State Of Punjab v. Sukhdev Singh @ Sukha




   
  

"#$%$&'(')*



#"#$ +),"- ..$//")#  0$1(+( +23%$4')536+23"

 $(.)%$)#  *  78  
9 8



1$($)#* 1'23'/93.1":$.+#;%4&"#$$)$1"/:

+),"-:1#3$"..$//")##"#$ ('4;"3"1<":%4&"#$ 8$5"/'%+)($/!:

11$(.)%$)#

 =3$#3$1#3$ $.1#$1(/&"/)$>(.".$1<";-$"//>$%#($$ #3$,+%5<$)#?

 -$1$$11$%##3$ $.1#$11)#  =3$#3$1#3$,+%5<$)#(3+/%-$1$.1#$%')#3$%'5$(#?   8

: 3$#"#$ +),"-3"('/$%#3'("..$"/"5"')(##3$ ,+%5<$)#%"#$%@  :."(($%-;#3$/$"1)$%%%'#')"/$((')( +%5$:"1)"1"):4'%$>3'&3"&&+($%+23%$4')53"/'"(+23" >"("&A+'##$%#3$$)&$.+)'(3"-/$+)%$1$&#')BC#3$
)%'") $)"/%$ ')(31#7
7! 3$  -1'$  .1($&+#')  (#1;  '(  #3"#  )  BC :  
9"<"/,'#  ')53  #"#')  +($  '&$1!  "/)5>'#3  #3$1  ./'&$ '&'"/(:>3'/$5')51< /'&$#"#')93"/1"#4'//"5$"1/':

 &)1)#$%#3$"&&+($%)$"1#3$%$$)&$%1"')"#"-+# * # #3"##'<$:"&&+($%>"(&<')5)"<#1&;&/$<"2$$1)%" ./$)%$11<#3$('%$4'//"5$'%3>"))#3$
1"%#$1 ')A+'1')5"-+#)"<$")%"%%1$((#3$.$1():3'(($"1&3>"( &"11'$%+#:>3'&31$(+/#$%')#3$1$&4$1;+1-+)%/$("2$ &+11$)&;)#$(%$)<')"#') :>1"..$%')"./;#3$)$ -"5 3$##"/)+<-$1"2$&+11$)&;)#$(%$)<')"#')

&"<$#CC:>3'&3>"(+)%#-$ :CC:

3$ ("<$>$1$#"2$)')#.(($((')  +53('#$./")./"&$ 1$&4$1; D E!>"(.1$."1$% )  E  : 
 5')%$1  ')53  ")%    '(3") ')53%$.('#$%#3$"2$&+11$)&;)#$(')4$1)<$)#+11$)&; #$( 1$((:"(3'2 "%: "3"1"(3#1":1")"/;('( #$1#3$ 1$&$'.##3$1$.1#1<#3$4$1)<$)#+11$)&;#$( 1$((:

"(3'2 "%: "3"1"(3#1":#3$&3"//")+)%$1$&#')(BC:BC :BC")%
>"(.1$($)#$% &&+($%>"(&3"15$(3$$#$%+)%$1$&#')BC
:

#>3'&33$./$"%$%)#5+'/#; .14$'#(&"($:.1($&+#')$D"<')$%
5')%$1 ')53 

= !: 
)(.$&#1
 9"<"/,'#  ')53 

=!:  )2"1  "#3:

+)'1(('(#")#:  '&$:"1)"1")

=!:"),$$49+<"1 %

=!:"2(3'(3')53:#3$) 

