High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1113/2016disposed of

Aslam And ANR v. State Of Haryana

2019-10-18Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu17 pages

!""!

%& ' ((())%% * +

,- ((()

. ( +"' !

'))%% ( (*"/+""

0 ,-( 111

( 2'" ))% " " "

" ' 3&

((

#- '"

"%+"6 .!'/%"+" 7(

89'#- '))%% 9'9!'9"

' " !)"'#%+!

':".% " ' ;

' :.; +!

" 80 ' . !

" '"% & +<% !!

'" ' ;

'.+!

;'#!"!

! ""&)"& )" 9 -- )- " (

5!'

" '.+!

(: % )-& " '"&)%"&)"& -(

% " " )" (

59 #&"

"& !&) "+!

" $ '.+!

'+!

"84 "&"%.! "' ;.;(+%&=' 9'9 "

%9"

' '))%% 9!>"

'!'(

2'! ')! "" '%%"

?+:

+9 .(+("&39) 0& +!'% ="'' ) %%"( + #" +"' 2& +"' " ,(7(

="''

'"'&9"

!&)%" %%"

?'" " & 9"

''% # - 9' 9 %

0& %+!'% +!

'"'' ''

/"9%/( '" !&#!/(2' &"%-' " %!

'" % "# '!% # !(2'-)!

''##!

#-&( '#" '"!&)%" !5 :.9"

.(+("3("" " " "&9!(

&"&3 '"'(+'9 &"!%%%-<&" &""% ,)"

% '"'(,

" ?(.((9 ! # @(6: '"'

?9'"'%% '' #)#-!!%& '( ' !9 '# !&&"

")/ +/ " '3""!

" .(+( .!'/% !9 ..!'/%(+!

"? .+!

9 " ("" " " ')%! !!!9")!

"&9!+!

" (.((+'9)!# " .!'/%9''

" ?(.((9 ! (

?( !+!

"4 :.+!

" 8 &!

9(2'!!9 (@ !+!

" '&!

9% ( !&)% " " " ") +!

"4(.((9) ( ( 2')! "<&"&# 9"

)) (2'

'!!+!

"(.((9!(2'-"

'%% "%%%" '&)%"!!(,9 '-" %-"!" '" !( ?( 2'))%% 9!"!

! #( ,! '"))%( 8( A''%!% ') "' ''

'3& !(

.A + #" +"'

' "!

"& 9 '" " 9 - '"&( +'9 0& %+!'% +!

'"'"

'%" '-

? # 8(

.'' '' 9%/# " (2'

' &))%"!

"B<(.# +, .%"!+

"&3 '"'( ," " "'"" )" (,"" 9!

& '# "&3(:!<&" #-!% '!!

'# 99"

''(,&"

'""

9- &'& > %-

?( +'&- !&)%" - '"9')) '( 4( .A

' #" '" 4((

(+'9

!%"0& %+"+!-+!'% +!

'"'(+' &"

'#" '! " "!

B<(. ) !B<(. # '#% '(

'9'"&!

"9"

'') ' 9 " ''(+'9 ""(+'&" ' # 9-(2' ' #!/ ''(7 '"')) '(+'

'!!) " ' " - '" '( '> '@(.(.('9!%' "%(:!<&" "#-

" @(.(.('

'@B<(. '+<%% : & "C& B<(.B# '#'" (+'" ''"!% '!

'9<%%-%

? #

.( +'" '"& '

B<(.C(+'&"

B<(.0! +!

" ?(.(#'" )" (+'%&"

'9)!# ':%>" (

? !"'

" ?(.((+'" " "'" '

B<(., )" ( .A2&+"' ' "&

'"'

9 # 8-(,(( (" 4((

(+'9 0&

%+!'% +!

'"'"

'%" '-

# 8(

. '' '' 9%/# '" ( ,"+ #"+"'&))%"!

"# +(,((.%"!+

"&3( ,"'

? &#+ "&3(+'9 &"!%%%-<&""""%,)"

% "&3(

?'9 )!# " '"'9''

?(.((9!(

(

'' ' " ' " "!

