← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1067/2014dismissed

Ram Chander v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-01-19Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron5 pages



     

!"#$#%&'&()*+

!,-!($#. /00#11!(" 2#.'3' 4"!"#!.5!(!!($"-#.' / #'0($#("'  )  67  4444   67  4

 

.#'#(") .438-$##0 !.,!.9$:%!"#."-#!00#11!(" ;;; 444!.(9  -&' !00#!1 -!' <##( &1#$ <5 "-# %,01!&(!(" !, -!($#. !00#11!(" !=!&('""-#!%>3&""!1.#'0($#("'" <5"-#1#!.(#$$$&"&(!14#''&('3$=#9 !(&0!"."-##(%#' 03(&'-!<1#3($#.4#%"&(? !($?

($&!( #(!1$# @ AB .'-."  -# .#'0($#("'  "  C#.# ".&#$ . %,,&""&(= $C.5 $#!"-  4(&! C&"-&( '#:#( 5#!.'  -#. ,!..&!=# %%.$&(= " "-# %,01!&(!(" !00#11!(" 9 -&' #1$#. $!3=-"#.(!,#154(&!C!',!..&#$C&"-!3.!: .#'0($#("  ( * !' 0#. &($3 .&"#' !($ %#.#,(&#'  # ,!..&#$ -&' $!3=-"#. !"#. '#11&(= -&' -3'# !($ '0#(" !<3" ' 1!%' &( ,!..&!=#  # =!:# ! ,".%5%1# &( $C.5  -# &(1!C'  -&' $!3=-"#. $#,!($#$ ' 1!%9 C-&%- -# =!:# " 4, !"-

.#'0($#(" !"-#.&(1!C-&'$!3=-"#.&(.$#."'!:#-&' .#'0#%""#.,!..&!=#94(&!C!'<#&(=-!.!''#$!($"."3.#$.

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

$ =(# 1C  ( .#%#&:&(= "-# ,#''!=#9 "-# %,01!&(!(" !1(= C&"- !1C&($#.9 ,!'( C#(" " 38-&H!1(5C-#.#-#3($"-!"-&'$!3=-"#.C!'15&(=("-# 1.&("-#1<<54-#C!'%:#.#$C&"-!<1!(8#"-#.#C!'! <13# ,!.8 !.3($ -#. (#%8  # %,01!&(!("  &(>3&.#$ ., -&' '(&(1!C !3.!: .#'0($#("   !($ -&' !"-#. 4, !"

.#'0($#("   <3" ( '!"&'!%".5 .#015 C!' =&:#( <5 "-#, -#(-#&(.,#$-&'"-#.!,&15,#,<#.'("#1#0-(#-#5" %!,#!""-#01!%#"-#&(%&$#("-#%,01!&(!("'3'0#%"#$"-!" -&' $!3=-"#. 4(&! -!$ <##( 8&11#$ <5 -#. -3'<!($ !3.!:

.#'0($#("  D -3'<!($6' 53(=#. <."-#.' E$#:!.'6  (!,#15 4!3.!:!($ !:&D,"-#.&(1!C(!,#15-!($#.F!1! .#'0($#(" ?  !($ !"-#.&(1!C (!,#15 4, !"- .#'0($#("  .#'0#%"&:#15<5-!(=&(=.("31&11&(="-#&.$C.5$#,!($' 3.&(= ".&!1  "-# %!'# %,01!&(!("

!00#11!(" $&$("'300.""-#0.'#%3"&(%!'##&("#. !1&!'"!"#$"-!"-&'$!3=-"#.C!''3#.&(=.,,#("!1&11(#'''&(%#

 <#.# -#. ,!..&!=# !($ '-# 3'#$ " .#,!&( 3($#. ,#("!1 $#0.#''&((!%%3("C-&%-'-#%,,&""#$'3&%&$#(  "&''"!"#$"-!""-#!%%3'#$ &#"-#.#'0($#("'" !%&(= ".&!1 C#.# (" &( !(5 ,!((#. .#'0('&<1# . "-# $#!"-  -&' $!3=-"#.4(&!!'"-#5-!$!1C!5'8#0"-#.C&"-1:#!($!#%"&( -# %,01!&(!(" C!' $#%1!.#$ -'"&1# <5 "-# 1#!.(#$ 3<1&%

