← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1321/2006dismissed

Jarnail Singh v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-14Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

 

     



    !"

# $% &&##  '"( )( *+ &         )" 

",% -. "%&&##  "/%## -/-)( *+   &&## 1(!"

# $%2"+3#"

&# !($-4"5&(" 467  

"  ( " 8 7""($ )3%"&(+ -  98 %" """":  -)# "-45#,  .*($; 8

-%2 . %"%  ( " 8   ";"" 8

-%2   ( "$"$"(;&" ; " 3" &3  -

-

1  (#%"("%"( "$"$"( ;&" ; "&" 3"

 "#3-%%-&"%&"(

." "%  

-6/("&" $%-6 %"$)#) " 2#-)# "-45#, %" """"% .$ $  "16   2  % $    &#  &"3     %3  2" &"  %".##$/% 2# #-2%" %( $%

  (,%" $%;%6 %2* 2%%&#&"3< 2% %&#&"3&"("%" 

 2%&"## $ %"%%+"$ #; " %"/% 2#! - (!"

# $%2&; $ ;"3#";% .##$%( <  $%&#&"3-%("("

+,+(%2 "&< + $ =("+(-%(#%

; %"&"(#"<%6 #%(%%(&; > ;"#+ $"" %;"3#-%""2  "%  % ;    %  % (  %   "$%  $  %  "% (%" &" ;$5""$"<% ($.%& %"%+$ ( &"  $5"<;; %"$"2&"&"-%(;+;",+3 %( +3%2 <" $#3)2" &  $%2(;; %&-2%"%%"# $2% $.% "( %( $%%2$5"

&45#, %%(%#$#"$%$%"% ( &" ;%"$5""$"< %2."-%("&% )2" & $%-"$" 2%%  ;;2&"&"-%(;+;",+3%( +3%2   ?%""-  "( )2" & $%-6 ("%%2+$-2%%2"# %;"3# %(<%2"(   &&&3"2<%( (# &"( 3# "&";"& % "+ ?%6 ,2;&#8 $";%";%+$-&"&"

 ("&"&"#%"<%"; $&&&3"2 %+$2 ( +8,$<%+$2"# ." &"#-% ## %>&"#2"#+3%6 2%%#+" $;&"  :/:<)2" & $%#&(%#%. $ "& ::

##%&"#<;&##;&" %6 )2" & 2",  %<)2" & $%,&%#2%%;#- 2%"%6 "(% ."%#&".2 %(  $%<% % "&"&"32,  &#& . "."3;; ?%6 .$ $ " "(=%&# -

%+2%%";#462""(2" $#3 "" %&""(#-&"&" $"=((; ?% .$ $ "&"&""($%&# %&#"."3 ""; 2 

 "("

   %  &#   -  % 6 .$ $  "

% ."% "&"&"36@# $%-% A %&# -2%#%&"&"32%%# %. $;&" @-&"&" $;&##;&" ?% % &"&"3 %(2"&"(+"#"

$"-2% &  (%   ""  (" $  %  ("     .$ -  % ;&#&"#2" %%;#B>; "-)( *+- % $"% &""&"".%"";-%2"( + %    &&&3  "2  "  ;&#     .$     %"

";#-%## $ %(2&"&" # % ("



&"  %%## -&%"2"(&&# %("- .$( "  C") ?%   +". $%&";%"$"  ( " 8%2#$ %(-%2 %"$%" $#3-2%%-%&# $(#3 #; "# (" $%(". -%&"( >;  %##2 $2 

)DA/(". $%-%""";&#&"# ;&##;&" %%;#B>; "-)( *+- % $"%  &  %    # $    %  "#  ";     % & - ;&" $%"2%%, &# )D6@# $%-% $A %&#

  

-&"$" $%&" $% "".#% &# -%6 %&"(%(# $2%% &"&"3+"%; %%#%&"&"32%%# %. $ "& :@:&"&" $&; #;&" %""

, &#& % "&"&"3.%  $."

;;< % >3-%&"(%(  "&"&"3 +"$"+ $(%  ""A% ;&# &"# ;&##%%;#B>; "-)( *+- % $"%%"($%A/(". $% # $%&"&"3 ";  %&  %"%;&"2%%; "% ##2 3+3# )D  6  (" "   $%-  2%  (" $  %  ("  

 .$ %""; 22 & % "$" )D )2" & $% 2%&" %+$

& %(%+ "%"(# $ "."3 "+ -)D8 +#(,%&# $%-2 "."3 )D 6/("&" $%-6 -2%2% $%&#&"3-2%%% &&"% %( "."3";%;-(&&"% &"(  "3    ;"#  &  &##3  2%  "$"    % "."3 "+ ";%& %(6 

)D 6/("&" $%&"$" $% .$ $ (+3 %;&". $."((;  ?%&"( "#(&  ."# (;   #( "&"";%%;#B>; "-)( *+-% $"% B>) #%&"( . ; %(2""( "  ")- 2%%##% ";  $"(;  %&"(

.   &&" $  $   %; 2"  &(    %;  +(  %     % ##$    $%%2

  %+ ##3 .#. % 

?%( # 3.  %  ?%  "#  ("  %  ";(#  %  ##2 $  &   "

"; 

 D%    %       >; $    %   #3   &   2 "."3+3%&"(

D%%"%# ,. ;&#E

 

D%%"%&" )2" & $%%&# "."3&".+3 " +#(+E

.D%%  # $4@";%&E  "%" $"$(; -#"

