Jaspal Ram And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

 



       
 

"# $#%&'&()(*+,
-
 './0($"1#+' #"&"&(#+' 2#+'*' 3""# *(45($("1#+ #'.($#("'




67 $(8/9+($"1#+' #"&"&(#+' 2#+'*' 3""# *(45($("1#+ #'.($#("'

 ) :8  33 

83 88 +#'#(") +;#'135"&-$<%"# +"1#.#"&"&(#+'  +51,/3&(91 &//- -*(45 ===


  1&'0""#+&'5#&(9";#(*. +1#+&(9"1+*91<&$#%( #+#(%&(9 $*#"*"5+#; "1#.($#0&%- 2


 '   ($
67   +# ";#( *. + 1#+&(9 ($ $#%&'&("9#"1#+'&$#("&%/&''*#&'&(</<#$"1#+#&( +,#+&(5"1>+&".#"&"&('&'"1".#"&"&(#+'"1#+#&(+##("&"/#$" "1#5#(# &"*($#+"1# '%1#0#(%0./#"&( ?,#+'-,#+'($
?,#+'  '#+<&%#("1#$"#(>1&%1"1#,%0./#"#$"1#'&$.#+&$ '#+<&%#($("

+0
'"(*+, "1#,#+ "#+%0./#"&( ?-($
?,#+' '#+<&%# 1<#1#+$/#+(#$%*('#/ +"1#.+"&#'($1<#9(#"1+*91"1#

&/# ($&'.*"#$ %"' +# "1" .#"&"&(#+'- &( 5"1 "1# %'#'- 1<# 5##( 

+$#$ "1# 5#(# &"     '%1#0# (" +0 "1# %"*/ $"#   %0./#"&(   ? ,#+'-  ,#+' ($
? ,#+'   '#+<&%# 5*" +0
'" (*+,   "1# ,#+  "#+ %0./#"&( ?,#+'-,#+'($
?,#+' '#+<&%#8#+(#$%*('#/ +"1#

  .#"&"&(#+' +#/&#' *.( $#%&'&( $"#$

 
7 &( 
@ "&"/#$ ' (4&" 3&(91 1+ <#+'*' 1# +&(%&./ 3#%+#"+,- #.+"0#("   ++&9"&(- *(45($("1#+ ""%1#$'((#B*+#7&(   
@($((#B*+# @&( 
67 !($$#%&'&($"#$A
 
&( 
?
 
@"&"/#$ '+#'14&"3&(91(($($"1#+'<#+'*'3""# *(45($("1#+ ""%1#$ '((#B*+#6&(   
@($((#B*+#A&( 
67 !("1# 5<#'&$.#"&"&('-5#(# &"  '%1#0#(%0./#"&( ?,#+'-,#+'($
?,#+' '#+<&%#'3*5&<&'&(/

&%#+-1'5##(9+("#$""1#.#"&"&(#+'- ' .#+("& &%"&( $"#$
@
6 3"($&(9 &('"+*%"&('$"#$
7? - ( >1&%1+#/&(%#>'./%#$5,"1#3""#&("1#'&$.#"&"&('>'$*/,$&'%*''#$&( $#"&/&( (4&"3&(911+C'%'# '*.+! ("1#+#./,'*50&""#$&("1#.+#'#(">+&".#"&"&('-5#(# &"9&<#(""1# .+"&#' &( (4&" 3&(91 1+ ($ +#'14&" 3&(91 (($C' %'# '*.+! &' (" $#(&#$ " &' '""#$ "1" "1# 3""# 1$ $#%&$#$ " &/# 8 &( +#'14&" 3&(91 (($C'%'# '*.+!5*"&"&'("$#(&#$"1"5#(# &"1''&(%#5##(

+$#$" +#'14&"3&(91(($($"1#+'&#.#"&"&(#+'&( 
?
 
@($ ..#/ 1' (" 5##( &/#$ "&// $"#  #/&(%# 1' 5##(  '"+#(**'/, ./%#$ ( &('"+*%"&('$"#$
7? "$#(,5#(# &"""1#.+#'#(".#"&"&(#+'># "1# $"#(>1&%1"1#,%"*//,%0./#"#$?,#+'-,#+'($
?,#+' +#9*/+ '#+<&%# #"&/'+#9+$&(9$"#' %0./#"&( .#+&$ ?,#+'-,#+'($
?,#+' '#+<&%#&(%'# //"1#.#"&"&(#+'-&(5"1"1#>+&".#"&"&('-1<#(" 5##($&'.*"#$($+#"1#+# +#-("5#&(9(++"#$&("1#+$#+ /#+/,-'"($";#( 5, "1# +#'.($#(" D3""# &' 5$*+"# ($ "  ""/ <+&(%# >&"1 $#%&'&( $"#$ A
 
->1&%11'5##(.''#$>1&/#+#/,&(9*.($#%&'&($"#$

 
7

 &( 
@( (4&"3&(911+C'%'# '*.+!-"1# *+"1''*%%&(%"/, $#/">&"1../&%5&/&", "1#'"($&(9+$#+'E&('"+*%"&('$"#$
7? "&' .+<&$#$&("1#'"($&(9+$#+'E&('"+*%"&('$"#$
7? "1"//./%#0#("'&( "1#1&91#+'%/#''1//5#9&<#(#

