High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/509/2013dismissed

Mohan @ Kala v. State Of Haryana

2017-10-25Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri11 pages

Sumit Gulati 2017.11.13 10:38 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

! !

"#$%

&"%#$%

! ''())*+,- #.*+ *)**+/ *0(-. *01.*2($3)(/ *$#4(-,*,(/-('*4*,(54363+*)*''(*)-*7*3+-,*5#66#+01/7(6(+,#$ 5#+235,3#+/*,(/ %*+/#4/(4#$-(+,(+5(/*,(/8 %'*--(/ 9:)(*4+(///) (--3#+-1/7( #.,*;23/(<.35.,.(:<(4(5#+235,(/ 1+/(4(5,3#+%4(*/<3,.(5,3#+%= *+/-(+,(+5(/,#1+/(47# 437#4#1-36'43-#+6(+,$#4)3$((*5.*+/,#'*:*$3+(#$>(*5. *+/ 3+ /($*1), ,# 1+/(47# * $14,.(4 '(43#/ #$ $#4% 6#+,.- $#4 5#663,,3+7,.(614/(4#$#+( *+934-># 0*)* *6

43($$*5,-#$,.(5*-(*4(,.*,/(5(*-(/ *+934<*--(423+7 3+

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

+& 8,.(#4(+-3553(+5(*9#4*,#4: */.19*+

*4+*)-(+,,.(4('#4,*$,(45#+/15,3+75.(635*)(A*63+*,3#+#$23-5(4* /(,(5,3+7)163+16.#-'.3/(@ ()'.#-B3+'*4,-#$-,#6*5.-6*))*+/ )*47(3+,(-,3+(-)32(4-')((+*+/;3/+(:- = .(4(*$,(4 *+ *'')35*,3#+ /*,(/ % 8 @A B <*- 6#2(/9:.*6-.(43+7.94#,.(4#$/(5(*-(/,#,.('#)35(<.35.3-*- 1+/(4 C

# $ %"

& "

'() * $ $ + "

# $ $ % "

% , $ " #

$ " * - "

* )

./0 $ 1

" &

2 $ + "

$ "

3 4 $

$ 56/05002 *"

7 58/05002 $

# 9

" 7 52/05002 3:;0 $ "

$ " # ## , ## "

"# "

## $ "

$ "

$ 9 " '1

- ##< $

, $ $ # "

<# =

( # "

" "

= "

$ -

# % " ?$ 7 $ /350 $ $ # " (

$ "

" "

" " $ %$

" ##

# #

( #

$ " #

$ "

# # $ $

= @ " > $ * ,

$ # A

+,.(9*-3-#$,.(*$#4(-*3/-,*,(6(+, # %/*,(/ % 8 1+/(4 (5,3#+ %>%= #)35( ,*,3#+ (.*6 <*- 4(73-,(4(/ E+-'(5,#443,.233+7.3+-'(5,(/,.(-'#,'4('*4(/ 4#17.-3,(')*+*+/4(5#4/(/,.(-,*,(6(+,-#$<3,+(--(- 551-(/*4#0 *+/ *0(-.<(4(*44(-,(/*+/#+3+,(44#7*,3#+,.(:-1$$(4(//3-5)#-14(

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

# "%%==$#4,.('(43#/ 8 8,# 8"""%&&%$#4 ,.( '(43#/ 8 ,# 8 8 "8"&"8= $#4 ,.( '(43#/ 8,#= 8*+/8 8,#= 8"""&"8%$#4 ,.('(43#/8 8,#= 8*+/& 8,# 8*+/ "888=&$#4,.('(43#/ 8,#% 8<(4('4#514(/ & $,(45#6')(,3#+#$,.(3+2(-,37*,3#+4('#4,1+/(4(5,3#+ % 4 <*-$3)(/*+/,.(*551-(/<(4(5.*47(-.((,(/$#4,.(#$$(+5( 1+/(4(5,3#+%4(*/<3,.(5,3#+%= ,#<.35.,.(:')(*/(/+#, 713),:*+/5)*36(/,43*) #'4#2(3,-5*-(,.('4#-(51,3#+(A*63+(/*-6*+:*-% <3,+(--(-

+$#4,1+*,(): *551-(/ *4#0/3(/ /143+7 ,43*) .(4($#4( -,*,(6(+,-#$*551-(/ *0(-. *01*+/ #.*+ *)*<(4(4(5#4/(/

& 1+/(4(5,3#+%% 4 3+<.35.,.(:')(*/(/3++#5(+5(*+/5)*36(/ $*)-(36')35*,3#+ .(*551-(/(A*63+(/E,#E%3+,.(34/($(+5( "