B<(. )

B<(. ': " " "! 9'"!'9 /" )"" &&B<(.= 9'"!'#'"" (:!<&" #-!% !! '

'# '9>"

9%%99"

'(,%&"

' 9- & '' > %- &--(+'' &-!&)%" - '"9'')) '( ( .A?+:,)%+"'

'9) "

# .%"!+

""&3( - !") ))%"!

"B<(.9"

& +: +9 ' ! &% C: B<(.@ & & B<(.@5( ( .A8+:+9

'9) " .%"!+

""&3(+ #"+"'&))%"!

"B<(.# '"&(, && B<(. '& '' #% + 7" .%"!+

"&3 !" &%C:(,)) ''"

)%B<(.5 ')%! &9' "&'((

"& 9 ! & + "&3( +' 9 &"!%%%- <&"#-+:+ -"( ,&))%"!

"B<(.5

" ?(.((!# '&!% #! "&9 " "

"( ?(

" "&9 )!# :%%>" "))%"!

"B<(.5 !"'

" ?(.((# '

!% #! "!

"&9(

? "&9")!# :%%> " 9''

B<(.0+!

" ?(.((9!#- @(6: '"'( '"!" %%9"

'"3""!

" .!'/%

'!& '"!9' ')%"! "!"% .!'/% "&&B<(.5?( ( .A +"'

&" ' "! ..!'/%

( (

8/" @5+:=&%"

'""

3"0'"

./""%%+/ " '#" ' )) '&!

"&'))!%"

)%B<(.7 9'"!'#'"" ( ( .A4+:+ - .%"!+

""&3 '"') (

? ' "!

"&9! & ' + "&3( ,

" (.((9!(+'9 &"!%%%- <&" ., "&3( ,)))%"!

"B<(.D5( &"! %%<&" " '%)!%% " "&9'

'&9! "!

"&&B<(.D 9'"!'9

#-@5/'

"( 2'"!

"&9)!# @(:%%>" !"'

" ?(.((# "

!% #! "&9 ))%< " "

"(2'"!

"&9' ') '!)) -9)"

',.%"!+

"( ?( .A$(+"

' "!% "! ""%,)"

% "&3

(

? '"!

"&9)!# ' '&"!%% <&" ""))%"!

"B<(.D5(+' / '! "&(+' % "%%) '*"!

"&: & "C&B<(.B(+'&"!%%%-<&"

"& '@" '""B<(. 9'"!'#'" (2' #%&)% "&9%# " ' ' "!

" &" '" "B<(.(+'% %

B<(.5 C+@ '"'(2'"!

"& 9)!9"

'%%'" - <%% (+'

"')""

')"#"%"

- <%% ) "&!% #% ( 8( :!<&" #-!% '!! '

' 9"3- ')" ) "&( +'9!%% ' <&" ""!'" (%)!%! ""% ++C+@ '# 9)#%!/99 / (+'" " ""

#" 9 "&9'"!''# /" )" '&"! %%<&" "( ( .A , +/

+"'

, .%"! +

" "&3

'"'

(

?%)!%! """'

$ ,%9"

'&)%%9 )"

''"&( (

8 )!%9' +:7=& 9'"!'9! "!

"&& B<(.+9'"!'#'""

"9"

( 4( .A , 73 =& ) ?(

? !! "%' ) " '!

9&"!%%%-<&"( &"!%% <&" !

' '"& %)!%%9"

' 9" %

!)- @&)%%9'"!'9 /" )""&& B<(.2 9'"!'#'""

"9"

( $( .A #%0&"%+"') (

?!! %&+%&=') " '! 9&"!%%%-<&"( &"!%% <&" !

' % )!% % 9" 9" %

!)- @ &)% % 9'"!' 9 / " )""&&B<(.E 9'"!'#'""

"9"

( .A B, %/ +"' ) " )" " ' ! )) -9"

'C+@ '#(

( .A+: &)

(

?!") C: 7( $

?+!

" 54 :.+!

"? .+!

%9"

)"" ) -" "!

- "! .

