← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/315/2013allowed

Surender v. State Of Haryana

2017-08-30Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri14 pages

     



 !



   "

  

# "

$"

%

&

"""""

''(( "

)"

&  

 !

 """""

'"

* + , 

- ) .

/ ( """""

''(( "

)"

&  

 !



"""""

'"

*+ 0  

1 

"""""

''(( "

)"

& '

 """""

'"

22222 34# 3-5 67 4"

89&:7 :"

"&"

4-- 3-5 67 4"

89&:7

4  &-; &-9

#          

 

         

 !   

"

##$% &

'" '

      (   )  

 #*  "

     #  #+, )  

 #*   * -   

#.

 " ##  +  )  

 ///// 4  &-; &-9<8"

0#-"

. #  ## 1     #

 

2  

 1 

1&   #'"  

 +   3 

"

 #&  .

 #  

-"

.   " *&* 

#    * .#4 - 1 



 *+ 9=& ""

>  

(

'"  

(*,5!2 

 5! 6 #   7

( '8  #  7(*,5! ' & # 

( 9"  #

# : & 

( 0*  # +  3

" 

(*,5!2 

 5! 6 #   7

( '8  #  7(*,5! ' & # 

( 9"  # #  # *  #*   "  " &  0  )  

 #1  1&      .

 #    #   -"

.        "     * #  #+ * ;"  .# .

 #  , 5 1  ##" #  1 ## #  <=8!%>



)

1&% #"

'(' " ' . 95+



)"

' # 7(

( (,  !  <#?5!?>

'  #* .# !'  &$

.

 #'

# ( . !" #!

 

 " @ * # 

 # # #  

#"

4 A 

      

         

    

  

!"#$%&

 

' 

' ( '

    ) *+  '

  , -./ 0! & 1 



' ) 1 (  





2"#%&1 1

1  

      %

(         )      1 1 1

'    

  

1 1 

  '  (& 

1



'  

    1 

  

      ' %

 (&  )

(

 

 

'11    ) 

-

       1   ) 1

2    (&  '1   

 ) 

'    1  1  

'   ( 

     *

'3-

4

   .5 36 

'

   754   

' 

 (1  (& 



 ( 1 

 ) 1  %

( 



'

(

 8    ) / - /      1  

  % &.)

2 

'  % &          

5   

'           0  9:/)  (&   

 (  

(    ( 1)              '

   (  &      

 ( ' ) ; 

' 



< 

,1 % &.)  '      -  ='   ) '

 (&   

 (  >   0   #.

  * #   "  1&     

    "

 ' 7   ! "  )7  <  #  B!B>  * #  #"1

  #  *  " '## #C"

.  )

 5  &  .#* .

 ##8   



# !D# *8   " 7

 6   

&

?

#* #

# .#* .

 # #

  

 

"

' 

 5! ' 



*' 

 5! ' 



*' ,5! '  7

*' 

 5!

'  7

*' ,5!

'" * # .# &" &

 1#

   ."

'  # #*

  #" * ###*8   # 0#" 8   & E* ###

 

  "  &   #" # .#

.

 #  '  #  * "

'  ! 

 &        1 .   #&     "#

 " " #=8, #"   E 0  "  #  .     1   

  

 #    1     #(  #   '" 

+  3

"

1" ;"  1 '

 '"  +"

# .#1&. .1  "1 %     *  #    #     1    1&    #(  #  .

 #      

 #    * #  

  #1  1&  .

 # ;"    .

) 5# ." 1& " # #(  #

#  # #" # * #'

# *#

. 1 ##  *

 ." #   #

# #   % #" "* # .1   " &  .  *#&

 

  #   #5# # ."  . ##   '

   #   #  1  .     1&     

   *

# .  # #1#@ * #" 5#"

."    # * # '

#

#



#  #  

&" 

 1",:?@

&

  @#  #

 #"#  * #. 1&'

#

# 

   .  1"E4! # 

&  # .   1  1&'

# "* # .1   " # 1"   " # #" .

 .  C      *  * #         

  #"  ##.  .  **#-"# #   #(  #  5   #  #  1  ."       #    

  1     #*##    .  #  #

# # ."     

&1  ;" 1&  "  #  

 #   # # #    ;"  : 

 #1  ." 1& ' " #  * #* .     1  ." #   #1&  # 1 "1

##" &  .&1  

#   1&  "

#

# ;" &  1&#"

"# 1  #

#1 ### % # ."   &  ##  * ## 1#   

"  # '

#* #"

1  

  .& # .

