Avtar Singh v. State Of Hy.
!"#$%!& '() *+ ,,,,,-- .( )( ,,,, -
(
/(, , ,+(#' (+-- , /(,.'0) ##( , -- 2'() *++-(((+ -- + * *3 *4 ((%5,%6,$%%$-7 + ( ) *# -8+(7 +-- +7 '(+ -
+7
() !& +(( * +(-) 7 9(+(: ) :;#!<=&
(*(*( 4-( 4 (
(7- !#%%#%%%>? +(
(*(*( 4-( 4 ( (, ( (+ 4+@ 4(#)# A6 8 -( !=,%5,$%%% *8+ +() *+# 7 )8) *+ 7 48 ( +7
# -,-( 9-- ;8 * - *
7*7+(8+(7 * *8(+ *(+
37--,+(8 +(*
7*
(+- 7* 8++ + -( 8 *, + -( 4 74 +*++- -( , - #)
4+@ 4( *8++(--(+ +4,(' +
4 (7'() *+ (+ ) *+# @+ - 3-# ( # ) ( # ( +(- (,
( ) &% ) 8 (' - +4,8--(++8 -(( * 4 ( 7 +- *
7*, 7 *0# 8++( + 8 0 7 (+ + -( 4 B ((/*(#+-- -(+(+ 7 + -( /*(, +((# )
4+@ 4(# -+ 03@ 4(#+ (# A&#
'
-(4 # - (C +4(++- (( , 03@ 4(# A&(++- *8++( 447( '( 4 3-,8--(+,
03@ 4(# A& ( +4 + + ( ) 4+ @ 4( (+ + 7* 8++ + -- 8 *,)++7*8(- , + 7*#D"0*--- + 08
++(- *
7* $60*--- + 08
,)4- $&%*(4+(47+ +7*8-(,)-(4- 8(-(-( + (4 (--- + 08 4 8-( , + ( -( 8(-( 8+ @ 0 -
' ('( 44 E,
# 8++8 7 03 @ 4(#+ (# +() *+ 7 )8) *+, ) ( 8+ '( +() *+,
CE, 8 +- +78++(4 E,
>!8((, 4 +*+( 8 *+ - E, 8 -(-( 7 ) 4+ @ 4(# A6, 8 (4( ((, -(-( # + 8 8( -( 7( *+7( ) *+# ) # A5 ( '( , *+7() *+# A5'(+ '* E + ) + (-( ( A6#) 4+ @ 4(-+-(-( 8+/,-(-( 8 +((-8+/#(+@ 4(# A!,)4- 8( ( ) F7(( # /+ 7 @( ( E4 %5,%=,$%%%,)4- 8( --- (8,
4- '* #(-(
() !5D (, ,,8-( ,-- ? 4( ,+(*8 (4 * + ( + -
+7
( ) !&+ ), ( E4 4 ' 8 -(' , -- ? 8+ * (4 * 4( >' - +4
( ) D!D (, ,, -
4- ,' 8 , F( ( ( --( ' (( + + -( + -(' 7 ( 7 7* + +(7 ' *+4(+ -
+7
( ) !& + )
!
* +4 7', **(' +((4 -( -- +7 -(((, F(
(+-- '+4 (* ++-- ++7 4- ,+( ' (( -+-- +-( , ( (4# - 8 + 7
+4 *('( 7 +-( '
+ *+ 4 - + + * ('( 8 +7 8++7 - (C 7
47(-- , 74+ (8' *+ 747 +- - 8 8++ '+ (( , (+((* ++4- C 8 ( ( E4 + ( ) F7(( /+ 7 ( -$% ,+( - 7 E-
(+ ( * +4- (E4 , +((#' 4-( *
(
(+(4(# ( 7 ) 4+@ 4(# A6+'7
+ '( +() *+#8++ 7 E4 7 +-( ,+((# ' + *
, F(
(+-- 74++ +-(-( 8(
77(0 8+ -(
(+4( ,) -8( -( ,+((#( * ( 7 +'( +-( '( ,
(*+84- (4++7*+' 7 0
"
7 +- #8++4 ( ,
(+(4(#+(
4 0(+ )F(4, ( 4+ 4 A!#/(+@ 4( +(-, (+( 74++-(-( 8 '(-( 7(+ /*(#8++ ( 4- +-- , ?4- 4 ( -(' ) &% ) - + *+4++('( + 7 4 (4+-( +-- ,8'(# (
(+ -- 74+ ( *' +
() &%+ )+(+ 74- -(-(4- 8++4 8' ('( (4+-( + , '8+7'#)+, , ,+(# (
( +-- '+4 (* ++ ' +-- 7 7,F( ( (+44*(' ((( ( (4- -('(3 *4 ' *+ -- ,+((#+-( ++-( -- 7 8 +-- 7C ++(** +4, F(
(+ )8+ ( *+7' (* 4 74 + +( '(8+ 4 * '
(( 8++ - + -- ,+( ( 4- +-- +, +'
