Karam Chand And ORS. v. State Of Haryana
# &
'
----- ..
0!-
)%
-----
1
# &
'
-----
0!-
)%
-----
- 2+
56,7*
-
))
12+
56,7*
6/,
7 $)- 9%
,:
..
; "
<
.) :
; "
1 < $)- 6,+ ) + )* ,:
; "
<
; "
1 <- $!- + * & )%
=
;
) "5 ,6) "7
6)!
/<&
**
.6" !+
6",
>?1 ?1 1?1 >?1 '& '@?> - 6
@
,&
/, ",& ",& 9*
76 /
":
56,7*
1-1-
** !!
.6" !+
6",
1> & 1&1 >& '
>
>
",
;
AA<- " "7
/%
+"
*& 0 9) "7+& !+4 ",& )!+ /&
*& /& !+ /& "7+&
6)
C6
7 : "7
*- 0 ,
1->- &
":
) 7 *.) !
"*
! D
&?
6/
**
.6" !+
6",
1> E ) 7 *.) !
"*
**
.6" !+
6",
'
E ) 7 *.) !
"*
**
.6" !+
6",
> E ) 7 *.) !
"*
! D +!
**
.6" !+
6",
) 7 *.) !
"*
**
.6" !+
6",
> - //
!63!
)6"
" 6)) /%
":
7
56,7*
":
, ..
",& ",& 9* ++
6.
..
/- 2+
*
1
) * "
: !
C6
/%&
/ 9
+ !E
@-@- &
.+
+ +F ,.6)
)3 !
*3
%&
7+
./
" 7+
: //
+
6))
,*
: /
/& *3
%- "
+ !& -- (6/4
;2<
"74
69+3 )
)3 !
*3
)6C
$B!
: /
*3
%-
. "
)-
,6
/,
))
& ", 7 )+- "56)
*& 6)*69+& 6) ", (6* )& 6) (6* )& (6*
9 "7
6.
-- (6/4
"7+&
D-- !
*&
'-@- E 3)
6)" "7
+ +F ,.6)
# -$-&
,) 4 "7
;<
4+ +
67+
+
)* &
++
)* &
)* &
)* &
)*
&
)* & (6*
) "5
)*
>
&
3/6
) "5
)*
&
)* & )!+
*
)* &
+"
/
)* & 0 9) 0 9%
)*
& 6)
)*
& !+*
)* &
+
)*
+
)* &
! ,
+
", "7
67+
/,
++
4!
"
+ !&
)* A A 4+ +
$
3)
",- 2+
):
3/
",- 9*
3/
",-
7!
",- ++
;
<
4!
7!
6/, )-
)* A A
//
*)
"% : //
)&
7 : "7
&
2+ /
: "7
+)
%&
,& )&
..
6"
' 9 //
*-
** !!
) *
4+ + / 9
+ !E
6"
)*
+) 67+ 4+ +
4 )
A A
) "5
4"-
// "7
(6* ) "5 "7+- "
6"
, 6
7)
**
)*
"
%- "
;D-<&
.6
+6*3 *.)
,*
))
+ *
(6/4
D-?1
)6C
+ +F ,.6)
7 !
6.
/5
7 !
)* D-?
D-?
)6C
" "7
6)*69+
-- (6/4
4+ +
D-- 67+
./
D- "
@-@-
-- (6/4
", 7 )+
../
D-
. "
), "7
"7+&
4+ +
. "
D-?
D-
../
@
9 "7
. "
), "7
4+ +
D-?
6"
"
=-@- & !6../
)%
4+ + D-
)7
) "5
D-- "
) "5 ;! "
,<
":
/:
6))
)*
-
3/
6)*69+
6)
) "5
"
../
D-
)& : /
/& *3
9"
4+ +
",-
. "
3/6"
6/,
4 //
7 :
: "7
!6)7
. "
"-
. "
D-?- "
-@- &
-- (6/4
../
D-
9 "7
. "
7 :
4+ +
. "
D-?