.!'/% '!)!"B<(.* & '',73=& .%"!+

"((( !" &% C: 9'"!'C:7($

(

B<(.*59" #-+:

="' =& 9' % & '" & B<(.*5 ( 2' " " " '!9' @5+:=&%"(

( ,) (

' "&&%-2& +"''(( ( " "!

B<(. %9"

') !B<(.

% "!

"& 9'"!'9 /" )""&&B<(.=9'"!'9

#- '"&2&+"'(

(

!!%&+%&='9 #-@5+:=&%"( (

!!%&+%&9 " #-@5+:=&%" '-&"!%

B<(.*5 B<(.*5?)!

"%-(2'-9"" '- !

'"%"

>!- %(2'- ' "!%

B<(.*54B<(.*5$(!!"'%"9 #- @5+: =&% " " '" )!( ?(

!! "%' 9 " ' "!%

B<(.*58(%% ' '!! %& +%&"%'% ')%"!) - &!

')%! 9' '-'!&&"

)) "&"&&B<(.*5 (

( ( (

8 +: +9 & .%"! +

" "&3 ' '!& % " C:7( $%9"

')' "& 9'"!'9 /" )""&&B<(.5?( (

8 , +/

+"'

'%/' .%"!+

""&3' %)!% "&%9"

' 9"%

&)%%9'"!'

9 / " )" " && B<(.+(

8 ' / " )" ') B<(.*5 &"!")%) "0'/ .3# "(( ( "&(!!"

'(( ( "&9

4((

(

( .A? @5+: =&% " &)%" !'

. "!

.!'/%)

(

? '" " " '"!9' '( # "" ')"" ) -" "!

- C:7($

(

?9%".%"!+

"((( $(

' !

"(( '# ' "!

"&+!

& (.(((

' "&' " ' " "!

B<(. %9"

') B<(.9'"!'9 /" )"" &&B<(.=(?(

"&9! & + +!

'"'' ') (8(

"&+!

" (.((9!#-'( '&!

" "!

"&'""

') !!!))'"

)%B<(.F )%! !!!(

?( +' & ))%"!

" B<(.F5 (

? !"

"&+!

" ?(.(()9'"!' '

B<(., 9 !( '+!

"4 :.9

(

!!%&+%&9 (" " " '- "!%

B<(.*5B<(.*5?)!

"%-( +'&))%"!

"B<(.F5 !!

") !- /"#% &)% 7) "%" !!+%&%&( &"!%% <&" '!

' '%)!%! ""9

'!!%&+%&%9"

'#%&)% %) C+@ '#&)%% !(9'"!'9 /" )"" &&B<(.E(!!"%'9 (

?(" "' "!%

B<(.*58(%% ' '!!&!

')%! !!!9' '-!&&"

)) "&"&&B<(.*5 !!"%'9)!# 0%,)"

%+!

.!'/%( &"!%%<&" '!

' '&)% #% %9"

' 9"%

%)!%&)%%9'"!'9 /" )""&&B<(.2( '" "!!%&+%& !

& '"%"

>!- %(2'-

"!%

B<(.*54B<(.*5$)!

"%-(

( (

8 ,+/

+"'

'%/' .%"!+

"&3' '%)!% "&%9"

' 9" %

&)%%9'"!'9 /" )""&&B<(.+(2' !)) -9)"

',.%"!+

"(+'" " " '!! " '!

4( .A8+:="'=& .(+( .!'/%)" !" &%C:B<(.*5

(

$( .A " =& 6" "

"!")% !"%

0''/ " "!

,'") .3##'

'""%!) "" (( ( "&52&+"''"& ';&7"= " " "7( ( ,

' (( ( " "!

B<(. 9 !!

!!" '!"#- '" "!(!!" '! " "!

'(( ( "!

"&" 4((

(,%) '! " "!

B<(.*5 " #- '%!%" " ' "!")%!"% 0''/(

( .A4:)!

+3 +, .%"!+

"'"&" .!'/% ) !&)% " " " ')) "%) +!

"4(.(() "

# %:%%>" ( ( .A (&3 +"'

0, +!

.!'/%

(

?)%"!>

'&"!%%%-<&"!!%&5 '%"

- % 5,(7( ?

