High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1030/2005dismissed

State Of Punjab v. Sarbjit Signh & ORS.

2017-09-25Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri8 pages

% "&'( ) %*#$+# ,

%% " -.* % /

*.% 012 ( ( &%( 3) 453

$# " ""

& " '" "(' " )(*+,- .

*+,- / & )("

)"* +,-

1-&10

1))) )(./ .224""

"0 )" 0) !

(!( " 2.

%334'

! 6 ""7

" ""

) "'"

8" "'

"") )( 6 ! "(

) '" "" "

8" "

" ./1

) ( 9.: .4 8" " %3;59 "

< <: (" "

" ('

( "('"$

" ./1'

' " "( " 6" = "( 7" 9.: .4 "

" = "( " " " " '" " 6

> " 6

" ""7

" """ " () )( 6 "

" "( 8" 8" " " "(" ;9: .. = "( " '

" ./1" ! "' "

' "

) ( 8" ""$) ! " " "( ! 8" "

? ( " "(" '" " ! '"

" % 6" ") " "( ! 8" "? (" 7" 9/:

/ .4 ' .5"

= "( ! '" "

) 6 ""7

8 " ")

" "" 0) 8 "" )" !

! "

"( 7%2 () )( 8( ..9;:9: "$"

" "("' ! " "(""

! ') ) 7%2 " )(7 6 %1 -01 %1 (( 7 %8 ( 9( ( (1& %1 '% *-% %1& ( 7( 9& (%&%1'

-%(&% : 9( ( (7(91&& 9% ''-(& #% !"

0%%0%1( :(&" %5* % : 9&'1(*& "+( (% (1 7%1%( 7(8%%'%%%(:((&%7(8%7:" (- 01% 71'1 &(% :( %1 '%9 0&%( " %1

(%'&(1(7(:;& : %1<-(%

" ''-(& 71 1( 7 =& *-% (-'1

%-%:1(*""

&&% ''-(& #% ! %1 % " 1' :(& '%0 ' 1 (%7("

-&% *((*:!!!>& %1(9:81

&%1%%1((1 %001%19

''-& &-0 %1 '(( " %80 ( & %( (&0% %11':(% % "%11' :(%7(9'

9:&% %1''-(& #% !

& '-% 1( * 9& '

&+ (1 70 %1%

''-(& #7( "3?( 19 18% 7@&

:+ & '-%1(*'& "(1 70 %1%''-(& !&!7%1( (*( ( -"'%-0'

:A @ " ) 7%28 " )"

""'"'

.4"7" "9%:94: "7 6#B

CD 1 ('%'&:(%% 71 ( ":('%'& 1(*(-*%%&"

%(% :((-&(-* ('% CED "('% ##+(1+7%1 & "%1%:&:(+ &9% %1('%'&('% (-*%%0%(0& %&-'%%1('*&"

C#D1('%'&('% '%%1 "(1 &9 '

: "%1 %% %1( " 71 %1(7(%8&(1%%1 %1'

-(: ('-% ('% "%1( C!D:& '-%- %0% * %(0& *:('%'&:(%(1*9&' "%1"'%( (%%& %1+ & (-'1 9&' (1 * ' '-(9 -((%1( " 71 %1(7(%81( 7%1%7%:

01%&:( "%1'% "'

: "%1 % %"&7%0%1('%'&('% %1 '

-% *"

71'1 : '&0( ('% " %1 (&0%1%1%&(% &&-'9&' '

% 9( "%1 % CBD (( %1 ( 1( &: * %(%& :(&%1%('%'&(5* % :+ 71( 1(-&(-* ('% C!D %"& 1(%% "&&-'09&''

% 9(

"%1('%'&:(%4( %+%1'

-%:+

"%( 7 % %(&('% %%1<-(%

%1 "%1'

% "%1''-(&+'-( %1( "%1('%'& &-'&*"

%1 0(%%-&(-* ('% CED "('% ##% * (%"