6"
)&
-@-
3 )
.+
=
", 7 )+
+) 67+
*
"
)*
6",
1
,,
//
7 !
)&
+ "7 ", 7 )+&
!6** )%
4+ + D-
"C6
D-( "
../
D-
$ -
,%
))
/&
)@ ", 7 )+
*
D-?
*
,%
",6
*
D- - !
*
3)
!6/
"56)%- //
! ) 3
*
"56)% - !6
), "
)%
6)!
!-
" "7 6", )4
4+ +
"-
)&
,%
5* "7+&
)!- "
-@- & --(6/4
":
3 )
,6/%
A(A
@&
/& ", 7 )+E
" "7
D-- "
=-=- &
../
: /
/& *3
%&
9 "7
. "
"56)%
6/,
!! 3/
& : "7
../
D- 0
. "
D-0?
!! 3 /
"56)%
""
)6/
+ !
. "
-=-
), "7 ",-
../
=-=-
6/,
!! 3/
4+ +
. "
!! 3 /
;)
,<
""
)6/
"
--
./
4+ + D-H-
B D-
)%
* "
D-
!+ )
D-3
; <D- !
/%!
D-?
!+ )
6", , ! "
7)
+ !
. "
), "7 ",- : "7
../
D-
-- &
. "
67+
6/,
!! 3/
-
. "
D-?
!! 3 /
""
)6/
"
'-@- 2
/5
,6 "7
2
,6
" "7
",
4+ +
D--
A A-
)&
))
",& 63 "!.
;2@<
/% ":
))
"
1-@- &
, ! / !6)
",& 9* ++
D-
/%- 6!
.6)!6
, ! / !6)
D- ?
/ "7
(-
./
./
)%
D- ?
"
.6)!6
, ! / !6)
9*
(
D-?-
./
./
)%
D-?
6!
.6)!6
, ! / !6)
(
D-?-
./
./
)%
D-?
6!
++
.6)!6
, ! / !6)
4+ +
(
D-?-
./
./
)% D-?
"
@-@- & )- -(- )7&
)& : /
/& *3
//%
* "
6/!
*& 6) ",
6)*69+
() !+ *3
%-
)6C
D-
*3
@-@- ), "7
,* !!
"7+&
"7+&
"7+& ) "5 ",& !+& 6) !+& 6) ", )& 6)*69+
*-
D-
I)
" "7
6) ",
) 7+
! ,
D //
6",
I I)
/*!
D-
D- I)
D- 4!
6..
6/"
5I)
/* D-1- D- I)
" "7
6)*69+ 4!
6/"
I) I)
/*!
D- >
- + !
I)
-@- - 6) !+&
* "
D-
I)
), "7 6)
6",
*- "
" "7
6)*69+
() !+
D--
)% ":
"!&
.6
", "7 .) *
,&
)7 !+
**
.6" !+
6",
>?1 1?1 >?1 '?1 ?'@
> -
)7
, ,
./
76 /
/- 6) "7
6)!
/&
) "5
9 "7
6",
11 )---
4+ +
./
""
77)
) "5 ;,
,<
**
*
* ",
) "5 "7+&
).
3/6"
"!- "
;
,<
)
3/6
../
4+ +
: "7
../
/
*.
(6*
3)
9 "7
",&
*& "7+& 6) ", )&
!+& !+& 6)*69+& 6) ", )& !+&
).
3/6"
"!-
./
/9
+)
3) 9!
4+ +
*&
) "7
"
* "
*) 9
: / 6)7
*3
3) 67+
7 !
+!
--@
+6!
D-- "
* "
* )9 !+& &
& 0& + +F ,.6)-
D-
@-'-
) "7 @
C6
7 !
6! "7
@ @- 5 ", &
D-
4)
+ +F ,.6)
(6* )-
--6"
7 :
6.
/)
,%
!!
* "
..
!!-
) "7
! ,
..)
* "7
),&
/,
"/% @
/% ",&
*& ++
6& 9*
76 /
** !!
.6" !+
6",
1> & 1&1 >&1 '
>
>
" "7
C6
7 : "7
@
1->- &
)/
56,7*
$)- 9%
,:
..
