High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/744/2007dismissed

Surjit Singh Alias Bittu v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-20Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

!"#$

%%&& ' (#)!*

% )

#&'+, #%%&&

- #&&+-+)!*

....

%%&& !"#$'0 *1& 2"+ %& +3 456 ///

7 /8 6 ")1# %*+ 87 # 9 + " 0#)& +3 (# &#,,!":

+#0,# # 0###0 *3 : %#, 1+#0 " " :% : 1 %1 /+

; & # " # " :% : % 1

5#&&+##% #//

7+ 52" %"#+< )& +3 # #5,"" ;5 &"0#5#, %&

"## %&&0#& ,&&"&(:%( = *" ,*1*&*"###&%&6>( % -!! 4 ?% +3 +0# - !"#:# &3"0##5 @*

% :

+#: :#3 " * " 6 ) BA C7: 3'%@#5 "&&#:%0### *: , # 0 #&#@#0%% #*"D + #&#:# % & @#5 :# ##%#*%: *+ #0 #### ##&"& "#* #% "? " @#%"# # % "? @::E= )# " 0% % + 0##0#:*: 3*1#*1#0

(##5 0 &:"# - :"#+ )0# D ##%&"0#%#" %# @ ::)- :"#&"0#*&3#%&>: +

&)#" %# ,#%@#5 %% )- : "#*##@# )- :"#& #1##",# # # *1)- :"#@::# " 0% % + #:*: 3*1#*1#0

(# + )- : "#+ #5

# ## :#%&1#*"+0##

0#"" :##3# +%:0 , @/

" :#%:0% :%&%:&&%& *=+0##0, % &@*"0"## %: : 3"

" :@ 0 0 %% # : %&1#*"%&%&*=+0##0, % &@*##% &0 #&*1#5 0##&#,"

% 929 *1 # ) - : "# 0# # & #," %9-9@:%&&#E= )A0% % #5 # , #& 5#, )&"#+0# #) - :"# #&0##:&@##% % 10 3%&%*1#5 ,::E= )*1# 0@# &"0#0&3% , , 1::E= )8 (#0 #% & F#& "#:+#% & #0+0## & , 1 1

,"& :#0&&#+0##0 3%, , 1 :: E= )7@ " 0 & # # ::E= )/ 0% % # "

(# 5 D E= ) # %& # "# *&# "##*0## :&45E= )/ 0 *15 !"#)& +3 (#5

&% % # "#%&#%& , 1 E= )// :0

#%&+5 3%#% % 1 B><6 #% , #=1+#% #

&"0##% % 1# 5&&D" :," %%& E= )/A 0## 5&&D " % E= )/ B 5&&D" * 3"%#&# *&3% &% / " :%: % ,:%& , % % &@ # # *&3 % & % ,:%&% &0 &*1#5&&D" 0## &#,":% 9<9

#%&+5 3%#% % 1 B><6 #0% , <&& % E= )C)<&D "# ,"+#:%& % &0##:&E=: +)!*+#" # % % E= )/7 ,# :+#:%&0* #%:

:%&,"# :&+ #&&"#0% % &#

% ##&&+%# 0 %%& # +," )

(#* ,"#% :# " /8#0&"#+#0 # "# "&1+0##+#%&"&1&: &

"# ,+#% =: #&&0"0

)F/<# "#+0#0%<)& + 3 + :& 0+ , # ,E= )/

+###/

70##

0%#+52" %"#+< #%&# %0##:*&3% &%:&0##&#," :% 929 9-9 &" 0# %: & :% #+ 3# & % "#% % 1# # <-&&+25+3 /

7###, :%&% &"/ " :%:&0##&#,"

:% 9299-9&"0#%:&:% # 3B"##0# %# &# #:&E=: +)!*+#" # ""3 : # )+ 3 # B "# # "&1 #, # %#:# "#% #% % 1#1# #:% 0##: #&&01&

)F )- :"#+0# # # ##* &" , 1 * & # D ,+ %" 0##% 1

)FA52" %"#+0##%% ## , 1 :#:% #)- :"# %# " *## ,"*1#:+ % ,", :

)F < 3#%& >: + )#" %# + )& B+ 3 %#//

7+0#&%#+ % :" :52" %"## "#<)&B+##" #%&"0#)- :"#% % ,:,#

% " <###, ,:,5 2" %"##%

)F7B"##+# #:%&% &# #:&E=: +)!*+#" # , #,E= )/C%0# " 1# :%&% &&&%##:&E=: +)!*+ #" #

)FC 5 0 %& "#+ 0 , 1 %% #% 1: &%

B )*&) #",%)F- !"# #,"*0, *1#

& % ,+ : # 0 A/A ) + 0## && # :" : %% " # % , "#:0 %#*##&&" "##0#*&&1,&,#

"#,+#=:F/ #:"#+0##/

7*//;/ + ! "#&"0# # % :#: * #*+3 ,"#B6-@#::%& &: # :#%&B6- - 0 ###* # ##1%#:* #,"&30# "#0+#D :

#%&*#: #%&&#:# D 1+#

0&* & (#%&#30##:# % #"0 , :#%

# " ":+& & , #:*,+0##&#:"" , ##&#% %%&+0##03%/C

+0# 0: "& # " , 10 :1 %%& A8 ) #,"* & *1 # %%&&; % # :% : "#%1%%&+#:0&&0

:"%%&&;0% "#%1#%%&#0 * & *& #" D*#2+3

60#%%&#:% &# "

5#,# & & #%%&&G+ & -+ #)!**""# "##

< &&#0 , 1:&1)F )- : "#+)FA52" %"#)FC50 %&"##, &&1%% #% 10# " #,"* % * (#10 =: &"#*#&#*#13# "& *# 1: &% 6% ,:1*0#:

