High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8705/2017dismissed

Balwinder Singh And ANR v. Dilbag Singh And ORS

2018-11-13Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu7 pages

! "#$ % &

'()* $#+* ,-' $' .-# /#.*.* #0 1#0!0 *(2',+* ,-' $.-#0 /#03 $# .0 % 45 6+

+75 #0# .% 6+!* $# ',8$9"'.# .-#3#.*.* #0 61* $:-! ,#8$9"'.# .-##03 $# .0 ;;; < =

-'((# ,# * .-# #9*0* 3#.*.* ! $# .*"(# .-#

0.*.!.* $*' *0 . $# $'.#$

3'00#$ 2> .-# (#' #$ $$*.* '( *9*(!$,#+*98 *$$#2'-''(()* ,.-#'33(*"'.* *(#$ 2>#03 $# .0?$# '33* .@# . 5"'( @@*00* #. .# $) .-#3->0*"'( #'.!#0 .-#0!*.(' $ <= *# '".0 .-# "'0# (#'$* , . .-# *(* , .-# * 0.' . #9*0* 3#.*.* '#.-'..-#3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0 *(#$'0!*. 3#@' # . * A! ".* #0.'* * , .-# #03 $# .0?$# # $' .0 "# '(( @ "'9* , !. ' > B-'(8 ('>* , ' > ! $#,! $ )'.# 3*3# ' $ '(0 @ @'B* ,' >"!(9#.'0'(0 @$*0300#00* ,.-#3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0 @ (' $ @#'0!* , B' '( @'('0 "@3*0#$ * :-#)'. & 8 :-'.'! * C 8#".' ,(# 8:*((0&?

DE8?

DE' $?

DE'03# '@'2' $* .-#>#'

D &0*.!'.#$)*.-* .-##9# !#(*@*.0 9*((',# +'-*2 -' $8 #-0*( *$$#2'-'8*((#,'((>8 "*2(>' $)*.-!.' >*,-.

<&= -##03 $# .0?$# *(#$')*..# 0.'.#@# ."('*@* , .-'. ' '(0# 0!*. -'$ 2## *(#$ 2> .-# 3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0 '0 0' ".* #$ F3'BB'4)'.#"!0#)'0'(#'$>! * ,* .-#0!*.(' $' $ !.-#.-'. 3#9*!0(>F 'BB'42#.)## B*(('0 C' $ #".

&)'0.-## ' $ .-# #03 $# .0?$# # $' .0 )## **,'.* , .-#* (' $ .-!,- )'.# "!0#2#.)## B*(('0 C8 8' $ #". .)'0 !.-# " .# $#$.-'..-##03 $# .0?$# # $' .0-'$* *.*'.#$3"##$* ,02# # ' '(#3'.@# ...'B#.-#*.! )'.#'..-#3* .2#.)## B*((' 0C' $ #". )-##F3'BB'4B-'('(#'$>#G*0.#$' $.-'..-# 3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0)' .#$.$*0@' .(#.-#)'.#"!0#! $#.-#,'2 * A! ".* ' $#9# .-#>3(#'$#$2# # ' '(#3'.@# ..-'..! )'.# ' $ F 'BB'4 @'> . 2# ,*9# . .-# #03 $# .0?$# # $' .0 '0 .-#> -'$ * A! ".* .-# *9*( !.8.-## #8.2* ,.-#.!#3*".!#2# #.-#

!.8 *. )'0 #"#00'> .-'. ' 5"'( "@@*00* # 2# '33* .#$ . .# $) .-# 3->0*"'( #'.!#0 .-# 0!*. (' $ * $# . 3#9# . .-# 3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0 @$*0@' .(* ,.-#)'.#"!0#'

.#.-#3'00',# .*@#' $ ' #

#".*9#' $A!0.$#"*0* .-#"'0# <= #3(>)'0 *(#$2>.-#3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0'((#,* ,.-'..-## )'0 B-'(2#.)## B*(('0?

' $?

