Vijay Kumar v. Suman Rani And ANR

 



      

!"#$%#&'('$)* ++ ,'-!./01!2 3#"'"'$)#2  401!)!)'!)5!)$"6#2 3+#(7$)5#)"(

$2!1*

$)89:#2+0("'&#+4+;!:'! 2#(#)"* 2+(6'(6,#21!<5=$&!"#%$2"6#7#"'"'$)#2+ 2+ >6': /!(6.!7< 5=$&!"# %$2 2+ !2=##) /+ /!"!2'!< 5=$&!"#%$22#(7$)5#)"$(+ + ??? +4+;!:'!<+ 2!: 


6!::#)@# ') "6# ')("!)" 2#='('$) 7#"'"'$) 9. "6# "#)!)" '( "$ -05@1#)"5!"#5++A7!((#59."6#:#!2)#5#)" $)"2$::#2<12'"(!2 !(076#:59."6#:#!2)#577#::!"#0"6$2'".<12'"(!2='5#-05@1#)"5!"#5 B++< $25#2')@ #-#&"1#)" $% "6# 7#"'"'$)#2 $) "6# @2$0)5 $% )$) 7!.1#)"$%2#)"!(C#::9$)!%'5#7#2($)!:)#&#(('".$%"6#:!)5:$25$C)#2(+
 D#!2)#5 $0)(#: %$2 "6# 7!2"'#( !2#
  $) "6# %!&"0!: !(7#&"$%"6#1!""#2<)!1#:.$%"6#(6$7<')E0#("'$)<%2$1C6'&6#-#&"1#)" $% "6#7#"'"'$)#26!( 9##) $25#2#5<9#:$)@')@ "$ "6# C'%# !)5 5!0@6"#2') :!C<2#(7#&"'=#:.$%!-/01!2%$2C6$1"6#(6$7'(2#E0'2#5%$220))')@ "6#90(')#(($%(#::')@&$)(01#272$50&"(#"&+
 D#!2)#5 $0)(#:&$)"#)5(C6':#:#!2)#5&$0)(#:%$22#(7$)5#)" $(+ !51'"("6!"#)"'2#7!.

1#)"$%2#)"50#"'::5!"#6!(9##)1!5#"$ "6#2#(7$)5#)"(!)5"6!"')"6#&'2&01("!)&#(<"6#($:#7$')"')'((0#'(C+2+"+ =!:'5'".$%$25#2$%#-#&"1#)"$%"6#7#"'"'$)#2%2$1"6#72#1'(#(')E0#("'$) $)"6#@2$0)5$%9$)!%'5#7#2($)!:)#&#(('".$%"6#:!)


B D#!2)#5&$0)(#:&$)"#)5("6!")$5$09"<"6#($)F60(9!)5$%"6# &$$C)#2(<2#(7#&"'=#:.!:($6!(!(6$7%2$1C6'&66#'(&!22.')@$)90(')#(( 90""6#(!'590(')#(('($):.502')@1$2)')@"'1#!(C#::!(#=#)')@<C6':# 502')@5!."'1#<6#5$#(90(')#((!(!6!C>#2(!:#(1!)<"6#2#%$2#<!5#E0!"# 72#1'(#(!2#!=!':!9:#%$2"6#60(9!)5F%!"6#2'):!C<2#(7#&"'=#:.$%"6#&$ $C)#2($%"6#(6$7')E0#("'$)!)5"6#7#2($)!:)#&#(('".!((#"07'()$" 
  1$2#($<!(!-/01!2%$2C6$1"6#(6$7'(2#E0'2#5'(5#7#)5#)" 07$)6'(($)!)55!0@6"#2'):!C%$26'()##5(+
A

  
<:#!2)#5&$0)(#:%$22#(7$)5#)"$(+ &$)"#)5( "6!""6#($)F60(9!)5<2#(7#&"'=#:.$%"6#&$$C)#2($%"6#(6$76!(6'($C) %!1':."$(077$2"%$2C6'&66#5$#(90(')#((')"6#1$2)')@!)5#=#)')@ %2$1 "6# (6$7 $C)#5 9. 6'1< C6#2#!( "6# &$$C)#2( '+#+ "6# C'%# !)5 5!0@6"#2'):!C $%"6#(6$7')E0#("'$)2#E0'2#"6#(6$7$C)#59."6#1%$2 "6# 
  7#2($)!: )#&#(('". "$ #)!9:# 60(9!)5F%!"6#2'):!C< 2#(7#&"'=#:.$%"6#&$$C)#2($%"6#(6$7"$&!22.$)"6#90(')#(($%(#::')@ &$)(01#2 @$$5( ') ='#C $% 6'( 9#')@ ! 2#"'2#5 7#2($) !)5 "6!" ') "6# &'2&01("!)&#(<'"'()$"$7#)"$"6#"#)!)""$5'&"!"#"6#1!))#2$2"6#)!"02# $%90(')#(("$9#&$)50&"#59."6#:!)5:$25!)5"6!""$$9.')('("')@"6!""6# 60(9!)5F%!"6#2'):!

