Babar Ali & ANR. v. State Of Punjab
!"
#$!
% & "'
& "
&( ) *+ ,-./.
0 12)
(+ +2+
(( $250 "
)
!"#$ $ %$ $ (, 26 3)/ )7 *(
(+ 5083/ )) /$250 $ %$ &!
+((
3+ 0
) 0-
(+ 0 + 2 ) :) + 288 52)8 ( ) ) )( ) ;; ++ ) 0- (3 ))( ++ +%2)8 /82 4) 28 )52)8 () ) /(3
(+37
* 7*( ))+ )( 2) 8 8 2+ + ( - + 0 +) + - /< *3 ) 2(3 + ( += (3+) 2( 2+30
2) ;> )?(3 ; $)+ + )( 2) 8 8 2+ + ( - (3
2+30 2) ; )?(3 ; $ -+(( )/(3 *(+ (3( )* 8
(
( 3)2(:/$@A/?+ 7 )$ * (( *(-
:
( 7
( >B 78(3 0
+)
(/ ? 83
) ( (3 7
(/ :
(?3 52 )?+) * )2(( :
+(( ( ? 83 8 ?
( ( 7
(/ :
( CB) ) *( ) *8(3 52 )(( :
+(( (/+(( ( 3)2(:?+ ) ) ( 3)2(:+(( )(3(3 ?+ +) ( 333((/ :
( 2+28D?( 8 8# +( 2 7
(3+3 3)0
+(-8(3+3 2+
?+ (28 (3
+3 3) E0 >B(0 2(( (8 F$
33 F
3( ) *8 (( +3 ( 2*3+ *8 ((
?3 /**2+ ):) ++ 0 +2)0 +27 ) (3 +) +@5) * )(3(* (+3 2)0 (283( ++ +3 ?+( +8(3 0 -+(3+/0 +2 *( ): 0 ? 3+7 : 0 ??+*( )0- 0 +2 3+ (:@3 3 8 2) **2+ )0 +2*( )52- 3+83(:?(3 3+:
3) 8 2)?3 :) + *( )(?
0 ?+?(33+: () 0 ?
(:) +((*:
)38)+(3
(( )( ?) (3 0 ??(33+ (3)3 +2+( 52- (320 3+ (3)@3 3 + )/(3
**2+ ) )( ?)+ 33) 8?(3(3 ?
+@3
( (8/(3 -(3 ( -?
2):3) **2
?+?( ++ )0- 3) E0/$@. (?+(:
(
;
7
(/ :
(0-"5 +3 ) (7 *(8 52 +?+(3((3 **2+
+ ++2+
*( )3 ( +8(3
-+ *(- (3++(( ( =$@A< / # " =$@><?+ 8+( )2) ; )?(3 ; $"
283+(
?+
)0- ?83(( (+
?( ++ + ?
) ) 52-
0 8 ) * ) + )8 2+( CB/ 2+30 2) ;> $?+)) ) **2+ ) ?
+( ) B 0- %:
83)+* +2 +(( (/ =$@>< /0 8+2 )0-0 + 2/ : 2+ ) * ++ (3 ?+ )(3 G0 8 2+ * G ?+(:
++ ++ 7) =$@><
-?+ *( ) **2+ ):) + * ( 7 +(8( / *3<
( 2) >;$?+ )38 ?+ )8+((3
**2+ ) + 2+30 2) +;>/; ) ?(3 ; $ >/( ?3*3(3 - ) )
)* )( $ *2( = ) ?( ++ +( (+*+ **2+ ) ?3 ) -8 *(8 **2+(* + 2( ( (3
) ) ) + *( # 2 ?( ++ + ?
= )) ) ( 2( * +) 8 (3 7) )/ ( *(+)**2+(* + *+ * *2)
*2( 3) )(+*+ - ) + 0 ) 20(E2(3
(+ ) * 7*( ) (3 (3 + + *38 ) ) ) (3 + ( ) 0 88 ) (3 / (3
+((
3+0
)0-(3
(+ )* 2+
(+((3 7 - 2(+ ( 82 +(3((3 )( 2(3+
0++ 5 *(2 + ) +2+ + ?(3 2( )7 (8 ( (3 7) ))3+? 8-* 7*( ))+ )(3 **2+ ) (+ 28 ) (3( 3) E0/ $@./ (3 ) - ?( ++ 3+ ( +2
( )(3 *2( 7 + ++ * 3+0
+2
++ ) ) (3 * **2 3+ ( 0
= ) #2(3 / - : 3+ )- 0
) 0 +2 3+: ?+ (0
)+( )) ?
