Sher Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana





   
     

 !"!#$%&&'

)!#*( # )"

+&,, -- "

)"/"

 )0

+&

",#

 1$  231 & 
&&1 

  







 !! "

 #!

$

% &&&& &&14& '(  !



+!%

 /0 

(( !

( .*,

(

  0

(

*

)

!#

5

(, * (+ ( +

%

(

 4 

*!

* *,

(, * (+ ( +

(

 %   (, * (+ ( +

(

   







*

*!% 3 (

+( 







 !!

+!%

"% + !

+ , "% + !

5*(

,

+

#

!

,  !!

(( !!%



+ 

*

  !!

%  !

 

(+ *,

 ( 5*(

+

( !% 

 %

7

3 ( (,

!( %

 *%  91  *

+ !

#

8*+

+ (

 $*) 
#!

+ *)+(   !( (

(+
 

 ((, 

(!!, ."

1

 !( ( 811

9(( * :;< 1(, ( 

*  /7940 *(

+

(

*1(

 !( (

!(

9((

,  :;< 1(,

* (+=

0  ) 0 + *  +

1  ! +*))

(,+

!(  .( *=  )  + # *  

(* 8!

 (, ( %

* * *= #(!

!

, *(  ! %

07  +*

!

+

(

/

 

 + 1(

  ( +((, =

*

(! ( !%(, * 

,,, *

 

:

<

#% * 1=

!!(, 

 8 !+

+(*+ (, , ,

 >

!1(, ; (! =

)! #!

(=

(+(!   + *

 4

1  4 1 #%

1

*(

(,

*

*! (( % (!= +( (   (

 1(!!

*( +

(! (,

+

5*((, )

(

!( (



(!!,

(* 8!

#

*

+ !

%  )

( ! **

 *! ,((

+!

?3

(, 9*(,

*

(,(



2 !

,#(  * 1 9*(,

* ( ,(

*%+ (

/

1(

 %

* 

* !% *

 **

( * +

*(!

8*!

*

+ !

8( @!

"* "%

+ !

*! 

!

!(+



(,

 22



*

A (

!!

.*( (!

,( 3
!

 * !(

(

*+ !( (





( 0

 '

((,

B !*( !% ()!

(

.*( (!

,( 3
!

( 

 /

++(

(

# *

(( !

( .*,

1 A ( 

(( !

( .*,

) (+

(

+

((

 + ( 

,

(,!%

! ,*(!%

!(+ (!

(

/

"% "*

!( !

!(+

 

!(

* !+%

!! *)+(

++(

# !( (,
!!

+ 

A 2

+ !

8( @!

!

!(+

 !(

 ( * !+%

!!

(!

++(+

,( + + !

,

3


9*(,

*

( (

B+( +% #!

#( ( "

#( C

3  ( C

)! ;+ 8*+ C/


9+)( C

( (#

9 *% * (

9

C

)! C>

C0

3 A+ 1 C7

*( "

*( C2

3 ( C

 9(%


.

C 9%

 3 C C( (

!* +

 //



!!

(+((,

( *+  (,

( !!,(

(,  (



!!%

 (,

( ! % (  (, ,*+

+( )

!

 !!

,,(

(!   ! 

*!

 !!



( 

 $!



% )(  *,



(

+(   ! +(

( (

*!

 !! 

 + ?3 C0 #!!

C2 *( "

*( ( * 

>  % !

(! #(=

(  #( 

( *(, (,( !

%

!!

*

9!(

*

*

# ,!%

*! 5*( A





*!

 *, C0 C2 *( "

*( #

(!  % (,  %

*!!%

 +(!

 

!

 (  (

* +(% )#

(!

#(

!!,

!!%

* *

 *!!%

(

!!



( B !(  

*!

!*()!

(, ! *, ?3

+( 0  +*

!

+

#

!

, *( "

*(  ! %

*

 )!((, ((% *

!!(, 

 8 !+

+(*+ (, , ,

 >

!1(, ; (! ,(  3 ( *

 ( (  ! *,

 !

,  *

2

(

# ( ( (

(+ '%

(!

*

(

(  *

1 #% (

*

1 #% *

()!%

*( "

*(

%

*%+ (

/

1(

 %

 **

( * + + , #% #(, ( ( (

(+ (

 (

   *)+( 3  (

*

* ! C ( (#

9 *% * (

9

*!%



DB7

!* 

+

  C> )!

( * + +

3 (,(,

 ,(,

 % 

  !%

(

(  !  ? +

C0

C2 *( "

*(

 %

+"

B 

 ? +

C7 3 A+ 1

C 3 ( C ( 3  9%

+

*!

(,(

+

(

*



*!  %  )!

!*()! B !(

!!, !!,

! (+ !( (

*

*

 *!!%

(

3
 #!!

   (!

  ((

(

 ( (

!#

( (+ *, *

(

,*(!%

*



((, !!

( *+ B !(

# *(+

( *(+

 # *(+

!%



 %

*

 '

(!!,!(%

(+(% ( (

 * !

#  !

*

% +( + (+(

(,!% 3   !!

+!%



)(!

+

  * )(!

 

 !! '% 



1 (

* % +

*,

+((,   % ( , (*

( .*( (!

,(

1

  6&&17 %&&'

    )!8 C  1(,4  E4

C  )!  E4