Manoj Kumar v. Mahesh Kumar
"#$ %$&'(')* ")+,-."/ 00$11")# 2$/(-( "3$(3,-."/")%")#3$/ $(0)%$)#(
* 45 , 5 /$($)#* /%'#6""(("-/7%8&"#$7 /7 / 52$/."7%8&"#$7 /#3$"00$11")# /3'8,-."/7%8&"#$7 //$(0)%$)# /"/8$$)99"/:"17$0-#6 "/6")"7
//$(0)%$)# ;3$#3$/#3$$0/#$/( 1&"1)$:(0"0$/."6<$"11:$%# ($$#3$+-%9.$)#= <$/$ $//$%##3$$0/#$//)# > ;3$#3$/#3$+-%9.$)#(3-1%<$/$0/#$%')#3$%'9$(#= , 5
5!
>? 3$$9'(#/6'(%'/$&#$%#"(('9))-.<$/##3$"00$"17 ')8'$: /%$/0"(($%<6" /%')"#$$)&3 #3'( -/#) >@ 7 9/")#')9 1$"8$ # '1$ "00$"1 "9"')(# #3$ +-%9.$)#
"&A-'##"1 %"#$% @ >7 0"(($% <6 #3$ 1$"/)$% -%'&'"1 "9'(#/"#$(# 1"((7"/'%"<"% "')"00$"1 .0-9)$%')#3$0/$($)#"00$"1'(#3$+-%9.$)#%"#$% @ >70"(($%<6#3$1$"/)$%-%'&'"1 "9'(#/"#$(# 1"((7
"/'%"<"%78'%$:3'&3#3$&.01"')# '1$%<6#3$0/$($)#"00$11")# -)%$/$&#')>? #3$$9#'"<1$)(#/-.$)#(??7:"( %'(.'(($% (0$/#3$&"($ #3$&.01"')")#73$"%8")&$%"1") (>7
##3$"&&-($%)
B7 /#3$0-/0($
0-/&3"(')9"01#"#,"."')"+"(#3") 3$"&&-($%'((-$%" &3$A-$ <$"/')9 B@B@B %"#$% @>
@7 / ( >7
7 %/":) ) )%'") ")C7 $&#/7 "/'%"<"%7 ') "8-/ #3$ &.01"')")#7 /#3$%'(&3"/9$ #3$("'%1'"<'1'#63$("'%&3$A-$ :3$)0/$($)#$%<$ /$#3$")C:"(/$#-/)$%<"&C"(-)0"'%:'#3 #3$/$."/C(4&&-)# 1($%4 5$"/)$%0/D6&-)($1"00$"/')9 /#3$1$"/)$%&-)($1
/ #3$ "00$11")# 3"( "/9-$% #3"# #3$ "&&-($% 3"( "%.'##$% 3'( ('9)"#-/$( ) #3$ ("'% &3$A-$ 3$/$ /$7 0/$(-.0#') -)%$/ $&#')(>?")%>@ #3$$9#'"<1$)(#/-.$)#(??7:"( /"'($%"9"')(##3$"&&-($%")%'#'( /#3$"&&-($%#/$<-#'#3$ 1:$/ -/#3"(:/)9163$1%#3"##3$0$/()(7'):3($0/$($)&$ #3$1"):"("%8")&$%7:$/$)#$D".')$%<6#3$&.01"')")##'( (#"#$%#3"#)&$#3$&3$A-$'(0/8$%")%#3$"&&-($% "'1$%# %'(&3"/9$#3$<-/%$)7#3$&"($ #3$&.01"')")#(#")%(0/8$% $1'")&$3"(<$$)01"&$%)#3$"-#3/'#6 #3$)4<1$-0/$.$
-/#')'#$)"1"12$/(-( /"#')%/")"#3")$/+$$7
>!
/'.')"1!
> 3"8$3$"/%#3$1$"/)$%&-)($1 /#3$0"/#'$(")%3"8$ "1(&"/$ -1169)$#3/-93#3$ '1$ #&.$(-##3"##3$1:$/ -/#3"(#"C$)#3$8'$:#3"# :3$)#3$1") (>7
:"("%8")&$% /#3$0-/0($
0-/&3"(')9 " 01# <6 #3$ "&&-($%7 ) /$&$'0# :"( #"C$) 3$ 0$/()(7 ') :3($ 0/$($)&$ #3$ 1") :"( "%8")&$%7 :$/$ )# $D".')$%3$(#")% #3$"&&-($%')(#"#$.$)#/$&/%$%-)%$/ $&#') >> / '( #3"# 3$ )$8$/ '((-$% #3$ &3$A-$ # #3$ &.01"')")# /%'(&3"/9$ 3'(%$<#/1'"<'1'#6"#3$/73$&1"'.( #3"#3$3"(9'8$)#3$<1")C&3$A-$"(($&-/'#6" #$//$&$'8')9#3$ 0/'E$.)$6')&3'# -)%1##$/6##3$</#3$/ #3$&.01"')")#7 )".$1672')%7%8&"#$7 ')#3$6$"/
#'("%.'##$%<6#3$ &.01"')")##3"#"&&-($%:"(:/C')9')1-.')'-.<-(')$((:'#3 #3$-)&1$ #3$&.01"')")#3$&.01"')")#"1(&1"'.(#3"#3$ 3"%<//:$%#3$.)$6 /.3'( "#3$/#"%8")&$#3$1");3$) #3$ "&&-($% :"( /-))')9 " <-(')$(( :'#3 #3$ -)&1$ #3$ &.01"')")#7#3$)"##3$ '/(#')(#")&$73$'(1'C$16#"00/"&33'( <-(')$((0"/#)$/ /1")3$&.01"')")#3"():3$/$$D01"')$% "(#:363$:-1%9##3$$D#$)# <//:')9#3$.)$6 /.3'(
"#3$/7("(#"%8")&$#3$1")##3$"&&-($% 3$/$ /$7#3$ 1:$/ -/#3"(/'93#163$1%#3"##3$1$9"116$) /&$"<1$%$<#'()# 0/8$%3$1:$/ -/#3"(#"C$))$ #3$#:0(('<1$8'$:( 3$/$'()0"#$)#'11$9"1'#6/0$/8$/('#6')#3$+-%9.$)# "&A-'##"1
3$/$ /$7')#3$"00$"1"9"')(#"&A-'##"17#3'( -/#%$()# ')% ")69/-)%#')#$/ $/$')#3$+-%9.$)# "&A-'##"1 $)&$7#3$ 0/$($)#"00$"1'(%'(.'(($%
, 5 !
(+C(