M/S Prakash Marketing And ANR v. M/S Bector Food Specialities Ltd




     


!"

#$#$ #"

%&' ()'*+,+ -  



#., %/%,0#% /'&+-1%-)%- &0'

2'&+&+ -'

3'

,4, #.,'*& , ) 5'*+%6+&+',7&) 2',5 -)'-& # 87#  9

7  ','-&
# 3+,0%6% 1 % :%-%;)< *%&'%-) #  +,0)''5# %%);)< *%&';%-) # 3%,4 0%-)+6=%;)< *%&';( &0'5'&+&+ -'

#, 4>%-?+&9%4 ;)< *%&';( &0' ',5 -)'-& 



 9

7

 "

" 0 410&0'5 ','-&5'&+&+ -(+6')4-)'

'*&+ - @
 &0'

5'&+&+ -'

,  ,''/  A4%,0+-1  (  )'

 )%&')    

  &0 410  :0+*0  &0'

))+&+ -%6 ',,+ -,4)1';74)0+%-% ( ,0 &;&0'%55'66%&'* 4 &" '?'*&')%- %556+*%&+ -(+6')B=&0'5'&+&+ -'

,,''/+-1&0'

'+-5'

>+,,+ -& * >5 4-)&0'

(('-*'4-)'

&0' '1 &+%B6' -,& 4>'-&,*&; @@  ( ,0 &;&0'*&" &+, (4 &0'

5 %=')&0%&,+-*'&0'5'&+&+ -'

,% ':+66+-1- & -6=& 5%=& &0'

',5 -)'-&&0''-&+ '*0'A4'%> 4-&B4&%6,  '%)=&  '%, -%B6=* >5'-,%&'

+&;&0'* >56%+-&B'% +-1 #.C

C.
 $







    









 
%6 -1  :+&0  %66 * -,'A4'-& *'')+-1,;+-*64)+-1&0'5'&+&+ -'

,D* -<+*&+ -;B'A4%,0')+-&0'6+10& ( &0'14+)'6+-',6%+)) :-B=&0' &+- 


  
 !
 " !!

"

0' ',5 -)'-&(+6')%* >56%+-&4-)'

'*&+ - @ (&0'*&

E
F

B'( '&0'4)+*+%6#%1+,& %&' ,&6%,,;74)0+%-% ( ,0 &;&0'& +%6* 4 &"

&0 410:0+*0&0'5'&+&+ -'

,:'

', 410&& B'5 ,'*4&')( )+,0 - 4  (% *0'A4'1+<'-B=&0'>& &0' ',5 -)'-&( %-%> 4-& (,
;!;.$(&'

,+(&+-1&0''<+)'-*'6')B=B &05% &+',;&0 410?4)1>'-&)%&')  

 &0'& +%6* 4 &* -<+*&')%-),'-&'-*')5'&+&+ -'


& 4-)'

1  +1 4, +>5 +, ->'-&(  -'='% %-)& 5%=(+-' (,
;.$+ '*&+ -,:'

'%6, 1+<'-& 5%=&0'*0'A4'%> 4-&%,* >5'-,%&+ - 0'5'&+&+ -' ,(+6')%- %55'%6%1%+-,&&0'%( '* -<+*&+ -%-),'-&'-*'%-):0+6'&0',%>':%, 5'-)+-1;&0'=(+6')%-%556+*%&+ -,''/+-1&0' '+-+,,4%-*' ()+ '*&+ -,B=&0'

%55'66%&'  * 4 &  (  * >5 4-)+-1  (  &0'  (('-*'  -  &0'  1 4-)  &0%&  &0'

5'&+&+ -'

,:'

' '%)=& 5%=& &0' ',5 -)'-&- & -6=&0'*0'A4'%> 4-&B4& %6,  '%, -%B6=* >5'-,%&'+& +-*'&0' ',5 -)'-&)+)- &1+<'+&,* -,'-&& &0'  5'&+&+ -'

,D  5 5 ,%6;  &0'  %55'66%&'  * 4 &  )+,>+,,')  &0'  5'&+&+ -'

,D %556+*%&+ - &+,+-&0','*+ *4>,&%-*',&0%&&0'5'&+&+ -'

,0%<'/- */')&0'

) , (&0+, 4 &,''/+-1 '6+'(:0+*0:%,)'-+')& &0'>B=&0'%55'66%&' * 4 &

"

0'5 ','-&5'&+&+ -*%>'45( 5 '6+>+-% =0'% +-1B'( '&0+,  4 &  -  



  -  :0+*0  )%&'  6'% -')  * 4-,'6  (  &0'  5'&+&+ -'

,4B>+&&')&0%&&0'5'&+&+ -'

,:'

'- & -6= '%)=& 5%=& &0' ',5 -)'-&&0'

'-&+ '*0'A4'%> 4-& (,
;!;.$B4&%6, & (4 &0'

* >5'-,%&'+&& &0'

&4-' (, ;;.$ &:%,(4 &0'

,4B>+&&')&0%&&0'5'&+&+ -'

,:'

'%6, :+66+-1& )'5 ,+&* ,&,+-&'

>, (&0'14+)'6+-',+,,4')B=&0' & +-

"*%,' ,45 %"

"

-&0'6+10& (&0'%( ',4B>+,,+ -,&0+, 4 &+,,4')- &+*'+-

',5 -,'& :0+*0#, 4>%-?+&9%4 ;)< *%&';%55'% ') -&0' ',5 -)'-&D, B'0%6(0'

'%(&'

;&0'5'&+&+ -'

,%-)&0' ',5 -)'-&0%<'%1 '')& (+-%66=

EF

B4 =&0'0%&*0'&+-*%,'&0'5'&+&+ -'

,: 46)5%=& &0' ',5 -)'-&(466%-) (+-%6%> 4-& (, ;

;.$

"

)>+&&')6=;&0'5'&+&+ -'

,0%<'- & -6=5%+)&0'%1 '')%> 4-& & &0' ',5 -)'-&B4&0%<'%6, )'5 ,+&') G (&0'*0'A4'%> 4-&:+&0&0' 7'1%6 '

<+*',4&0 +&=;4-?%B

!"