"&3"@B<(.( :'")"" '9 '" !!%&!% ) & !

<%" !( '&- '%&"!%%%-<&" !!+%&='5:>'&&

- &% 5G448 ' . .!'/%"@B<(.5( :'")"" '9 '"

!!+%&='!% ) &!

<%" !(

)%"!>

'%&"!%%%-<&"!!"%' %"5 " -&% 5G

"0 "&3" @B<(.5 (:'")"" '9 '" !!"%' !% ) &!

<%" !( ( .A

+ "' =& "&"% '%& +'( ,(+( 39

6: '"'#'

'&&!

?(,) " "&B<(.

"&! +!

" ?(.(( )%"!> B<(. 5 !" '

> B<(. 5 ))%-" '! " "!)-(," " " '" +'(,(+( 39 @( 6:'"' E(2( '#

" ?(.((''#9/" ')"" '"@( 6: %)"( .A ,+ ' ) (

8'9) ,".%"!+

"(((.!'/%( -'' '! )) - "(( )!%! "" '!% ' ') ! B, %/ +"'7(4?

"!") ( (

8 )"

'&"C+@

'#(B, %/+"' )"

" '!)) -"C+@

'!") '"& '&-( ( .A

+"' '='"/ +"+!" " "! "! +%- C+@

'# =% ,-)

(

8'!" '% )!% & "%- """ C+@ '# " C: 7($

(

.%"!+

"(((.!'/%( ,)'") " 7<&" "5& !'"B<(.(,) ') 9))

' #" %!

)'&5%%%"! !' ( 2' &% %%%"! !' "

B<(.5H%%%"!!' "B<(.5 (,)!)- H%!

)'& "

&7(B<(.5 !)- H%!

)'& "

&7( B<(.5?

!)- H%!

)'& "

&7( B<(.58 !)- H %!

)'& "

&(B<(.5

!)- &%%!

)'& "

&(B<(.54 !)- &%%!

)'& "

&7( B<(.5$ !)- &%%!

)'& "

&7( B<(.5

!)- &%%!

)'& "

&(B<(.5 (2'!") "

& 9 & " " '" ) B<(.( : ') ' "% ! """

&( B<(

'"%! ""#%&)% "

&( B<( '"%! "" '"

&(B<(?(:

&(9 9B<(( ?( 2'.#%"!.! ""!) C+@'# B<.HB<(.H5( 8( C& '#"!"

"!% "&9'9

'!%"0& %+!'% +!

'"''% ''& %%% # # 8(

? 9%/(A''"

' &"%-!' '(," "% !' '-< - "((

?'# '+ #" &))%"!

"B<(.# +,

.%"!+

"&3 '"'9')C:7( $

B<( .@ +!

" :. 9 " .+ "&3( : " "9 (" " ") !+!

"? .+!

4 :.9( 2'"!

"&9!(

? &# "&3( +'9&"!%%%-<&"#-.A$(+" ' "!% "!

""%,)"

% "&3 '&- /"'! (.A$% "%%

) '*"!

"&: & "C& B<(.B( %&)% "!

"&9% # "( 4( +

"&9! 9 "&+!

" ?

(.((C" # '@(6:'"'

?9'"!'"B<(.0

'# '@(6:.!'/% (

?9'"!'"B<(.,(:# ' '

'#%- $ '

?'' 9%/ +/ "./(A''9"

"" ')/%&!!%9"

''" 9

' "!& '(2'-9%%/(%&'(2'-' # "(2'- /' '") ')/)'#-( !&&"

") '-% '%"&""&39'' &"!!" 9-( $( 9'"%)"" .A '" - '"' ')) ' '!!'- '" '(+'

?''&!

"9"

'') 9 (+'9 "" - ' 9-(+'9!%' "% !<&"#- '@(..(:!<&" "'9! 9"

" (.((B<.C

?B<(.6 8(

?9''' # #")#- '!!(:! <&" "'" " "'" '

" ?( .((B<(.0B<.,&"

''#)!# " (

? !" '

( +'%&"

' " @B<. '+<%% : & "C&B<(.B( .A+ #"+"'!&)%"

# ' "&.A 2&+"'

' "&)# "&'"% '&

? '" (2'-%)# '!&)%"

" &#-.A+ #"+"'(2'-%) "&9!

