High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/886/2012allowed

Harish Kumar v. State Of Punjab

2018-08-23Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri5 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()** +&',-./+ ******00!11( 2!+'.' 3 !"#.(45 ********!'0"($!(

) 67 * 3 ** 67 * 3 - 73 +!'!( )

+*3**3*3&$,.8$9"% !8 #"+00!11( *

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

$";+<+ &%1!'&( ,!',0!"#&+"(5"A8"(!'"#'! 8"(!$".51!5!$828 !#+&=!+ "+8 ""1!+($5". "1'"# ="1$* "1$;'=&9!( ",!+ $.=, !+<" &($,!+&(1;'#/&1<*. ;,!(,!+$.=, !+;'0+!=(( 8 ,!+'"(&(1;+&',3,+/$!/($!$/" "+%<%1!#+"/ ,!/*:,!( ,!+$.=, !+=9!5&+ , "'"(8 ,!<=9!="1$%,&(;!&=,&(=D.+ !+ " "(! "1 ",!+$.=, !+6''"(8!++&(="(! "1 " (4& -.+8/" ,!+&( 1;"#<" &* %%"+$&(= "+& !'8%1" ,!';!+!=&9!(($"(!/" "+%<%1! !+""($''&"(1.';'=&9!( "%%.'!$85. ,!+$.=, !+;'5!&(= ,+''!$5<,.'5($($,!+&(1;6' #/&1</!/5!+'8(/!1<819&+

,($# ,!+&(1;

8 (4& -.+/" ,!+&(1;

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

"#0(%,< "#9&11=!?&$0.+($0(%,< "# ,!&+9&11=!($ "( ,!&+ E&(=+!'0"('&5&1& <8<" &;''!( ;& ,%%.'$0+ <8#"+;,&%, ',!;'(" 0+!0+!$* (*B*8 5". F) &( ,!/"+(&(=8 (=&+&71,.'5($"#%"/01&(( +!%!&9!$0,"(!%11#+"/ +&', 3,+/ , <" &,$!A0&+!$*:,!(&(D.&+!

,";<" &$&!$8+&',3,+/+!01&!$ , &( ,!/"+(&(=8;,!(<" &$&$ (" ;E!.08,!%/! "E(";5". ,!+$! ,*:,!( ,!<%/! "E("; 5". ,!+$! ,8 ,!<1"(=;& ,+!1 &"('+!%,!$,!+$.=, !+6'&(1;6' 9&11=!?&$0.+* ,!&(1;'#/&1</!/5!+'"#,!+$.=, !+ ;!+! E&(= ,!$!$5"$<#"+%+!/ &"(*,!<' "00!$ ,!/&( ,!%+"''&(="# 9&11=!($&('0!% !$ ,!$!$5"$<"# ,!&+$.=, !+*+".($ ,!(!%E8 ,!<#".($&(4.+</+E'*,!<0+!9!( !$ ,!%%.'!$#+"/%+!/ &(= ,! $!$5"$<($&(#"+/!$ ,!0"1&%!8"(;,&%,$$& &"(13 8 "1&%!

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

1&9&(= ,00&1<*"$!/($;'/$!;,!(%,&1$;'5"+(85. ,!<=9! ,!=&# ' "# ,!&+";(*,!+ &%1!' ,! &/!"#/++&=!;!+!1'"=&9!('=&# ' ($ (" ' $!/($ "# $";+<* ,! ;& (!'' ;' $!%1+!$ ,"' &1! ($ '!+%,&(=%+"''!A/&( &"(5< ,!$$1***#&1!$ "!A +% (<#9".+ #+"/ ,!;& (!''* :(=&+&718# ,!+"#$!%!'!$81'"' !$ , '"/!

F $&'0. !,'+&'!(# !+ ,!/++&=!5! ;!!( ,!0+ &!'85. 1 !+"( ,! '/!;''! 1!$* &'$.=, !+,$/"9!$(001&% &"(8&(;,&%, %"/0+"/&'!;'!##!% !$($%%.'!$,$ E!(<" & ",!+/ +&/"(&1 ,".'!*!' !$ , ,!+$.=, !+;'(" ,+''!$5<%%.'!$*!%((" !11' ";, &' ,!%.'!"#$! ,"#,!+$.=, !+*:;'1'"$!%1+!$ ,"' &1!5<0+"'!%. &"(($&(%+"''!A/&( &"(8,!$&$(" /&(%!!9!( ;"+$5". ,+''/!( ($$!/($"#$";+<5<%%.'!$*,!+!#"+!8;!+! "# ,!9&!; , ,!$!/($"#$";+<&'(" 0+"9!$* "('!D.!( 1<8& &'("

0+"9!$ "5!$";+<$! ,8 ,".=,& &'.(( .+1$! ,* ,!+!#"+!8 ,! &(=+!$&!( '"#3!% &"(@ +!(" #.1#&11!$($%%.'!$%".1$(" 5!

%"(9&% !$.($!+3!% &"(@ * :!+!"# ,!9&!; , 5.+$!(&'"( ,!0+"'!%. &"( "0+"9! , & &'(.(( .+1$! ,"(%%".( "#$!/($"#$";+<;& ,&(<!+'"# /++&=!* 3&(%!&(=+!$&!( '"#'&$"##!(%!+!(" #.1#&11!$8 ,!+!#"+!8 %%.'!$&'=+( !$5!(!#& "#$".5 * "('!D.!( 1<8 &'11";!$* ,!&/0.=(!$4.$=/!( "#%"(9&% &"(($"+$!+"#'!( !(%! $ !$**80''!$5<$$& &"(13!''&"('.$=!8!+"?!0.+8&( '!

"* "# 8 %"(9&% &(= 00!11( +&', -./+8 #"+ "##!(%! .($!+ 3!% &"(@ 8&''! '&$!* ! &'%D.& !$"# ,!%,+=!'#+/!$ =&(' ,&/*!5!+!1!'!$#"+ ,;& ,8&#(" +!D.&+!$&((<" ,!+%'!*,! #&(!8&#(<0&$85!+!#.($!$ ",&/* **

- 73

** '4E'

:,! ,!+'0!E&(= +!'"(!$ ) !' "

:,! ,!+!0"+ 51!

) !' "