High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/917/2011allowed

Baljinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-01-22Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu60 pages

!"#

$ %& !' () )!"#

"#$#%&#$#'( )

"#$#%'+#$#'( *

' , - (.(%'( / )

" 0,1&'((%1 * / *

2 0 $ / %.2 3

40$ 5 6 /7 , *

' / / ' /- / *

- - * /

2 0$

+ , %(.'((% 8 6 - * * / * / # 9 - * - : 6 - * 6 * 9 - ;

#+#$#&((( * - - - < /

< * < / * * < = /

8 6 - -

/ - / > * - >

? < >* - ) - * * < & / 6 *

,* - '2( - - * / 6 * +@ 6 - 6

+ * * - A A - * * >" *

, / * 6 = * * B8 *

, / * 6 < -

- - * "

! "

'( ') *'!!

. :# >" C- * > / DEF - 6 / '@(.'((% , / * - /

% :#' >"

6 / DE > / * * - / 8 < >< (2 , / * - @ -

@ ;

/ - , / * E / '(.'((% * ) 6 < '@(.'((% - * " - DE- > - -

- * - - %(.'((% '@(.'((% > - >"

C-

'@(.'((% ( :#+ >" *

%(.'((% 9 - * - * * 8 < * 6 * - @(( ;

0#+!#&((( "

/ - - - < /

, * < 6/ / * , / * - ,

, 8 6 - 6 - / ; > >

- ?

8 < 8 <

- DE 8 * /

- - 6 /

/ - 9 - , 8 <

- "/ - / , / ; * - , * * - ; 8 - - / -

, 8 < - / 6 * ,* -

'2( - * * / 6 * - - +@ 6 * * - , - * 8 < @ - & 6 / 6 * - A A , * - , / - * 6

/ - - DE" , * - &

@ - * - & & , ; * 6 <

8 < / * - ; >< 8 # E- / ; - '(1'2 > ; - * - */ , * - ; * ;

, / - E ((( , 8 < 6 - * / , * * * * > *

# E- > - '(1'2 * 6 / - - -6 - 9 - * / - / 8 < > 6* - *

- ?

:#@ ,

- * ' :#2 >"

'(.'((% * "/ < / >"

- / / 6 * ++&2( 6 * * - A) A & - '2( - / 6 * - A) A * & - '2( - / 6 * - 1 * - > * / ) 6 ") < - /

/ ) 6

+ :#G 8 6 - - * - %(.'((% * * / 9 - - >

- :#+ >" *

- * * >

- ? * / - > ; >

> / -

>< >< / - ) 6 ") DE:G1$ '((.'((% > / * >"

6 9 -

- * - > * - G+( : 9 - 6* " - - -

/ - - / - * - , / 6 * / * ;

& 0 / 6 * + 1 +H 6- = * ' '( -

@ :#& 8 8 6 - - / * - > E - A A > - / * >"

6 "/ < E / / - ) 6 ") DE:G1D > : 9 - * -/ / > - -

/ 9 - 9 - - * - * - -- /

2 ; * / , / * -

- , 9 - * * * >* * E- * 8 6 - - - - DE , - -

DED DEB * , , D / ? 9 - >" * - - - , * :#+ >"

* * :#+ *

G 9 - /

/ * - - * / -/ * 2( 0$ , - *

* 8 * - 2( 0$ * - / , -

- E- -- / 8 - :#' >"

6 - - * - - %(.'((% '@(.'((% , B DEF 8 - * 8 6 - > , "

!!" #$ %& '(()*+, *% -, ./'0 1%12

!!" #$ 31 4 '((5*', *% -, ..'

% !!" #$ %& '(66*6, *% -, 7'. - * * * 8 * - /

/ /

& , 9

#- "

#- " ./

" # $

" #

% % !& ' #

( !

)

) *

" + #+ +

, % ) #

- . !

" #

* % / !

# ##

0 0 " ) 1# % % 2 # #

- . !

+"+ + ++ +++ +++ 3 /

# !) 4 ( ( * !)

$ ( *

# 5

% #

- . !

)

( !

6 !