.'#%3". !($ C!' %.''#I!,&(#$  # C!' %(.("#$ C&"- -&' 0.#:&3' '"!"#,#(" I J  <3" -# '"!"#$ "-!" ( '3%- '"!"#,#(" C!',!$#<5-&,<#.#"-#01&%#-#'"!"#,#(""-3=-<.#-&' '&=(!"3.#' !" 0&(" 9 -C#:#.9 -# :13("!.&15 '"!"#$ "-!" -# C!' 3($#. '-%8 $3# " "-# $#!"-  -&' $!3=-"#. !($ "-# 01&%# -!$ <"!&(#$-&''&=(!"3.#'(<1!(80!0#.'#$&$(".#,#,<#."-# (!,#  "-# 01&%# &%&!1' C- <"!&(#$ -&' '&=(!"3.#' ( <1!(8 0!0#.'  # .#'&1#$ ., -&' #("&.# '"!"#,#(" <#.# "-# 01&%# F!,1#'-

G+  ,"-#.  4(&! $#%#!'#$  !1' $&$ (" '300." "-#0.'#%3"&(%!'#!($'"!"#$("-#'!,#1&(#'!'-#.-3'<!($

!,-!($#. !00#11!(" F,!1

G $!3=-"#. !, -!($#. !00#11!("   !1' $&$ (" '300." "-# 0.'#%3"&( %!'# -# 1#!.(#$ ".&!1 3." 8##0&(= &( :&#C "-# '"!"#,#("' "-#!00#11!(" !,-!($#.

%,01!&(!(" 9!"-#."-# $#%#!'#$D F!,1#'-

G+ 9 ,"-#.  "-# $#%#!'#$ !($ F,!1

G 9'&'"#."-#$#%#!'#$&("#.,'.$#.$!"#$?9 <'#.:#$ "-!" "-#.# C!' ( 0''&<&1&"5  !(5 &,0.:#,#(" &( "-# 0.'#%3"&(%!'#<5#I!,&(&(="-#.C&"(#''#' !"-#.&"C31$<# !<3.$#(("-#4"!"##I%-#>3#.49!11"-#.#,!&(&(=C&"(#''#' C#.#=&:#(30!($"-#0.'#%3"&(#:&$#(%#C!'%1'#$

 7#!.(#$%3('#1."-#!00#11!(" !,-!($#.'3<,&"' "-!"&(!%""-#!00#11!(" !,-!($#.C!'3($#.0.#''3.#!($-# $&$("&("#($".#'&1#.,-&''"!"#,#("<#.#"-# 1&%#"&' '"!"#$ "-!" -# C!' &( !%" "-.#!"#(#$ " ,!8# '3%- '"!"#,#("' <#.# "-# 3."  # -!' .##..#$ " "-# $#0'&"&(  $%".'6 0&(&(C-&%-&("#.!1&!&'("&%#$!'11C') @7&=!"3.#,!.8'&K#+L+%,5#11C&'- <.C(&(%13.!($-!.$1&8#0!.%-,#("( <"- '&$#'  (#%8 !($ &' $&.#%"#$ <1&>3#15 30C!.$!($3(".30"#$(0'"#.&.!'0#%" 1#" '&$#  ( 3."-#. $&''#%"&( C-&"# =1&'"#(&(= "&''3# 0.#'#(" 3($#.(#!"- 7&=!"3.# ,!.8 &' 01!%#$ !<3" "-5.&$ %!."&1!=#A ' 0.# 0&(&(  "-# $%".9 &(H3.&#' !.# '3&%&#(" " %!

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

3.,&" !,  3$=# *+ !,&" "#) G-#"-#."<#.##..#$" #0."#.) #'M