← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/47/2015dismissed

Sukhwinder Singh And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2016-01-217 pages

   

       

     !" #$%&

"'()*!+,# *!-( !+ !./(,# 011,22 !/3 4,#3"3

/ /,.5 #$ !  !+ !./(,#  0 ,31.!+,!/3   67

8

8   97

8

   

#,3,!/ #8!'*/( "+( #*%+4.: /,5.#/(, 11,22 !/3

  %8

.8;<=.5 (,1# $,#> +,*!/(, 112*: /*.!*3/.:.!+.!,/(, +,2 $.5<+ $3*!5*2*!-/(, 11, 28

"55*:*,!/: "3,( 3?,,!3(.)!*!/(, 112*: /*.! 5.#/(,:.!+.! /*.!.5+,2 $8,!:,%/(,+,2 $*3:.!+.!,+8

 

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

8) 3 ##,3/,+ .!/(,3 >,+ $8,3"55,#,++*3:2.3"#,3/ /,>,!/C8 8;.! 888!1"#3" !:,/(,#,.5%(,*+,!/*5*,+/(,12 :,)(,#, (, ( + 22,-,+2$ :.>>*//,+ # 1, )*/( 11,22 !/ .8 4*+, +,!/*5*: /*.! ,>.% C8 88 , ) 3 23. -./ >,+*:.2,- 22$ ,C >*!,+8 ! :.>12,/*.! .5 *!4,3/*- /*.!% 5*! 2 #,1.#/ "!

,:/*.!;#8 88) 35*2,+?,5.#,/(,#,  -*3/# /,8  11,22 !/ .8 22,-,+ /( / 3(, ) 3 # 1,+ ?$ /(, ::"3,+5.#/(,5*#3//*>,*!(,#(."3,*!,:,>?,#%; !+ 3,4,# 2 /*>,3 /(,#, 5/,#% ?"/ 3(, +*+ !./ +*3:2.3, /(,3, # 1,

; *!:*+,!/3 3/(, ::"3,+( +/(#, /,!,+/.'*22(,#("3? !+8/ ) 35"#/(,# 22,-,+/( /.!88%/(, ::"3,+ 3',+(,#/. ::.>1 !$(*>/. *#3 *! /# *!8D(,!/(,$-./+.)! //(, # *2) $ 3/ /*.!% 3(, ) 3 -*4,! 3.>,/(*!- /. , /8 5/,# :.!3">*!- /(, 3 >,% 3(, ?,: >, "!:.!3:*."3 !+ #,- *!,+ (,#:.!3:*."3!,33 / E..# (*?% !+,+ ( # 3/# )(,#, 3(, ) 3 +>*!*3/,#,+ . /( .5 3,:#,:$ #,- #+*!- # 1,% 1,#1,/" 22$ +#"--,+ !+ ) 3 +,3,#/,+ ?$ /(, ::"3,+ /

*2) $ / /*.!%B 2 !) 2*.!888 (,1#.3,:"/*.!*!.#+,#/.1#.4,*/3: 3,%,C >*!,+ 3> !$ 3)*/!,33,38 / /,>,!/.5#,31.!+,!/.8"!+,#

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

 /( //(,1#,3,!/ 11, 2*3:.>12,/,2$+,4.*+.5>,#*/35.#/(, #, 3.!3/.5.22.)8 * (, 1#.3,:"/#*C 22,-,+ /( / 3(, 2.3/ (,# :.!3:*."3!,33 / *#3  5/,# :.!3">*!- 3.>, 5..+ 3"?3/ !:,8 (, @."#!,$ 5#.> *#3  /.  !+,+%

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

 )($ /(, 1#.3,:"/#*C+*3:2.3,+(,# 1 33).#+ /. ::"3,+)(. 22,-,+2$ ?+":/,+ !+# 1,+(,#8(, 1#.3,:"/#*C !.)(,#, 22,-,+ /( / /(, ::"3,+ ( + 5.#:*?2$.?/ *!,+ !$*!5.#> /*.!5#.>(,#8 ***  2/(."-( /(, 1#.3,:"/#*C% 11,22 !/ .8 #,/"#!,+ (.>, .! 88% ?"/ 11,22 !/ .8 11#. :(,+ /(, 1.2*:, .! ;88 !+ (,# 3/ /,>,!/) 3#,:.#+,+.!/(,4,#$3 >,+ $8(,

.2*:, / /*.!B 2 !) 2*5#.>/(,(."3,.5 11,22 !/3 *3 / ) 2'*!-+*3/ !:,.5>*!"/,38/: "3,3  3,#*."3+,!/*!/(,1#.3,:"/*.!4,#3*.! !+3"11.#/3 /(,#,31.!+,!/63: 3,#,- #+*!-(*35 23,*>12*: /*.!8 *4  !./(,# 3/.#$ 1"/ 5.#/( ?$ /(, 1#.3,:"/*.! *3 /( //(, ::"3,+-./ +>*!*3/,#,+. /(.53,:#,:$/. /(, 1#.3,:"/#*C #,- #+*!- # 1, .# ?+":/*.! / "#"+ ) #  (*?*! ( # 3(/# 8/*3"!,C12 *!,+ .!/(,#,:.#+/( /)($/(,1#.3,:"/#*C+*+!./# *3, !$ 2 #>/.! ?/(, ::"3,+ //(,"#"+) # */3,25 *5,4,#$/(*!-) 3!./+.!, ::.#+*!-/.(,#)*3(,3 !+:.!3,!/8 4

"'()*!+,# *!-(% ("3? !+ .5 /(, 1#.3,:"/#*C 3 D+,1.3,+/( / //(,/*>,)(,!(*3)*5,2,5/ /(, (."3, 3(, ) 3 ), #*!- -.2+ ? !-2,3%  -.2+ :( *!% -.2+ /.13% /(#,, -.2+ #*!-3 ?"/ )(,! 3(,

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

-( */ *3 /(, : 3, .5 /(, 1#.3,:"/*.! /( / D<  7 2* ,4* :.22,:/,+ /(, : 22 +,/ *23 .5 11,22 !/.8 3),22 3.5#,31.!+,!/.8%?"//(, 3 >, ),#, !./ ?#."-(/ .! #,:.#+% )(*:( # *3,3 3"31*:*.!/( //(,1#.3,:"/*.!+*+!./) !//(,."#/ /. '!.) /(, 5 :/ /( / 11,22 !/ .8 !+ /(, #,31.!+,!/ .8 ),#, *! :.!3/ !/ /."

 ./(,#1#*.#/./(,88 !++"#*!-/(,1,#*.+ 88 !+88 (,#, #,3,4,# 2./(,#> /,#* 2:.!/# +*:/*.!3*!/(, /,3/*>.!$.5/(,1#.3,:"/*.!4,#3*.!)(*:(+,>.2*3(/(,: 3,.5 /(,1#.3,:"/*.!8 ../(,#1.*!/( 3?,,!"#-,+ !4*,).5/(, 5.#,3 *++*3:"33*.!%),5*!+!.>,#*/ *!/(, 11, 28::.#+*!-2$%*/*3+*3>*33,+8 8             !" #$%& B