Karam Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab


 

     

   

 

         !     

 
  
       
     "#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-



 



!



  

 !



  

  !

"

 !

!

!



 

          55(-$) 2&16/2,*#76-5.,825%$)(,)$&$5%2.,4

7#2/$  .%#$&  655(-$)  ,6+$/9  6&6+  2,*#  6,)  "6-6:#6  2,*#  7$&$ 5.,825%$)(,)$&$5%2.,472%#%#$62).;$5%2.,4< //.;%#$+ #68$'.2,%/95#6//$,*$)%#$5.,825%2.,6,)-$,%$,5$16--$)09%#$%&26/

.(&%2,%#$1&$-$,%611$6/  %2-%#$56-$.;%#$1&.-$5(%2.,%#6%)($%.%#$*&()*$%#$ 655(-$)0.&$6*62,-%%#$1&.-$5(%2.,16&%9)($%.%#$(,6(%#.&2=$)$,%&9.; %#$56%%/$.;%#$1&.-$5(%2.,16&%92,%.%#$-(*6&56,$;2$/).;%#$655(-$)6// %#$%#&$$655(-$)-%..).,%#$&.6)6,)-%.11$)%#$-5..%$&.;)$5$6-$) 6/:6&2,*#7#.76-56&&92,*#2-;6%#$&"6:-#2-#2,*#6-612//2., #$&$6;%$&655(-$)"6-6:#62,*#6,)655(-$) 6&6+2,*#56(*#%#./)


.;)$5$6-$)6/:6&2,*#7#$&$6-655(-$) 2&16/2,*#)$/28$&$) :2&5# 0/.7.,%#$,$5:.;6/:6&2,*#7#.)2$).,%#$769%.%#$#.-12%6/ "6:-#2-#2,*##6)/.)*$)%#$;2&-%2,;.&+6%2.,&$1.&% 0$2,*6,$9$72%,$--%.%#$.55(&&$,5$".*62,*#-.,.;+6&2,*# 76-6/-.1&$-$,%.,#2--5..%$&72%#.*62,*#-.,.;6)#(2,*#6%%#$ %2+$7#$,%#$.55(&&$,5$%..:1/65$$6/-.72%,$--$)%#$.55(&&$,5$ < "6:-#2-#2,*#6,)".*62,*#-.,.;+6&2,*# #68$-1.:$,2,.,$8.25$%#6%.,>>?6%60.(%1+)$5$6-$) 6/:6&2,*#76-%6:2,*#2-;6%#$&"6:-#2-#2,*#.,#2--5..%$& 55(-$)"6-6:#62,*# 2&16/2,*#6,) 6&6+2,*#7#.7$&$-%6,)2,* .,%#$+62,&.6)-%.11$)%#$-5..%$&.;)$5$6-$)6/:6&2,*#".*6 2,*#-.,.;+6&2,*#76-5.+2,*.,6-5..%$&0$#2,)6/:6&2,*#$ 6/-.-%.

11$)%#$-5..%$&55(-$)"6-6:#62,*#56(*#%#./).;%#$&2*#% 6&+.;6/:6&2,*#7#$&$6-655(-$) 6&6+2,*#56(*#%#./).;%#$/$;% 6&+.;6/:6&2,*#55(-$) 2&16/2,*#*68$6:2&5#0/.77#25##2%., %#$,$5:.;6/:6&2,*#6,)6-6&$-(/%.;7#25##2-&$-12&6%.&9121$765(%".*62,*#6/-.72%,$--$)%#$.55(&&$,5$#$655(-$)%#$&$6;%$& &6,6769;&.+%#$-1.%#$.55(&&$,5$76-72%,$--$)09"6,)"2, %#$/2*#%.;%#$-5..%$&-.;)$5$6-$)6/:6&2,*#6,)".*62,*# .*62,*#6&&6,*$)65.,8$96,5$6,)%..:6/:6&2,*#%.%#$#.-12%6/;.& %&$6%+$,%0(%(,;.&%(,6%$/96%%#$;&.,%*6%$.;%#$#.-12%6/6/:6&2,*# )2$))69$6&/2$&%#$&$%.%#$56%%/$.;"$,%$&$)2,%.%#$;2$/).;%#$ 655(-$)#$&$;.&$%#$9,(&-$)6*&()*$6-6*62,-%%#$)$5$6-$)" /.)*$)65.+1/62,%6,).,%#$06-2-.

