High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1183/2010dismissed

Anil v. State Of Haryana

2022-08-30Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat12 pages

"##

$$%% &'

(

)

*+',- " $$%%

,% %#/- *- )0

+ "#,#% $$%- .#2 "# +'2+

",, #" - #

",, #"

"#" #-

"3' +4# + " #,$#, - !#- - .", #,$ "+

# $$% #" 2# #"

- # 6

7- % # #% # 8'2- )#- 4+ +'2+ "+2 4 2# " # 7- 7 (- $" "

"#" #- ""'- 4+-

"+2 4 2# +, !!" $'#+.% " #

(- "

!##2 "3'# % 2#

- +'2+

$ "#2 - 4

- $" #,$ +#! 9 " " #,$#, - !#- "#"

! " #!

"#" .", 22# #"

"#" #- "3' +4# + " #,$#, - !#- .", #,$ "+ +,- .", % # # ' +2# +# $" # $$% .! '

2# $"' # " "# $$% ;- ( #2- +#

# ""' + -

$ , - '+# (%#" #- ##% >#- )#- 2 #!, # +'2+ %$+- '/4 $ ""' . #2- 2# *( )#- . ,# - )$# %- )#

"#$ #!, # , + "+ - )$# %- . # > #?' 6 >%

+ ,- 60/- #

+// #- #%40 #2- )#

" "% #?' 6 >% '!# ,/#2

5+! - . # ,#"% '33 $%#" $ - @. < - )#- ## +$# % #, 2# "#2 #?' 0 #, " "% #?' '!# ,/

$ ,

#?' "% !# ,/ , - + #?' 6 >% "- 4+#-

" "

*, #%

#2+ # #2

$ ,

+' #%40 #- )#- 2#2 8#$'- "+ 2 ! "#2 #%40 $+ /- 4 .0 2

"%% .+# /#2 +#, $- 4+ 2#2- $$

+, #% , '$ 60/- # #%40 B' - '0 62- )#

)# "",$%#" / / '

4+ +#,

$%0- /- #% .+#

. + 4+0 +'% / '

) 2 8#$'

+#- #% # +0 4#%% +#, 8#$'- 0#2 #%- ",$# 2$$% +#,

#% 2

/#! .%4 $-

'% !%% 4

! !%%#2 2'- +0 / '

A # $"/ -

A ."/ # $"/ $ .# "+

6/# ,.#% $+ .#2 6 ::- ! .", '""#'

) +#- /4 .'

'# " " ##2 "% + #% "', - .'

$ 4+ 2 +#, ,# +$# %

) !' + #% ",$# ! #?'#2 +#, /#! + % ,0- ,.#% '# "- " # / 2# +,

.# !# , -

" " #

( 2#

#2 # "# '

, 4# " # = (

4 "

'2+ # $% $%" ""'" $$

% # + %#! $%" ""'"

4 - +# #"%' , - 4 "

""' #% 2 " :

A +'

""' #% #"%' - /#! ' ",,## !!"- %0 . 2 " " ;

7- " # ' #2 !!" " #

(- 2# (

* (

#" " $#- #?'0 2' %#!- +! " # (

! ""%'# + !,%# # # #2 #- "+%% 2# " # 7A A7 ( !#% "' %%3 2#

#" !!" $'#+.% " # 7 ( 4 9"%'#%0 #.% "' # - +'$ " #

7- ",,# ' % # 8'2- )#- ' + 8.# #2+- + % 8'#"#% 2# - )#-

'.3' %0 # #2 % #% 8'2 ""

! +#2 # $'% "', - #" # $$

$#,!"# " " # " # :- " #

( " # 7 (- '

2# ""'- '"+- "+2 4 ""#2%0 !,

# $% 2'#% 0 "+2 "%#, #%

5+!- $"' # "%% % #" '$$ # "

$"' # 9,# ,0 % 4# - + % ('.%#"

("' "% $"' # #" ! #2 # #" ;> $ (::

(::A

(C ) )$%- )'?

% )+ + 4 2# '$ '"0 4#

5+! - 4 9,# " # (

9$%# "#"', " $$ 2# +, $"' # "

5+0 # $"' # %%2 #- $% #"" "%#, !% #,$%#" #

% "'% $$%% -

#2' '.,## .! ' + - #,$'2 #"

"#" #-

"3' +4# + "- .", $" #%0 "- #,$ "#" % #% 8'2 ""- '!!