3+0
) (3 **2+ ):) + (+7 (-82 )(3(( (+37
) 0-(3 * (3++(( (0 2( 0-+8+2+ * *2( 7 + (+* ) (3((3 * (?++3)-*3*( /30(2 ( =*( )0+*-E2 + /3+( +( -* (0
(++20(( **2 + )( 37
(:
* >B ( ?3 + (3 # " ?+ 8+( )( 0 2(A3 2+ CB(
/
++0(- 0 +3 ()* * (0 2 2( ) * 2+ (3
(++ * )+(3( 8 ) (+ ;> $ () 2((3 (*+
(++20((
( ( )
+ ( ( 52-
.
8)8 2+( /(3 /* 7*( 2) ;> $ * (0 ( ) )* 2+ (( ?3 2(8(3 0
+)82 (+3++2
( )(3 28 )52)8 () )
+20(+ (3(+2* ()* ( 7) + )/?3*3
+ * *(- (3 **2+ ) (3 * ++
- ) + 0 ) 20(
-+ 2 )8 (3 28 52)8 () )
37 3 ) )* 2+ ( +)2( - (3 283 (3 ) ?(3 (3 0 +++(* 52 ((3+*+ 3)2(:/$@A/3+87 8 3* ** 2( *) (+(2 ) )
3+87 * ++( + 0 ( 2(* + * ?(33+(+(( =$@A< (+ )(3(3 3)0
) * )2(( :
+(( ( >B0-(3 ) *( (7
(/ :
( + +(( ( ?+ ) ) (3 =( )- CB?3 ) *( ) * )3(( :
+(( (
+/(32+/ ) -++288 +( )(3 )88 # " *2+(* +37
)2- = ) # "0 8 8+(
CB $@;/&3
(%/3+* ( (?+ * )2(( :
+(( ()2 ( + )( / (*0 ) 7 )0-(3 **2+ ) (3 0+ 7( (3
* ++ =( &3
(%( *((3( ( (?+ +* 2+?3 0 283(( 3 ( (3((3 8 * )(
( (?+ :-#2(3 /(3 0+ 7( (3(((3 (
8 )* 8
(/ (3 ( ( ?+ ( ( :
+(( (* ( *+ **2+ ) (+0 2( (3 )(3(?3
* *3 )(3 7
( ( (3+ )*
(/(3 * (?+2) + )( )/(3 /) * )2(( :
+(( ( *2 7 + 87 0- (3 * ( + )2- ( ) 0- (3 )* 7) ) ( 7 )+-++=52 ++) ( )(3 )* 8
(/?3*3 +2) ,
! "
# $
% "
"
&
# $
!
%
# $
' !
" % %
&
!
% %
('&
) !
*
+ $
>B(+ /(3 * (?+
( )2
(.; 0-& 8/$@
*(( 52-
/
> & 8 )+2) , H ! ( %
,
"
%
!
%*
*
- *
,
%
%
- *
*
% .
$ ,
,
/
%
* %
%
# %
% $ ,
% .
$
!
("0
%
1
%
I & 8/$@/3+* -+(( )(3(3
(
52 >B (+ 0++
( (
=$(3(52-
?+) * )( )8 2+( 0++ ?3*3 2+30 2) ;> $?+ )) ) @3 8 (
( ( =$/ 2+
(++20(+(3((3+ (0
( (3((3 52-E2 +( ?+)8 2+( 3+* ( +
* -* 2+ ( (3 *((3(
( ( + ( ( ( * ( (2 52-/0
2+
+ + *(7 (3 (2 52- ( + (3 0++
( ( (3( =$#?+87
*((
(2 52-
+ (38 )( +288 +((3(52-
?+ ()8 2+( 2*3 +( ++ 3+ 0
) $@./ 3) E0 ( +2
(8 (3 *2( 7 + ( + +20(( ) (3( (3
- ?( ++3+ (+2
( )(3 7 + /* 7*(
**2+ )+ 8 =( ) +(3( 3) E0
C3)( )(3 *) (+( **2 >B * + * ?(3(3 7 + 87 0-(3 * (((3 ( +(8 7) +(( ( =$@A< + =( ) (
* ++ =( ?+ * )2*( ) C (3
=( *3 /3 +(( )+2) , 2 3" !
4
1 5 4
*5 - ##5 * 6
%
% %
% 5
# %
6
-
%5
5
6
,
!
5
$ -
% 6
7
$ *!
$
%
-
# *!
% 6
1
1
#
6
% $
8
, 6
% ! -
1 5
%
4!