!& $)- 6,+ ) + )* ,:
;) : !
" !
<
6"!
..)
* "7
),-
)76
6"!
..
":
",& ++
**
) *
//&
"% 7)
..
!&
6/,
%-
, !.6
& 0 + ,.6)& !
*3
;21<&
3)
9 "7
@ @?- 5 ", ;21<
D-
4)
+ +F ,.6)
(6*
! ,
1 +
7 !
3)
9 "7
, !.6
+) 67+
4 )
) "5
!6/
!6../% , !
6)3
) "5 "- "
4)
+ *
7 !
&
"6)! "7 7)6,7
!6 +&
77) )-
4+ /
) "5 "7+-
*
* ",
) "5
) "5 "7+&
).
3/6"
"
;2 <
67+
,*
", "7
) "5
4"
6"
6))
) "5
../
(6*
"E
" /6, "7 ) "5 +!
3/6&
;
"<& 6)
6",
=?' )---
;2<
6) ", (6* ;2=<
))
..
!- +6!
6"!
"*
63/
,7
"- "
>
) "5
)!&
7)6,7
%- :
)4 !
6))
./
3
77) )- :
":
)&
./
6))
) "5 "-
)76
6"!
) "5
D-I
7 : "7
6))
7 !
) "5
":
"- :
) "5 , ,
"% ) * "
) "5 "-
!
!6 +
!6!
6"!
)) 7+ :
)4 !
77) )&
) "5
!- "
%&
6/,
/%
) "5 "- + !
4!
77) )-
)76
6"!
..
! ,
!6
=
!6
' !6
!
!6 +&
77)
"/%
+ !
)76*
6"!
"%
!
C6
77)
""
)* "
! !
6",
! ,
/,
6)!
) * "
!&
) 6*!
//%
6/
"%
3) "7
* ",
.) " ./
*3
)% ) * "
)%
) * "
6/,
**
,&
**
2+
!6
4 "7
!! 3 /
),!
*&
3 / 6/, !4 6.
* ",
!6 + 7)
*.
+ *
**
""
)6
9"
"-
/*
*.
!! 3/
6")
6// , *
, !.
),!
+ !
.) " ./
).
!
# $%
&'
())* +),
-.* "
!
#$$
!#%& '(
%#)*(+
@ "
.) " ./
, ! 6!!
)76*
6"!
77) )&
"%
)76
6"!
..
,7 "7
- !
6))
./
'-@-
# -$-
;2<& 4+ + D-&
# -$
@-@- - + !
,7 "7
,6) "7
,&
!6
"!6/
67+
7 : "7
" ,
6)!
,7 "7
"!.
7" F
C6 )
6/,
,7
!! 3/ 2+
,7 "7
,&
"/%
%&
.!
,6
4 !
67+
!- +6!&
""
6/.) !&
!6/
*6 +
67+
"!6/
, ! 6!!
"- 4&
C6
) !
,7 "7
) D-
2& 2
2=&
6))
./
'-@-
# -$- 6!
6))
: /
/& *3
%- )- 6,+ )% ;2<&
//%
=
* "
(6*
",&
)% " 7+
#1'
-$
$B D--
//%
* "
6) (6*
D-E
$B D-
#''
$-
//%
* "
"7+&
#'
6)!- 6C
D-
" + )7
*3
), "7
6/
,* !!
,&
"6*3 )- 6C
'# -$- -- (6/4
;2<
.+
)3 !
*3
7+
./
: //
+
,6) "7
" 7+
7+
,*
: /
/& *3
%-
$B
& )3 !
*3
%&
)6C
: /
/& *3
%- 6) "7
6)!
!! * "
'# -$
)3 !
@#>'
-$-
+ "7 : /
/& *3
%&
../
D-
9 "7
. "
), "7
*& 6)*69+& 6) ", (6* )& 6) (6* )& (6* )&
*&
7 :
"
+ !&
. "
))
", 7 )+
7 :
+ !