;7#25#;2&-%2,;.&+6%2.,&$1.

4
&$*2-%$&$)  "& 6,.' (1%65.,)(5%$)1.-%+.&%$+$@6+2,6%2.,., %#$)$6)0.)9.;6/:6&2,*#.,?>?6%60.(%6+6,);.(,)%#$ ;.//.72,*2,'(&2$-.,#2-)$6)0.)9
A




     





  

     

                         

!  

 

           

   "#        



  

$#          %          

 #B > ,#2-.12,2.,6/:6&2,*##6))2$))($%.#6$+.&&#6*25 -#.5:6,)&$-12&6%.&9.0-%&(5%2.,)($%.%#$6,%$+.&%$+2,'(&2$-56(-$)09 6-#6&1$)*$)7$61.,6-)$-5&20$)60.8$ ?

55(-$)"6-6:#62,*#6,) 6&6+2,*#-$%(161/$62,%#$2& -%6%$+$,%(,)$&$5%2.,44 & %#6%%#$72%,$--$-$@6+2,$).,%#$-2)$ .;%#$1&.-$5(%2.,#68$)$1.-$).,655.(,%.;1&$82.(-2//
72//#$9#68$ 5.,%$,)$)%#6%%#$97$&$2,,.5$,%55(-$) 2&16/2,*#-$%(161/$62, #2--%6%$+$,%(,)$&$5%2.,44 & %#6%#$76-2,,.5$,%0(%#$76- ;6/-$/92+1/256%$)2,%#$1&$-$,%56-$ #$ %&26/  .(&% #682,* 6)8$&%$) %. %#$ $82)$,5$ ., &$5.&)

<
5.+1/$%$/9&$/2$)(1.,%#$$82)$,5$.;"6,)"2,%#$065:*&.(,).; %#$+$)256/$82)$,5$6,)%#$ &$1.&%6862/60/$.,&$5.&)5.,825%$)6,) -$,%$,5$)%#$655(-$)6--%6%$)-(1&6  $6&,$)5.(,-$/611$6&2,*;.&611$//6,% 2&16/2,*#7.(/) -(0+2%%#6%%#$1&$-$,5$.;"6,)"6%%#$-5$,$.;5&2+$6%1+ 2-).(0%;(/6-%#$9#6),.%5#.-$,%.2,%$&8$,$6,))2-&(1%%#$.,
-/6(*#%.; 655(-$) 2&16/2,*#7$6:+.%28$6//$*$)76-6/-.,.%$-%60/2-#$)% 6,9&6%$2%2-#2--(0+2--2.,%#6%655(-$) 2&16/2,*##6)6//$*$)/9(-$)6 -+6//:,2;$6,))$/28$&$).,/9.,$0/.7.,6/:6&2,*#6,)%#$&$;.&$%#$ .;;$,5$(,)$&$5%2.,4 76-,.%+6)$.(%  $6&,$)5.(,-$/611$6&2,*;.&"6-6:#62,*#7.(/)-(0+2% %#6%655(-$)"6-6:#62,*#76-6)+2%%$)/96$65#$&091&.;$--2.,$ 7.(/),.%#68$'.2,$)#6,)-72%#%#$.