%
%
%
5
%
I @3 3 ?+ * ) 2(3 * ++ =( B.; 3 + ) 3+ +() ) +(( ) (3( (3
+(( ( 87 C 0 (3 ( 2( 3) 0
) ) 2) (3 ( ) ++2 3) 2(:/ (3
(
) **2+
+ 2( (3()-
*2+ ) 52 + (3
+ (3 * ( 3+
>B
+ 283( ( = 3+ 7 ( * 0- +-8(3(( )8 3++(( ( 2( C// 3+* +* *:
)3)(3 ( 3 ? ( (( + =+&J )&' )) ++ )( ( 2(
0+ 7 )(3 **2+ 378* (( )(3
/3 ?
/)(+(3(3 3) )(
* *+ -383 *+0 2((3
++2 8 = ( )2
3D (( =&J+)( ); ) =&'+)( ); + + (3* 8+ ( ?3(**2+(* ?++(2 ( *:83+* +*
( + )3>K (3+ )
+8 0 ( 2( (+ 7(( ( ((3++(8 (3( 3) E0
) 3+ +8(2 + 3+ +(( ( ) C ) +20+ E2 (- B.; !)2 ) ( $250 D (( + =+&J)&' ?(( )+8 )$250
?
/ 3)
E03+**
( )(3 +) (( +( 37
?(( 0-3
87 ?(3
*2**2+(* ++( 0 /(3 + (38( ((3+ 2( -82
+(( () 0- 3) E0 C ) ( 3+
7) + ) ( - **
(0 8)8 (3 ( / * ) *) ( + ?
+ ) ((- (3 **2+ ) - *2+ 3) E0*3 ( 0*:(*: + +0 +(: ? ( 3 3+ +(( (/+ (8 2) 8 83+
( 7) (++ ((
+( (3((3 ( 7) +( ?( ++
) (0 )+*) )"
* *0 *
((3
?3*3+ +* ) +* ( )0- 7)
) ( (3 ( (3 ) ( +288 +( (3( ( 3)2(:+
+ +3)-*3*( * (0
-7( 7 (3 +)7 (+ **
( )(
(2 /()
+ ()7 +((3 *2( 7 + (+7 *(-$ 2+
( +( - (3 2) ?( ++ + (3((3 - 37 ( +(( * (+))*(?3 +2) 2 ( =*( )E2 +?(37 2+
+ +2) 2 ( =*(
+0)*3*(
*(- -: ?0 +2**2+ )/?3 + ( /
*(0
+ 0882 3+-0-) 80 2)(3 - 3) 3 ) -(38 0) 3
?
/ (3 * ++
=( / ?(3 7 * )((3((3 -37
(3 * ( (:
- ( =*( - 37 ( )(3 383 2(3 ( +0 2(* +2 ( ( =*(0- 3)2(:&@/&@;)&@/2* 2* +/37
)(( **2+ )0 +2+ (*(6 @)
* *0 * +2*3 (:
*(+0- ?( ++ + ( **2+
+ + #2(3 * ( 0 3
(++(3( ?
?+ ) :) +) : ) 0 +2?+ (0
)+( (3 0
) +( ) * + ?
) ) (:
(
++ ++ /(3 /(3 *2( *+ +)) )?(3) 20(
3+* ( + *( ) )* 7) +52 +
+ ( 37
*2+ )0-+3 )8 )?
: ?+ ) 2+2( ( )+* +2 +(( ( 0- 0 + 2#*((3((?+ (0
)+( ))
+ () (*( (3
*(- ) * )0(- (3 *2( 7 + 52 (3+87 8 3*)) ( )** 2( ?3*3 (3 52 + ?
*2+ ) ( 3 0- (3 **2+ ) 3+ ** 2(+)2-* ( )0-(3 )* 7) "
- : **2+ )0 +2+ (+2+
*( (3+0
)2- )0- ?83/$@>/?3 3) = ( 8) 8+((3 **2+
+ +
?E2(3 **2+ ?3*3-37 ( )3( + - *( +)**2+ ) -/ - : (3 **2+ ):) + * ( 0 8 2) *E2((8 3 (3 *
?3 8)* ( 7) )( (+* *(-
(+ 7) ((3(**2+
+ +* * ( *2+ ) 52 + ( (3 * ( 3) 2(: ) * ((
2+30 2) +;>/;/; $
7 ? *(+)**2+(* + *+ /(3
(+37
83(-* 7*( ) + 2+30
2) +;>/;/; $ ((3++(8 / )* 2+
(++20(+ (3( (3 E2(2 +
) 2
(3
(+ 0
)2* ) ) + 8 2+ + ( + - + 2) ;> $+ (* +2( ?(3(3 E2 +(
87 ?(3 87(- )(2 52 +/ 8 2)?3(+
+) 2( -7( (3
)2
(+
(3+0
28 ) + E2 (-/(3+
+)+++ ) '% !()*
-./.
(+