. "
D- ?- -- (6/4
;2<
,6) "7
6)!
!! * "
),&
*A!
/% "7
,*
) "5 "7+A!
/% "7
,*
),-
67+
. "
: "7
../
), "7
"7 "7
) "5 "7+A!
%- + !
../
D-I
../
. "
D-I?
. "
7 :
+ !
. "
7 :
#1 -$- ",
) 6*!
!&
;2<
-- (6/4
;2<
# -$&
7 "
"
,7 "7
-
*-
6))
# $- *
: "7
/E
* "
)E ", "7
)*
), "7
,* !!
" "7
. "
), "7
!&
7 :
""
6")
"% ""
)- "
6",
9 "7
, "7!
+6!
), "7
# -$-
!
!6 + 7 : "7
6"
,7 "7
&
"%
)76
6"!
..
6)*69+ 7 :
!&
)- -(- )7 ;2<&
).
"E
>
'
3/6"
"-
"/%
6)*69+ "7+&
9"
4"
).
,7
!6 +
"! !
+6!
)76*
6"!
!6!
),- 6) ", (6* ;2 =<
//%
!+
6)*69+ "7+-
"/%
6)*69+ "7+- :
4+ + !6..
2& 2
21
)* A A&
56"
!+& 6) !+& 6) ",
6)*69+
*-
//%
!
!6 +&
).
,7
/ 9
6)*69+ "7+& 6) !+& !+& 6) ",
",
) 6*!
!&
""
"%
"%
"/% 4!
7 :
6)*69+ "7+-
)76
6"!
./
6))
//
+)
+)
./
6))
;2<
&
+ *
;2 <
./
6))
"7+- 6) ", (6* ;2=<
./
6))
, "7
!
!6 + ./
6))
,&
C6
6"!
!6!
;2 <
./
D- H- -- (6/4
;2<
67+
./
D- -
6))
4"
!
!6 +&
6/,
,!
"!- "
%&
*.
.6
C6
-- (6/4
;2 <
;2 <
"
3!
""
./
6))
4"
./ "!-
?
, "7
C6
"-
)76
6"!
)- 6,+ )% ;2<&
//%
* "
6))
"/%
",- $B
D-
)- , )!+ (6* )&
)& , "
)"*
/&
", 7 )+ ;2<
",-
//%
* "
, ,
6/,
6/
6"
"! !
" %
"%
"! !
" %
6/
6/,
"/%
"- "
2
//%
3) "-
%.
,6) "7
6)!
",/ "7
,%
",&
: /
*3
", 7 )+- )- 6,+ )% ;2<
//%
* "
$B D-
)/%
,6) "7
6)!
!!
* "
"%
3)
6/,
",/ "7
"!.
))
/- !6
"56)%- 2
. "
D- 0?
!! 3 /
"56)%
6/,
)6/
. "
D- I?
!! 3 /
"56)%
6/,
)6/
"
-- &
../
D- &
. "
!! 3 /
"56)%
6/,
)6/
+ !
. "
D- ?-
6"
"56)%&
!! 3 /
6! "7
"56)%
""
)6/
!
!6 +&
;2< %!
7!
",&
+6!
""
"! !
6/
"! !
)- , )!+ (6* ;2<
",6
* "
,%
",-
)76*
6"!
%&
).
,7
).
,7
"- + !
)% + 7+/%
6/- 7
6"!
"%
)- -(- )7 ;2<
//%
-
6)*69+
).
"- :
)- 6,+ )% ;2<&
//%
* "
. "
!! 3 /
"56)%
""
)6/
)- , )!+ (6* )&
)& , "
)"*
/&
", 7 )+ ;2<
# J
1
!
! !
!
!
"
#$%#& ! !
!
'
! !
(
!
+6!
""
6"
%&
"%
6/-
9"
4/ ,7
:
)4 !
! *./
!-
9 // + *&
6/,
! /%
+ !
6"!
"%
3/ !+
3)
+) 67+ 4+ +
4 )
) "5
@ @?