%#$&655(-$) (&%#$&#6)#$ 655.+16,2$)%#$+62,655(-$) 2&16/2,*#72%#6,2,%$,%2.,%.56(-$%#$ )$6%#.;6/:6&2,*##$7.(/)6/-.#68$0$$,6&+$)72%#6/$%#6/7$61., (&%#$&2%2-#2--(0+2--2.,%#6%%#$6//$*$)$@#.&%6%2.,+6)$09655(-$) "6-6:#6  2,*#  2-  ;.(,)  %.  0$  -$/;
5.,%&6)25%.&9  #$&$;.&$  2%  2-  #2- -(0+2--2.,%#6%%#$1&$-$,5$.;655(-$)"6-6:#62,*#6%%#$-5$,$.; 5&2+$2-).(0%;(/".*62,*#-.,.;+6&2,*##6)+6)$-(0-%6,%26/ 2+1&.8$+$,%)(&2,*%#$5.(&-$.;%&26/#$&$#6)0$$,6)$/69.;4#.(&- 6,)+2,(%$-2,/.)*2,*%#$;2&-%2,;.&+6%2.,&$1.&%%#6)168$)769;.& 2,%&.)(5%2.,.;655(-$)6,)72%,$--$-%.%#$5&2+$ 6-%/92%76--(0+2%%$) 09/$6&,$)5.(,-$/611$6&2,*;.&655(-$)"6-6:#62,*#%#6%#$76--#.7, 2,5./(+,.09%#$2,8$-%2*6%2,*.

;;2526/6-%#$&$76-,.+6%$&26/%.


-#.7%#6%#$6/-.'.2,$).%#$&655(-$)2,5.++2%%2,*%#$5&2+$  $6&,$)5.(,-$/611$6&2,*;.&655(-$) 6&6+2,*#7.(/) -(0+2%%#6%655(-$) 6&6+2,*##6),.5.,,$5%2.,72%#%#$.%#$&655(-$) #$&$76-,.+.%28$;.&655(-$) 6&6+2,*#%.6%%65:%#$)$5$6-$)#$ -5..%$&6//$*$)/9(-$)09)$5$6-$)6/:6&2,*#76-2,%#$,6+$.;-.+$ .%#$&1$&-., #$-5..%$&.;.*62,*#76-,.%&$5.8$&$)2,%#2-56-$ 55(-$) 6&6+2,*#76-6/-.,.%6&+$)72%#6,97$61.,#$&$;.&$,. 2,%$,%2.,56,0$6%%&20(%$)%.#2+%2-%#$&$;.&$-(0+2%%$)%#6%%#$655(-$)

6&6+2,*#2-$,%2%/$)%.65D(2%%6/  "$6/-.#$6&)%#$-(0+2--2.,-+6)$09/$6&,$)))/  (,'60-(11.&%2,*%#$8$&)25%.;5.,825%2.,6,)-$,%$,5$16--$)09%#$%&26/

.(&%6-6*62,-%%#$655(-$)
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

>
-%..)2,%#$,6+$.;6%#2&)16&%9%+690$656-$7#$&$%#$)$5$6-$) 7.(/)#68$0.&&.7$)%#$8$#25/$.+$%2+$-%#$8$#25/$1(&5#6-$)-%6,)- 2,%#$,6+$.;$&-%7#2/$.7,$&#$&$76-,.&$6-.,;.&%#$2,8$-%2*6%2,* .;;2526/%.&$5.8$&68$#25/$.;6%#2&)16&%92;6%6//2%76-,.%(-$)09%#$ 655(-$)6%%#$%2+$.;.55(&&$,5$#$2,8$-%2*6%2,*.;;2526/#6)%#.(*#%2% ;2%,.%%.&$5.8$&%#$-5..%$&(-$)09".*62,*#6-2%76-,.%(-$)%. 655(-$)%#$.;;$,5$#$&$;.&$,.,
&$5.8$&9.;%#$-5..%$&(-$)09" .*62,*#).$-,.%%#&.76,9).(0%.,%#$8$&-2.,.;" < #$.55(&&$,5$#6)%6:$,1/65$.,>>?6%1+#$&$ 76-6,6%%$+1%.,%#$16&%.;"6,)"7#.72%,$--$)%#$.55(&&$,5$ %.-68$%#$/2;$.; 6/:6&2,*#096&&6,*2,*68$#25/$%.%&6,-1.&%%#$ 2,'(&$)%.%#$#.-12%6/(&%#$&%#$.

