High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/372/2013disposed of

Shahid Iqbal Bhatti v. State Of Punjab

2017-11-21Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri33 pages

$ #% &'# ( (# &'# (# ((

% $ # &'

% ' "

( !"

# (#) ) * !'+ $ , !'

#"- . /

1"- &"

2 "- #"- )" "

4$ -"

* 5$ 4$

4$ -"

5 $ )-+ 7 ".

8!) /0

.* 9 $ )-+ 9 ".

8!) /0

.* 9 $ )-+ ".

8!) /0

.* 9 $ )- +

8:!) 0

7.* / $ )-+ ".

;!) 9

.* 70 $ )- +

/ ".

:9 0

.* $ )- +

8 ".

/ !

4< 0 5: /0

.* 9 $

" = "

" 0 "#= -"

80 " =

/)) !":/ 4 >) !

) ?5

- " ;

;! -+3 -=

0 ! ,"1- -%@ +)& -

77/+)"'= - +)"'= -

9+)"'= - 7 )+# -

897= "0 - ' !

** 2*79 0+)1- -

- "0 - -

-(-!

A 0 ( %' 2

- ! 0'

- ! - !'

0 0 !' + $ , !'

-"/0 =

- "

" $#- +$#- +' ' - "B! :;778*79888 "

#3 & )3 876 6 "0) C&

= %'! += -

= !'

- 0 ='

- - 0 +=

= " ='

# D0=

- - 0

0 - !'

- 0 -= "

0 !"

# =="

-)=' % - + = - =' '=

- ,"

0 " - - 0

= "

! - " ! 1- - "-)

+# - 06$ : ;

/3 : 86 - :89 !

:9 /!

4< 0 5:

8: 7 / ; ! ) 4 E E5

! - -=

" ' -

-,"

D - - )

3 = 0 0 =

0 $# - + $# -

3 " - =

!' + $ , !'

'-= " - - "

0 =

" " -

+ ;

;

#3 &

" & = %' ! = ==)!B = " == '

6 /9 - 089 - = " !"

+ - $# - '

"'B)3 ' "' '! C!

" $#- $)0 - B!*$*; = '

3 " !

= '

" "

= "

0 "

;

0 * ) - = " - !'

0 C - "

& = %'! !" " -

" - " =

' % 0 "

, )" ) " " 0 " = "

D = )"

= = -* - "

8:88989;8;/!)

:9 /!

4< 0 5 : /3 :/ 8 6 - :89 = -"

" " C = 0=

!A % ! ) % - ' ! +3 ! ""

97999/7 $#-

+ "

$#-

= - 0 " "

87& = ! D "

= " 0 %

," = = "

D =

<C ! "

'<C !

<C !D%)<C ! +" "

;

0<C !( 0"

+ 0 <C !+ !A1- & D

% -

' ! )A ! =

- ="

!# ," = , ," 0 = =

"0 "

+ "

- !# ," <C !1

'<C !, -<C !& D '

!A/%

," & = "

-)0))38& = !

9= "

= "

- !"

#3 & "0) C)3 87& = ! "

' $#-

"=' "

)0) "

" $#- -" = F./ 0 - -

" " '! =

= "

) 0 "

9 "

+ " " %' <C !

" "

%'6 +

" %'( <C !

D ;

; '

= "

!'+ $ , !'

+" "

" -

$#-

- 0 !A81- -

$D3 "4B !

5 "- " - -0 -- B!*$*;= = $#- +$#- 2* + - " $) =

" 9 9 + " $# ," $-

<C !A8.

+ $) $#- " 6 :

9<C !A8.

88 ' 8<C !A8.)

" 0 " & ' $ " %

" ) <C !A8. ;87 "0$#<C !A8.< <C !A8.6 <C !A8.( 0 0+6) '&

. <C !A8.+ " <C !A8.1'

= 0$D34

5 , --= <C !A8., - - *79;;.9

" ;

;

9 0 $# ," $-

4D 53 $D3 "<C !A8.&= = 0 &%2 " <C !A8.% -= <C !A8.

" - = 0

*C 0 = - 0 = - 0 '

= - - 0 $#-

" -6$ = =

)" "

!A7 0 ) ' %"

) ""--

" $# -

+ "

" <C !% -= <C !

)<C !G 3

1 - % 3 + <C !%.

- "

0 %

3 + <C !%.

- "

+ <C !$

" $#-

"--

" /8 =

$# - 9 :;= E =

2* + - " + -'

=" " 00"

" "

" $#-

= "

; E '1- E 0

- /8=

;0 %< <C !$

= =

" !

0 - <C ! -

D =

= -- 0 -

!A9% -)" % -B)3 ' " " '- -

- "

$#- "

$#<

2* + - " + "

" !

