Achhe Lal v. State Of Haryana
!"##$ % & !##$ &''()*)*+),')-()* ###..**) /
% /)/ 0 ) -) ) ###.
/
1!
2( 1#
! "
#
$$$
3# % &
!
%' %% ()%)
+
,-.
/ '01 (2 %% ())3
4'4 4'5 4'' 42'
-
6 %0') 7 8-69:
# +
&
00 &%
/ & 4'4 -6 .
#
. %)));<
4'5 -6 .
#
. %)));<
4''< -6 .
#
. %)));<
42'
-6 .
#
. %)));<
( ( #
(4 %% ())3 =
%1<#
&
*
(5 %% ())3 &
!
#
#
#
/
7
:
-
#
=
>
*
! %' %% ()%)
?
&
# *
#
"
*
*
%'
#
/
# @
*
&
# ( #
*
=
,
AA.
/
# " *
# # &
# -
+
# ())3
#
#
9
#
B
#
,-.7 :
? *
!#
*
#
'
? *
)% %( ())3
&
#
# !
$
#
# #
5 ( "
= #
&
(4 %% ())3
*
* )% )5 %33'
&
# = *
* = * *
*
# =
#
#
* &
*
#
C # #
-
* #
* #
*
6 : ()%5 7
()%59:
/ *#
()%5
6 :
())) 7
()))9:
"
()%5
. %(
6 :
. ())2
())) *
#
-
* "9*
.
*
!!
"
# $ % & $ ' % % (&$) * %+ && ,- . %$+%
/& $%& %$+,$+&0 %%% + %,, &%& %%&
/&%&%+$%%,,& % 0 % 0 $ & & 1+0 +& % %2 %% 0$ +, + , %
/&%%$,+&% &+$,&, %$+,$% &
/& %% 0$ %+&3 %%,& $0%3, &$0$,4 & $ %
+ 1+ & ( /& $5&$%5 $,$0 + +0 05 &0$%&$ ,%$ & &$0%%%0% & , & % &+& &%
/&)
6 &&%+,& %&+&&
/&%$ & &0% &%+& ',&&$0
/&$ , %%$+,$% + %%
$& &$+, %*
!" # $ $ # % !#! &
& ' () ** + ! $ * * , ! # # $# ! - ./0 ! ' ! , ! %!1 '2 2 /0 # ! 2 /0 /0 /0'#
!
! # !
!! 1 .
!! 0&%& $ % + 1+ $0 & ( $& % $ %0 &$%$%%+&$0
6+ +0 0 &% 0 $%%%+&+ %,%$ & &+,*%%%**0% & ,& %*&+&&%& +0
/& + %% &&0 0 % & & $ +1+%%&& 7(
%%%&&$ %
"8 8,0 %% &+&$0 %+$+%&$0+%+
& %% .4 '$+&%0%+ %+ %$%,%5 %++& $$3+ &+ &&+ 9+ :.4 & ;+ : +0 '%&&%&&%0 8 % $%&&% %%, $
! !
7
() /0/0 $ ! '3% 45 6$ $57 !!!
87
:
.
* !
+ " /)0 / !059: ,
# #
*
A #
,-.
#
#
"
*
#
# =
# -
= * ! # # "
* ! "9*
+ ; +! < /5(90
(
" .
D *
'$<%%,+ &,, %
%% % $ 0 ,&, + %% %
& %++ %& 0&$0 %% %0%%% %% +:0&,,% 1+ %+% $% % + +, +&0 0,%$&, % 0 &, %&++&% (,,&+&%0%%+&$ &%+% %%&0&,, % %+&$%%0( &=>
8 %) ,
B1<
" B5< .
A
@
* * B0< /
*
=
" +
*
"
=
# -
*
*
#
* * *
%% &
B2
*
() %% ())3
(4 %% ())3 -
#
*
# "
# * /
,
#
=
"
* # = #
* *
#
C
> =
1<5 "
#
#
*!
* "9*
+!= >+!! /< +0? /505
::
8%+% & %+(
+% $ , & %& $+ & % &%$ &%0% $$&$% , +&$&,0 %, & %( -
* # " *
@ #
* "9*
;
;! 6 @ 55/0 / !0 (
A
*
?&+$ %+&+%&,+0
%% %0& %+(%%+ &&% % %&& %$$%+0 +%0 +$ %&&%+&$%,1+0/+ % & & %+( %, % + &0$ <&$ +&,% &&%,0&$&
+ & ,+0%&%&& %%,% % 2 % % &+ & 9;& & % +> ,
* "9*
>? < +? /507
5
,
-*
#+%&& @%,%%@%+&$ 0,1+0&$%%%+& $ +%%$ ' + %&, % %+ %% %+&$ % %++0 %'%1+0%+%% %+% %% +& $
& +& $ % ++%%% &$0%+%%.+&$
+&$%%0% , %, & 0 %% 3% % &+ 0$ +%+&$ + & %% % %+ 1+ +%&'%+&$0 %%+ %%'%%%+&$ %%&%%4 ( 0,&%%++% 0$& +&+ %%+&, 0&+$% + + %% & % % %1++%%+&4& 0%+ , %+%% & %+%&
& % &&( '%&%%+&%%0
%0%%$%& %+&$3% &%+ % &%+&$0 %%,3 + %%&+%&,+0,&,% 0%%+%%1+%$%% %% %+%%$ & $& %+%%$&%@%,%%@%% $ &$0 ++0$&$%& ,+0$ +%&'$ % % %&%%% + %+& & % 0 &+ 0 & $<% %+& %& % +%&$ +0,0
%%%+ , %&, &,+0,,&>
( %4 -
*
@
7:
#
%1
!
#
protracted delay in this case as it is a matter of profound concern. The appellant being a poor labourer could not engage a private counsel due to lack of resources. The appeal was filed in 2010 through a legal aid counsel. The learned counsel for the appellant moved an application for suspension of sentence in 2012 but the same was dismissed vide order dated 29.11.2012. While the Registry was directed to list the appeal within 6 months, it is deeply troubling that no further action was taken. The High Court Legal Services Committee also failed to take appropriate steps to secure a hearing for the release of the appellant. The matter was finally listed out of turn, on a priority basis, since the appellant was still languishing in jail.
His appeal is finally heard in 2024, after a lapse of 14 years, and has led to his acquittal, but tragically, by now, he has already served the entirety of his sentence. This delay has highlighted an unacceptable lapse in securing the ends of justice which has gravely undermined the appellant's personal liberty and has shocked the conscience of this Court.
up before Hon'ble the Chief Justice for appropriate administrative action, he may deem necessary, in similar cases.
:
(5 )3 ()(1
<0A% B
; +;/ B *
+;/