"#(" .   %(;  +.-2%%#%;$$". %%#%&" &&#-2%%2, (&  

-2%

2;""$(#"%" $ "."3 23(" %&  3%&&#

&&# ( " 9 ") %. $+ #+3%&&## 1("(&  %  ;&" ; (" $%&  3&&#-%;2##2 .""8

C "; $  %&&## 2 (& (" $%&  3%&&# %2;+#- % #"

!-4"5&("

 72%&&#%;(&" #%" $ 

6%.%"#"

( #"%&&## F( .-#"

/"%)( *++$ $%"($%% "" 8 A"  %  2     "."3  ;#3  )D  ) 2" & $%-)D8 +#(,%&# $% )D 6/("&"

 $%%.(##3(&&"%&"( "32%"$"( %. $+ (   (&  "+  ?%32" ">; # $% +%#%(+(%3(,%" $(  (# +%" 3;"#&  7&".(  ;3+2 %; %(F .%+ ##$"

&".&";&+32%%%3;$%%. .#.%( %

 2" $#3 &$ %;##3("% .

?%( $. +3%)D;(+2"%3"#  

4";%; %"2 )DA/(".

 $% )D6@# $%-;(%%&"&"3% ";  (3 %;&#&"#%"%% %;#B>; "-)( *+-% $"%2%# &"% %;#B>; "-)( *+-% $"%#$%2%  "# $% #3%;&#&"#2"(  +%&&&3"2 C @"

( #"%&&## %,%;&($  *($;  ."($"( 4"+ $% 8%%

+ ;&#2%-( $&"*(%( 9 A2."-"$ $%"($%%""-6  ;3#  $";   2%  %  #"

  ( #  "  %  &&##   4";  % . +"($% ""+3%&"( -;(%"

"."3-%(# $2%%&"&"3%+ &"( +"#"

$"-2%%(% %&"&"3 %%&"&"3%";  (3##%;&#&"# "%%%;#B>; "-)( *+-% $"%   

  %"  "$(;   .   +3  #"

  ( #  "  % &&## 2% #"2%%"2$%%+$%+

#(">#(6 3-6 %%   %&"( %8,$&&&3%(,%+ "."";% & %(6%(2 -%(#%.$

 #" ";%6  %"$"+(2  ?%2$% %+$ % ;(%"#. 8 ,$%&&&3%(, ;2%   ;;"#=( 3 +3 "% ;$  - +%2$%+$2;"% ,$ +" $ $%=( 3 "+ "."+#% 8 ,$

 ;;"#=( 3B. %"2- "; 8% -2%"% ".   .#.=( 3#"% ;;"# =( 3+($""% ;##=( 3-% % &( %+#"

%;&" ; -2%%;3>  3"  -2%%;3 > #,%B. -, %%2$%"." "+ (#+#% 8 ,$+(% +" $% 2%   ;##=( 3?%""-%""&( %; (& 6" 3"  #,%?%&"#3%&( %;  ;&+3%"#(" %?%""2$%%+$+ ;"% ,$"#% % ;,;(%"  

)  $    %  "."3  ;;  #"

  ( #  "  % &&## % "# & $;(%# %#2"&"  %;;% %(&&"&" -%" "%(; (+(#  "&"( $%(; -6 %%($%%& +2 %#  . #3&"+(,& $ .2%#3 %"(; -%(; 

+" %"."3 % "+ ";% (& %(  +#%;#"#3-%+ & (%%(;+;&"  %(&&" %2" $ %  ;;?%( %(#%.$ "3#" ";%6 2% %&&"

 %("(" $%"#  

 !"!#

$%& '

(+3%(&";(" &&# "#

-2+".%#2 %& ."3 #"%. %" 3"&"("###$#3  ( %"% 5("-%. ##%"+32## +; ;+# %("2(# "##%"(;   (2%%" 3"(&"*(%+ (%(6% "% 5("2 ;&# %#2 &"(" %"2 3&+#3%. ###,#3%.+

;&"2%" "&#(" $%("(%"%"5("- % -(#+%%.  #+#+;+#

.  ?%&"( %&".%"$$ %( #(.#3     ";.#3   ?%  (  (#    " "   " +#"&#(+#>&#  "%##$#;&#  "

(#%( "& % "+ 2%( 3# "

&";  %"+3  %2 $  %  %  2     (  &    % "+ 

"$"%  &"-%(2   ( "$ "$"(;&" ; " 3"-2%%%; ;(;

&""+      "  &    ;;"#  =( 3    % "+ B. %"2-%&&## 1("&( "3+  &&#32%#. %#%&&#%"+3;, $%;

, $"($?%"($&#"%.((##3"3% #+"("3 #3(%%2" $(#&%(%3&

  &"  +#2%";#3 "

#3  3;&%3

+%2 %;#%%(#&".+( "&"(. "(#  ""($", $?%""-%  2"% &&## 1( ( + ."3%$%  ## " 3"(

8 ?%;&($ *($;  . ""  &+3%"#(""2## "  -+(& &"&"

&&"# &&" .  "" "&" #2 ?%" ##$#3" ";3%" ?%*($;  .

 ""  "(&%#2%"%&&#( + 2%( 3;" %;;" $#3 

6"#. ;  %"%(  &&"  %(%" &" "%"($%( #-%  +#+#2""  2"""+(&"%"&"".-%% +

"" #$ (+!#-45#, C @"

  %  !(#  $"-  45#,    "   ."3% % ,("%" "3  %;" ;,%&&## (( "$%"; $    &3    %  *($;   +       !-  45#,  "

"3;&#    

  !"

  #   $%&'

()%* $+!',  &) % #   *& $-.

 &) %