#%" +0"1# &+'"$, (*+, "1#,#+(#B" " "1# ,#+ &( >1&%1 ( #0./,## %0./#"#' "1# '.(   '#+<&%# +#F*&+#$ + ./%#0#(" &( 1&91#+ '%/#  "#+ ("&%&(9 ("& &%"&( $"#$
@
6 ($ "1# '"($&(9 +$#+'E&('"+*%"&(' $"#$
7? - &" &' 5'#+<#$ &( +$#+ $"#$

 
7 &( 
@  (4&" 3&(91 1+ <#+'*' 1# +&(%&./ 3#%+#"+,-#.+"0#(" ++&9"&(-*(45($("1#+!'*($#+) "

 0   "1# <&#> "1" "1# 9*&$#/&(#' %((" <#++&$# "1# ("& &%"&(&''*#$&(#B#+%&'# "1#.>#+'*($#+"1# ('"&"*"&( ($&>1&%11'"1# +%# /> 1#&('"+*%"&('%("++,""1#'&$ ("& &%"&(1<&(9 +%# />-+#"5#&9(+#$ 1#("& &%"&( $"#$
@
6 ((#B"*+# 6! '"&.*/"#' "1"
? ,#+'  .+ &%&#(%,'"#.*."5#9+("#$(%0./#"&( 
?,#+' +#9*/+ '#+<&%#&("1##("+,'%/#3&(%#"1#.#"&"&(#+%0./#"#'
?,#+' +#9*/+'#+<&%#(
6 
7-"1#+# +#-"1#.#"&"&(#+&'#("&"/#$" #("+,'%/#(%0./#"&( 
?,#+' '#+<&%# +0"1#'&$$"# ($"1#9*&$#/&(#'9&<#(&(((#B"*+#
+#.+$*%#$5<#+#"5# &9(+#$ <#(&(%'# '5&+3&(911($*->1>'4*(&+""1# .#"&"&(#+($>'.+0"#$<&$#'0#+$#+-1#>'/'9+("#$
? ,#+' '%/#(%0./#"&( 
?,#+''#+<&%#># 
6 
7 1#+# +#->1#"1#+"1#&('"+*%"&('$"#$
7?  ((#B*+#
! >#+# 5+*91" " "1# ("&%#   "1# *+" &( '&$ %'# + ("- 1+$/, 0;#'(,$&

#+#(%#

('#F*#("/,-"1#.+#'#(".#"&"&(&'//>#$ 1#+#'.($#("' +# +$#+#$ " 9+(" "1# .+ &%&#(%, '"#. *. " "1# .#"&"&(#+ ( %0./#"&( 
?,#+''(
6 
7 ('#F*#("/,-"1#.#('&(  "1#.#"&"&(#+'1///'5#+#<&'#$ 1#++#+' "1#+#<&'#$., ($"1#.#('&('1//5#+#/#'#$""1#.#"&"&(#+>&"1&(0("1'

?

+0"1#$"# +#%#&." %#+"& &#$%., "1&'+$#+3&(%#-"1# .#"&"&(#+..+%1#$"1&' *+"(/,&("1#,#+ 
@-1#>&//("5# #("&"/#$"(,&("#+#'"("1#++#+'($&("#+#'"'1//5#.&$""1# .#"&"&(#+ +0"1#$"# &/&(9".+#'#(">+&"GH.#+((*0"&// &"'.,0#("I //>&(9 "1&' $#%&'&(- 
?
 
@ +#'14&" 3&(91 (($ ($"1#+'<#+'*'3""# *(45($("1#+!>'$#%&$#$(A
 
 1# '&$$#%&'&('1<#5##($*/,&0./#0#("#$ 8#+(#$%*('#/ +"1#3""#&'*(5/#"$#(,"1"(..#/ 8! 1'5##( &/#$&(#&"1#+ "1#">%'#'3"&//"1#3""#-'"#$ '"/,%("&(*#'"+#/, *.(&('"+*%"&('$"#$
7? "";#(*(4*'"& &#$'"($"1"5#(# &"*($#+ "1# '%1#0#&'(""5#+#/#'#$""1#.#"&"&(#+'>&"1#

#%" +0"1#$"#( >1&%1"1#,%"*//,%0./#"#$?,#+'- ,#+'($
?,#+' +#9*/+'#+<&%# 3*%1'"($&'%/#+/,*("#(5/#1#(%#+#4#%"#$(%#"1#0""#+%/#+/,'"($' $#%&$#$ &" &' (" .#( " "1# 3""# " ;##. ";&(9 '*%1  '"($ &( %0./#"# %("+$&%"&( " "1# +$#+' .''#$ #+/&#+ ($ "1*' .#+.#"*"&(9 *((#%#''+, /&"&9"&( 1*91>'&(%/&(#$"&0.'#%'"'5*""+$#("+#F*#'" /#+(#$ %*('#/ +"1#3""#-$#'&'""1#+# +0 +#'#(">+&".#"&"&('+#-"1#+# +#-//>#$&("1#'0#"#+0''&(


@ #($&(9../&%"&('-&(5"1"1#.#"&"&('& (,-'"($$&'.'#$ %%+$&(9/,  8&' &//! (*+,
-
  *$9# Rts