#". 8.-## #8.-# H!#0.* * .# .* .-# 3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0 . $*0@' .(# .-# '((#,#$ B-'($*$ .'*0#'.'((' $ !.-#.-'. )! $#.-#,'2 '33* .@# . 5"'( @@*00* #8#03 $# .0?$# # $' .0)' .#$."#'.##9*$# "# * .-#* '9! )-*"- "!($ . 2# '(()#$ '0 .-# 0'@# )!($ "'!0# 3#A!$*"#..-#3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0""$* ,(>8'3'># $*0@*00'( .-#'33(*"'.* )'0@'$##(*' "#)'03('"#$2>.-#(#' #$"! 0#( .-# 3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0 .-# $#"*0* *

!" # $

% #&'($ ) *+

, -.,.

,/"

# $

#)&$ <= -#(#' #$.*'( !.)-*(#20#9* ,.-'.*.)'00#..(#$.-'.'

@@*00* "!($ . 2# '33* .#$ . '0"#.'* )- )'0 * '".!'( 300#00* .-# 03. 2!. ' @@*00* "!($ "#.'* (> 2# '33* .#$ . '0"#.'* )-'. )'0 .-# '".!'( 30*.* '. .-# 03. 5#' #$ .*'( !. 20#9#$ .-'. * .-# * 0.' . "'0#8 *. -'$ 2## '((#,#$ 2> .-# #03 $# .0? $# # $' .0.-'.'0' ".* #$F3'BB'4)'.#"!0#)'0'(#'$>! * ,* .-# 0!*.(' $' $ !.-#.-'.3#9*!0(>F 'BB'42#.)## B*(('0 C' $ #".

&)'0.-##' $.-#>**,'.#$.-#*(' $.-!,-)'.#"!0# 2#.)## :*(('0 C8 8' $ #".

&' $ !.-#.-'.*.)'0 ,* ,2#.)## :*(('08' $C8 #". )-##'0 .-#.-# 0*$#.-#3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0-'$" .# $#$.-'..-##)'0 B-'(2#.)## B*(('0?

' $?

#". 8.-## #8.-#'

#@# .* #$ '".0 "!($2#'0"#.'* #$ (>.-!,-'03.* 03#".* .-#"*"!@0.' "#08 .-# (#' #$ $$*.* '( *9*( !$,# + *98 '33* .#$ ' 5"'(

@@*00* #.'0"#.'* .-# '".!'(30*.* '..-#03.2>9*0*.* ,.-#03. 2>,*9* ,3* .*"#.2.-.-#3'.*#0)*.-#03#"..$'.#' $.*@# .-# 9*0*. <C= 5#' #$"! 0#( .-#3#.*.* #0?3('* .*

0" .# $#$.-'.*. )'00#..(#$(').-'.'5"'( @@*00* #"!($ .2#'33* .#$ .-# 3!30# ,'.-#* , #9*$# "# #*.-# .-# 3'.*#08 .-## #8 .-# *@3!, #$$#)'0(#,'((>! 0!0.'* '2(#' $(*'2(#.2#0#.'0*$# .-*0 " .#G.8#(*' "#-'02## 3('"#$ '$#"*0* .-*0 !.* /"

0 0" ./"

0 #$

# $3#!0'( .-#0'*$$#"*0* #9#'(0.-'..-#0'@#)'0'"'0#)-##'33(*"'.* '33* .@# . 5"'( @@*00* #)'0$*0@*00#$' $.-*0 !.-#($.-'.

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

!. * // (, /"

0 2

/ // ! 0 #3$ & / 4./ /"

%#$

# $%)-##* *.)'0 -#($ .-'. $# '33* .* , ' 5"'( @@*00* # )'0 . #9*0#'2(# #(#9' .#G.'". .-#'

#0'*$$#"*0* *0#3$!"#$'0! $#%D

" # $ %

& '

<= -'9#" 0*$##$.-#0!2@*00* 0 (#' #$"! 0#('33#'* ,

.-# 3'.*#0 $# C !(# E $#'(0 )*.- .-# '33* .@# .