D =

' ' <C ! "

<C !2 <C !H " <C !@ - 0

' "

::7; = = 0 "

= ' "

!A & - $ , ' )"$ " "

- "

::7;

$#-

D =

- -= - "

<C ! $#- " 0=0 "

<C !

6 9<C !)) - 0

1 "

$# - <C ! 0 0

" 0 "

<C !<<

' ' <C !66 + "

= 0 ""

0 - "

'0"

!A;! '#)"- % & )"- , " " - "

-<C !2 "

= D"

- " ='B)3 ' = "

$#<

" " " " "

"%' "

-<C !H D '

% -!

- " "

" + '

0 '

= "

"' $#-

!A:% # - - 2*+ - " 0

$#- "

+ "

= "

- ' +

- = 0-

- - "

" " D =

= 0 ' "

0" " 0 "

0 " +-

0 "

" 0= 0- -

C )" !A #06" , ) + - "=

- 0 " "

) "

" -0

" 0 6

&0 - 4B !

<C !(( " "

-= +

* C 0 06$ - -

+ " "

- " = = - --0 "

<C !%./

!," ;

; = ! 1- "

= 00+3! -= "

#3 & 87"0) C& =

%'! "

= "

6 "

=)!B '

)

<C !I<C != '&( !

<C ! <C !/ <C !8 =<C !7= '

= 0+3! - = -

E!E "

= '

<C !(( D =

" /9 - - % 0

4<C !9 <C !75 89 - 0 - <C !7J = " <C !7/ <C !78J !"

# <C !77J

+ - <C !79J <C !$

" "

$# - J"

$#- <C !<C !66<C !

<C !)J

'<C !7

" !# ,"J!

<C !7;J ',',2*<C !7:J D% <C !9<C !9

" $# - J $)<C !A8. $#- 0 -- B!*$*;= "

<C !++J D - " . = = %+)"'= -

- 7 ;

;= = 0 0 +3! -

- -= D - -

)

&" 4$" "

= -0 ! - = " ' " - 0 ) - - "

+ "

0 "

= = 876 6 & = ! + " <C !11

- "

<C !

" ='

0<C !GG= = 0 D - !A %

! 0 6 - $-

$- 3 - "

,//9 8 / 7"-)! $

+ " !'

/ / 7 + " " " " <C !A. <C !.

-= % <C !A.) !A/+) - '

!A8$ # - 6$<C !33 = = - 0 "! -

!A71- -==

00! -= '=

-"0 ;

; ! - / -

, "

"= ! - -! -= D - - * )

&" 4$"

- ,"

- =

0! -" = < " =

= 0

0 $#- "

, !'

+= 0 - '- " -

7 -

= D =

;.* 0 ' " "

= - =

" =

+ '

-<C !98 <C !97<C !9 0<C !9:

-= - - <C !<C !:8 + "

!A9+ - - - -" = "

-)0 ) ) "+= "

I 0

)0 ) I ) " & =

- " !"

) = '

= 0

$#-

+= "

- " "

C 0 + '= "

" - = "

" - =

& '

<C !DD =

D =

!A +) (" - = =

%+)! 1- ;

; ! - = =)!B " : - " / = " '

'! "

$)0 -- B!*$*; - ' " "

;.* !"

# D"

0- - 00! - - -3 '

!A;!# ,"= #0," ! " "

= -"

' - =

' "

= 0 "

0 =

*C " "

!A:

! - - -3 = 0 "

-"0

- 3 ;

;

- -!'

!'+ $ , !'

0 - 0$#- +$# - = "

- >!"

? "0) C! == "= - 0 !'

- =

# = " 0

"<C !:." = 6$=

. - "

!) 3

6 - !

:9!

4< 0 5 : = "-)

$# ,"

D E 'E 0 = D - # E 'E 0 & !

= "

-,"

-" "

= - = 0 =

3 " 0 $#- + - " + -=

' = "

- = + - - - 0

0!A71- -

3 -

)" !A ) 2 % =

- ( 3 (

- + G"A ) ) % + ! &" 4$" 5 -= "

. - '

0" <C !,, <C !&& <C !A.<C !A.

<C !A.)<C !A.<C !A.< <C !A.6 <C !%%- K <C !A.("

<C !A.+- K

<C !A. <C !A.1 - " <C !A., + -

0 " =

+= " = -

= 0 = 0"

A C "

// ) !

) "

07 A

= ," 0 "" <

0 " =

0 " = 0 "

#" !"

# +

0 0 +

0 #"- <C -= " <C

- - "- )" "

- 0

" - $#- %"

" - $#- +$#- " -!