? & # "&3( 2'- '9 " )!" "!%%- "&)%"!

'!!(: !

"!<&" "#-!% '!! '- ' " <!%) '!!(2'-

9''9! &

'# '9%%/>"

9%%(+'' !&)%"

'& - '"9'')) '(2'-%

"& % '' > %- &--

?( ?

'" '%) '!!"-&( C " '" !

'"!!%"&"!%"!" '!!%&"%'" & C+@) B<(.( ) '")

' &%H+2 %-"""!

'7) "% "

&7( 9 "& "& !'"9"

' '7) "% %& ! "

&7( '#% &)% %&7) "% "%' ! "

&7(#%&)% "%'!!%"%-) '- '&#"%"!%""( ,9 '7) "% +%& ! "

&( #%&)% +%&" & !'"9"

' ' 7) "% "

&7( 9 "!

"&(C+@) B<(.H5""!

'&&9 !

"% 9# B<( %" B<(# 9 "& B<(!9%%9 %&( 2')! '&& '"%9# B<( %"

B<(# 9 "& B<(! ' !

'7) "% 9 "&& !'9"

' '7) "% '#%&)% %&"%'9"

' '

"&+!

" ?( .(( " " '! ')! " "&'#)#-

'!!%&"%'( .A$(+"

'' " " )"#"%"

- <%% "&!% #% ( .A (

# &3 +"'

0, +!

.!'/% &"!%%<&" "

' !!

' 9 '" ' !! 9 "!)#% ) &"<%" !( ?( 2'"!

"&'#) #!'"%9"

'" '&" +!

'.+!

(2) ' "& ')! "' %"B<(. B<(. '

!)- ' '#" ' "& ') /9'"' #" ''#! 4((

2'"!

"&))".A ' '))".A'

' #" ' 9 4((

( " =& 6" "

0''/ " "!

,'")))".A )! " "!

B<(.*5

"#- '" " ' ' 0''/9'" ' #" ' "&"! 4((

(,%) ' #" '! " "!

"&B<(. "!!

) '"!( C& '" "!"

") ' #" ' "&" 4((

( ' '"!" "((

?'9% '?-( ?

@( % ' !! ' "! .A $ (+"

' 9'"'!<&"

'9"3-

')" ) "& '"""!

"&9 ! ") - '!

<%" !( ?( D"

) & ' !

#! "3- ')" )

"& "

% %" - '!' )&/"

! !

'"& ! !"

") "&"!'"%9"

'" &" +!

(+!

3" 9' )")! !&&"

" !+!

" 8 4 '.+!

' '%%)& !')'!&&"

' ! '!&-#% '! -")( 2' !!' ##% # ')&) "+!

( ??( 2' !

' &"%- "&'!&)&"9"

' !!% ! '! '!!(@(2"% ' "!

'))%"!

" )%!"! '!&)&"9"&"#- (

("&"%"") #- '!! >'" )!"" '&9"&"#- ',"'

(

( ?8( 2' '"!) & '!!%" ')! "' )#-#%# !!%&"%'!&&"

' ! ) "<%% ) "& " +!

"8 '.+!

9'"!'")"'#%+!

" .+!

( ?

2'@("

"%+"6' ! '& :

- /" # '&""&& !)!"# ' ! +!

" '.+!

( ?4( 2' !!! "

?( ' % "& )"'& )" +!

" ' .+ !

9 I

J ?$( @ #- ' . !

" '"% & +<% !

&& !

" 9&( ) '&+!

')"'& )""I

$ ?

2'))%% %"#% # !) ')""" &!

(: ' !

!"!& ! '"! ! :

-&-#)))"

( !!"%- '))%") %-%%9( 2'!"!

" ))%% K!!+!

"8 '.+!

")'%(,9

'" !"! &:

-9"

' " (

5!'

-9"

' " (

5 !'

" % )-& " '"&)%"&)"& -(

( '

(

)*+,-.

& " A' '+)/"5 H A' ') #% H57