,  '    #           ' .  1& ." #   -"& #   

# # "& 1&#" 

  # .

 1

 # 

1&F & "

<!D

> *  .*   " #8  

1 &

  #=8!D

( !D



"&#* # 

<=8!D

(>   .* * .

 -"#*"

4 A2

'   ) 1  (   ( )

? $ ;  ((     1  ( 

 ;

         0    

       '     @ 1 8 1 

  )  

   A0 /

  

( 

1 

   ( 



   

( 

'  



 ( 1

 '

 (     ( = < 1 ?

'  1  9 ( 

  

 

'

1         1   (     )



 

'       )  = 

  5   

 1 

  ;

(   

' 

'

    

  

   '

B    

'



)

      ,

5 1   (

>  F & "

<!D

>  #"#  "#

 # #* #  "   -"#

 -"#* # 1   "

#"  "#   " "#% #"# 1*  -"&

 * # C  >

1*  

#8  * C0

>

%  % #"<!D >#&* ##" 5  # #* #   1"E4!   .*# * . ."# 1@ # .#

# *

 .&

* #   1"E4  * &"  * #"#!

 

& ** #* .  #"

 &  ** #1 .

 1& &" .1&

'

# ( .!" # !

 *   5#"# 1&#* ## '

  #@"##

 ## .* &*  @ # 

   # <% #">G1" # 1&  .

1"1@ * 5 #"1 #

 '

#. * #1@

#  1 .# 

#** #    .

(" * # "

&5   F ' .<!D7>'(%  #

 -#'( ' .  

& *'

# #* # G1"& * & "   1@* #!

 1&1

# .

#5#"#  

)  1",:?@    .

'

#

#



#

"   @#   #    

 "  #  "#  &      *    #;" #0"#    # % #"<!D > ##@  & 1" # '

#( .!" # !

 

 #  " @ *    * #   .    & %*  *  # .  1          "  !D

% #"#   "

&  7

) 1&# 

&           * &  '"   * #   .  

$ & '" * #  * #'

#* # . 

 ## 

# !D *

@ .##  1  7

)*  .#  95

# &#@  1" & # #

 . & *  

# 

 ## F&  #"# .&  !D  % #"  #       "   

) )

) * #

* # &



)

 1 ##    ##

1" '" 

   . &  5 #1 # 1&!D 

##    '

# #+  3

"#( -1 ( .

% #"#  ###8   C 



      :

   1     (

 1

(      1 

 ( >% #"# +  * #   1&  

) #  

  @ * #*#

#  .*'

# 

)

  " + 

#'

# 

&" %

 " .## 8        #  #   <=8!%>   

 .     

##   #'

#

 #

 * ## 1&  '

#

#  1 .* * #    .

( , !D7F ' . #- #1 &* ##

1 # 

1&!D % #" " #  

0 <=8!%>

1&!D % #" )

* # . &#

 *   .*# * #   * &

." ##*

1 .* ## 

  # ."

& !D7 F ' .  .* -#  

  *

##  #  '  <=8>!D7F ' .* # 1&'5   "

'  ! 

) * & # &*  1& &" .1&

'

# (  .!" * #  

 # '

# @"##

 #*  @#1  "<#   # >

  # #" # * !D % #"

1" * 

# " "5#" #  "

% #" * &

 '

#. * &

#  1 .   

#    !D % #"  5          #       # &#  "  " .   !$5  @ 

" # 1&'

#

 # &#  * &* ##  #'

#

 &" .1&

#     1" & #    0# #   <=8>



 .#      '"1  .#  $

 5 #*#       #   * 8" 1& "' .".# 1 "<#   # > $!   "'

#(

' . #(0@

(  .!" #!

 .

 . ##"

$

  #   

(0"# # "  &# '

 ( .!" * #@ *   # # 



 7 '

#(

' .(!" * # 1&'5      E

) E '       -#  #(    ' .  * #    1&  '5    

)

 ##  # # #F

' . * #'

# ( .!" * #"   # #* # % #" )  @#<!D > ## 1  " 

)

) 

.  #*  "D     

# * '

( 



1&#

&* @ . 1"  # % #"# 

'

    . #"

1 1&  #

      C   1*     #

 '

  (



 "&1.  .