2 $# 0- .'# 0 2 ,#$$"# #- $$"# # #" "

3' %0- +0 + 2' #,$'2 #"

3'+- #

#%0- % "'% 2' + - #"

"+%%2 .! ' 4%% ,# - 4 # .",#2 # ! 4# +- '

$"' # " .", - $# # #?'#" #,- 4+ $$ # 4# .9 (C=- $# # (C7

+ $ #"# ""'-

7- #"# .", $

"#"

7- $$% ;-

#,- %0 $%#" "' 0 ; 6 =7

7- ,.0#2 +# !!" " # ' " #

(

'#2 "' $%#" # 2 #-

#"%' (:

#2- 4+# "! 2'#% - , """' '+#%

"$ #"#$

3' %0- '+#% +! - + , 0 #% .", $%#"

# ,0- #"# - ""'-

7- $"' # $%" %#"- $# # (C=- (C7

+ $'$ "'% 4# ""'"

; 3'

9 - .", 2#

7- #

#?'

#" #, 6 >%- 4+ +'2+ $## ,.# ( A- "

&,- +" .", "% !# ,/

5+! #?'#" #, 6 >%

,.# (

- % 2# # $$% ;

+ #?'#" #,- (C7 "'% 4# #"# +" 4 3'# ". #2 2# $"' # "- .", ,.# $$% ;

(C= 9,# ##"+#!

$ + -

'.% #2 #%404%/#2 4 $% !, , $%"#2 2- + '+#%- #% # +- / 4+ 2#2- $%# 2#2 8#$'

,#2

)4- #!# 2$$% % +#, 3' +, + / ,0 +#,

6 +%- #!# #% 2 4 /#! .%4 .,- +! !%% 4- +'2+ '.3' %0 +0 !% # - %0 ! "+#2

A- ,.#% $+- .# '# "

) ',. ,.#% $+ .#2 ::

'#2 "' #!#" # $ 9# " #2 ' (

.", #2- .# # #!#- ' -

# ,0- !" #2 9" #2 " 9,# #- ,# $#' " 4# #2- % , '+#% D',-

"$ #"#$ %2 #%- #"#

) $ . + *$% % , '+#%- !"

"%' '$#"#- "9,# # - 4 , ""'- '% %0

%#2 , "#"

(

- 4+- ,#

! (C= .#2 4 # # 0 #% ""- !" ', $$ + . ,# !"- % $2$+ "9,# # (C=- !!#, # 4

'22 # , % !" "'%- " "#"

#% /4 +#,

(C= +'2+ $ (C7 *$% "",$0#2 +#, # ""- 0 (C7 $ "'% 4# ""'"

5+!- 9,# ##"+#!

/ ". #!#" #- (C=

)4- /#2 , ". # #!#" # (C=- ",

$ "%' '$#"#

.", ",$# !" ', + - " 9,# #- . '.% 0 !#,- ,2 #!%#" /#! #?'# ., (C=

- #"- $ "9,# #- $%#" "+ +$# %- #2+ # #2

$%#" + - 4# ""'"- 0 '.,# - $%#" # "

$$ !" ',- ",$% %0 ' ' +!'%- # #2 #2 !!#" ""- $$#2 # 4# .9 (C + ". !" ',

- #!

!" ', ' +!'%%0 $ (C=- + + 4'% + . 0 $$ '# 0 # #2 #2 !!#" ""- ! /#2

"% #-

&,- .'

#" #,#?' 6 >%- .#2 !# ,/

, - + 2# ;- #"# - ""'

# #%%0 4+ !' + "#.#%# 0 (C7- .", ",$# !" ', 3'

"9,# #- + %#2 4 # # 0 #%- 0 "+ 4 , '+#%- ""#" + "%%#2 + "$ #"#$ - '+#%

6 +%- #!-

+4 '.

"$ # $"' # " # !,

#"#.#%# 0 $# # (C7-

. .'

#%.#%# 0

# -

"$ #"#$ % #"# '+#% %2 #%-

" +'2+ # # # 0 #%- $"#%%0 - % $2$+ "9,# #- ,- (C= !"- % !" "'% ,# - %# !,#%## 0 (C= # # 0 #%- +!- ! # #!#" #- ' - (C= #%- ""- # # #!#" # "

%% " ' %2%%0 4/

5+'2+- $"-

# - " "#"

'+#%- ",

"%' '. - (C= $ (C7- % +#, .'

$"-

# - %

7- ,/#2

$%#"- $# $'$ %0 0 4# #2 # - '% %0 $# # 3'

.", #"#.%- +! ,'"+ % + , ##2 , '+#%- + # #2 #2 !!#" ""- ""#" - 2'- '+#% "%%#2 %' ,- 2 +

"%' '.