( # % 3

) #

! # + +#+++# 7+ !(

#- "

#$$

% & $ ' ( % ))

$' % #- " ./ + " # 80 9: # !2 3

# 3

3 !29, # 3 " # 80 9, !29, # ( 1 3

3 $ 3 !29

!29

; !29

; 3 ) # 6

<9 , 6

<9 & # <

!29

!29 &

" !29 1 1

- .

" 1

# # % # !29 3

' 80 9: 3

# 9, # # !29, " # !29, 3

3 !29, 1

!29 !29

!29

; !29 % # $ & !2 !29,

# !29

!29, / # !29 #

% ! 3 # = & #

- .

# !29 #

!29 , 3 # !29 !29,

- . * +>)

+ " #

2 #

(# # ++ +

+ !)

#- "

*+ ' ( ,

5 4

% #- " ./

% # # # # / ?3+; + 000++++++++000++++++++000

@ + ' / ?3 ;A # * 7 / ?3 ;A

# * 7 ?3 ; # * 7 #

" 0 / ?3 ;A ' #

@ #

" % # # / ++?3+; 0

'( 9 - /

* - > - >A

- " #

- !!" #$ 31 4 '(65 18%""

#1%! +5/+ , 9 >A - "

# " " *

# !

+++++++++1+ # % # # ) #

) #

# % # 1 ) #

2 %#

+# + , % # ) ) # # # # # % # # % # %

# 1

# + +

++++ % # 0 B $ * # # "

* %

# #

G #

% # # # B " 0

1 # +#+++ 7+ ' 8 !!" #$ !!% 3%9"

: ! ; #%" # 6<7. 18%"" #1%! ''6 9 >A - " E - * * 6 $ / -6 - / 3 2 "

%@&7 * / - 6

= - - - - >*

= *

- -

/ -

* /

/ -

- E

/ , 9 >A - "

# :

C 2 # # * * ! # )

! # # 1 / # # 0 A 1 # " # # D %+ + + + + + #+ + + + + + + + #++

+ :E++ +*++*+!A + + + + + + + + #+ + + + + + + + + + +

+ 1+ + + + + #+ + ++ #++ +#++ "+ + + + + + + )+ +++ +++ +++ + +% + + + + + + + + ++ + ++#++

+++ #++++ ++ + +++ +++#++

+ + #+ + + + + + + + + + + + #+ + +$+ + ++#+ + +++++ + ++ ++ + + + + #+ + #+ + ++ +++++++ + + + #C+ + + + + 0+ + + + 3+ + #+ + + + + + # + % + + + + #+ + + + + + ++++ +#+#++#+ + + + + + #+ + + #+ #+ + + + + #+ + + *+ + *+ ! + 2 + + + + + + + )++ +++++ ++ ++++ +# + % # ) 6 B %

# # % # #

) % #

++ +#++ + 7+ '' 8

" !!" #$ !

*6<)7, 6 18%"" #1%! " 6/* 9 >A - " / - > " -

% * - , 9 >A

- "

+ * * ( * #

$ 0 # # * ( * ) * 2 % 1 # * ( * ( * 6 # 6 % ( * 6 #

( #D % ( * 6 ! # # #

# # ( * # 6

++ ++ 7+

'( '+ 8 "

!!" #$ %& *6<<7, 66 18%""

#1%! " )(< 9 >A - " / / * -

* - , 9 >A

- "

! " "

$ #

# %

& #

# !

'(' "

" !

)

'@ , 9 >A - "

- "% 9 #!

"% !!" #$ 31 4 *'((., + 18%"" #1%!

" 7/. * -/ 8 " - * =

' / I * - / / , 9 >A - "

+ % # # *

# # $ 1 A # ++ +#+++# '2 8 !!" %"8%" "

!"9 4& 8"=!#% #$ 3#-=" - =" > !?

#%%18!# %1= %8-- &81- *'((., . 18%"" #1%! " ''+ 9 >A - " / - * B8

/ * 8 /

6 8< , 9 >A

- "

# @. 2 # ( *

# * ! * -% ! >. #

'%6 # # 1 # 3 " # # 3 # # # , E *

# *

, F E 6 B * G !