= !:+18"/')53

=@!")%&/($%#3$.1($&+#')$4'%$)&$ =3$)$D"<')$%+)%$1$&#') 1 :"&&+($%

 %$)'$%"(')&11$&##3$$4'%$)&$/$%"5"')(#3'<$%'%)#/$"% ");$4'%$)&$')%$$)&$ #$13$"1')5/$"1)$%%%'#')"/ +-/'& 1($&+#11#3$ #"#$:/$"1)$%&+)($/1#3$"&&+($%")%5')5#31+53#3$'/$: #3$/$"1)$%%%'#')"/$((')(+%5$:"1)"1"):4'%$,+%5<$)# %"#$%@  :"&A+'##$%#3$"&&+($%#3$&3"15$1"<$%"5"')(# 3'<
3"4$3$"1%/$"1)$%$.+#;%4&"#$$)$1"/1#3$ #"#$:/$"1)$%"<'&+(&+1'"$ /$5"/"'%&+)($/!1#3$"&&+($%")% 3"4$"/(&"1$+//;5)$#31+53#3$'/$
)  #3'(  &"($:  #3$  "//$5$%  1$&4$1;  >"(    CC  "2$ &+11$)&;)#$( 3$($)#$(>$1$(#"#$%#3"4$-$$) 1$&4$1$%1<"./;#3$)$-"5&"11'$%-;#3$"&&+($% =3'/$ "&A+'##')5#3$"&&+($%:#3$/$"1)$%%%'#')"/$((')(+%5$:"1) "1"):  3"(  1$/'$% +.) (<$ %'(&1$.")&'$( 
 5')%$1 ')53

= !  ")% 
)(.$&#1
 9"<"/,'#  ')53 

=!  (#"#$%  ')  #3$'1 #$(#'<)'$(#3"##3$##"/)+<-$1"2$&+11$)&;>"( CC:#3+53 "&#+"//;'#>"(CC
#>"(+1#3$13$/%#3"#)')%$.$)%$)#>'#)$(( >"(  ,')$%  ')  #3$  ')4$(#'5"#')   3$  $.+#;  +.$1')#$)%$)#  

/'&$>"("/()#&"//$%#,')#3$')4$(#'5"#')A+$(#')>"( .+###3$"&&+($%#3"#1<>3$1$3$-#"')$%#3($&+11$)&; )#$(
#>"(+1#3$13$/%#3"##3$.1($&+#')&+/%)#.14$#3"# #3$"&&+($%>"(3"4')52)>/$%5$11$"()#%'(-$/'$4$#3"#(+&3 &+11$)&;)#$(>$1$15$%1&+)#$1$'#

 $&#')BC
.14'%$("(+)%$1* F


       G=3$4$1 3"(  ') 3'( .(($((')");15$%1&+)#$1$'#&+11$)&;)#$1 -")2)#$:  2)>')5  1  3"4')5  1$"()  #  -$/'$4$  #3$ ("<$#-$15$%1&+)#$1$'#")%')#$)%')5#+($#3$ ("<$"(5$)+')$1#3"#'#<";-$+($%"(5$)+')$:(3"// -$.+)'(3$%>'#3'<.1'()<$)#$'#3$1%$(&1'.#')1" #$1<>3'&3<";$D#$)%#($4$);$"1(:1>'#3')$:1 >'#3-#3H .$1+("/1$.1##3$ 4$1)<$)#+11$)&;#$(

1$((:"(3'2 "%: "3"1"(3#1": D

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

  $4'%$)&$>$4$1:#3$"&#1$<"')(#3"#CC"2$&+11$)&;)#$(

%$)<')"#')>$1$1$&4$1$%1<#3$"&&+($% >:  +1#3$1  A+$(#')  >+/%  "1'($  >3$#3$1  "); ')%$.$)%$)#>'#)$((>"(1$A+'1$%#-$,')$%?
"<#3$4'$>#3"#')#3$.1$($)#&"($:#3$1$>"() 1$A+'1$<$)##,')#3$')%$.$)%$)#>'#)$((3$1$&4$1;>"(1< #3$  -")2    #3$  %1"')  >3$1$  )  ')%$.$)%$)#  >'#)$((  &+/%  -$ $D.$&#$%3$1$'("/()1$A+'1$<$)##3"##3$ <+(#-$&"//$% ')(+&3/'2$&"($(
)1%$1#(+..1##3$.1($&+#')&"($:#3$.1($&+#') $D"<')$%
)(.$&#19"<"/,'#')53:#3$#3$) 

