Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab
! "#$#%&
' ()#*#%+, -%.
) /& 01/
!
" # $%&! ' ( $"&"'! ( ) * & " ++++ 2
,- --.'
& / '0
'( * 1 & ( & , & 2 3 "( 4 '5662 7 83
9 ( '( '
:---;* '
1 &
&< "
"
& $ ;$ --
( =< > :- --
;
. & . < "4
' !('
( 1' "%
4 "% ?@"
%!&"
4
&
/ '0
5-. -- <( A 0
1 & <( A 4 (
:---;* (
9
' 9 2
3 - -: --
---;*
0
!&"'B 1'/ > & ?@"
(
---;* %!&" !&"
! & '
C 4
) (& '4D
> & !&"( @
"%
&<1 & ( > &
0
(
(
?@"' D
?@"
' "
& B 1'
/ !&"A
'=< ?@"&
'
"
& $ "% > &
'
'> &
'( !&"
D
D
' D
( ?@"! '
! & ' (
'
( ( D
' D
( ?@"4 ' D
D'
D
D ' D
( ?@"= <( A
( =< > :- -- "
& $
D
( ?@") <( A ?@"
( '
& , 4
4 " 2 E4"4E3 4 .* (
& -,4"4'
& , & 2 3 ( -6- -- '
:* < '
@
(
F* @ & 4"4 ( =< > :- -- & '
' C ' & F<"4
"( % % (%
< ' "% >(% 5-. -- 0 & &>'
&
/ '
9 ' A .-. -- ' (
"( % % (4 !&"B D
/ 0
( "% ,* > (
6* A (
' ( & , & 2 3
5* ( (
-* <( $%&! ' ( ' ' $"& "' ! ( ) *& " ( @
* < ' $%& ! ' ( '
' ( 0 ' 0
' ( 4 0
( 0 * &
> & ' ( 0 "
& '
B 1'/ B 0
(
* 0
4 5-. --
.-. --
( ?@")
> .-. --
<( A =
"-&</
& ' 9 <( A =< > :- -- ' >
.. -- &<1 & ' @?@!11
0
'
& '
0
' (
' .4$ 2 '
56
5*#7#% (6 '
2 * %!* , 9( ( *#: !# 4$ -.
2 '5;6 5*#7#% (6<= #* %.
%, #4$
*#$$
56 5*#7#% (6'>= .* 0 (
" "% (
" > & '
D
' '
( '".! & "5 !&" % (
'
(
:* 0
D
( F* 0 D
<( A (
,* 0 "F 1 !
' 0 4D' A & & "
'
' & & "
& '
(
' -%.
)4$*
7.# #%+,
5'6 5*#7#% (6><
' ( 6* A ' ! ( ) & " @?@!1
"
& $ '
"
& <
.. --
0
'
'
0 > & '
'
'
! & "5!&" %= '
' (
D D ' ( 4 5* <(
-* < '
(
< & 4"4'
.-. -- '
.-. -- '
--: -- - -: -- 1
.-. --
* "5!&" % D
"
=< > :- --
& F;
& .< "4
'"
& $ ( ?@")< ( '
' ( > ; . C
'
( > 6: 6, C <
'
(
' & '
"%
>( % 9
.-. --.
( - -: --
""
'
.-. --
( ' (
<
> .-. -- '
@?@!1' ( ",$04 %'"
& $ "-&< /
& ' 9 <( A =<
> ;
-- "
& $
1 &
"
& $ ' @?@!1 ?@")
=< > ;
-- "
& $
.
"% "
( '
5-. -- > .-. --
(
(
0 < > .-. -- (( (@ "5!&" % D
=<
> ;
-- ' @ (D ( ?@")
?@") <( A ' ( =<
> ;
-- > .= "-&</
& ' (
"
!&" %& ' =< > ;
-- ( "5 !&" %'
"
"-&</
& (
"5!&" %' D
( ?@") > .