##"C  *  

 . * #.

 .



@#1&'

#( .!" 

"# 1&  # , :?@ 

)

 #;"  .." #1&# '

  # # 

&

) E4 0"# #"  #  &

 *#   #    

#&* ###!D7

!D   # 1" #" C   #* ##  "# &

E )

)    * # 

" 

  "  # .* .

 . .

 #   1&  )

)0#* ## ## &

  ###8    @ * 1"" 

 #  

)

% #"

F ' .

 -#  

 # "

 

# # .

  ..

 ."   #

1" # #* ##  ## 1" .  #    & 

E )

)=   "  ,7".  -"

.    "#   C 

'

  1  



    %8

   (') 

(

>

 &* ## -##(' .'

  #1 . "1&#" #  





 #;" &  # &    F  ' .  <!D7>  .

 .

   +  1# "1"

#"   @ &# 

0  " #* .&  "# 

 # 

. #C     '

 1"

 & # 

  #"1*   '



  # 5 #.

#" #& .   " &  

) ,

)< @AH>1" * # #" 1"  #  % #"

#" .  *#&#1 .1" "1&#"  0  95+,

 E

)<=8!I>

 .#

,

)<=8!J>  #* .& "  ##     '

#(

 ( 



 '

#( . !"  +  3

"

 !#<=8! >

  .<=8!7>  .   1      '"     "#"

    #  ##" #  <=8!D)( >

#* .  1 

 #  ' . <!D)>

  - ' . <!D

>





)

 &#   1 . ##1 

#"

& "#  ##"   '"  

 &." #

"#  . &#    #  1&  '"  ."  "

 #

, ' &   % * ' .<!DE>.

 .8  -"

  ## * #.& "

 11&  "

## 1#  

  ,".  -"

. 

#    * ##* #-   #1&5 #.

 .

:

 0#  F ' .<!D7>* # 1& 

) !$5'

 @

 #   * # & .

 * &*# # &

"  '

   #  (   .  !"   

   ." #  K #" & '

#(

' . ( .!" # .   # 

* # 1&   E

)

 



)F ' .<!D7>

% #"<!D >#  #  

# '" 

'"  "# &* ##  #

'

#( .!" 

 #;" & * # .

  

)"

# #'  )!1& '"1 #   C"

    .#  $

        1& 5 #('%:6 @* ' . ."

# #"    "

" . #.

  .

 #'

 #(

' .  #C ( .!" !'5#

#!

 

##"  #" # #  *#&

# # #

0"# # . # 1&F ' .<!D7>



 % #"  <!D >  .#             # 

 ##1  "# # 1* ### 1 # 1* ###

   1   # #*#  &

 1" 

&   ##" 

"#   1* ### #* .&1  " 1&

 "

0#   # # # # .   #.

 * # " 1&

' . '!

!

 1" 1  * ##G 8   1&#"   # #  1#  @ *      *   ##  "1  "        #.

  # #

# . # =     F ' .<!D7>% #"<!D >  &     ##  #*

 * #  1&  &

.  "1 ##  # # 1"   "1 #* &

E '  &&#    # 1# "1" *  1F ' .<!D7>

% #"  <!D >       ##    "1    @     &

) 0#  #       #      #"       #(  #* @ * F ' .<!D7>

% #"

<!D >  # # &* @ * 

"   5 * 1 #"#"&    #  #F ' .<!D7>

% #"<!D >  #"   #  #'" 

+  3

"*

? ##   . .

 # #1&# . #

 # .#

 #  @# 1&

 #

"1  #"

# @#*#"  #

 1 "  #;" &   # 1&'" 

+  3

" .

 #  

#    

&

 ;"  .# .

 #'"  # 

& "#"

  ## 1&#"  

+  3

" 1 # "# &*" ##*  #  #  '    '" 

+  3

"  1  ;"

#        1   &#  #+<)  

> ##  .  

 # *

;" 1&  "  " #     

      1

" ."#  .1# "   . #1   "*..  1&  "* ;" .#  #+  #;" & * @ 1&  "* ;" .##  ####1 *

 1 " *1&#"%     1& % #"     . .    ;"     '

  '"   1 +"

## 1& ### *:"

"&"

4--+ *4  &-; &-9+

89;7

89;7

"

$"

%"

# D# @ .( # 

J#(+ D 1 J#(+