-

"*%,' ,45 %"&0' &0%)6%+) ) :-14+)'6+-',%,& 4-)'

:0+*0*+ *4>,&%-*', (('-*',4-)'

&0'*&* 46) B'* >5 4-)')0','14+)'6+-', '%)%,4-)'

$ H
I+&0 '1% )& &0'5 ',,+ - (6+&+1%&+ -+-*0'A4'B 4-*+-1*%,',;&0' 6'% -')&& -'='-'

%60%,4 1')&0+, 4 && ( %>'14+)'6+-',( %1 %)') ,*0'>' (+>5 ,+-1* ,&, -5% &+',:0 4-)46=)'6%=* >5 4-)+-1 (&0' (('-*'

&:%,,4B>+&&')&0%&&0' 'A4+ '>'-& ()'5 ,+& (&0'* ,&,:+66%*&%,%)'&'

'-&(

)'6%=')* >5 ,+&+ -;,+-*'%&5 ','-&;( ''%-)'%,=* >5 4-)+-1 ( (('-*',%&%-= ,&%1';0 :'<'

B'6%&');1+<',%-+-*'-&+<'& &0') %:'

 (&0'*0'A4'& )'6%= ,'&&6+-1&0'*%,',( ='% ,-%556+*%&+ -( * >5 4-)+-1>%)'%(&'

,'<'

%6='% - & -6= ',46&,+-&0',=,&'>B'+-1B4 )'-')B4&&0'* >56%+-%-&+,%6, )'5 +<') ( '(('*&+<'?4,&+*' -<+': (&0+,,4B>+,,+ -;:')+ '*&&0%&&0'( 66 :+-114+)'6+-', B'( 66 :')  7



+" -&0'*+ *4>,&%-*',;+&+,5 5 ,')%,( 66 :, #$
0%&)+ '*&+ -,*%-B'1+<'-&0%&&0':

+& ( 4>> -,B',4+&%B6= > )+(+')  >%/+-1  +&  *6'%  &  &0'  %**4,')  &0%&  0'  * 46)  >%/'  %- %556+*%&+ -( * >5 4-)+-1 (&0' (('-*',%&&0'(+ ,& ,'* -) 0'% +-1  (  &0'  *%,'  %-)  &0%&  +(  ,4*0  %-  %556+*%&+ -  +,  >%)'; * >5 4-)+-1>%=B'%66 :')B=&0'* 4 &:+&0 4&+>5 ,+-1%-=* ,&, -&0'%**4,') # $ (&0'%**4,')) ',- &>%/'%-%556+*%&+ -( * >5 4-)+-1%, %( ',%+);&0'-+(%-%556+*%&+ -( * >5 4-)+-1+,>%)'B'( '&0'

#%1+,& %&'%&%,4B,'A4'-&,&%1';* >5 4-)+-1*%-B'%66 :'),4B?'*& & &0'* -)+&+ -&0%&&0'%**4,'):+66B' 'A4+ ')& 5%= G (&0'

*0'A4'%> 4-&& B')'5 ,+&')%,%* -)+&+ -( * >5 4-)+-1:+&0&0'

7'1%6 '

<+*',4&0 +&=; ,4*0%4&0 +&=%,&0' 4 &)''>,(+& # $ +>+6% 6=;+(&0'%556+*%&+ -( * >5 4-)+-1+,>%)'B'( '&0'

',,+ -,   4 &   %  +10   4 &  +-  '<+,+ -   %55'%6;  ,4*0 * >5 4-)+-1>%=B'%66 :') -&0'* -)+&+ -&0%&&0'%**4,')5%=, G (&0'*0'A4'%> 4-&B=:%= (* ,&, #$ +-%66=;+(&0'%556+*%&+ -( * >5 4-)+-1+,>%)'B'( '&0'

'>'   4 &;  &0'  (+14 '  : 46)  +-* '%,'  & 
G  (  &0'  *0'A4'

%> 4-&J

"

0'*%,' (&0'5'&+&+ -'

,( * >5 4-)+-1,A4% '6=(+&,:+&0+- &0'%( '14+)'6+-',

@"

-&0'6+10& (&0'%B <';&0'5 ','-&5'&+&+ -+,%66 :') 0'

E F

(('-*'( :0+*05'&+&+ -'


0%,B''-* -<+*&')B=&0'& +%6* 4 &+,

)'

')  &  B'  * >5 4-)')  ',46&%-&6=;  * >56%+-&  B'% +-1

#.C

C.
 $







  
 


 





 %-)%66,4B,'A4'-&5 *'')+-1,&0'

'& ,&%-),A4%,0')

* ,&,  



































E9

7F ,0%>,0'

 I0'&0'

,5'%/+-1.

'%, -') ',.

I0'&0'

'5 &%B6'

',.