< "5!&" % D
=<
> ;
-- 0
@
D 9 @ D =<
$04 "
&
$04
"5!&" %
> .-. --
< ( .-. --
( ' ( (
( ( 1
(
< D
( > .-. -- ( @ D =< ?@!1
' (
"
& $ < >
.-. -- ( @ - -: -- ' ' (( @ > . D
"5!&"
%
@ "5!&" % (
$ ('
0 ( ( <( A 0
( (
B "5!&" % D ' @ ?@!1
.* ?(
.-. -- "%
>(% 5-. -- = "
'
=< .6<
>(%'
>(%<
"%(
> 6, C 4 ' ( "%< ( D ( ;
7:8 ( 7.8
;
7.8
;
E E< ' E : -- "%'
E .. -- E
( >
' .. --
<
(
' D .. --
'
"-&</
& '
"
& $
' "
" % (
"% ".! &
"% > &
&<'
(
'
' <
( .-. --
- -: --
:*
@ (
.-. --
( "%
@
<
.-. -- ' ' (
( 1
D
F* < ( (
--: --
( .-. -- D
& '
>(
.-. -- ( > .-. --
' '
' 4 9 ' (
--: -- - -: --
,* ""%
--: -- ' ( ( - -: --
:---;*
---;* '
!&"B "5> &
0
' > & "& $ 0 > &
"
& ' > & ' (
---;* D > & ( ' / ( ' 1 &
B A ( D
6* " > &
"%
"
& "% (
"% 0
" % D
"%
'
' "%"% (
---;* ' '(
9 0
0
!&" 9
$ ( D
" % " > & '
'
---;*
" %
5* C ( ( ' '
( D
9 (
= "5!&" %
9
"
& $ <
@
9
:-;F-
&0A
(
" > &
'".! &
"5!&" % <( A D
9 (
G ?@"4 ?@"
9
"
& '
'
"%
' ( -*
( " " %
(
---;*
D " > &
"%
'
" % " % (
---;* '
( (
(
D D <( A ' D = & C '"4 @ = & C ?@"'
& ' D ' ;
D D
@ ' '
D < @ '
D
( * <
7 $,?-7 *-8 4$ / !,3
! $,'<<>5'6 5*#7#% (6< 2
(
( 0 8@4 (
' '
D <
/, *7 4$ %!,* ! $, ''5'6 5*#7#% (6 ';2
(
( **( D 0 8@4 (
% 4$ ?
*%
'
6 5*#7#% (6>>' ,-( #%+,4$ #7 ", (
! $, '
56 5*#7#% (6'
( (
'
( ( D
9
(
'
D D
(
9
(
"" % ' " > &
' ".
! &
"5!&" %!&"
<( A '(
(
9 & 4"4' (@
D
9 <
*7!, %! * (# $
*)!,, %! *4$ -%.
)
>56 5*#7#% (6;<2 (
D
( 4
@
---;* < ?
%$,#
74$ -%.
)
>5 6 5*#7#% (6
( >
@
0 8@4 (
< $@ % #%+,4$
<5;6 '2
---;* ( < 4 (
<( ' (
'
( '
' ( ( .* ".! &
C **4 A / 0 <( A 0 ( ' ( ( 0
& '
' " "% '"
> &
'" ! &
"5!&" & '
---;* " %
(
(
& ' .4$ 2 3'
* %!* , 9( ( *#: !# 4$ -.
2 3 #* %.
%, #4$ *#$$ 2 3' '9
:* A ' & - (
( ' / !,-9 *, $9 ** $,#4$ / , $, *
6 5*#7#% (6= 56 F* <
?@"/"F&<;0 4D1!
(
?@"/ 0
& & "
<
@
D & & "
# - &&" ?@"/ 0 ( '
&&"' (
' ?@"/ & & "
<
,* < 7#( !- 4$ 7!
%'<<;
-885'6-8* 7 -* $ $'' ! B
(! (
A
A 0 4 &
' 8@4 ( & '
0 4
&
0 8 @ 4
6*
4
9 $, #A# 4$
-%.
)'<<'56 " % *#7#% ( 8* $2
'
<
( 5*
0 8@4 ?*#$,% 7-* ,3 4$ ?
*%
56 5*#7#% (6
<2
D ' .-*
?@"/
D
& & "
?@"/ @
& ' ?@"/<(
'
-%.
)4$*
7.# #%+,2 3' ' .*
'D (
'<
( 4 .
9 ' (
* 0 0 :
4 / $ '0
'
<' ' 4 / $ '0
' D (
!&
' 5 6