%(% :((% %1(&* % :+ 71'1(1+7%1 & "%1%:&:(+8 %1%(% :((& %7%0(0&*:+

-& %1 -%1 %: "+ %1 '% " %1 %('%'&(5* % :%1(-%%1 "+ &(-'1 %(1*'

'-(99&' "%1 "'%((%%&%1A .3 " "7 6#F

CDG1 9+ CD %(+-"'%-(+((+(% '8( =1*%( ( &(%*-%(:('%'&&& *(*&&-&(-* '-(CD (-*

'-(CD (-* '-(C9D "'-(C8D ('% !H C*D %( -"'%-( : ('%'& 7%1 -%'%"'% "0(%% H C'D-"'%-(+((+(% '8( =1*%("

(

&(%*-%(('%'&7%1 -%''H

C&D(( &(%*-%( ('%'&+ '

%9% "('% #,H CD '-((('%'&+%1-( "71'11( * 1*%&-&('% #,+% *-(& *::7 8H C"D *(%-'%( ('%'& ('% %1 ='( " 1( 7( &('10 " 1( &-%( -& %1( '% %1 -( & %1-&+(1*-(1* CD "

%1"(% ""'+7%1( % % 71'1 : =%& % %7

:(+ 7%1"71'1(1 %* ((%1%%1 -(&-(*-%71'1 :=%&% ""%:%1 -(&-(+

;

7%1* %1H CD"

%1('

&&(-*(<-% ""'+ 7%1 ( % "

% 71'1 :=%&% %1:(+ 7%1" 71'1 (1 % * (( %1 ""% %1 -(&-(*-%71'1:=%& (9%:

"9%1 -(&-(+ 7%1 * %1 C#DG1 9-((('%'&'

%9% : 9( "%1('% :-&%1-& (1*-(1*7%1"71'1(1 %*((%1 "9 1-&& -( *-% 71'1 : =%& % "9 %1 -(&-(+ ( %"

%71'1:

=%&% (= %1(+ 7%1* %1 C!D G1 9 '

%9'( : " %1 %1 9( ( "%1('% :-&%1-& :

&% "'%"'% "0(%% ''0%& %1-&+(1*-(1* CD "

%1"(% ""'+7%1( %"

% 71'1:=%&% :+ 7%1"71'1 (1 %*((%1"9%1 -(&-(*-% 71'1:=%&% %7%:

"9%1 -(&-(+

7%1* %1H CD "

%1 ('

& & (-*(<-% ""'+ 7%1 ( %"

%71'1:=%&% %7

:(+ 7%1"71'1(1 %*((%1% %1 -(&-(*-%71'1:=%&% ""%:

%1 -(&-(+ 7%1* %1 CBD ":( '

9'%& " ""'-& %1('%'

%( 8 ""'"%7&(%(1* 7"- "

%1 '

-% *"

71'1 %1 ('

& (-*(<-%'

9'% %8('% '-(%1 ""&4( &' "(&'+%1 ""'&%1%:

(&% *-*(1&(-'17(( (-'1

%1(%1'

-%:&'%A > ( ) .3 "

( "'

( ( ( 8" 8" " ('

( "('" 8" 8"

8 " ""

"" ", ('

( "('" 8" 8" C

" " ) ) "(" ( ! 8" "? 9

" .:C (( ( = "

" ('

( "(" 8" " 6" 7"" ! 8" "? ")

"" !""

" ""

" '

"" ( ) ) " ) ' "( 7" 8 ' " '

" ""C " ('

( "( '"$ ) "( 7 ", " ( ! 8" " ? 8 ( '

" " 6

" "" ('

( "('"$

' ) )

(7" "9.:9/: .4 " "( " 8( ("

" 7" 9.: .4 ' ""'

(

( " ' " " 8" "" ' .5" "'

! 6") 7"", ") ( ! 8" " ? &7. ) " "

" 8" "' "

" ./1

( "" '" / //D"" 6

"E "('" " " "C

8( " ' 7"

8" "

" ./1 8" ' " "

!"6 " )" (("

"( ")" 6' "("" -

)

%*#$+# , C1-&1D @0 -&0