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

?
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

#$+$)256/$82)$,5$$-%60/2-#$-%#6%%#$0/.7)$/28$&$).,%#$ ,$5:76--.)$$1%#6%2%56(-$)%#$)$6%#.;%#$)$5$6-$) ;5.(&-$%#$ 7$61.,(-$)76-6-+6//.,$0(%%#$8$#$+$,5$72%#7#25#%#$6%%65:76- /6(,5#$)6,)%#$-$6%.;2,'(&97.(/)*.%.$-%60/2-#%#$2,%$,%2.,%#$ 655(-$)  7#2/$  )$/28$&2,*  %#$  ;6%6/  0/.7  (&%#$&  %#$  655(-$)  #6)  ,.% $,5.(,%$&$)%#$)$5$6-$)7#$,%#$)$5$6-$)76-6//
6/.,$"6,)" 6/-.7$&$1&$-$,%6%%#$-5$,$.;5&2+$#$&$;.&$%#$655(-$)#6))$52)$) %.)$/28$&6;6%6/0/.772%#6//8$#$+$,5$6%#2-5.++6,)6,);/$$6769 ;&.+%#$-5$,$.;5&2+$(-%0$56(-$%#$&$76-.,/9.,$0/.7%#$56-$.; %#$1&.-$5(%2.,).$-,.%-/212,%./$--$&*&682%9.;.;;$,5$(,)$&$5%2.,

C
4<

C %2-%&($%#6%".*62,*##6--%6%$)0$;.&$%#$ .(&%%#6% #$1&.5$$)$)%.%#$;2$/).;6:-#2-#2,*#%.$,*6*$6/60.(&$&6,)2,;65% 162)6-(+.;
F
6-6)86,5$%.6/60.(&$&#$60.8$8$&-2.,76-,.% ;.(,)2,#2--%6%$+$,%(,)$&$5%2.,> & "#6),.%5.+$.(% 72%#%#$1(&1.-$.;#2-82-2%2,#2--%6%$+$,%(,)$&$5%2.,> & 6-#$ #6)  ,.%  0$$,  %#.&.(*#/9  $/252%$)  09  %#$  2,8$-%2*6%2,*  .;;2526/  8$, .%#$&72-$%#$D($-%2.,76-7#$%#$&#$76-1&$-$,%6%%#$%2+$7#$,%#$ .55(&&$,5$%..:1/65$ $2,*6,6*&25(/%(&2-%#$7.(/)#68$82-2%$)%#$ ;2$/).;6:-#2-#2,*#%.$,*6*$6/60.(&$&;.&#2+8$,.%#$&72-$#25.#$&$,%%$-%2+.,9).$-,.%5&$6%$6).(0%6-&$*6&)-#2-1&$-$,5$6%%#$ -5$,$.;5&2+$ 

.+2,*%.%#$$@#.&%6%2.,&62-$)09655(-$)"6-6:#62,*# %#$&$2-6-/2*#%86&26%2.,2,%#$$82)$,5$.;",%#$;2&-%2,;.&+6%2., &$1.&%"#6--%6%$)%#6%655(-$)"6-6:#62,*#$@#.&%$)A% 