5+!- #" # + (C= (C7 +# $" #%0 $#' , 4# #2- # #2 #2 !!#" ""- % +#- /0 "+" # #"

$+0#"% ! ' "

"#"

'+#%- '"+- !# #, # #!#" # ' - %2%%0 4/- '% $# +

%# # #!#" # $- # #!# +, $- 4+ 4 #%.%-

)4 0 %" 0 4'% .", ! -

# #!#" # $- - "'" '+#%- 4+# (=- (C7 +" # #!# '% +# $" #%0 $#' , 4# #2 "#. +#- /0 "+" # #"

$+0#"% ! ' "#"

'+#%- +4- # +$$

5+!- # #!#" #- ' - (C

'$- '+#% + ",

/ "%' '$#"#

)4- 0 # ""%'- # #!#" # !# #,- ' - (C=- (C7 '+#%- + %#,# #2 ' - ,/

!##2 "#" # +#,

!,#2 ""%'# ' !" ', + - #" #"# '% "- '% "'"0 4 +

A- + # , .",#2 "+ ""#" #" #,#?' (C=

3' %0- #!

'#2 "' $" # "' #% # 2 # ""#" - #2 ' #"%' , - 4+# "+ "! +# 2'#% - +! % ,/#2 % "#-

+# $" # # "- # #2 #2 !!#" ""

"3'"- $%0 #2 ' #"%' , - ""#" - "3' +4# + %# "# #"#,# 0 # ,- 4'% ",$% %0 + "%#$ #%%!!" - #!

0- (C=- (C7 + !# #, # #!0#2 '+#% %0- ' - 4'% ",$% %0 '%%#!0- #%%!!" - #!

0- %"/ "#.#%# 0 #!#" # (C7

64- .-

#2 #!#" # ""'#2 9,# ##"+#!

(C- 4+ # #2 #2 !!#" ""- + %#2- '#2 "' #% !"#2 $%#" # 2 #- ,/#2

#"%' , - 4+- '."#. #2 '- +# "!#2 2'#% - .# "!#2 $ #"#$ # +# '+#%- + "#%0 "0 !!" - # 2 #2 %% #%%!!" - #!

03'

!# #, # #!#" #- ' - '+#% (C=

3' %0- "3'" +4# + #%- +'2+

"0 ,, ,.# ( +" "' "# #"#,# 0 # ,

- '#2 "' '+#% D', !"#2 $%#" # 2 #- #2 ' #"%' - .! # #2 #2 !!#" ""- (

#2- +# %0 "! 2'#% - ' / ' "0 ,.#% # # .",#2 +# ""% + # #2 #2 !!#" ""

#2 ' #"%' , $" #%0 ""#" - 4+! $$ # .", "-

+# $" # # "- # #2 #2 !!#" ""- $" # $%" +# /$#2- +##2- "$#"''%0 + "3'# # #0 4 +- '% # 9# " +# $" # #2 ' +- A- % $!

+#E .#2 2# " #

)4-

#2 #" "- #"% 0 !"

'$- + .",#2 $$2 ""#"

3'% 4 #"%' - "3' +4# +

"#- ",$% %0 '22 - "#" .",#2 "" #"# - +$$-

(C $ ( A ,.0#2 $##

&, "%#2 #?'#" #, 6 >% !# ,/

5+'2+- $#,0 #" +!

.", ",$# (C $$#2 # 4# .9- #" (C $ !,#%# " E +4# #24/ '"+- $$#2 # 4# .9

&,- $#2 ( A- ', 0 %"

- %#/4# $ (- "

&,- +" "%#2 '% #?'0 '!! #" #, 6 >%- 2' %#!

"3'"- ,#"% #" ",$% %0 '$$ $# # (C=- '$$ "!# 2'#% - ""#" - +'2+ +# $" #%0 #"%' , - 4+! "' "# #"#,# 0 # ,-

+# $" # # "- # #2 #2 !!#" ""

"3'"- #,$'2 #"

"#" #- "3' +4# + "- .", $" #%0 "- #,$- "#" % #% 8'2 ""- '!!

2 $# 0- .'# 0 2 ,#$$"# #- $$"# # #" "

)" + ,# $$%- #,#

)4- # "%#!# #" ",,# %# 9 #%- ,.0#2 +# !!" " #

(- +" ' 3'

$$# #,#% $$% .#2 6

- '$+% #"

"#" # ,- % #" #2 '

5+!- #!

"#"

.", 0 2 +! - , !# .", $, '%0 % $# $$# $$%- +'$ #,$# # 9 " +%% +! ' # $%%- A- 9 %0 #,$ " +%% ' ""' # "

'$ %#! #,$#, .",#2 #,$- '$- %#! "#"

$$ 0 0 ! 9$#0 $# %#,# #

" 4 ! +4# +

(#2 ,#"%%' $$%#" # - #!

0- - #$

!" ""

#$%&'$ $&#$&(')&*+,-./(&*'0-&12 &'/0