 4 : () #" # !

( *! *# &! * #*!)!#:*C 3 # **##) 4 () #8 *"

%J !&*** ("#38** 8((& "

#" : %J2"

!9*8 )*

(*# #: *"# ##) 4 8

*4) *(7** "

4 :8 ("# : :"( 2*#)* & 4! 3*#*"

! * ( &#: # "

4 4 ) * ""## ; * !2("!) !)( 4

!&#*: #8 #&# & !!" #$!% & 4( 3*""#"

("# !&***

( :)*

8 *"#: *"

4 "

* ! ! *( )!(3*# !#

*""##*# !:9 ( # *

:** "

* ! #&# &8 *"#: # ("

(* 2*#)* & 4! 3*

( (# ""# & ) !(&

3 ''

' +# &*# 4

!3(

)*% 3 & )* !* /!

)* ! ) * 4 "38* (#""#& )!(& , + #&: ("# !&*** ( !##:3*("!) !)( 4

""##;* ! G! ** ) ()*(&:) )*(*& !& 7* ""## 43 (#: !3

(

)*% 3 & )* !* /!

)* !& #

(*! :

*8*!#8 ( 2( & *G!

* ("# & '

#(!!#$!) *+,-.-/00

J** "

&#P

-L

J** -"9)P

-L