$ +H +B

I , * # 3

F 3 # 3

# # A #

# % # #+ ++++ I AAA AAA AAA

( * 1 # JJ '%6 ) # 0 )# 2

# '%6 # % # #

'+ 1 ( * # # '%6 # % #

'%6

# # # # # % ( * 1 # 0 # + AAA AAA AAA :

+ > # ! -. ++ +*++ +) 7 'G 8 "" !

!!" !

%#1

8"=!#% #$ 3#-=" *'((., / 18%"" #1%! " '+( 9 >A

- " * / - - * * - * ,

9 >A

- "

!29@ % '%6 !2@ !29@ # # # 6 / #

( * # # #

* ( * # '%6 F * !

* # #

* #

> B#+ +++#+ +C I2 # '%6 # % # #

1 1

++ I :

% !29@ # 3

'2 # ) !29@ # # 9 ( 2 ++# 8 * :#G 6 - *

'& 8 %98

!!" #$ 31 4 +'((5, 5 18%"" #1%!

" //) - * - >A - " 8 ) * - - , 9 >A - " '((.*/, 18%"" #1%! " ''+

" % B

# # * # >

B+ +++ ++C+ F

# '%6 # % # #

'G 1

( * # # '%6 # +++++ * * # # 1

B # 3 %# ;

+ ++++++ + 7+ '. 8

2% 88 9% #!

"% !!" #$ ;% !2 *'((<, B 18%"" #1%! " 7<( 9 >A - " / -

/ -

* - -6 , 9 >A

- "

# @ + #

* $ #

6) - KEF - .

** @.

/ #

( - KKF - .

** K+++,.+ #+++++ +++ + / #

'& # # #

# 3 '% 8 #9 ;1% !!" #$ 31 4 *'(6/, + 18%"" #1%!

" ''( 9 >A - "

!2@

# #

'%6 # 1 # # % 0 $ >

6) 6 ( * # ' % 6 ( # % +*++ C+

* ( * # $ 0 # # ( * ) * 2 % 1 # ( * ( * 6

# % ( * 6 #

( #D % ( * 6 ! # # #

# # ( * #

+7 +

+ % / >

( * !29 !29: $ *

F- . # "# -!#. " K@

% 0 * # &+ +!+ + +*+ C ,

2 # !2 : * ( *

'% # % ( # # $

# 0 F *!*

+#7 +

% # > B * 1 ( * ) 1 < '%6 3 # #

0 # 9# #

9 ,

% !

:- .

:- .-. "

* G !

$ +H +B + ++ +++ C @

, * # 3

F # 3

+( # # #

# % # #+ ++++

@ + " * +++ C+ F

( * 1 # 7 '%6 ) # 0 )#

2 # '%6 # % # #

1 1

( * # # '%6 # % #

+ #

'%6

# # # # # % ( * 1 # 0 #++ 7+ $ * $ +H ++/ + +-.

K " )

B# >

% @-.

-.-.

" K@

; # !2@ '%6

# # #

* ++B+-.+++ C+ :

% !2 @ # 3 # )

!2 @ #

# 9 ( 2 + +++# 7+ :

+ % !29@ # % # % #

B# 1 # / B +++ + +( 8 :#G 6 - * - - > - * >< , 6 /

:#G 6 - " , / / 6 * / * E-

++ "

" -

- * - , E

? *

/1 / , * -

, / *

- / -

+ :

* - * - , - / # E- 8< * # E- / ,

++ +' , 9 >A - " C % 441-- "2 9 #!

"% !!" #$ 1%! 9 #!

"% *'((., .

18%"" #1%! " 6/5 * - / - 8 / * - 8

- - - -

8 " / , - * * * --/ --/ - / - / 9 >A - " *

+ "

" * G2 D .&' E E- >*

- - */ / -

, - -

/ * " / = - , " / / -

- , 9 >A - " - - +% "

" E / " / +.G +% -/ * , 6 -/

+@ * -/

+% -* - * /

/ -A - * / , 9 >A - "

# :

6 )