@@*00* . @'B# ("'( * 9#0.*,'.* 0 -# 0'@# *0 #3$!"#$ '0 ! $#%D

3#!0'( .-## #9#'(0 .-'. * ' > 0!*. * )-*"- .-# !. $##@0 ' ("'( * 9#0.*,'.* . 2# #H!*0*.# 33# .-# 3!30# #(!"*$'.* ,' >@'..#* $*03!.##."*.@'>*00!#' @@*00* .0!"-' 3#0 '0*..-* B0 *.$*#".* ,-*@.@'B#0!"-* 9#0.*,'.* ' $.#3. .-## ..-# !. <E= $@*..#$(>8

*9*( +!*. *0

#0.'* * , #03 $# .0?$# @0#..* ,!3'B-'(' $! $#,! $)'.#3*3#0 * .-#0!*.(' $)-##'0.-#0.' $ .-##03 $# .0?$# # $' .0*0.-'..-# B-'(' $! $#,! $)'.#3*3#0'(#'$>#G*0.* .-#0!*.(' $ -## #8*. *0 #00# .*'( ' ("'( * 9#0.*,'.* . 2# "'*#$ !. .-# 3!30# #(!"*$'.* ,.-#@'..#* $*03!.#'0.)-#.-#)'.#B-'(' $! $#,! $ )'.# 3*3#0 #G*0. '..-#03. . # ## "# * .-*0 " #".* "' 2# @'$# . ' $#"*0* 42(# .-# #(' ,' ' ' $ $-' '$#0- *,-

!.* "'0#.*.(#$'0. /"

5 !

61)-##* *.)'0-#($.-'..-#2A#". $#C !(#E *0 ..'00*0.'3'.>."((#".#9*$# "#)-##.-#3'.>"!($ 3"!#.-#0'@#2!. #(!"*$'.* ,' >@'..#* $*03!.#.)'0 !.-# -#($.-'.*.)!($2# #"#00'>.'33* .'5"'( @@*00* #3'.*"!('(> )-# ' > '@! . #9*$# "# * .-'. #,'$ @'> . -#(3 .-# !. * '*9* , '. ' "#". * $* , '0 #9*$# "# * .-# 3'.*"!(' '".0 ' $ "*"!@0.' "#0 .-#"'0#)!($2#'9'*('2(# .-#03.'..-#,! $? *#($ ' $.-'.'0*.!'.* 0!"-'0.-'.)!($$# * *.#(> '(()*.-* .-##G3#00*

6 I#(!"*$'.* , ' > @'..# * $*03!.#J '9*$* , '$$!"* , @!"- '( #9*$# "#)-*"-)!($ . (>2#.*@#" 0!@* ,2!.)!($'(0!(.*@'.#(> 2# 3'".*"'('33'"- '""!'.#$#.#@* '.* .-#(*0#(#9' . #G.'". .-#'

#@# .* #$$#"*0* *0#3$!"#$'0! $#%D # $% &'() *

% ,,-() * .)/0

! 1

% &'!()*

$ 3 1 !

4 2!

5 !

! 1

'9* ," 0*$##$.-#0!2@*00* 0 (#' #$"! 0#( .-# 3'.*#08'@ .-#" 0*$##$9*#).-'.0* "#* .-#* 0.' ."'0#.-##*0' "('*@ #0.'* * ,.-##03 $# .0?$# @* 0.'((* ,)'.#B-'( ' $! $#,! $)'.#3*3#08)-##'0 .-#.-#-' $.-##*0'0.' $ .-##03 $# .0?$# # $' .0.-'..-#)'.#B-'(' $! $#,! $)'.#3*3#0 '(#'$>#G*0.08.-## #8* .-# '".0 .-#* 0.' ."'0#*.)!($2# #"#00'> .'33* .5"'( @@*00* #.'0"#.'* .-# '".!'(30*.* '..-#03. ' $'0*.!'.* 0!"-'0.-# #* .-#* 0.' ."'0#)!($$# * *.#(> '(()*.-* .-##G3#00* .-#.#@I#(!"*$'.* ,' >@'..#* $*03!.#J <

= .-#"*"!@0.' "#08$ . * $' >* *@*.>)*.-.-#$# 3'00#$ 2> .-# (#' #$ $$*.* '( *9*( !$,# + *98 *$$#2'-' '(()* ,.-#'33(*"'.* ' $'33* .* ,'5"'( @@*00* #.'0"#.'* '".!'(30*.* '..-#03. < = ""$* ,(>8 * $* , @#*.* .-##9*0* #.*.* 8.-#0'@# *0$*0@*00#$ +7'(*' !$,#

'@*. 7-#.-#03#'B* ,?#'0 #$ % #0? 7-#.-##3.'2(# % #0?