E .*7*, *694#17.,5#':#$ 4(73-,(4(/*,,.( 3+-,*+5(#$*551-(/*4#0*)*1+/(4(5,3#+="8*+/=& *7*3+-, .(43+)*<-3 ( 00*))*3+7..*+'*,3<3$(#$ 0*))*3+7. 43-.*+ .*6-.(4*+/*)3'-#+-#$ 0*))*3+7.#+,.(9*-3-#$5#6')*3+,1+/(4 (5,3#+&@%B 4

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

1*+,3,:#$*)163+16'.#-'.3/($#1+/3+,.( 23-5(4*#$,.(/(5(*-(/<*-3+-1$$353(+,,#5*1-(.3-/(*,. *-,):3,35#+,(+/(/ ,.*, ,.( ,43*) #14, .*- 74*2(): (44(/ 3+ 5#+235,3+7 *+/ -(+,(+53+7,.(*''())*+,-#+,.(9*-3-#$-,*,(6(+,6*/(9:*:(*4-#)/ 5.3)/<3,+(--+*6(): *+3-.E % (*4+(/5#1+-()$#4,*,(#+,.(#,.(4.*+/-1963,,(/,.

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

#$,.(/(5(*-(/ .(4(*$,(4E*)#+7<3,..3-6#,.(4@-3+5(/(*/B.*/ 7#+($#4*-)(('*+/5#+235,*''())*+,- *01*+/ #.*+)($,,.(')*5(#$ #55144(+5( E=*423+/(4<.#3-,.(-#+#$/(5(*-(/G-94#,.(4 43-.*+ ,(-,3$3(/,.(*$#4(-*3//('#-3,3#+6*/(9:E3+.3--,*,(6(+,9($#4(,.

#14, (/('#-(/ ,.*, #+ 8 *, *9#1, ' 6 .(<*- -,*+/3+73+$4#+,#$.3-.#1-( +,.(6(*+,36(*4#0@*551-(/-3+5( /3(/B*)#+7<3,.E5*6(,.(4($#4')*53+7,.(/1+7 .(4(*$,(4.(-*< 5#+235,*''())*+, *01#+*6#,#45:5)(.*+/3+7#2(4*'*5;(,@'143*B,# E *+3-.*+/E.*+/(/#2(4,.(-*6(,#*4#0@*551-(/-3+5( /3(/B +.3-*-;3+7*9#1,,.(5#+,(+,-#$-*3/'*5;(,*4#0@*551-(/ -3+5(/3(/B4(')3(/,.*,3,<*-.(46(/353+( & E.43,1) *4:*19323-3#+*)1/353*) *73-,4*,(

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

B 5 < / C 3 " *#

$ >

" # > ,

B 5 < / C 2 " D E#'3+(/,.*,,.(5*1-(#$/(*,.5#1)/9(*-5(4,*3+(/#+):*$,(4 4(5(323+7,.(4('#4,#$*+/5.(635*)*+*):-3-#$23-5(4* E#+ 4(5(3',#$9()#<6(+,3#+(/4('#4,/*,(/& 8@A B23/( <.35.)163+16.#-'.3/(@ ()'.#-B<*-/(,(5,(/3+'*4,-#$-,#6*5. '*4,-#$-6*))*+/)*47(3+,(-,3+(-)32(4-')((+*+/;3/+(:-#'3+(/,.( 5*1-( #$ /(*,. #$ /(5(*-(/ /1( ,# 47*+#'.#-'.*,( '#3-#+3+7 @)163+16 .#-'.*,(B @<4#+7): -'())(/ *- G.#-'.*,(G 3+-,(*/ #$ G.#-'.3/(G*-'(44('#4,B C/ , # # =# > "

" < %/

/ D # < /% 8 E% */**+//('#-(/,.*,#+ 8.(<*- '#-,(/*-+5.*47( :9(4 436( #.,*; (5#))(5,(/,.(5*))/(,*3)- *+/ )#5*,3#+ #$ 6#93)( '.#+(- 9(*43+7 # "%%== $#4 ,.( '(43#/ 8 8,# 8"""%&&%9()#+73+7,#*551-(/ *0(-.