# # 0 * )

# # 0 " ## ) 0 #

# ## + :

* #

# %

+2 * # # #9 ) 9 # J) J ) # * % * # ) ! B # # # ) #

* ) #0 # # 0 ) +) + :F

# 3 * %

# 0 # # # ) #3

# 1 ++++)+ + +%+++

J # # 8 ) # ' # B ) ' ) % # #

+++ + ,

5# #

# #

* # * #

# ; ! ) # %# % # # + ,:

* #

0 #

: * F 8# "

+& # ! ; * # #

# ) #

8# # )#

* # 1

* #

) *

* F 8# " : *

-. # * 0 -. * 0

# ) *

# * # # 1 % / 5 # G % * #

: # J *J J J J 1 J J J J J 0

* (# # # 1 # 0 ) 1 0 ) # *

* # ) 9 JJ # ;)

* # # # )

0 # 0 * : # )

% ) # +)++++ + +

% #

# # * * 1 % * # # # * 0 % 0

+% 0 # 0 0 * # )

G # * # # )

: * 0 90 9 0

# * 0 < # # # ) 6 * # # # ) +

:K * # * #

:@F # 0 # *

:K 0 * #

@( # :@F :K

# # ' * #

* # A * # #

:K 0 0 # )

) :K # J * # * 0 :K

# :K ) * # # ) ++++ +:K

:K # # # % *

@ ) #

* " 9 ) 1

)

# 1 * +++)+

* "

* * ,-

* "

. .

000+

# /

H /

( * :K * A ( * #

:K 0 % ( * ! :F ) :@ - .

* :@F

* # # ( *

:@F *

:K 0

:@F " # 6 J ++ +( +*+++++ :K *

# * # # # % # * #

1 # # % #

# 0 # # # )

0 %

@+ * # # * % # # # ( * # * ( * # *J # % # # 1# +++++ + ++ 8 2 ;1% ##%2":- !!" #$ !!%2 9 #!

"% *'(66, ' 18%"" #1%! " 6)5 9 >A

- " E * / )

G2 D

B ( 0 #

: * F 8# " # * # # (# B 0 F 8# " + 7+ +@ 8 3!"- "

= #94 9 #!

"% !!" #$ 1%! *'(6., 6. 18%"" #1%! " 7/) 9 >A

- " / ) / - /

@@ " / , 9 >A

- "

+ " # $ ( *

0 # ) #

% # " # ( * ) $ # # # 6 %

! E 0 B 0 +)

000+ @

% # # ( *

* " 9

+2 0 * - / , , G('(% 4$ # A / - 5 4, 6 * -# / $!5 * - $ / '(& ! -

E # - , -

, " $ E/ ?- , / / , ( * - 2 6 / , / * 6 - 8 =

/ B $

,6 B

'2 2&% *

'( - 2&+.G 6 > * -

, 3/ - * ' @+(

0$ '( - G+ ((( * < < , - 3<<,7 E- / + 6

- # 1 /

+G , / , 6 / - - , - " " > 8 /

@G 6 ,

6 - , 6 6 / 9 '((' - - / +& , - / 9 '((' 3

J J 7 - / / - - / - * +.

/ - + , '3/7

37 / 6

- I

+ * / / - 6* / 6* / / / / / *

- - = - / / - /# -

@ 2 - / - /# , $ / * 6 $ /

@& $ ? / $

* - / / - - 6 /

* / - * -/ /

-/ /

/ / E .( / -

- -/ , - /

. & ? ,

. ,

'( @(

' 0 $ /

%.2

/ *

- - / - - /

- /

, $

$ D - 1 1 )1$ /

* 37 2 G & % '( ' ''

'@ '2# '&# '% 0 $ / %.2 * - - / / - / ,

/ 3>- 7 ! -

8 <

37 '&# 0 $ / %.2 *

/ / /

/ /

- /

-- / @ >K $ > " :"9 0 '@( '(& !!" #"% "

! #$ #$ "- #!

"% * ,

@. 33 D .6 "!!

18 %=#!= E19 "= 9 !%=!C

* !

# 1 # % ; # "*! ;

# G -

%<"

%. -( * <* .

; 9 /(" 1

1 +++ ++C+ 9"

!$=!# #$ #! 8#! #$ 9%1 -"C 8

1 $ < #

@% + 4 9"

!$=!# #$ 8#!"