7 - 7 +--
(+(4(# 0' + 4- +( * +-(+- 8+ 4- *8+4 ( -(' + ),#+((# -( ( -+ *+ ' 4- - +
# -- +'+( (
(+-( * +( *++((,7( (4+((++-- 8 * 87* ( +7 # -,8 --(+ - ,8 (4'44E, + +(8 - -( ( 7 +7*
8+++8 * +++- +' *+(+ +-( B((/*(, -- -((( (+ 7 7( /*(, C # 03 @ 4(# A&# 8+ 8 - 7 + (# -E( *+-8(E '/*(8 +-,(++- +-( + +(+7++7*8 ,+ + +('( (4+-- ? ,+( +( '(4 4 + ' ((+8++ ( 8( 4
( 4 +-- , + + E*( * +-- 8+8' 8 +4,4 +'7 *4 + -(' ((, + #7 - 8
7 +-( , ++-(
'( 8 +'7 73*(( 4( ( , ( '(
7(3
?3 * - 8 8+ +('
((+8+++-( ( 8(+ , )4 ( #+(* 4 (7 (
(+ -- + +( 8 ( 03 @ 4(# 7
+ (# A& 7-( +6,%%-,4, (
7 ,
7 4 *(<,%%,4,&,%%-,4, 7 03 @ 4(# A& 7 + 4 4 + + - -++8-( 7 6,%%-,4,
8++ 8(0,+( ( 7 ' ((+4 +8 +
,
( (4-(77 (+ (7-( + 6,%%-,4,+( 7((-(+7 (8(0 *( &,%%-,4, / +(+7 ++4- 8( (( E4 ( ( 8++' + ( , C (( !=,%5,$%%% + 4- 8( %5,%=,$%%%, ( +(-( ( ) F7(( #E, ( ++ + 4- 8(
+ 8+-4 -( +(8( * +( , '# E, # + 7 74 7 7 4() *+# A$++84- 8*+ *$&% *(4+--- + 0+' * ) @ *8+4 ' ,!&%%5,%=,$%%%8(+ '(+4 + - + 4 8+ )F# /+ 7 # @( - + (- 70 + ((*
4, +( 8 4-( *+4- (+4- , )4 ( # A! / (+ @ 4(+ 74+ 'E, +++-(-( 8- 8++4 !=,%5,$%%% ++ '(+4(7 *
$ -8+ )F/+ 7 %5,%=,$%%% 7 4( ) *+,+(8 4-( *8++4 + ((*
4, + 8( (' 7 E, # )F(-(, + # *+4- +F7(( -(' +-( ,+7 + 7 + :7 ) -(4 ( %&'()(*+,-.&/0/1%1.20*3%4$$ 0)&.5.0&1%/./""
+ 4 ' + + -( 4- ( (' 7 + +4 E4 (#+ # -(' 7 + ++(8 4-( *8++( +4- * + 4- (' 7 + ( +4 E4 +4 (7 8++8('( (4+- + , +#+ "% *+4- (E4 8
(( ' + #--( ++ *+ 4- ( +4 E4 44( + ( 4 + -(3 +7 + -- , ++ )F(48 -(-(+ - 7( (4+((, ) 4+@ 4(+ - ++-(-(+ )F(4 +-#8++ 8*(8((4+) >) ,+*( + + )F(48-8++/,4 +7 7 ('7 +-- (4+4 A!/(+ @ 4(++ 404 7 + )F(4 + 4
( ) !6! (, ,, + *'
( 4 +, - 8+'( ' -( (
40('( * , 8+(+(+ B (8 4- 8 -7 ' 0 +' 7
4-(8+( (- ( *+ ( +(+( B (+ 7+ ++( ' +
, +( + * ((+8++ (7 C
8 ('((4+-- (+84-(8+7 + , +( (
(+-- ++ +-(-( -( (8(
7 ( >7(0 + - 7 *-( +(
- + 4- +-- +8++ (7 8 '( ('( (4 + -- , + 7(3,) 7C + -(-(
7 ' 4- +-- '8+ *' , -( +(( (' +(4 * +-( ( 87 +- , 4 + ('( ,6%0*--- + 08('((4+ - +-- +-( +- 8 A&8+87+ (+4, ((+ +( + * (( +8 4 8+++ 4*++'* +-- C , + 7 + 7 + :7 ) -(4 (
7,%&%5)%8(*+,9/1%1.20*3%4 6#$+
- 7 +# ( -( 4+ + -7 4 +44+ ,) &" +(-( 4- * +-( - ( , -- + + 7
7 (7 +-( 4- , + # + ( 4 +# -7 ++-- +7 4-
+ -( , 44( C --- + 0 + 7
('( (4 + -- ,+( *(
8+'( 4- * + ' 4- - +-- , +( (4 ( * + ' 4- - +-- ( +
-(' *7 ( 7 7* +-- , +((* 4 +7 (, C #+-- 4, (/% (88 0'+.
!"#$%!& (