+= %"

) " 0 !A #0 6" %"

+ "

- '

" ! '

= -"

- "

+= 0

" -

+ = " -

)-+

/8 9

" --

)-+ ; - 0 " C"

$#- - = " 0 "- = "!

== - "

DC "

6" # -=-

"= # -

= C =

0 - "

# - 0=

C )-+ :

0 )- +

- - 6

- !'

- 0

0 = = =-=-

( " = =- - "=-

/ !) " = "

"0 '

(

:9) !

) "

0" "- = - =

)-+ 7 -

:/ %"' -!!!1- &" = " ' "

/3 :/0

0 2 ," B 0 4+5 (

! 0

4+5( !"

#) -

0 " = =

0 )" '- K +== - )-+

79/ 8

D )" "

" 0

-= =

)- + 7

- 0 " - % 2 D

" .

"$)0 B!*$*;

" "

" 0 0 "

8!) !A81- -

3 $D3 " 0 - -

" - 0 " "

= % 2 D

- - "

8!)

)-+ 9

- 0 " -% - ' ! & = !

"D%

- - "

8 !) 0 )- + = -

- 0 " - % - '! & = ! B)3 ' " ' "

" "

" D% " '

$# -

D " C !A% ! ) % - '! = - -

- '"

'! "

" $#-

0 +

0 0 !A/ %

," = " =' " =

C !A9%

- )" % - B)3 ' " " - -

- " "

B)3

' "0

" $#-

0 !A& -$ , ' )"$ " " " -

' 0

" $# - "

0 D

' "

B)3 ' " 0 !A;

+ ! '#)"-=

- "

B)3 ' = - "

! % - B)3 '

!A%

! 0 =

- 6 - $- $- 3 "

- 0 % 0

8 / 7

/ / 7= " =

% % . ) 0 , )=' +

$ & 4!'

" $#-

" - C "

//) !

) 0 07 =

," = 0 0 " <

0 !'

" = + 0 - " 6 "

' 0

"- " " 0

0 "

" $#-

, += " C 0

" ," '

-= ," B " "

= )"

0)-+

)-+ = -

0 - !# ," %

," 0

- 0

" -

$# - 0 " 0$D3 "'

- - "

8: !) !A; !# ," " "

)A! -

" =

' '

- - - - %

," =

C !A/ -

-" ' = 0 = "

- "

= - )0)0

$# - 0 " = '!

= "

- 0

- " $# -

- 0

)-+

)-+ = -

- 0

" -

$# - = ' "

+ "

;!)

)-+ /= -

- "

:9 6

" "

" -

"$)0

' "

- - D%

" D

-!'

-"-" = "

- "

)-+ 8= -

" !A%

! 0 0

#0 " 0

4< 0 5 :

& "

" =

- =

- 0 " - - -

- 0)"&"

" # - =

- 00'

- = #

- =

< !# ," =

- "

' ! =

- 0

= =

C !A;

" "

' - =

" "

0 = -

" -

C "

//) !

) C

0 " -

" "

" "- "

" 0

. & "

" " - - - -

" "

)-+ =

"= 0

" )"= #"

- " "

" 0

- #" )"

" "

= = 0

" 0 0

C )-+ /8 9 +

0 - "

= #" )"

&" 0 )""

" # 0

= - - "

8:!) -!# ," %

," "!A;!# ," " "

0 '!

)A! -

" =

!A/%

," -" '=0="

= - )0 ) 0

- $# - 0 " = '! "

- "

" "!A;!# ,"

" - " C

C - "

8: !)

0= !A/%

," " "

- 6 - # - "

" -

= -0 )" +== # - C =

- 0

C -

)-+ :

"- "

- -

= "

"= 0 )" )" "

" 0 "# = -"

/ ) !

) D

)$%/98;8 - "

= "

- -

- '"

6" = "

- 0

" - -

- %0 6

" "

!) "

" 0 " "

:9 "

/ !

4< 0 5: "

" += " "

:9 !

4< 0 5:="

" 0 - "

! )

-0

- -"

:9 "

4< 0 5:

$ "

0 )" " D " )-+ 7"

8!))-+ 9 "

8!))-+ "

8 !))-+ "

8:!) )- + "

; !)

0 " )- + / "

:9 )-+ 8"

4< 0 5:

" += "

)- + / "

:9 )-+ 8 "

4< 0 5:

" 0= "

)-+ 7"

8!))-+

8!))-+ "

8 !))-+ "

8:!) )- + "

;!)

)- + 79

" 0

" "

- -"

" "

- -"

/ 0 "

)- + / 8

D "

)-+

-= "

D ) */* / )$%/98;8 0

! (#$ /01 ) !# (( $ #0* A '

L .