=!"(>$//"( 
5')%$1')53

= !#3#3$<(#"#$%#3"#"&&+($%>"( "..1$3$)%$%1<#3$%$$)&$%1"'))#3$
1"%:>3'/$3$ >"(1'%')5$1)%"./$)%$1<#1&;&/$3$;"/(.14$%#3"# "2$&+11$)&;)#$(%$)<')"#') >$1$1$&4$1$% 3+53:#3$;(#"#$%#3"# CC)#$( >$1$1$&4$1$%:-+# #3$;(#"#$%#3"##3$($>$1$.+#')"./"(#'&")%>$1$($"/$% +1')5#3$$D"<')"#')
)(.$&#19"<"/,'#')53

=!:)#3$ 1$A+$(##3$/$"1)$%%%'#')"/ +-/'& 1($&+#11#3$#"#$:#3$ ."1&$/#3$"2$&+11$)&;)#$(>"(.$)$%')#3$+1#")%'#>"( +)%#3"##3$1$>$1$CC"2$
)%'")&+11$)&;)#$(:>3'&3>$1$ $D3'-'#$%"(D # CC 
)#3'(>";:#3$1$&4$1;"2$ &+11$)&;)#$(1<#3$"&&+($%'(.14$%

)%$1$&#') @#3$
)%'")4'%$)&$&#: BE:

@ >3$)#3$"&#("1$$(.$&'"//;>'#3')#3$2)>/$%5$");.$1(): #3$-+1%$).14')5#3$("'%"&#'(+.)3'<
)#3'(&"($:#3$ "&&+($%>"(+)%').(($((')CC"2$&+11$)&;)#$( %$)<')"#') 3$)#$(>$1$')+1-+)%/$(
#>"( >$//  >'#3')  #3$  2)>/$%5$    #3$  "&&+($%  #3"#  1<  >3$1$  3$ -#"')$%#3($"2$&+11$)&;)#$(
"<#3$4'$>#3"#')#3'(&"($:#3$2)>/$%5$#3$ "&&+($%#3"##3$&+11$)&;)#$("1$15$%1&+)#$1$'#'(#-$ .1$(+<$% -4'+(/;:#3$)#$(>$1$)#<$")##-$#31>)">"; ")%>$1$#-$+($%"(5$)+')$ 3$1$1$:#3$')51$%'$)#( $&#')BC
"1$+/'//$%')#3$.1$($)#&"($ 8$"1)$%&+)($/1#3$"..$//")##"#$3"(1$/'$%+.) #3$"+#31'#;#3$)7-/$+.1$<$+1#')      

   ! 1'<')"/!CB"(>$//"(#3$ "+#31'#;#3'(+1#')    



 

  ! 1'<')"/!C
)#3$.1$($)#&"($:#3$>'#)$(($(3"4$(+..1#$%#3$ .1($&+#') &"($ ")% #3$ 1$&4$1; 3"(  -$$) .14$% -$;)% "// 1$"()"-/$%+-#( 3$1$"()')55'4$)-;#3$#1'"/+1#'()# "&&$.#"-/$
#'(-"($%)(+1<'($(:&),$&#+1$(")%+)"&&$.#"-/$ 1$"()')5 (  "  1$(+/#    #3$  1$5')5  %'(&+(('):  #3$  .1$($)# "..$"/'("//>$%3$'<.+5)$%,+%5<$)#%"#$%@  :."(($% -;#3$/$"1)$%%%'#')"/$((')(+%5$:"1)"1"):'(($#"('%$

E ")%"&&+($%1$(.)%$)#(#")%(&)4'&#$%+)%$1$&#')BC
 9$$.')5')4'$>#3$)"#+1$1$&4$1;:#3$"&&+($%'(($)#$)&$%# +)%$15  1'51+(  '<.1'()<$)#  1  #31$$  ;$"1(  ")%  ')$    (

::')%$"+/##3$1$:#+1#3$1+)%$151'51+('<.1'()<$)# 1  ('D  <)#3(  &&+($%1$(.)%$)#  '(  1%$1$%  #  -$  "11$(#$% '<<$%'"#$/;")%&<<'##$%#,"'/#+)%$15#3$1$<"')')5."1# #3$($)#$)&$ &&1%')5/;:#3$.1$($)#"..$"/'("//>$%

8

!

 



(,2(