6"
6.
4+ +
6",
=?' )--- ",
) 6*!
!&
)*
,/%
"!&
> 3&
C6
3:
6/,
56"
6))
,*
6))
!- ",
) 6*!
!&
6"!
: "7 9"
4/ ,7
!6!
6"!
D./
"7+&
) "5 ;! "
,<
!- )- 6,+ )% ;2<&
//%
* "
6",- "56)% -
).
,7
3/6"
"- !
)- --6"
;21<&
//%
* "
"7+&
, 6!
D) ,&
6",
"7+- I)
D- - )- -(- )7 ;2<&
//%
* "
$B D- 4+ +
B 9
4 !
$B
) "5 D- -
4+ +
!-
"%
6))
,*
: /
/& *3
%& 56!
6)) ) "5
'
4"
":
, ,
)6
!6 +
%-
>
!6
*.
/% *6 + "6*3 )-
"! !
4+ +
":
,&
!6 +&
""
/%
D./
,&
, !
"
, ,
"%
) "5 "7+&
""
"- "
":
":
", "7
,&
*-
6"!
;) : !
" !
<
=
) "5
":
"/% ! D
",& 9*
6&
",-
" "7
C6
7 : "7
56,7*
!6!
*&
" ,
! ,
) "5
C6
6"!
: !
" !
":
"7+&
@
6",
1>
4)
6/,
":
6",
1> - 2+ /
6! "7
",&
+ "
9"
4/ ,7
6! "7
,/%
",- !
!6 +
**
6",
1>
6",
1> -
*3
6"/ 6/
*3/%
!6 +
":
,&
" "7
+"
C6
":
",& 9*
6&
",- "
" "7 7 :
/00
"! ,
6"!
: !
" !
" "7 7 :
))
"%
6!
+"
C6
,& , ,
"% "56)%
"%
%-
6)!
) 36
*-
6)!
!6
6/,
!6
/, ":
/:
) * "
"56)% + *&
) 36
+ *-
67+&
6)
6) ",
).
"56)%
6",
6) ", )- !
!6 +&
=
*.67"
56,7*
C6
/%
+"
"
, '
)&
'
:
) 36
"/% "!- "! !
/%
: "7
9- "
!&
/, "A3/
6.)
",
6"!
../%
>
)%
)6 /%
/,
56,7*
":
"/%
"/%
"! !
/%
*&
) 36
/,
)% 56,7*
)7
"6*3
6/,
":
"
//&
67+
C6
,/%
)* ,&
) 36
*- :
+ "7
/,
"%
9 //
%- !
!6 +&
!! 3 /
"D
"%
,&
""
)6/
+
3/ !+
9 // ",-
"/% ! *./
!- 2+
! 6
) "7 !&
3/
7!
9*
3/
9- "
6"
"56)%& )- 6,+ )% ;2<
. "
, ! 6!!
!! 3 /
""
)6/
!
!6 +&
""
",- "/%
"56)%
",-
!6
!-
!
!6 +&
""
9 //
"%3 ,%
)*
,/%
"!-
6/,
*3
%-
9 //
*- :
",-
", "7
7 : "7
! "7/
4+ +
/&
6/,
6", /
1 &
!6
"% %- B 9 4 !
", "7
4+ +
//!
6",
1> & !6!
"
",&
)7
"*
"-
"/%
):
! 6
!
!6 +
//!
6",
1> -
6)7
", "7
..
", "7
: !
..
: !
, !* !!
6,7*
":
1-1-
1->- &
..
/&
",!&
6, 7 !
":
))
**
.) !
): "7
" "7
)%
.!&
*./%
56,7* ,6
*.
6,
. "7
../ 3 /
: !
>
) * "
)
,6)
!63*
+ "
+!&
.%
!
6,7 *3
"!6)
, )
+& + "
!63*
**
/%
)-
7 !
)%
!63* !!
!&
.6
6.
+ "
**
/%
D. )%
((
-1(2 +
, %3!
4