High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/7/2016allowed

Charanjeet v. Karambir & ORS

2016-01-156 pages

!"#$#%&'&() *

+!,!(-##" ..#//!(" 0#,'1'

2!,!34&,!($"+#,'

#'.($#("'

) 56 2 6 ,#'#(") ,-!7!&(8$9%!"#8,"+#!..#//!(" ,$&"7!!(:+&!($',#,(! +!($(!8$9%!"#'8 ,,'+;!(&+!,$;!-8$9%!"#8 ,,#'.($#("'

<+#"+#,"+##.,"#,'/%!/(#;'.!.#,3!74#!//;#$" '##"+#-1$:3#("= 4#,##,,#$""+##.,"#,,(" <+#"+#,"+#-1$:3#("'+1/$4#,#.,"#$&("+#$&:#'"= 6

+&'&'!(!../&%!"&(1($#,#%"&(>@ ? , , :,!(" /#!9# " !..#!/ !:!&('" "+# ,$#, !%A1&""!/ $!"#$

>8 .!''#$ 47 "+# /#!,(#$ 1$&%&!/ !:&'",!"# /!''8 &'!, ,"+#,#!'('3#("&(#$&("+#:,1($'!..#!/8"+# /#!9# " !..#!/ !:!&('" "+# ,$#, !%A1&""!/ $!"#$

>8 .!''#$47"+#/#!,(#$1$&%&!/!:&'",!"# /!''8&'!,8&':,!("#$ +##:&'",7&'$&,#%"#$"!''&:("+#(134#,""+#3!&(!..#!/ ../&%!"&(&'$&'.'#$

!&(%!'# 3.1:(#$ &( "+# .,#'#(" !..#!/ &' "+# ,$#, $!"#$

>8 .!''#$ 47 "+# /#!,(#$ 1$&%&!/ !:&'",!"# /!''8 &'!,8 9&$# ;+&%+8 !"#, ,#%,$&(: "+# .,#%+!,:# #9&$#(%#8 "+# %3./!&("&/#$47"+#.,#'#("!..#//!("1($#,#%"&('? B8?8 ?8 ?@8 ? 8 ?*8 ?8 8 /&%# "!"&( !,;!/!8 ;!'

$&'3&''#$8+/$&(:"+!""+#.,'#%1"&(+!'!&/#$".,9#&"'%!'# 4#7($!//,#!'(!4/#$14"' +#4,&#!%"'"+#%!'#!,#"+!"!%3./!&("8!//#:&(: "+!""+#!%%1'#$+!',:#$+&''&:(!"1,#'!';#//!'"+#'&:(!"1,#' +&'4,"+#, 3!,C!'+&(!:,##3#(""'#//$!"#$ B?8 9&$#;+&%+?C!(!/'/!($&''"!"#$"4#!:,##$"4#'/$8;!'&/#$ 47"+#!..#//!(" %%1'#$!/'&/#$!%&9&/'1&" +#%3./!&(!(" !//#:#$"+!"+&''&:(!"1,#'!($'&:(!"1,#'+&'4,"+#, 3!,C!'+ !,# ,:#$ <+#( "+# !:,##3#(" " '#// $!"#$ B? ;!'

.,$1%#$ 4#,# "+# /;#, 1,"8 &" ;!' 1($ "+!" &" ;!'

&("#("&(!//7 $#'",7#$ 47 ;!"#, !($ %+#3&%!/' +# &(:#,.,&("

+!($;,&"&(:#D.#,".&(#$"+!"%#,"!&(.&("'+!9#4##( '%,!"%+#$;&"+'+!,.#$:#$4/!$# +!9# +#!,$ "+# /#!,(#$ %1('#/ , "+# !..#//!("8 /#!,(#$%1('#/,"+#,#'.($#("'!($+!9#!/'%!,#1//7:(# "+,1:+"+#&/# +#/#!,(#$1$&%&!/!:&'",!"# /!''8&'!,8+!'