      B(%2,$82)$,5$ "#6-)$1.-$)%#6%655(-$)"6-6:#62,*#$@#.&%$)A

## 





  # B "$).,.%;2,)6,9 +6%$&26/5.,%&6)25%2.,2,%#$5.,%$,%.;$@#.&%6%2., 6%%/$%&$-16--7#25# 76-%#$0.,$.;5.,%$,%2.,0$%7$$,%#$655(-$)6,)%#$1&.-$5(%2.,16&%9 76-%#$56(-$;.&+(&)$&#$$@#.&%6%2.,6%%&20(%$)%.655(-$)"6-6:#6 2,*#  0.%#  2,  %#$  ;2&-%  2,;.&+6%2.,  &$1.&%  6,)  %#$  %$-%2+.,9 .;  " 2,)256%$-.,/9%#$5.,-$D($,5$-.;$@#.&%6%2.,+6)$09655(-$)"6-6:#6 2,*#


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



.+2,*%.%#$&./$.;655(-$) 6&6+2,*#2%2-%&($%#6%#$ 76-,.%&$/6%$)%.%#$.%#$&655(-$) $6/-.76-,.%6&+$)72%#6,9 7$61., (%%#$%&(-%7.&%#9%$-%2+.,9.;"6,)"7.(/)*.%. $-%60/2-#%#6%655(-$) 6&6+2,*#6/-.76-1&$-$,%6,)6--.526%$)%#$ .%#$&655(-$)09%2*#%/956%5#2,*#./).;%#$825%2+#$&$76-,.&$6-., ;.&%#$1&.-$5(%2.,16&%9%.2,5/()$655(-$) 6&6+2,*#2;6%6//#$#6),.

5.,,$5%2.,72%#%#$5&2+$ #$&$;.&$655(-$) 6&6+2,*#6/-.56,,.% $-561$  ;&.+ %#$  5&2+2,6/  /2602/2%9 '(-%  0$56(-$  #$  76-  ,.%  %#$  ;6+2/9 +$+0$&.;%#$.%#$&655(-$) 4 (&%#$&7$;2,) %#6% %#$+.%28$;.&%#$+(&)$&16/$- 2,%. 2,-2*,2;256,5$2,656-$7#$&$%#$56-$.;%#$1&.-$5(%2.,2-06-$).,%#$ .5(/6&%$-%2+.,9#$&$;.&$%#$7$6:+.%28$.&,.+.%28$;.&%#$5&2+$ ).$-,.%*.%.%#$&..%.;%#$+6%%$&


< ,.(&5.,-2)$&$)82$7%#$%&26/ .(&%#6-&2*#%/9$86/(6%$)%#$ $82)$,5$.,&$5.&)6,)5.+$%.%#$5.&&$5%5.,5/(-2.,%#6%655(-$) 2&16/ 2,*#5.++2%%$)%#$+(&)$&.;6/:6&2,*#7#2/$%#$.%#$&%7.655(-$) -#6&$)%#$5.++.,2,%$,%2.,%.56(-$%#$)$6%#.;6/:6&2,*#0956%5#2,* #./).;%#$#6,)-.;%#$825%2+%#$&$09;652/2%6%2,*%#$+(&)$&.;6/:6& 2,*#  "$).,.%;2,)6,9+$&2%2,%#$611$6/#$&$;.&$5.,;2&+2,* %#$'()*$+$,%.;5.,825%2.,6,)-$,%$,5$16--$)09%#$%&26/ .(&%%#$ 611$6/-%6,)-)2-+2--$) > 55(-$)
611$//6,%- 6&6+2,*#6,)"6-6:#62,*#6&$., 062/#$2&062/0.,)--%6,)56,5$//$)#$9-#6//-(&&$,)$&72%#2,)69- ;&.+ %#$  )6%$  .;  %#2-  '()*$+$,%  0$;.&$  %#$  #2$;  ()2526/  6*2-%&6%$ (&)6-1(&;%#$9;62/%.-(&&$,)$&%#$/$6&,$) #2$;()2526/ 6*2-%&6%$ (&)6-1(&-#6//%6:$5.$&528$-%$1-%.-$5(&$%#$2&1&$-$,5$6,)-$,)%#$+ %.'62/%.(,)$&*.%#$&$+62,2,*16&%.;%#$2&-$,%$,5$     !

  $0&(6&9    !

(/6%2