#G,#*&&" % ,% :%*10## #1:"##,,&,##0 "&1% "#:&&1 #, (#",*1# )F : * 0 #1 & (#"# #1 &

0 * : &1 # + # % * % B "&2"#

!"#$ "

%& '#()

# * # * ,#0# , 1%% *1#&0&1+ #% " # :##&1 & ## :#&*=:0#= 0## #1% 0 #1 & 5# &&1% "#%# 0+ 5 1 * # :+ # #1 ,*% &% #% 1 *& "# :#:)F<3#%&>: +0##% % # , :, # % " # % (# :, , 1 :% % : " &" 01 % ," # , 1 *#* :#&:*1 #%

(#&3,##*% ,*1)FA5 2" %"#+)F/<# "#0#0#:#% % 1# *%*1#5 % "#:* #5&&D " )F7B"#"#+ #:%&# #:& E=: + )!*+ #" # && #: % 0# " 1#:%&% &# &&" # : # % (# % : # #:&E=: +)!*+#" #E= )/7"#0## :%& % & 0 , # &* 1&" 0# 3

7&#:%&% &&&0##%:& :% 9299-9&1#:%&0 *#%:

B & #%%&&##0, & 0# # :%" !": " # # :1 &%#& :# "," *#:* # #&#% 1*# & ,&1 " # 0 "&1,#%%&&

(#% *1& & #%%&& # "

!"!# $ !# !%"!

&&'( )"!*"!%+& $( & !

(

+, (-.#/

#.&$ ( $(+&

'"+!&+(-%.& !+ 1.2"!

# .& . $(+&

'"+! %"!

&& %" ( &'3 "!

./& !

+0"!# $ !# ! +((+/+(."+! , (&"+!*", !/-

+00"

".3%"!

&& &/

+2 &#+'/0'3.!#&+'3#!+/ ( 3"

# '$+! 5##& & #%%&& *,1: - !"#0",%*1#% # #0#,"*0, *1# & 1&+#&0 , 1# ,&,##0 "&1%"#: &&1 #, (# %#** 0 #1 & "&## !":,# ,$*# !"#$ "

%& -$./)

# * # * , # : # & 0 1 # :

, 1,&#1# 0# : * :%&1# &" ,## $0

!"#$ "

%& -$./

# * 0#%0 #*! "# # , 1 *@## %% 0 #"##" 0 % *&3 %% 0# # # , #%& 3+#* ,##0% #&"#**&,#: " , %% #," 0 : &&*"*10 *&3%% (#:1#00#&* &*& 0 5 # , 1 !

":+ *&1 &;%& 00 0* ,#0## &&"1:1"#%&&&&1:%& #%%&&# 0 #:%"# %%&&+# & # "#&1&#=: % 0 # , 1 *" 0 , *1 # 1*#% E,# 0+ #%&0 % 0##% 0 4 # : +% * &% D : &0 5 0# % , 1 # % * :*# +# #% !

& .3.0 ('& %.&!+.!# #+, (+"!# $ !# ! %"!

&&/'+.%"!# ($.3"!*

(# % ,&0# #5 # , #&#%0 (# +#5 # " + ", 1 * # : * # #&#% 1 5 ,# ,$*# !"#$ "

%& -$./ % +0#&#0# 6 ")1# %*+/ 87 , 1 *+ #&0#, #%&&% 0+0&& 1#%

5,0#&*,* ,"## % % 1# :1#:%&% &# ##:&E=: +)!*+#" # +#*!%&"

!3-+!

&.2$3 +0+$"'2%.&#(.%! 5& #0#%%&&; 0% !1: # #5 0"&1 :%&%: :# , %:

#::# 3%,0#0##=1 , 1+#% % 10 % * 5&&D" +##%#*&3% & 0/ " :%: % ,:%&+##:%& *&3% &#*&0##&5&&D" #," %9<9 (# #" #0### :, 1 %%& " # % , :%& &1 5&*:# #0##% % 1 #*% * #5&&D" +, 1# % % 1 , :#//

7#**:

& " +0##% # "#& # % % 1 * &&1" 0# # , 1 %

)#" %##% % 1#&*"3#

B " #% ##% % 1=%# :%& * % % 7 # # :0#&#% % 1*3%!&B><6% & (#& #&:#% #:% " 0##% % 1#3%&1%:

(#% #% ,# ""# &,&1 :,&1 (# & 1 *& %&*&=%& #&&"&:%& &# %# *0#1& % :# *1#0"##0%# * 5 ,# ,$*# !"#$ "

%& -$./ % + 0&#&#0## 0 , 1A73&" :%%%1#3 #*" :#%#%%&&#+# #"D1# **%&*1#%& : 0 +#+! #&:%&+#, %%&&;0 %#&

" # % + # ;%%&& 0 " " :% :1 %1 /+

; & # " # " :% : % 1 +0###:::% * %:: &D1# * (#"# 3%" ,0 # D1 # * , : #

%%&&+0## ::: &D1+: # # ::: % * & #, * 0 # %%&&

<0, +# & #0&10 #: 6# # 1 #:% :0 # %%&& &"&&1% :*& /C

(#:%"!":, %*1# & 0&& +*%% % %% &%% , % &0

(# &&"&1 :1# (#!":, %#&0# #%%&* 0#1: #:: "&1

%%&& !"#&**& " #: *1 # < *& && # 2& " + 3 #* 0 " #: :3#: "# :"

6 1:*#D

(") 6 (( .&+!

#7&$ .8"!* +7 & 6 (( $+(./3

+7 &