> ,##,,#$""+##9&$#(%#!($'"!"#$"+!"+,&+!3'+#,&(:+!/&C8 &(:#,.,&("

!($;,&"&(: D.#," < +!' (" .&(#$ "+!" "+# '&:(!"1,#' !,# ,:#$ !"+#,8 +# +!' .&(#$ "+!" "+# .#,'( .''#''&(:"+#$%13#("8+!'31"&/!"#$&"&("#("&(!//7;&"+3!/!&$# &("#("&("&'1,"+#,+#/$47"+#/;#, 1,""+!"#D%#.""+#,!/ "#'"&3(7"+#.,#'#("!..#//!("8"+#,#&'("+#,#9&$#(%#("+# &/# ('#A1#("/78"+#%3./!&(";!'$&'3&''#$89&$#&3.1:(#$ ,$#, !3 "+# 9&#; "+!" "+# /;#, 1," +!' !&/#$ " .,.#,/7!..,#%&!"#"+##9&$#(%# #%"&( ?* , &( "+&' ,#:!,$ &' ,#.,$1%#$ !' 1($#,) E?*<+#(!%%1'#$'+!//4#$&'%+!,:#$

81.("!C&(:!//"+##9&$#(%#,##,,#$"&(#%"&(??8 "+#!:&'",!"#%('&$#,'8,,#!'('"4#,#%,$#$8"+!" (%!'#!:!&('""+#!%%1'#$+!'4##(3!$#1";+&%+8& 1(,#41""#$8;1/$;!,,!("+&'%(9&%"&(8"+#!:&'",!"# '+!//$&'%+!,:#+&3

"+&(: &( "+&' '#%"&( '+!// 4# $##3#$ " .,#9#(" ! !:&'",!"#,3$&'%+!,:&(:"+#!%%1'#$!"!(7.,#9&1' '"!:#"+#%!'#&8, ,#!'('"4#,#%,$#$47'1%+ !:&'",!"#8+#%('&$#,'"+#%+!,:#"4#:,1($/#''F "'+;'"+!""+#!:&'",!"#&'"#D!3&(#!""+#'"!:# %+!,:#!'";+#"+#,!(7%!'#&'3!$#1"!:!&('""+#!%%1'#$8& 1(,#41""#$8;1/$;!,,!("+&'%(9&%"&( ("+#/&:+""+#'!&$.!,!3#"#,'8"+#.#,1'!/"+# ,&:&(!/ &/# '+;' "+!" "+# ,&:&(!/ !:,##3#(" " '#// $!"#$

B?8;+&%+&'%/!&3#$"4#,:#$8;!'&("#("&(!//73!$#

? ;#"8'!'"$#'",7"+##9&$#(%#,:#,7 +#,#.,""+# &(:#,.,&("

+!($;,&"&(:#D.#,"%/#!,/7&($&%!"#'"+!""+#'!&$;#""&(: ;!' $(# &("#("&(!//7 " +&$# "+# ,#!/ !%"' #:!,$&(: "+# '&:(!"1,#'$##$;,&"#,+,&#-+&($#,&(:+8$9%!"#83!,C#$ !' 5G>58 &" ;!' 4'#,9#$ "+!" +&' '&:(!"1,#' ;#,# !/' &( ;#" %($&"&(841""+#&($#("/&(#1($#,"+#'&:(!"1,#"+#$##$;,&"#,

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

%%1'#$ "&'%/#!,"+!"&("+&'%!'#8"+#$%13#(";!'&("#("&(!//7 3!$# ;#" !($ 31"&/!"#$ !($ '3# #,!'&(: ;!' $(# +# $%13#("&(A1#'"&(;!'&(.''#''&("+#!%%1'#$!($&";!' ;&"+&("+#'.#%&!/3#!('C(;/#$:#"+#!%%1'#$!'"+;"+# ;#""&(:!($#,!'&(:;!'

* #%"&( "+#($&!( 9&$#(%#%"8 @8,#!$'!'

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

("8&1(,#41""#$8;1/$,#'1/"&( "+#!%A1&""!/"+#!%%1'#$ "4#&(:'8"+&' 1,"&'"+#9&#;"+!""+#/#!,(#$ 1$&%&!/!:&'",!"# /!''8&'!,8!&/#$".,.#,/7!..,#%&!"#"+# #9&$#(%#&("+#,&:+".#,'.#%"&9#!($+!'#,,#$&($&'3&''&(:"+# %3./!&(" ('#A1#("/78"+# &3.1:(#$,$#, $!"

>8 .!''#$47"+#/#!,(#$1$&%&!/!:&'",!"# /!''8&'!,8&''#"

!'&$#+#%!'#&',#3!($#$4!%C""+#/#!,(#$1$&%&!/!:&'",!"#

/!''8&'!,8,,#+#!,&(:"+#!,:13#("'("+#A1#'"&( %+!,:#!($,,#'+!($;#//,#!'(#$,$#,8&("+#/&:+""+#

4'#,9!"&('3!$#!49#+#.!,"&#'!,#$&,#%"#$"!..#!,4#,# "+#/#!,(#$1$&%&!/!:&'",!"# /!''8&'!,8(?

* '-C'