$#4,.('(43#/ 8,#8 8"8"&"8=1-(/9:*4#0$#4 ,.( '(43#/ 8 ,# = 8 *+/ 8 8 ,# = 8 """&"8% 1-(/ 9: *551-(/ *0(-. $#4 ,.( '(43#/ 8 8 ,# = 8*+/& 8,# 8*+/"888=&9()#+73+7,# *551-(/ #.*+$#4,.('(43#/ 8,#% 8 "

E *+3-..*/5*,(7#435*)):-'#;(+*9#1,,.((2(+,-,.*, .*''(+(/#+,.($*,($1)+37., E. ,1) *4:* (.*6.*- /('#-(/,.*,*$,(4-*,3-$:3+7.36-()$$1)):,.*,E9(3+7*5.3)/<3,+(-- <*-*9)(,#6*;(-,*,(6(+,4(5#4/(/.3--,*,(6(+,<.35.<*-<3,.#1, *+:3+$)1(+5(#4'4(--14( .(?1(-,3#+-*-;(/9:E,#E *+3-.

<(4()#735*)):*+-<(4(/ E *+3-..*/$14,.(49((+54#--(A*63+(/ *,)(+7,. 1,,.(/($(+5(.*/+#,9((+*9)(,#-.*;(.3-(23/(+5( .(4($#4(,.((23/(+5(#$E *+3-.5#1)/-*$():9(4()3(/1'#+$#4 4(5#4/3+75#+235,3#+*7*3+-,,.(*551-(/*''())*+,- .(-(?1(+5(#$(2(+,-(A')*3+(/9:E *+3-..*2( $14,.(49((+5#44#9#4*,(/9:,.(6(/35*)(23/(+5(<.35..*-5#6(#+ 4(5#4/,.4#17.'#-,6#4,(6(A*63+*,3#+*+/,.(4('#4, E4 !3;*-.*/+#,(//#<+*94*-3#+-#+6*+/39)(*+/)($,*+/437.,;+((- .(4('#4,4(2(*)(/,.*, *+934/3(//1(,#'#3-#+*+/)163+16

.#-'.3/(<*-$#1+/3+.3-9#/:'*4,--(+,$#4(A*63+*,3#+ E *+3-.

.*/-'#;(+3+.3-/('#-3,3#+,.*,#+,.($*,($1)+37.,<.3)(*551-(/*4#0 @-3+5(/3(/B5*17.,.#)/,.(.*+/-#$/(5(*-(/ *+934*+/*551-(/ *''())*+, #.*+5*17.,.#)/#$,.()(7-#$/(5(*-(/ *+934*551-(/ *''())*+, *01*$,(47323+7*$3-,9)#<3+,.(*9/#6(+#$ *+934,##;#1, *,*9)(,$4#6*'*5;(,*+/'1,,.(-*6(3+,.(6#1,.#$ *+934*+/<(+, *<*: .(4($#4(,.(6(/35*)(23/(+5(*)-#7#(-.*+/3+.*+/<3,.,.( -,*,(6(+,6*/(9:E

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

,.*-5#6(3+,.( 4('#4,,.*,)163+16.#-'.3/(@ ()'.#-B<*-/(,(5,(/$4#6,.( 9#/:'*4,-#$,.(/(5(*-(/-(+,$#4(A*63+*,3#+ E*)-##'3+(/,.*, ,.( /(*,. #55144(/ /1( ,# 47*+#'.#-'.*,( '#3-#+3+7 @)163+16 .#-'.*,(B@<4#+7):-'())(/*-G.#-'.*,(G3+-,(*/#$G.#-'.

4('#4,B<.35./1):5#44#9#4*,(-<3,.,.(-,*,(6(+,6*/(9:E= *423+/(4,.*,.(.*/-((+*''())*+, *01.*+/3+7#2(4*'*5;(,,#

*+3-.*+/ *+3-..*+/3+7#2(4,.(-*6(,#*4#0@-3+5(/3(/B E *)-#.*/-'#;(+*9#1,,.('*5;(,$4#6<.35.*,*9)(,<*-'1,3+,.( 6#1,.#$ *+934 = + 23(< #$,.(*$#4(-*3/ 5.*3+ #$ 534516-,*+5(- *+/ ,.( (23/(+5(*2*3)*9)(#+4(5#4/3,5*+9(-*$():5#+5)1/(/,.*,3,<(4(,.( *''())*+,-<.#5#663,,(/,.(614/(4#$ *+934 E($3+/+#-19-,*+5(,# /3$$(4<3,.,.(<())5#+-3/(4(/01/7(6(+,'*--(/9:)(*4+(/,43*) #14, + 23(< #$ ,.( *9#2( ,.( 01/7(6(+, #$ 5#+235,3#+ *+/ -(+,(+5(/'*--(/9:,.(,43*) #14,-,*+/-5#+$346(/*+/,.(*''(*)- -,*+//3-63--(/ "

# "

5,#9(4 1)*,3 E.(,.(4 ('#4,*9)( (- E.(,.(4'(*;3+7> (*-#+(/ (-