!- 188-"% " 1 ++++++ + .' =!# 1F '< #$ 3 =! ! 4"!!#% > =# 8%!#% " < K !

" +++ ++++ + .+ 9"

!$=!# #$ 8"% # :!

8%"#1 =# =!#

#% 8"

= " $#% !2

14 ! !" :"-- 8%""

!" =!# 8 ! < # # ## !

" # !

" 1 # 1 # E ## + + ..

="9 =!# 9"% "=!# )) =! EE B# B " )# "

./ "

1-% ! !# 1- "%4-" = ##- 9"

!$"9 4& "

=& !# 9"

!$& !

" 8"99-"% !)

" 8 ?* # # # 5 # L "

.7 "-8 $%# %1 "8!F 4& "!!

#9- $$="% 88# !"9 !

9 !%=!

-""- G !

( '

2( - ( . 5 % 1 4 * !

" ## !

++++++++ + .) %

" # $#% 8#-=" #$$="% $#% =8=!& 41-9

8%#

" ! !#

2-- 6 1 # # # # !

+"++ +

++++ #++

* !< $ ++ + + , @ * !<* ;

##++++#+ + / / 99 EE B# B -* ! * . "

! # @ B# B $ M %%%

E $

0 0 17 #3 < / / 0 =0 1& EE BB " ) 19 # 1<

# 0 # " #

2 / / H # )

EE BB "

<0 1 ) # 0 1< # 0 17 EE + +BB+" + / / B# B $ %%%

E ?# * @ B

E 9 # - . < #3 < #< 7

?# *

* < < # < @ <

, >K $ > " ) ) #888 '((+'(& * * / E 4E = 5 *

? 1 ,

4E = 5 * - && ) ) , >K $ > " $

0 / 0 $ / / - - - # -/ --/

* ? ? -#/ / 8 >818$ / * - - / 0 / , / 8 / 9 /

6 6 / - " / , 2' =

/ - =/ - / - - - * = - ( 6 - -

= -

, -

/ = ?

2+ = *

6 6 *

- /

'( ') *'!!

9 9

@G >* * - * * - / - / / >A $ > " :"9 0'@( '(& !!"#"% "

!#$ #$"- 9 #!

"% # , ! - * -6 * # / , $ / "-- 0 < -6 ? * # - , ! - -6

* - -

, ! - 6 8 < - <- 0$ /

2@ * 0$ ,

- - 8< +

! - $

6 / 9

'((' - B8 0$ <- / /

/ / / * -

- / - - /

- /

- - ! - " * E - - / , -

, ! - / " , "

# G

- / #- 0 <

/ B / - # 8 / /-- / -- , * ? #

- &

, ! - # - - . G 6 , 6 * $ 6

6 * - .

, $ 8 *

- - / * 6 "--

!? < - B

$ - %

, "-- / -

<- 0$ %.2 = /

(

, DE !? -

0$ -

2( * * / >A - " 8 / " - - -

, < - / / -

0 /1 = / - 8 / = 1 -

1 - , - * / * / DE $ - , "--

/ - * '@ 6 / / - '

, $ !

6 +

, $ 0 " /

-- / 6 *

6 #

2& 7 D 0 " / *

- *

- -- / 6 / 1 *

6 7 / 0 " * * 6 - 7 , 0 " 6

'% 0$

7 D 1

* * / 0$

- 0$ = * 6 = - * 6 - 7 , $

D ! -

! - / - / - 9 6 L , - / - / -- 6 - 7 , 0 " 6 - * - *

* 7 ,

/ - * 6 *

7 , - , $

D $

D , - 6 @

, ! - * / , ? = , * 2

, ! - - # = *

, ! -

D - / -

6 # - / / / (M (M'

, /

! - ! -

2% / C "

, - , ? 6

- -- / %

! - ! -

! -

- /

/ " " # - -

- - '(

, ! - ?

, = * 6 6 / E *

- /

# ''

/ # '+

/ E- / $

/ /-- / :

G( 6 - -

6 - - '@ , -

, /

& 0$

+ ,-./ +

- / %"0% 1

#+H :

N 10 :

N 10