C $% "6# &$$C)#2( (6$0:5 5$ "6# 90(')#(( %2$1 "6# (6$7$C)#59.6'(($)C6#2#"6#($)!:($&!22'#($)90(')#((+
G D#!2)#5 &$0)(#: &$)"#)5( "6!" '" '( (#"":#5 :!C "6!" '" '( "6# :!)5:$25<C6$'("6#9#("-05@#$%6'($C))##5!)5'"'()$"$7#)"$"6# "#)!)""$5'&"!"#"#21(')2#(7#&""6#2#"$"$"6#:!)


 D#!2)#5 &$0)(#: 2#:'#( 07$) "6# 5#&'('$) $% $)89:# "6# 4072#1# $02" ') H
   

          

8<         



 < "$ &$)"#)5 "6!" ') ! 7#"'"'$)%$2#-#&"1#)"<"6#:!)5:$25'($):.2#E0'2#5"$(6$C!



 
  2#E0'2#1#)"< C6':# ') H   

  

 +8<       

<'"6!(9##) 6#:5"6!""6#:!)5:$25'("6#9#("-05@#$%6'(2#E0'2#1#)"%$22#('5#)"'!:$2 90(')#(( 7027$(#+  D#!2)#5 &$0)(#: &$)"#)5( "6!" ') H 


   



8< ! "  < '" 6!( 9##) 6#:5 "6!" "6# 2#E0'2#1#)"'("$9#(##)%2$1"6#:!)5:$258(!)@:#!)50):#((($1#0:"#2'$2 7027$(#&!)9#(0@@#("#5$2%$0)5<"6#)##5C$0:5$25')!2':.9#
  ')(0&6&!(#(+
 D#!2)#5 &$0)(#: &$)"#)5( "6!" $)&# "6#2# !2# "C$ !50:" 1#19#2(')"6#%!1':.!)5$)#$%"6#1)!1#:."6#($)')"6#')("!)"&!(#'( $C)')@6'($C)')5#7#)5#)"(6$7!)56!(!%!1':."$(077$2"<'"'(%$26'1 "$(##!("$')C6'&61!))#2<6#'("$&!22.$)90(')#((')(!'5(6$7!)5'"'( )$"$7#)"$"6#"#)!)""$&$)"#)5"6!""6#60(9!)5F%!"6#2'):!C$%"6#&$ $C)#2( $% "6# $"6#2 (6$7 (6$0:5 &!22. $) 90(')#(( %2$1 "6# (!1# (6$7 C6'&6'($C)#59.6'(($)+  6!=#&$)('5#2#5"6#(091'(('$)($%:#!2)#5&$0)(#:+
  51'""#5:.

<"6#(6$7')E0#("'$)<'(2#E0'2#5%$2"6#
  7#2($)!: )#&#(('". $% !- /01!2 '+#+ "6# 60(9!)5 F %!"6#2'):!C< 2#(7#&"'=#:.$%"6#&$$C)#2("$#)!9:#6'1"$20)!&$)(01#2@$$5((6$7 ')='#C$%6'(9#')@!2#"'2#57#2($)+ 6#1#2#%!&""6!"!-/01!2%$2 C6$(#
 )##5"6#(6$7'(2#E0'2#56!(!($)C6$6!(!

B )$"'17:."6!""6#)##5$%!-/01!2'()$"@#)0')#$2
 9#&!0(# !51'""#5:.!-/01!28(($)6!(6'($C)%!1':."$:$$>!%"#2!)5%02"6#2'"'( &$)&#5#5"6!"!-/01!28(($)'(&!22.')@$)90(')#((%2$1"6#(6$7$C)#5 9.6'1502')@1$2)')@6$02(!(C#::!(')"6##=#)')@<C6':#502')@5!. "'1#< 6# 5$#( 90(')#(( 9. (#::')@ @$$5( !( ! 6!C>#2(!:#(1!)+  6# -05@1#)"($% $)89:#"6#4072#1# $02"!(2#%#22#5"$!9$=#!2#=#2.&:#!2 "6!"$)&#"6#
 2#E0'2#1#)"'(#("!9:'(6#5<'"'()$"%$2"6#"#)!)""$ 5'&"!"#"$"6#:!)5:$25!("$C6#"6#2"6#7#2($)%$2C6$1"6#72#1'(#(!2# 2#E0'2#5&!)5$90(')#((%2$1#:(#C6#2#!('"'("6#:!)5:$25C6$'("6#9#(" -05@# $% 6'( 2#E0'2#1#)" %$2 2#('5#)"'!: $2 &$11#2&'!: 7027$(#(+  ) "6# ')("!)" &!(#< "6# #='5#)&# $) 2#&$25 %0::. #("!

9:'(6#( "6# 
  2#E0'2#1#)" $) "6# 7!2" $% "6# &$$C)#2(< !( C#:: !( !- /01!2 !)5 "6# :#!2)#5 $02"(9#:$C6!=#!&&$25')@:.!)(C#2#5"6#'((0#')%!=$02$%"6# :!)5:$25+$#='5#)&#!((0&66!(9##)7$')"#5$0"%$21#"$"!>#!='#C 5'%%#2#)""6#)"6#='#C"!>#)9."6# $02"(9#:$C+&&$25')@:.<%')5')@)$ 1#2'"')"6#')("!)"7#"'"'$)<"6#(!1#'(+
  ::7#)5')@&'=':1'(&#::!)#$0(!



























 ++ #
$ %&  '%%  
( )* 
  + ,*- '%%    
  + ,*-